The Official Cake Lady: New City, NY’s Go-To Custom Cake and Dessert Bakery

The Official Cake Lady Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For local residents in the New City area of Rockland County, finding a

Bakery

that combines artistic flair with genuinely moist and delicious flavor is a treasure.

The Official Cake Lady

, situated at 191 S Main St, is precisely that find. This specialty shop, spearheaded by a baker who has earned a loyal following, is renowned for its custom-designed cakes that truly bring a vision to life. Customers consistently rave about the personalized service and the quality of the final product, often noting that the cakes are not only visually spectacular—sometimes even incorporating creative elements like lights for themes—but are also incredibly

moist and flavorful

While the core expertise lies in custom cakes for major celebrations like birthdays, anniversaries, and

Wedding Cakes

, The Official Cake Lady is also a welcoming neighborhood bakery offering a satisfying selection of daily treats and beverages. Here, you can indulge in a single

Cake Slice

, a gourmet

Cupcake

(with 16 tempting varieties typically available), or unique baked items like

Crumb Cakes

and rich

Brownies

. They also cater to different tastes with savory offerings like

Empanadas

and provide a full cafe experience with various

Coffee

and tea options, making it a perfect spot for a mid-day sweet escape in New City.

Location and Accessibility

The Official Cake Lady is conveniently located at

191 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA

, positioning it as a highly accessible destination for customers across New City and the wider Rockland County community. The shop has been noted by visitors as being

super cute

, offering a pleasant and inviting atmosphere for in-store shopping.

For local users who plan to visit in person, the bakery demonstrates a commitment to accessibility, offering a

Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot

. This thoughtful inclusion ensures that access is simplified for all patrons. Furthermore, the location’s position on South Main Street makes it easily reachable for those running errands or looking to pick up a pre-ordered cake. The surrounding community benefits from this bakery’s central and well-connected location.

Services Offered

Custom Cake Design: Specializing in bespoke cakes for all major celebrations, including multi-tiered
Wedding Cakes
and elaborate themed birthday cakes.
In-Store Shopping: Customers can visit the physically welcoming shop to purchase daily selections like cake slices, cookies, and crumb cakes.
Curbside Pickup: A convenient service allowing customers to quickly and easily retrieve pre-ordered items without leaving their vehicle.
In-Store Pickup: The standard option for collecting custom cakes and online orders directly from the counter.
Delivery: Offering service within the local area, which is particularly beneficial for large, delicate custom cake orders.
Takeout: Fast service for all daily baked goods, coffee, and drinks.
Beverage Service: A full range of hot and cold beverages, including multiple coffee options (Latte, Cappuccino, Frozen Coffee) and various Teas and Milkshakes.
Payment Flexibility: Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments for smooth transactions.

Features / Highlights

Exceptional Customization: The bakery’s defining feature is its ability to create personalized, artistic cakes that exceed expectations, often including advanced design work and specialized themes.
Moist and Flavorful Cakes: Despite the focus on design, customers consistently highlight the superior quality, moisture, and flavor of the cakes, featuring options like vanilla and chocolate cake with vanilla frosting fill.
Diverse Menu of Daily Treats: Beyond custom cakes, the shop offers an impressive variety of walk-in items, from
Cake Pops
and
Cookies
to unique savory
Empanadas
(Jerk Chicken, Beef, or Pork).
Signature Dessert Items: Features popular comfort food classics with a gourmet touch, notably the creamy, layered
Banana Pudding
.
Full Coffee Menu: Offers a comprehensive selection of
Coffee
drinks, including specialty hot and iced options, making it a complete destination for a treat and a caffeine boost.
Customer-Focused Service: The staff, often including the owner Kimmy, is praised for being
easy to work with
and
kind
, even assisting customers with finding external items like cake toppers.
Amenities: Provides
Wi-Fi
for customers who wish to linger and enjoy their coffee and treat in the shop’s cute setting.

Contact Information

Address: 191 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA

Phone: (845) 470-2299

Mobile Phone: +1 845-470-2299

What is worth choosing

For local users in New City, what is truly worth choosing at The Official Cake Lady is their signature offering: a

Custom-Designed Cake

. The bakery has a proven track record of creating cakes that are not only show-stopping centerpieces—capable of handling complex themes and designs—but are also genuinely delightful to eat, a combination that can be hard to find. If you have a significant event coming up, securing your order well in advance (a minimum of three weeks is recommended for custom work) is the single best choice you can make for a memorable dessert.

For a quick treat or a taste of their craftsmanship without the need for a full custom order, you should absolutely sample a

Cake Slice

or one of the specialty

Cupcakes

. The vanilla and chocolate flavor base is highly recommended by frequent customers for its superb moisture. Additionally, the

Banana Pudding

is a must-try for dessert enthusiasts seeking a rich, classic American treat executed perfectly.

Finally, The Official Cake Lady stands out by bridging the gap between a high-end custom cake service and a friendly neighborhood coffee shop. Choosing one of their specialty coffee drinks, like a

Large Frozen Coffee

or a simple

Small Hot Coffee

, paired with a savory

Empanada

or a sweet

Brownie

, makes for a rewarding break during your day in New City.

The Official Cake Lady Wedding cake

Milkshakes
Medium Milkshake $9.00
Large Milkshake $10.00
Small Milkshake $8.00

Pudding
Banana Pudding $13.50

Empanadas
1 Empanada $3.60

Tea
Small Hot Tea $2.25
Large Hot Tea $3.00

Cake Slices
1 Cake Slice $6.00

Cake Pops
1 Cake Pop $3.85

Cupcakes
1 Cupcake $3.00

Cookies
1 Cookie $3.75

Coffee
Small Cappuccino $3.50
Small Hot Coffee $2.50
Latte $5.00
Small Latte $3.50
Large Frozen Coffee $5.25
Medium Iced Coffee $5.25
Cappuccino $5.00
Small Iced Coffee $4.00
Espresso Shot $2.25
Medium Hot Coffee $3.55
Small Frozen Coffee $4.25
Large Iced Coffee $6.00

Crumb Cakes
1 Crumb Cake $5.50

Cold Drinks
Extra Large Cold Drink $5.25
Large Cold Drink $6.50
Medium Cold Drink $5.75
Small Cold Drink $4.75

Brownies
1 Brownie $5.50

The Official Cake Lady Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

The Official Cake Lady Photos

The Official Cake Lady Location

The Official Cake Lady

New York Rockland County New City South Main Street

191 S Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA

The Official Cake Lady Reviews

An average rating of ★4.9 from 40 user reviews.

cupcakespartycookiesmilkshakesbaby showerravingidea

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

All I have to say is wow! Kimmy did such an amazing job on my son’s cake. It came out way better than I expected. We gave her a vision and she excelled! The cake was so moist and flavorful. We did vanilla frosting fill and chocolate cake 8 inch. Her shop in New City is super cute as well! I have already recommended to others and plan to use her again for future cakes! Thank you! :)
April 29 · Kristin S
The official cake lady is officially our go to bakery!! Kim did our sons cake for his superhero party this weekend and WOW so cool and creative even included lights (iron man themed) !!! The cake was delicious too!!! She’s done a couple of cakes for us already and everyone raves about it!! She was so easy to work with and so kind!! She even texted me links from Amazon for a cake topper. It was a pleasure Kim to work with you and your staff!! Thank you!! People are still talking about your cake!! ;) Oriana from Liam’s superhero party!
December 18 · Juan Fernandez
I have been going to the official cake lady now for 10-11 years and about 3-4 times in a year. Kim never ever disappoints. She makes our vision come to life. The cake is so good we drive over an hour to pick it. Kim is always professional and listens to every detail needed for the cake.The cakes are always moist and delicious . We will continue to drive to get our cakes.Thank you
September 15 · CHARISSA COLON
I sent picture to Kim for what I want for my son’s 1st bday cake and her team got it! Thank you so much Kim and staff for the delicious cake and cupcakes you made for our party! Will definitely recommend you to everyone I know. 🥰
June 29 · Pauline Nuguid
Amazing amazing amazing. Not sure my family had words when the cake was dropped off at my baby shower. It was just as tasty as beautiful. Truly was the talk of the party and center of the decorations.Thank you for making my shower complete.P.S. the cannoli's, brownies are to die for here. My parents owned a bakery for 16 years growing up so I'm very picky with bakery items. Hands down amazing stuff. Everything we have had is great here.
May 04 · Michelle Ballane