Tosco's Pizzeria

- 400 NY-17M, Monroe, NY 10950

For residents across Orange County and the wider New York region, Tosco's Pizzeria in Monroe stands as a true local institution and a celebrated hub for both classic Italian-American comfort food and inventive pizza creations. This establishment transcends the typical neighborhood slice shop, operating as a full-service Italian restaurant that places a strong emphasis on hearty portions, reasonable pricing, and exceptional menu variety. Family-owned and operated since 1987 in the Hudson Valley, Tosco's Pizzeria prides itself on a welcoming, Casual atmosphere that caters to a diverse crowd, including Locals, College students, Families, and large Groups.

The restaurant’s heritage, hailing from the Tosco family who immigrated from Sicily, Italy, shines through in the authenticity and care put into their extensive offerings. Patrons frequently highlight the “generous serving size” and the comprehensive nature of the menu, which goes far beyond simple pies to include Specialty Pizza, Hot Subs, Cold Subs, Wraps, Pasta dishes, and a full range of Our Specialty Dishes. Notably, customer feedback praises the value, with one long-time patron remarking that a generous Chicken Scarpariello entree was priced significantly lower than what they would pay in northern New Jersey for less food.

Tosco’s Pizzeria is designed for convenience, categorized as a Pizza restaurant, an Italian restaurant, and a Delivery Restaurant, ensuring that whether you want a quick bite while Solo dining, a full family dinner, or Catering for an event, they have a service option to meet your needs. While known for its classic Cheese Pizza in multiple large sizes (16” Med, 18” Lg, 20” XLG, and 24” XXL), the adventurous specialty options like the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Penne Alla Vodka Pizza, or the unique Sweet Chili Calamari Pizza draw significant attention and solidify Tosco’s reputation as a creative culinary destination in the Monroe, NY area.

Tosco's Pizzeria enjoys a highly visible and easily accessible location right on a major state route, making it an extremely convenient stop for New York travelers and local residents alike. The restaurant is located at:

400 NY-17M, Monroe, NY 10950, USA

Situated directly on NY-17M, the restaurant is simple to navigate to, whether you are coming from the immediate Monroe area or the broader Orange County region. The location has been optimized for effortless customer access and comfort, particularly for those utilizing a vehicle:

• Free parking lot.
• Free street parking.
• On-site parking.

In line with providing a fully accessible experience for the diverse New York crowd, Tosco's Pizzeria is equipped with several features to accommodate all guests:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot.
• Wheelchair accessible restroom.
• Wheelchair accessible seating.

This prime location combined with comprehensive accessibility ensures that everyone in the Family, from students to large Groups, can comfortably visit for Lunch or Dinner.

Tosco's Pizzeria excels in offering a multitude of flexible service options designed to meet the fast-paced and varied demands of the New York clientele. The array of options ensures that quality Italian and pizza are available whenever and wherever a customer needs it:

• Comprehensive Service Options: The restaurant offers a full range of service types: Dine-in for a Casual meal, Takeout for quick pickup, and full Delivery, including Curbside pickup and No-contact delivery options for maximum convenience.
• Catering Services: Tosco's provides Catering for private events, business functions, and parties, allowing customers to bring their generous portions of Italian and specialty dishes to any large gathering.
• Flexible Dining Times: Serves Lunch and Dinner, making it a reliable spot for a meal at any time of day, whether for a quick bite or a full seated experience.
• Payment Convenience: Accepts a variety of modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, providing simple, seamless transactions. Note that the restaurant may apply an extra charge for credit card use in-store, an important detail for New York users planning their payment method.
• Family and Children Accommodations: The venue is recognized as Good for kids, offering High chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu to ensure a Family-friendly dining experience.
• Wide Menu Variety: Beyond pizza, the menu includes numerous options in the form of Cold Subs, Hot Subs, Calzone & Stromboli, Wraps, Soups, Salads, and a separate Mexican Menu, offering an unexpected diversity that caters to nearly every craving.

Tosco's Pizzeria stands out in the competitive New York food scene due to its distinctive features and commitment to exceptional value:

• Extensive Specialty Pizza Menu: The selection is a major highlight, featuring over 25 unique Specialty Pizza options. These range from Italian classics like Margherita and Sicilian Pizza to creative pies such as Chicken Bacon Ranch, Baked Ziti, Shrimp Scampi, and even Mexican Pizza and Taco Pizza, ensuring there is a compelling option for every taste.
• Focus on Generous Portions and Value: Patrons consistently praise the generous serving size of entrees like the Chicken Scarpariello, emphasizing that the food is very reasonably priced for the amount provided—a key consideration for New York diners looking for value.
• Diverse Comfort Food Offerings: Beyond pizza, the menu serves as a true Italian-American comfort food destination, featuring classic Pasta dishes (Lasagna, Penne Alla Vodka), Veal and Chicken Specialties (Marsala, Francese, Parmigiana), and robust heroes and paninis, all suitable for a Quick bite or a hearty dinner.
• Authentic Italian Heritage: The restaurant is rooted in a Sicilian family tradition, aiming to provide "real food that is fresh, healthy, and authentic," reflecting a deep, multi-generational love for quality food.
• Flexibility for All Customers: The Casual atmosphere and extensive seating make it popular for Lunch and Dinner, perfectly accommodating both large Groups and patrons enjoying Solo dining.
• Unconventional Menu Additions: The inclusion of a full Mexican Menu, featuring Tacos, Fajitas, and Chimichangas, provides an unexpected and enjoyable element of variety, distinguishing Tosco's from standard pizzerias.

For New York patrons wishing to place an order, make inquiries about Catering, or learn more about the menu at Tosco's Pizzeria in Monroe, please use the following contact details:

Address: 400 NY-17M, Monroe, NY 10950, USA

Phone: (845) 783-2411

Mobile Phone: +1 845-783-2411

Tosco's Pizzeria is worth choosing for New York residents because it represents the pinnacle of convenient, value-driven, and high-quality local Italian and pizza dining in the Hudson Valley. While New York has countless pizza options, Tosco’s sets itself apart with its extraordinary menu depth, moving far beyond a simple slice shop to become a full-fledged Italian eatery and Catering provider.

The sheer variety on the menu—from a 24-inch Cheese Pizza to Specialty Pizzas that include gourmet toppings like grilled chicken, roasted peppers, and fresh mozzarella (Tosco's Pizza), to classic Italian entrees like Zuppa Di Pesce and Chicken Marsala—means there is truly something to satisfy every member of a Family or Group. The portion sizes are particularly noteworthy and serve as a strong value proposition, providing an excellent return on investment for the price, which is often cited as significantly better than competitors in surrounding New Jersey and New York areas.

Moreover, the commitment to modern convenience is a major advantage. With multiple service options including Curbside pickup and Delivery, Tosco's ensures that great food is never more than a phone call or click away. Although there are some mixed reviews regarding consistency, particularly with side items like garlic knots and the pricing discrepancies between online and in-store orders, the overall consensus for the main entrees and specialty pizzas is overwhelmingly positive, with many customers affirming it as their "go-to" spot for great food in Monroe. For a generous, satisfying, and authentically diverse Italian and pizza experience, Tosco's Pizzeria on NY-17M is the definitive local choice.

Tosco's Pizzeria

400 NY-17M, Monroe, NY 10950, USA