Toto's

- 3275 Byron St, Wantagh, NY 11793

For New Yorkers seeking a sophisticated and high-quality dining experience on the South Shore of Long Island, Toto's in Wantagh presents itself as a must-visit Italian Steakhouse. It is a true hidden gem, providing a blend of classic steakhouse excellence and authentic Northern Italian culinary flair. Toto’s is not just a restaurant; it’s an upscale destination for those who appreciate prime cuts of meat, fresh seafood, and meticulously prepared Italian specialties.

The atmosphere at Toto's is designed to be cozy, trendy, and notably upscale, making it an ideal location for a special occasion, an impressive date night, or a celebratory dinner with a group. With a commitment to quality that includes using only the finest ingredients—such as Black Angus or better steaks, and wild, not farm-raised, shrimp—the restaurant focuses on delivering an incredible value through superior food and service. The dining experience is enhanced by attentive, accommodating, and engaging staff, ensuring a wonderful time from appetizer to dessert.

Location and Accessibility

Toto's is conveniently located at 3275 Byron St, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA. Nestled on Byron Street, the restaurant is situated in a residential part of Wantagh, providing a pleasant, neighborhood feel while still being easily accessible from major Long Island roads in Nassau County. The address places it right next to the historic Jones Beach Hotel, linking it to a tradition of high-quality dining in the area.

The establishment prioritizes accessibility and convenience for its patrons, offering several important amenities:

• Parking: Guests benefit from a free parking lot, eliminating the typical New York frustration of searching for parking, especially important for a dinner destination.
• Wheelchair Accessibility: The venue is fully equipped to accommodate all guests, featuring a wheelchair-accessible entrance, parking lot, restroom, and seating.
• Outdoor Seating: For those who enjoy dining al fresco, Toto's offers an outdoor seating option, perfect for enjoying a cocktail or dessert on a pleasant evening.

Services Offered

Toto's offers a refined, full-service dining experience, focusing on high-quality food and drink service throughout the evening:

• Dine-in: Offering an upscale environment with table service, perfect for dinner. The atmosphere is cozy and trendy, attracting groups and solo diners alike.
• Takeout: Meals can be ordered for takeout, providing a way for patrons to enjoy the high-quality cuisine at home.
• Reservations: Dinner reservations are highly recommended and accepted, a necessity for planning an evening out at this popular spot and ensuring minimal wait time.
• Bar Onsite: A fully stocked bar is available, featuring great cocktails, hard liquor, beer, and a Great wine list.
• Dining Options: The focus is on Dinner and Dessert, with the kitchen offering a wide range of menu items from Appetizers, Pastas & Risottos, Fish, and, of course, their signature prime Meats.
• Amenities: The inclusion of an onsite bar, comfortable seating, and a restroom ensures a complete and pleasant dining experience.
• Family-Friendly: Though upscale, the restaurant is "Good for kids" and provides high chairs, making it suitable for family celebrations.

Features / Highlights

What sets Toto's apart is its seamless fusion of an upscale steakhouse experience with authentic Italian culinary principles. Key features and highlights include:

• Prime Meats and Steaks: The menu specializes in prime meats, with steaks noted as "Black Angus or better." A reviewer's filet mignon was described as "amazing," indicating the high quality and preparation of the signature dishes.
• Authentic Italian Specialties: Beyond steaks, the menu offers a rich selection of Italian-American classics and regional dishes, including Veal Tre Funghi, Chicken Francese, homemade Pappardelle Bolognese, Lobster Ravioli, and Gnocchi Contadina with filet mignon chunks.
• Exceptional Seafood: The commitment to quality extends to seafood, with offerings such as Crispy Skin Salmon, Whole Mediterranean Sea Bass (Branzino), Twin Lobster Tails, and chilled jumbo Shrimp Cocktail.
• House-Made Desserts: The dessert menu is a major highlight, with items like the Tiramisu and Tartuffo being made on-site and described as "did not disappoint." Other options include Lava Cake, Cheesecake, and Key Lime Pie.
• Great Beverage Program: Toto's is specifically highlighted for its Great cocktails and Great wine list, offering a well-rounded selection of Alcohol, Beer, Hard liquor, and an array of coffees, from Espresso to Irish Coffee.
• Live Entertainment: As noted by one customer, the inclusion of a keyboard player adds a special touch to the atmosphere, enhancing the upscale and cozy dining experience.
• Generous Portions and Presentation: While portion sizes are substantial—a fish dish, though not specified, resulted in leftovers for one guest—the food is consistently described as "cooked to perfection."

Contact Information

For New York diners interested in experiencing Toto's Italian Steakhouse, please use the following contact details:

Address: 3275 Byron St, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA

Phone: (516) 783-6484

Mobile Phone: +1 516-783-6484

It is strongly advised to call and accept reservations before visiting for dinner.

What is Worth Choosing

For New Yorkers on Long Island seeking a premium dining experience, Toto's is the clear choice for several compelling reasons:

• The Perfect Italian Steakhouse Fusion: Toto's successfully marries the robust flavor profiles of a classic American steakhouse (prime meats, full bar) with the elegance and pasta/seafood offerings of an authentic Italian restaurant, providing a unique and expansive menu rarely found in the area.
• Commitment to Quality Ingredients: The explicit use of Black Angus or better steaks and wild shrimp, coupled with the owner's extensive restaurant background, assures diners they are receiving superior ingredients and preparation techniques.
• Ideal Ambiance for Special Occasions: The upscale, cozy, and trendy atmosphere—complete with a bar and live entertainment—makes Toto's the go-to choice for celebrating birthdays, anniversaries, or hosting an important group dinner where a high-end experience is desired.
• Acclaimed Desserts and Drinks: The rave reviews for the house-made desserts, particularly the Tiramisu, alongside the highlight on great cocktails and an excellent wine list, ensure that the dining experience finishes on a high note.

Despite a single mention of minor food and service issues (tough pork chop, undercooked broccoli rabe, and service protocol), the overwhelming consensus of a "wonderful dining experience" and a commitment to quality dining makes Toto's a premier choice for steak and Italian cuisine in Wantagh.

Toto's

3275 Byron St, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA