The Pizza Shop

- 9 Mill Rd, Eastchester, NY 10709

For residents across Westchester and the greater New York region, The Pizza Shop in Eastchester, NY, transcends the traditional definition of a mere Pizza restaurant. It is a full-service Italian restaurant and a cornerstone of the local dining scene, offering an exceptionally diverse menu that goes far beyond the classic pie. Located conveniently on Mill Road, this establishment caters equally to those looking for a quick, high-quality bite and families desiring a comfortable, full-course dinner experience.

A look at the menu reveals The Pizza Shop’s commitment to being a complete Italian dining destination. While the Pizza menu is expansive, featuring everything from a classic Large Pizza ($21.99) and a thick Sicilian Pizza ($22.99) to innovative options like Mac Attack Pizza ($25.99) and Shrimp Scampi Pizza ($27.99), the true breadth of its offerings is seen in its dinner service. The Dinners section is packed with high-quality entrees, including favorites like Chicken Parmigiana Dinner ($23.99), Veal Francese Dinner ($25.99), and fresh seafood options such as Grilled Salmon Dinner ($29.99) and Shrimp Scampi Dinner ($28.99).

This Family owned and operated establishment is dedicated to providing comfort food with genuine hospitality. Customers frequently praise the friendly, personalized service, noting that the staff often makes them feel “waited on by a good friend.” The atmosphere is distinctly Casual and Cozy, making it a perfect spot for Groups and Solo dining alike. With a strong focus on quality ingredients and a menu that accommodates nearly every dietary preference, including numerous Vegetarian options, The Pizza Shop has earned its place as one of Eastchester’s best spots to enjoy great food.

The Pizza Shop is centrally located in the vibrant Eastchester community of Westchester County, a vital area of the New York metropolitan region. The exact location is: 9 Mill Rd, Eastchester, NY 10709, USA.

The restaurant is positioned to be easily accessible to local patrons, whether they choose to dine in or opt for one of the comprehensive takeaway services. For those traveling by car, the restaurant offers multiple Parking options, including a Free parking lot as well as Paid parking lot and Paid street parking, ensuring convenience regardless of the time of day.

Crucially, The Pizza Shop prioritizes accessibility for all members of the New York community. It features excellent Accessibility amenities, including a Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating. This commitment ensures that everyone can enjoy the cozy atmosphere and diverse menu options within a comfortable setting.

The Pizza Shop operates as a full-service dining establishment and Delivery Restaurant, offering a wide range of convenience and dining formats to suit the busy schedules of New York residents.

• Full Dining Options: Available for both Lunch and Dinner, the restaurant provides comfortable Seating and dedicated Table service in its casual and cozy dining area, which includes Big Screen TV's.
• Flexible Takeaway Services: They offer comprehensive Delivery, Takeout, and even No-contact delivery options, providing maximum convenience for those who prefer to eat at home or in the office.
• Full-Scale Catering: The Pizza Shop excels as a full-service caterer, providing a wide range of items for catering orders to handle important occasions, from family gatherings to corporate events.
• Menu Variety: The comprehensive menu is organized to offer everything from Quick bite options and Small plates (Appetizers and Sides) to full-scale Comfort food dinners and extensive Dessert selections.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: The restaurant is Good for kids, offering a dedicated Kids' menu with favorites like Kid's Chicken Fingers And Fries ($10.99) and Kid's Baked Ziti ($9.99), alongside the availability of High chairs.
• Payment Convenience: Patrons can utilize various modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

What sets The Pizza Shop apart in the competitive New York dining scene is its combination of a vast menu, family feel, and commitment to high-quality ingredients and preparation across all categories.

• Exceptional Menu Depth: Far more than just pizza, the restaurant’s menu boasts thirty-four distinct Dinners entrees, including a wide array of chicken, veal, and seafood preparations such as:
  • Gourmet Veal Dishes: Veal Siciliana, Veal Alla Roma, and Grilled Veal Dinner (ranging from $25.99 to $26.99).
  • Specialty Seafood: Shrimp Alla Laura Dinner, Grilled Salmon Dinner, and Sole Positano Dinner (all featuring premium ingredients).
• Gourmet Pizza Creativity: The menu features two separate categories of specialty pies—Grandma Pizza and Gourmet Pizza—with creative toppings like the Mac N’ Cheese Pizza ($24.99), Chicken Pesto Pizza ($26.99), and the healthy Salad Pizza ($20.99). They also cater to modern needs with Gluten-Free 12" Pizza and a Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza.
• Signature Italian Fare: Customers highly recommend classic Italian plates, noting that the spaghetti and meatballs were delicious, showcasing the shop's expertise in traditional Pasta and baked dishes like Homemade Lasagna ($17.99) and Penne Vodka ($17.99).
• Diverse Lunch Offerings: The shop provides extensive options for a midday meal, including over twenty-seven varieties of Wraps and Paninis (all priced at $11.99) and a large selection of Italian-style Wedges, ensuring a quick and satisfying lunch.
• Appetizer Variety: The appetizer and side menu is massive, featuring classics like Buffalo Wings, Mozzarella Sticks, and house-made specialties such as Arancini ($9.99) and six types of Stuffed Garlic Knots ($5.99 each), demonstrating a dedication to classic comfort food.
• Friendly, Family-Focused Atmosphere: Being Family owned and operated with a Cozy environment and friendly staff, the restaurant delivers a highly personalized experience that makes diners feel like they are being “waited on by a good friend.”

For New York customers in the Eastchester area and beyond, The Pizza Shop is easily reachable via phone and physical address.

Address: 9 Mill Rd, Eastchester, NY 10709, USA

Phone Number: (914) 961-1999

Mobile Phone: +1 914-961-1999

Note: Business hours are typically Monday through Saturday from 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 9:00 PM (Hours may vary and should be confirmed directly with the restaurant).

The Pizza Shop stands out in the competitive New York market because it successfully merges the quick convenience of a pizzeria with the expansive, quality-driven menu of a full Italian restaurant. For local users, this establishment is the ideal choice for its unparalleled versatility and quality.

Choosing The Pizza Shop means getting an all-in-one Italian dining solution. You can satisfy a craving for a traditional New York-style slice or indulge in a full, sophisticated dinner entrée. Few pizzerias offer a dinner menu that includes premium dishes like Grilled Salmon Dinner, Veal Piccata Dinner, and a wide variety of shrimp and veal preparations, all served with dedicated Table service. This is what makes it a true Italian Restaurant, not just a pizza joint.

The commitment to variety also extends to convenience. The availability of No-contact delivery, along with a specialized menu for Catering and a family-friendly dine-in environment, means The Pizza Shop can handle any occasion. Whether it is a quick Lunch via a signature Panini or a celebratory Dinner with the family, the customer experience is always prioritized. The fact that customers highlight the genuinely friendly staff and clean environment further reinforces the choice. When you need authentic Italian Comfort food in Eastchester, from a simple, perfectly crafted Calzone to an elaborate, multi-course meal, The Pizza Shop delivers quality and hospitality that New Yorkers value.

The Pizza Shop

9 Mill Rd, Eastchester, NY 10709, USA