The Brass Rail

- 107 Forest Ave, Locust Valley, NY 11560

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers on Long Island seeking a dining experience that perfectly balances upscale elegance with comfortable, casual warmth, The Brass Rail in Locust Valley stands out as a premier American restaurant and Gastro Pub. Nestled in a prime location in Nassau County, The Brass Rail has carved out a reputation for exceptional, high-quality American cuisine, an impressive beverage program, and an atmosphere that is both cozy and distinctly classy—a rare combination that resonates with the discerning Long Island crowd. Patrons often describe the atmosphere as "timeless," built around a stunning antique bar originally crafted by two German brothers in The Bowery of New York City in the late 1880s, infusing the establishment with a piece of authentic NYC history.

The menu at The Brass Rail is a testament to elevated American cooking, featuring classic comfort food alongside contemporary, skillfully prepared dishes. From the Soup & Salads section, customers rave about the famous French Onion Soup, which one reviewer declared is "TO DIE FOR!" Beyond the soups, the offerings span from refined Appetizers like Seared Jumbo Lump Crab Cake and Spicy Rock Shrimp to hearty Entrees such as Filet Mignon, Steak Au Poivre, and Pignoli Crusted Halibut. Even the Sandwiches—like the Sirloin Burger Au Poivre and the French Dip—are crafted with a focus on premium ingredients and expert preparation. This dedication to quality across the board, from the complimentary dinner rolls served with butter to the last bite of the Brownie Sundae, ensures a consistently high-caliber meal that is appreciated by locals and visitors alike.

The dining experience is also elevated by its commitment to superb hospitality. The Brass Rail prides itself on fast service and a professional staff, with one customer review specifically highlighting a server named Christine for her "warmth, professionalism, and attention to detail." This blend of high-end food, inviting ambiance, and attentive service positions The Brass Rail as a go-to choice for a "fancy yet affordable" meal that is considered "on par with other restaurants" in the competitive Long Island dining scene. Whether for a business lunch, a romantic dinner, or a comfortable solo dining experience, The Brass Rail offers a reliably excellent American restaurant experience in the heart of Locust Valley.

Location and Accessibility

The Brass Rail is strategically located at 107 Forest Ave, Locust Valley, NY 11560, USA. This North Shore address places it conveniently within reach for residents across Nassau County, New York, offering a charming destination for high-quality American dining.

Accessibility is a key priority for the establishment, ensuring a welcoming environment for all guests:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance: Provides smooth, unhindered access into the restaurant's main dining area.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot: Dedicated parking spaces make visiting simple and stress-free.
• Wheelchair accessible restroom: Ensures comfort and convenience for all patrons.
• Wheelchair accessible seating: Thoughtful table arrangements are available to comfortably accommodate guests with mobility needs.

In addition to these amenities, the practical benefit of Free parking lot and Free street parking makes this a highly accessible venue for New York diners driving to the Locust Valley area. The ease of access, combined with a central location, makes The Brass Rail an ideal choice for both planned reservations and impromptu dining.

Services Offered

The Brass Rail provides a full spectrum of dining services, accommodating various preferences and occasions throughout the day, emphasizing flexibility and convenience.

• Dine-in: Guests can enjoy Table service in the welcoming dining room, available for Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert.
• Reservations: Accepts reservations, with Brunch reservations recommended and Dinner reservations recommended, especially for peak hours, to ensure seating.
• Takeout and Delivery: For maximum convenience, the full menu is available for Takeout and Delivery, along with an option for Curbside pickup.
• Special Dining: The menu offers Small plates, ideal for sharing or light dining, and the kitchen serves Late-night food for those seeking a later bite.
• Meal Periods: Comprehensive service includes Lunch, Dinner, and Brunch, catering to all daily dining needs.
• Beverage Program: Features a full Bar onsite with a wide range of Offerings, including Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Coffee, Hard liquor, and an impressive Wine selection.

Features / Highlights

The unique blend of atmosphere, service quality, and menu selection are the defining features of The Brass Rail, setting it apart in the Long Island dining scene.

• Great Cocktails & Wine List: A major highlight is the fully stocked Bar onsite, celebrated for its Great cocktails, Great beer selection, and particularly its Great wine list, appealing to those seeking a well-rounded adult beverage experience.
• Timeless Atmosphere: The ambiance is a remarkable blend of Casual, Cozy, Romantic, Trendy, and Upscale, making it suitable for a variety of occasions, from a business dinner to a special date night.
• Signature Comfort Food: The menu features acclaimed dishes that have become local favorites, including the "TO DIE FOR" French Onion Soup and the rich Lobster Mac & Cheese.
• Fast Service & Attentiveness: The restaurant is consistently praised for its Fast service and the exceptional attentiveness and professionalism of its staff.
• Great Dessert: The Dessert menu offers high-quality finishes to any meal, with options like Vanilla Bean Crème Brûlée, Mascarpone Cheesecake, and the popular Brownie Sundae.
• Wide Range of Offerings: Caters to diverse dietary preferences with options including Comfort food, Small plates, and dishes that utilize premium cuts like Filet Mignon and fresh Seafood such as Halibut and Bronzino.

Contact Information

To plan a visit or make a reservation at this Locust Valley gem, please use the following contact details:

Address: 107 Forest Ave, Locust Valley, NY 11560, USA

Phone: (516) 723-9103

Mobile Phone: +1 516-723-9103

What is worth choosing

Choosing The Brass Rail in Locust Valley is choosing an elevated, yet accessible, American dining experience that stands out in the New York metropolitan area. It is worth choosing for several compelling reasons that directly address the needs and desires of a local Long Island user.

The first compelling factor is the unparalleled dining atmosphere. The venue successfully blends an Upscale feel with a Cozy and Casual environment. The presence of a historic, antique bar from The Bowery of NYC adds a layer of authentic, captivating history that makes the space truly unique and memorable—perfect for creating an impression for a date or a group gathering. The fact that Dinner reservations are recommended speaks to its popularity as a destination spot for locals.

Secondly, the exceptional value for the quality of the cuisine is a major draw. While described as "pricey," customers acknowledge it is "on par with other restaurants" of its caliber, offering high-end cuts like Filet Mignon and fresh Seafood Entrees (e.g., Bronzino, Salmon, Halibut) alongside sophisticated Appetizers such as Grilled Mediterranean Octopus and Tuna Tartar. A true American restaurant, it masterfully executes classics, most famously the rich French Onion Soup, and provides thoughtful accompaniments like the complimentary dinner rolls. The availability of 15 unique, high-quality Side dishes, from Mushroom Risotto to Truffle Parmesan Fingerling Potatoes, allows for true customization of the main course.

Finally, the holistic experience is solidified by the excellent service and beverage program. The combination of an acclaimed Great beer selection, a Great wine list, and expertly crafted Great cocktails ensures that the liquid portion of the meal is just as high-quality as the food. With staff frequently praised for being "absolutely fantastic" and "incredibly attentive," The Brass Rail promises not just a meal, but a genuinely welcoming and flawless dining occasion, making it an essential destination for discerning New York diners.

The Brass Rail

107 Forest Ave, Locust Valley, NY 11560, USA