The Bagel Store

- 335 Hackensack St, Carlstadt, NJ 07072

Introduction / Overview

For residents of Bergen County and throughout North Jersey, The Bagel Store in Carlstadt stands as a quintessential local institution, delivering on the promise of authentic, high-quality New York-style bagels paired with the hearty, beloved breakfast and deli traditions New Jersey is famous for. Operating from 335 Hackensack Street, The Bagel Store is much more than a simple bagel shop; it functions as a comprehensive bakery, a go-to breakfast restaurant, and a full-service deli and caterer, all under one roof. The establishment has been a local fixture since 1995, specializing in bagels that are famously kettle-boiled and stone-baked—a technique considered crucial to achieving the perfect New Jersey bagel texture: crunchy on the outside, chewy on the inside.

The menu is a sprawling tribute to what North Jersey locals love. In the mornings, customers flock for the extensive selection of double-egg breakfast sandwiches, often featuring local favorites like Taylor Ham, alongside classics such as bacon, sausage, and steak. The commitment to freshness extends beyond the bagels; the store proudly offers homemade cream cheese spreads, freshly prepared deli salads, and a variety of homemade bakery items like famous crumb cake slices and muffins. This wide-ranging, high-quality menu ensures The Bagel Store caters to every meal need, from a quick morning bite to a full lunch spread or even large-scale event catering.

In keeping with the demands of the modern, busy New Jersey lifestyle, The Bagel Store places a strong emphasis on convenience. Services are designed to accommodate a quick visit, offering efficient in-store pickup, as well as robust delivery options through various popular platforms. This commitment to accessibility and a diverse, authentic menu has cemented its status as a highly valued local spot in the competitive Bergen County food scene.

Location and Accessibility

The Bagel Store is strategically located at 335 Hackensack St, Carlstadt, NJ 07072, USA. This address places it directly in the heart of Carlstadt's commercial landscape, a vibrant borough in Bergen County known for its accessibility to major North Jersey roadways.

Key aspects of the location's accessibility for local users include:

• Prime Street Frontage: Located on Hackensack Street, the shop benefits from high visibility and easy entry for quick stops, which is essential for a breakfast-focused establishment.
• Regional Access: Carlstadt is centrally situated for residents in surrounding towns like East Rutherford, Rutherford, Wallington, and Wood-Ridge, making it a convenient destination for a morning commute stop or a weekend breakfast run.
• Convenient Service Options: The business model heavily supports modern convenience, offering Delivery and In-store Pickup, which mitigates any potential challenges related to traffic or limited seating during peak hours.
• Payment Flexibility: To ensure a fast and simple transaction, The Bagel Store accepts a variety of payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, catering to the needs of customers looking for a quick visit.

Services Offered

The Bagel Store’s service profile extends well beyond simple counter service, offering a full spectrum of food and beverage options for the local community:

• Authentic Bagel Production: Daily production of freshly baked, kettle-boiled, and stone-baked bagels in over a dozen flavors, including Plain, Everything, Sesame, Egg, and French Toast.
• Breakfast Restaurant: Serving a vast menu of hot breakfast items, including famous double-egg sandwiches, omelette platters with home fries and toast, pancakes (Buttermilk, Chocolate Chip, Nutella), and breakfast wraps.
• Full Deli Service: Preparation of high-quality, freshly sliced deli meats for lunch sandwiches and subs, featuring premium options like Rare Roast Beef and Roasted Turkey Breast, along with homemade salads (Tuna, Chicken, Egg) and sides (Macaroni Salad, Potato Salad).
• Catering Services: Specialized catering for both breakfast (New York Bagel Baskets, Full Hot Breakfast Buffets) and lunch (deli platters, subs, salads), perfect for office meetings, private parties, or events across North Jersey.
• Convenience Services: Delivery, In-store pickup, and Takeout options are all core components of the daily operation to meet the demand for swift service.
• Beverages: Serving a variety of beverages, including freshly brewed hot coffee, an extensive menu of iced coffees (Vanilla, Caramel, Hazelnut, Pumpkin Spice), and a selection of hot teas and cold drinks.

Features / Highlights

The Bagel Store has carved out a loyal customer base in New Jersey by focusing on specific high-quality and locally relevant features:

• Authentic New Jersey/NY-Style Bagels: The use of the traditional kettle-boiled and stone-baked method ensures an uncompromised texture and flavor that meets the high standards of New Jersey bagel enthusiasts.
• The Ultimate Breakfast Sandwiches: A menu dominated by the famous New Jersey Taylor Ham (Pork Roll), Egg, and Cheese sandwich, along with hearty Double Egg and Double Cheese options, and the substantial BACON, EGG & CHEESESTEAK special.
• Homemade Cream Cheese Spreads: Offering a wide array of homemade spreads, including Scallion & Chives, Bacon Cheddar, Olive & Pimento, and Smoked Salmon, available both on a bagel or to purchase by the tub for home use.
• Homemade Bakery Items: Known for delicious, fresh-baked pastries, especially the large, budget-friendly muffins and the Homemade Famous Crumb Cake Slice.
• Extensive Deli & Lunch Menu: Beyond breakfast, the shop serves a full deli menu with Specialty Hot Subs (like the Original Philly Cheese Steak Sub and Roast Beef Garlic Bread Sub) and fresh House Salads, making it an all-day food destination.
• 99₵ HOT BAGEL Deal: A major draw for early morning customers, offering select hot bagels at a competitive price until approximately 9 AM, promoting the freshest possible product.

Contact Information

The Bagel Store is ready to serve the New Jersey community via the following contact methods:

Address: 335 Hackensack St, Carlstadt, NJ 07072, USA

Phone: (201) 460-8660

Mobile Phone: +1 201-460-8660

What is Worth Choosing

For New Jersey residents, The Bagel Store is the premier choice for three primary reasons: authenticity, variety, and convenience. The most compelling reason to choose this establishment is its dedication to the craft of the bagel. For those who understand the difference, a kettle-boiled, stone-baked bagel is non-negotiable, and The Bagel Store delivers on this promise consistently.

Secondly, the menu variety is unmatched. Whether you are craving the iconic Taylor Ham, Egg & Cheese on a fresh Everything Bagel, a healthy Protein Packed Breakfast Wrap, or a delicious cold-cut Sub for lunch, this Carlstadt location covers all bases. The extensive selection of both savory breakfast items and homemade cream cheeses, coupled with the deli options, ensures there’s a fresh, satisfying choice for every member of the family or office.

Finally, the operational structure is built around the New Jersey consumer's need for speed and convenience. With robust options for Delivery, In-store pickup, and a system designed for a Quick visit, The Bagel Store minimizes waiting time, which is especially appreciated during the morning rush. While some customer feedback notes occasional inconsistency or wait times—a common challenge for any high-volume, popular local spot—the core product quality of the bagels and the famous breakfast sandwiches remains a consistently highly-rated favorite, solidifying The Bagel Store as a true staple for breakfast and lunch in the Bergen County area.

The Bagel Store

335 Hackensack St, Carlstadt, NJ 07072, USA