The Fish Bar

- 2421 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY 10458

Introduction / Overview: Experience True Seafood Freshness on Arthur Avenue

The Fish Bar stands out as a hidden gem in the heart of the Bronx’s celebrated Little Italy, located on the iconic Arthur Avenue. While the neighborhood is world-famous for its Italian delis, bakeries, and traditional red-sauce establishments, The Fish Bar carves out a vital niche, offering a specialized and highly-regarded seafood dining experience. It is not merely a restaurant; it is a dedicated seafood haven where the quality and freshness of the catch are the undisputed stars of the show.

This establishment has quickly become a local favorite, particularly cherished for bringing a unique concept—where customers can often select their own seafood to be cooked to order—to the Bronx. This focus on hyper-freshness and customization elevates The Fish Bar beyond a typical dining spot. It provides a unique, interactive experience that customers rave about, noting that the ability to choose the exact amount and type of seafood, and dictate its preparation, is unparalleled in the borough.

The atmosphere at The Fish Bar is described as casual and cozy, making it an excellent spot for both solo diners and groups. It is popular for lunch and dinner, offering a relaxed yet professional setting to enjoy small plates and generous portions of the freshest seafood available. Customers consistently highlight the genuinely kind and attentive service from the staff, including the owner, which contributes significantly to the warm, inviting ambiance.

Location and Accessibility

The Fish Bar boasts a premier address within one of New York City’s most historic and authentic food districts. Its location is a major draw, positioning it perfectly for both dedicated New York foodies and tourists exploring the 'Real Little Italy.'

Specific Address: 2421 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY 10458, USA

As a key fixture on Arthur Avenue, the restaurant is easily accessible to residents across the Bronx and those traveling from other boroughs. The neighborhood is well-served by public transportation. For drivers, like much of New York City, parking can be a challenge; however, The Fish Bar offers the essential amenity of paid street parking nearby, allowing patrons to navigate their visit with more convenience. The ability to find parking in this bustling area is a valuable feature for those planning a visit.

Services Offered

The Fish Bar ensures a versatile dining experience that meets various needs, offering several convenient ways to enjoy their fresh seafood.

• Dine-in: Patrons can enjoy the cozy, casual atmosphere with full table service for both lunch and dinner. Seating is available, and high chairs are provided, making it welcoming for families with children.
• Takeout: For those on the go or preferring to enjoy their meal at home, quick and efficient takeout service is a popular option, praised by customers for its fast service.
• Delivery: Customers across the region can savor the freshness of The Fish Bar's seafood through their delivery service, bringing the quality of Arthur Avenue right to their door.
• Full Bar Service: The presence of a bar onsite allows guests to enjoy a wide selection of Alcohol, including Beer, Wine, Cocktails, and Hard Liquor, enhancing the dining and social experience.
• Flexible Payments: The restaurant accepts Credit cards and Debit cards, simplifying the payment process for all patrons.

Features / Highlights

Several key features distinguish The Fish Bar as a must-visit dining destination in the Bronx:

• Unrivaled Freshness and Customization: This is the restaurant's signature appeal. Customers can often pick out the amount of seafood they want, which is then cooked precisely to their specifications. This level of control guarantees the freshest possible meal, a feature frequently noted in glowing customer reviews.
• Exceptional Service: The owner, Bob, and the waitstaff are repeatedly mentioned for being "so nice" and "friendly." This warm, attentive service contributes significantly to the cozy and pleasant atmosphere.
• Great Cocktails: Beyond the food, the establishment is highlighted for its Great Cocktails, making it an excellent choice for an evening out where guests can enjoy a high-quality drink alongside their meal.
• Ideal for All Dining Occasions: The Fish Bar is popular for both Lunch and Dinner, making it a reliable spot for either a mid-day meal or an evening gathering. Its cozy atmosphere also makes it perfect for Solo Dining.
• Focus on Quality Small Plates: The menu includes an offering of Small plates, which are excellent for sharing among groups or for solo diners wishing to sample a variety of fresh seafood preparations.

Contact Information

Due to the high demand and the unique, fresh-focused nature of the menu, potential guests are always encouraged to call ahead for the most consistent service and to confirm operating hours.

• Address: 2421 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY 10458, USA
• Phone: (347) 270-3052

What is Worth Choosing: Signature Dishes and Menu Focus

Choosing a meal at The Fish Bar is all about celebrating the ocean’s bounty, cooked with care and simplicity to let the natural flavor of the seafood shine. Based on the concept and customer feedback, these items are essential to your dining experience:

• The Fresh Catch of the Day (Custom Ordered): This is the core experience. Ask your server about the available fresh fish and shellfish. Patrons have specifically praised the Sea Bass for being "made to perfection," and the ability to have any fresh fish prepared just the way you like it is the main reason to visit.
• Baked Clams: A classic seafood appetizer, the baked clams here are noted for being "fresh and hot and not with a bunch of breading," demonstrating a commitment to quality ingredients over filler.
• Grilled Shrimp and Scallops: The grilled shrimp is explicitly called out as being "good," and the combination of shrimp and scallops is a popular and well-executed choice, perfect for a light yet satisfying meal.
• Comfort Food Sides: To complement the main attraction, the restaurant offers Comfort food options and small plates, with sides reasonably priced between $5 and $8. These sides provide the hearty balance needed to complete a flavorful meal.
• Cocktail Pairings: Given the highlight on Great Cocktails, be sure to ask the onsite bar staff for a pairing recommendation. A well-crafted drink can perfectly complement the briny flavors of fresh seafood.

The Fish Bar is a highly recommended dining spot for any New Yorker who appreciates truly fresh seafood prepared with an emphasis on quality and customer preference. Its unique model and friendly service make it a standout destination on the legendary Arthur Avenue.

The Fish Bar

2421 Arthur Ave, Bronx, NY 10458, USA