The Bettered Bagel

- 1777 South Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314

For Staten Island locals and visitors alike, finding that perfect New York bagel spot is a daily mission. Look no further than The Bettered Bagel, a welcoming and vibrant establishment that has carved out a loyal following for its commitment to classic breakfast fare and a diverse menu that goes well beyond your standard schmear. This locally-owned business combines the tradition of a classic New York bagel shop with a modern, inclusive atmosphere, making it a standout choice for your morning routine or midday meal. More than just a place for a quick bite, The Bettered Bagel is a community hub, proudly identifying as both LGBTQ+ owned and women-owned, offering a transgender safe space for all its patrons.

The core of The Bettered Bagel’s appeal lies in its dedication to the versatile, beloved bagel. While many New Yorkers debate the exact science of the city’s superior bagels—often attributing it to the unique local water—this shop focuses on quality ingredients and a broad selection of toppings and preparations. Whether you crave the simplicity of a plain bagel with butter or the indulgence of a gourmet sandwich, the menu is designed to cater to all tastes, making it a true all-day breakfast and lunch destination on Staten Island.

Location and Accessibility

The Bettered Bagel is conveniently located on Staten Island, making it an accessible spot for many local New Yorkers. You can find them at:

1777 South Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314

The shop’s location provides ease of access for local residents. A significant convenience for customers is the availability of a free parking lot, which is a major benefit in the busy New York area and ensures that grabbing your favorite bagel is hassle-free. In addition to accommodating vehicle traffic, the establishment is committed to inclusivity, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring that all community members can enjoy their delicious offerings. The focus on easy access underscores its mission as a welcoming neighborhood spot.

Services Offered

The Bettered Bagel is set up to meet the needs of all New Yorkers, whether you're looking for a leisurely dine-in experience or a meal on the move. Their service options are comprehensive and designed for maximum convenience:

• Dine-in: Enjoy your breakfast or lunch in the clean, inviting atmosphere of the shop.
• Takeout: Perfect for a quick visit or grabbing your order to enjoy elsewhere.
• Delivery: For those days when you can't leave the house or office, the option for delivery brings the fresh bagels right to your door.
• In-store shopping: Ideal for browsing the full selection of bagels, spreads, and specialty items.

Features / Highlights

The menu at The Bettered Bagel is a clear highlight, extending well beyond the traditional bagel-and-cream-cheese combo to offer a full range of breakfast and lunch options. The quality and variety of their offerings, combined with a distinct community focus, make it a true Staten Island standout.

• Extensive Bagel and Spread Selection: From the simple Plain bagel ($1.00) to specialty options like Nutella & Strawberries ($4.00) and Cream Cheese & Bacon ($5.00), there is a combination for every craving. The classic Fresh Lox, Cream Cheese, Tomato, and Red Onion bagel is also available for a truly authentic New York experience ($10.00).
• Hearty Egg Sandwiches: They offer classic egg sandwiches, including the option of Two Fried Eggs on a Bagel, alongside more gourmet breakfast creations like Two Scrambled Eggs with Cheddar Cheese, Tomato, and Avocado.
• Lunch and Finger Food Options: The menu expands for lunch with Fresh Wraps, such as the Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Melted Swiss, Lettuce, Tomato, and Ranch combination, and Gourmet Sandwiches like a Beef Burger with Bacon, Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato, and other toppings. Classic deli salads, like Egg Salad, Tuna Fish ($8.00), and Chicken Salad ($8.00), are also available. For quick bites, they offer a range of Finger Foods, including French Fries ($5.95), Onion Rings ($6.00), Beef Patty ($5.00), and Chicken Wings & Fries ($11.00).
• Premium Coffee and Beverages: To complete the meal, The Bettered Bagel offers a full range of hot and iced coffee drinks, including Single Espresso ($2.50), Double Espresso ($3.50), Cappuccino ($3.50), Latte ($3.50), Macchiato ($3.50), and Hot Chocolate ($2.25). They also feature a selection of Hearney & Sons Teas, such as Chamomile, Ginger, Cinnamon Apple, and English Breakfast.
• Community Commitment: The business proudly identifies as both LGBTQ+ owned and women-owned, and operates as an LGBTQ+ friendly and transgender safe space, emphasizing its role as a welcoming and inclusive spot for the entire Staten Island community.

Contact Information

For New Yorkers planning a visit or needing to place an order, here is the essential contact information:

• Address: 1777 South Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314
• Phone: (917) 522-0333 or +1 917-522-0333

What is Worth Choosing

For many New Yorkers, a bagel shop's worth is measured by its classic offerings, but The Bettered Bagel stands out by offering more than just the basics. It’s worth choosing this spot not only for the food but for the total experience. The combination of classic New York bagel quality, expansive menu diversity, and practical amenities makes it highly appealing. The inclusion of free parking, wheelchair accessibility, and a variety of service options (including dine-in and delivery) makes every visit exceptionally convenient for local users.

When you visit, consider trying one of their premium bagel sandwiches, such as the Fresh Lox, Cream Cheese, Tomato, Red Onion combination, which is a New York staple. For a satisfying lunch, a Fresh Wrap or Gourmet Sandwich paired with a side of French Fries or Onion Rings provides a robust meal. The full coffee menu, featuring high-quality espresso drinks, also ensures you can get your essential morning or afternoon caffeine fix.

In a city known for its demanding food scene, supporting a local, independent, and community-minded business like The Bettered Bagel adds value beyond the meal itself. It's a place where you can grab a quick, quality breakfast—like a Cream Cheese & Tomato bagel ($4.00) or an Avocado Toast ($6.00)—or sit down for a satisfying, well-rounded lunch. The fact that they prioritize a safe, welcoming environment for all customers ensures that The Bettered Bagel is a genuine, local Staten Island gem that is well worth seeking out.

While some customer reviews mention occasional service inconsistencies, a common experience in busy, local shops, the overall consensus points to delicious food, impressive menu variety, and a clean, appealing environment. The quality of the food and the broad scope of their menu, including everything from classic bagels and smears to full finger food options, ultimately solidifies The Bettered Bagel as a prime choice for New Yorkers looking for a 'better' bagel and a welcoming local spot.

The Bettered Bagel

1777 South Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314, USA