The Milleridge Bakery

- 585 N Broadway, Jericho, NY 11753

For generations of New Yorkers, The Milleridge Bakery in Jericho, NY, has been far more than just a place to buy bread; it is an institution and a cornerstone of the historic Milleridge Village experience on Long Island. Located on the historic Milleridge Inn property, which traces its origins back to 1672, this bakery carries on a tradition of quality, homestyle baking that is cherished across Nassau County and the wider New York region. While the Inn and Village offer a step back in time with their colonial ambiance, the bakery remains a vibrant, modern source for fresh, high-quality sweet and savory treats.

The Milleridge Bakery is recognized as a full-service bakery and a specialist wedding bakery, providing everything from daily indulgences to show-stopping centerpiece cakes for life's biggest celebrations. Our focus is on classic, comforting American baked goods, using recipes that have delighted families for decades. From the moment you step inside, you are greeted with the irresistible aroma of freshly baked goods—a clear sign that everything is prepared daily on-site. We pride ourselves on the breadth of our offerings, ensuring that whether you need a quick treat for a coffee break, a loaf of specialty bread for dinner, or a custom cake for a monumental event, The Milleridge Bakery has you covered.

While we deeply value our history, we understand the needs of today's busy New York customers. We offer convenient options for Takeout and Delivery, making it easy to enjoy our famous bakes without disrupting your day. Whether you are coming in for a quick visit or planning a grand event, our dedicated staff is ready to assist you in selecting the perfect sweet or savory item to meet your needs. Our long-standing reputation in the community is a testament to the fact that we consistently deliver on our promise of delicious, fresh-baked quality.

The Milleridge Bakery is conveniently situated at 585 N Broadway, Jericho, NY 11753, on the grounds of the famed Milleridge Village. This location is easily accessible from major roadways in the heart of Long Island, making it a convenient stop for residents of Jericho, Syosset, Hicksville, and surrounding Nassau County towns. The bakery is part of a larger complex of shops and the historic Milleridge Inn, providing a unique and charming destination for your visit.

We prioritize accessibility to ensure a seamless experience for all our New York patrons. The location features:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance, offering easy access to the bakery shop floor.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot, with designated spaces close to the village entrance, providing convenient parking.
• Ease of access for a Quick visit, perfect for those needing to grab and go their daily treats.

For payment, we accept modern methods including Credit cards and Debit cards, catering to the needs of local customers looking for fast, efficient service. The environment of the greater Milleridge Village offers brick walkways and benches, creating a pleasant, old-world setting to enjoy your purchases.

The Milleridge Bakery offers a variety of services tailored to meet both everyday needs and special occasion planning:

• Takeout: Visit our shop to select from our daily fresh-baked inventory, including cookies, pies, cakes by the slice, and breads.
• Delivery: Have your favorite baked goods, from cookies to whole pies, delivered right to your door for ultimate convenience.
• Wedding Bakery Services: Specialized consultation and creation of custom wedding cakes and dessert tables, building on decades of experience in the Milleridge tradition (Note: Custom orders like wedding cakes may have different delivery policies).
• Custom Cake Orders (2-day Pre-Order): Our 'Build A Cake - Made To Order' service allows you to customize cakes with two days' notice for special occasions.
• Whole Pie Sales: Purchase 10-inch Whole Pies, perfect for holiday gatherings and family dinners, including classics like Apple Pie and Pumpkin Pie.

The Milleridge Bakery is famous across Long Island for several signature items and unique qualities that keep New Yorkers coming back for more:

• Iconic Cinnamon Bread: A beloved Milleridge favorite, this spiced and sweet bread is a must-try item that has been a staple of the business for years, often cited as a reason for people's enduring loyalty.
• Legendary Seven Layer Cake: A highly popular cake, available whole (Serving Size 8 for $24.95) or By The Slice ($8.00 at the Inn), known for its rich, layered flavor and consistent quality.
• Jumbo Cookie Selection: A wide array of large, specialty cookies designed for maximum indulgence, including Jumbo Caramel Chocolate Chip ($6.00), Jumbo Dark Chocolate Chip ($6.00), and the distinctive Jumbo Rocky Road ($6.00).
• Specialty Cakes and Pastry Squares: A focus on rich, classic American desserts like the vibrant Rainbow Cake, the classic Black & White Cake, and pastry squares like the Crumb square ($4.50) and Double Chocolate Brownie ($4.50).
• Savory Offerings: Unlike many bakeries, we offer savory items like 4” Round Quiche in flavors such as Broccoli Quiche and Spinach Quiche ($12.00 each), providing great options for a quick lunch or brunch.
• Part of the Historic Milleridge Village: The bakery is an integral part of a charming, colonial-themed shopping village, offering a unique destination experience that goes beyond a standard store visit.

You can reach The Milleridge Bakery using the following details to place an order, inquire about custom cakes, or check on daily availability:

Address: 585 N Broadway, Jericho, NY 11753

Phone: (516) 931-2635

Mobile Phone: +1 516-931-2635

For New Yorkers seeking a blend of historic charm and modern culinary quality, The Milleridge Bakery is an essential choice. What makes us worth choosing is the unparalleled reputation for classic, homestyle baked goods that have been perfected over decades. When you choose our bakery, you are not just getting a dessert; you are getting a taste of Long Island history.

The sheer variety on offer ensures that everyone finds a favorite. From the famous Cinnamon Bread, which has garnered a devoted following over many years, to our massive, rich Jumbo Cookies, the quality and portion size are exceptional. If you are planning a celebration, our expertise as a wedding bakery means you can trust us to create a beautiful and delicious center piece, whether it's a traditional Vanilla or Chocolate Cake, or a festive Black & White Cake. We are particularly recommended for our consistent quality in items like the Seven Layer Cake and our wide range of pies, including the seasonal favorites like Apple Pie and Pumpkin Pie (Whole Pies are $26.00).

Moreover, the convenience of the location—being highly accessible with dedicated parking—and the option for quick takeout or reliable delivery services make The Milleridge Bakery a practical choice for busy families and professionals in the New York metropolitan area. While one customer noted a recent issue with cannoli quality, the overall decades-long history and constant demand for signature items like the cinnamon bread, seven layer cake, and cookies, along with consistently kind staff, confirm the bakery’s place as a cherished and worthwhile Long Island destination. Choose The Milleridge Bakery for tradition, quality, and a sweet experience that will transport you back to a simpler, more delicious time.

The Milleridge Bakery

585 N Broadway, Jericho, NY 11753, USA