Umberto's of Oyster Bay

- 25 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

For New York residents—especially those on Long Island—the name Umberto's is synonymous with authentic, quality Italian-American cuisine, and Umberto's of Oyster Bay proudly carries on that tradition. More than just a local pizzeria, this establishment operates as both a dedicated pizza destination and a full-service Italian restaurant, offering a staggering array of dishes from classic New York slices to gourmet baked pastas and full chicken and seafood entrees.

Umberto’s of Oyster Bay is deeply rooted in the area's dining scene, providing comfort food with a professional touch. The atmosphere is designed to be casual and cozy, making it an ideal spot for any occasion, whether it’s a quick solo lunch, a family dinner, or a late-night bite. Adding to its unique standing in the community, the business proudly identifies as women-owned, contributing to the diverse entrepreneurial landscape of Oyster Bay.

The core of the menu is built around legendary New York-style pizza, most notably the famous Grandma Pie, which is a staple across many Long Island pizzerias. However, what truly sets this location apart is its remarkable commitment to inclusivity. While catering expertly to traditional tastes with favorites like Sicilian Pie and the Buffalo Chicken Regular Pie, Umberto's of Oyster Bay also offers one of the most extensive and highly-praised selections of vegan Italian food available in the region.

The extensive menu is designed to satisfy virtually any craving. For a quick bite, patrons can choose from dozens of pizza slices, rolls like the Buffalo Chicken Roll, or classic Garlic Knots (including a vegan option). For a full, sit-down meal, the offerings expand dramatically to include full-sized pies, baked pastas such as Baked Ziti Siciliana, and classic Italian hero sandwiches.

One customer review highlighted the impressive quality of the plant-based offerings, specifically the Vegan Grandma Pie, which was a hit even with non-vegan guests. The breadth of the vegan menu, which includes Vegan Puttanesca pasta, Vegan Eggplant Roll, and even Daiya Vegan Mozzarella Sticks, demonstrates a genuine effort to cater to all dietary preferences, making it a standout choice for the health-conscious and vegetarian community on Long Island.

Location and Accessibility

Umberto's of Oyster Bay is conveniently located at a prime spot in the Oyster Bay community, making it highly accessible for local residents and visitors alike. The exact location is:

25 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

The restaurant has taken steps to ensure a welcoming environment for everyone, providing essential accessibility features:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance for easy access into the restaurant space.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring convenience from arrival.
• Wheelchair accessible restroom to accommodate all patrons comfortably.
• The establishment maintains an inclusive environment, identifying as LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safespace.

Services Offered

Umberto's of Oyster Bay provides versatile service options tailored to modern New York lifestyles:

• Dine-in: Enjoy the cozy, casual atmosphere with full seating and table service for lunch and dinner.
• Takeout: Orders can be conveniently picked up at the restaurant.
• Delivery: Offering home delivery service, though prospective customers should verify the current delivery radius, as service areas can sometimes change.
• No-Contact Delivery: For maximum safety and convenience, especially appreciated by New York-area residents, this option is available.
• Outdoor Seating: Seating is available outside, perfect for enjoying a meal on pleasant days.
• Catering: Comprehensive catering options are available for special events and gatherings, suitable for both family and corporate needs.

Features / Highlights

Umberto's of Oyster Bay is distinguished by several key features and offerings:

• Women-Owned Business: Proudly identified as a women-owned establishment, supporting local female entrepreneurship.
• Extensive Vegan Menu: A truly impressive range of vegan options, including the popular Vegan Grandma Pie, Vegan Eggplant Parmigiana, and 10" Vegan Pizzetta.
• Fast Service: Noted for fast service, making it an excellent choice for a quick lunch or a dinner when time is short.
• Late-Night Food: Offers late-night food options, catering to those who prefer dining later in the evening.
• Diverse Italian Cuisine: Goes far beyond pizza, offering full chicken, shrimp, and eggplant entrees (e.g., Chicken Marsala, Shrimp Fra Diavolo), baked pastas, heroes, and salads.
• Family-Friendly: Clearly marked as good for kids, the restaurant also features a dedicated kids' menu.
• Beverages & Offerings: Provides alcohol and wine, alongside options for comfort food, small plates, and vegetarian selections.

Contact Information

To place an order, make inquiries, or visit the location, use the following details:

• Address: 25 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
• Phone: (516) 922-0434
• Mobile Phone: +1 516-922-0434
• Payments: Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments for streamlined transactions.

What is Worth Choosing Umberto's of Oyster Bay?

For New Yorkers on the hunt for a superior Italian-American experience, Umberto's of Oyster Bay offers a unique blend of heritage, quality, and modern inclusivity. What makes it a top choice is the sheer variety and quality of its menu. Whether you are craving a traditional, thick-crusted Sicilian Slice, a trendy Sweet Chili Chicken Grandma Pie, or a completely plant-based meal, this restaurant caters to all with equal dedication. The rave reviews for the Vegan Grandma Pie show that the kitchen excels in adapting classics for contemporary tastes without sacrificing flavor.

The fast service and multiple ordering options—including dine-in, takeout, and no-contact delivery—make it a practical choice for busy individuals and families. Furthermore, the commitment to being a family-friendly, welcoming space (LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safespace) ensures a positive and comfortable dining experience for a diverse Long Island crowd. While one review mentioned an issue with a hero and delivery range, the overwhelming evidence of the extensive menu, fast service, and high praise for specialty items like the vegan pizza and various baked goods solidifies Umberto's of Oyster Bay as a must-try local business. It's the perfect spot where classic Long Island pizza culture meets modern dietary needs, all under the banner of a women-owned, community-focused establishment.

Umberto's of Oyster Bay

25 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA