125th Street Pizza of Harlem ™

- 256 E 125th St, New York, NY 10035

When it comes to authentic New York pizza, few places capture the essence of a classic neighborhood joint quite like 125th Street Pizza of Harlem ™. This beloved spot, located in the heart of one of the city's most historic and vibrant neighborhoods, has earned a reputation for serving up genuine, hand-made pizza pies that stand out even in a city saturated with pizzerias. It's the kind of place that understands what makes a great slice: a perfectly crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and fresh toppings.

More than just a place to grab a slice, 125th Street Pizza of Harlem is a cornerstone of the community. The restaurant has garnered praise not only for its delicious food but also for its heartwarming commitment to local initiatives. With a strong focus on giving back and a welcoming atmosphere, this pizza joint is more than a business; it’s a destination that embodies the soul of Harlem. From the first bite of a classic pie to the friendly service, the experience here is truly memorable.

The menu is a celebration of both classic Italian-American fare and creative, modern interpretations. While the pizza is the main attraction, the menu also features a variety of overstuffed sandwiches, savory appetizers, and decadent desserts. This diverse offering ensures that there is something for everyone, whether you’re a long-time local, a first-time visitor, or a family looking for a delicious meal.

125th Street Pizza of Harlem ™ is conveniently located at 256 E 125th St, New York, NY 10035, USA. This address places it in a prime spot in the bustling heart of Harlem, a neighborhood renowned for its rich history, cultural landmarks, and lively atmosphere. The location on East 125th Street makes it highly accessible for both local residents and tourists exploring the area.

The restaurant's central location ensures it's easy to reach by public transportation. East 125th Street is a major transit hub, with multiple subway and bus lines serving the area. This makes it a simple and quick stop for anyone traveling from various parts of the city. For those who prefer to drive, the area offers a variety of parking options, including free street parking, paid street parking, and paid parking garages and lots, providing flexibility for all visitors. While public data doesn't specify interior accessibility, its location and service options are geared for convenience.

• Dine-in: The restaurant offers a casual and welcoming space for customers to sit down and enjoy their meal. It's an ideal spot for a relaxed lunch or a satisfying dinner with friends and family.

• Takeout: For those on the go, the takeout service is a perfect option. You can place your order and pick it up to enjoy at home, at a park, or anywhere else you choose.

• Delivery: 125th Street Pizza of Harlem provides both standard and no-contact delivery, bringing their delicious pizzas and other menu items right to your doorstep, a huge convenience for a busy city lifestyle.

• Curbside Pickup: This service allows you to place an order ahead of time and have it brought to your car, providing a quick and seamless way to get your food without having to park or go inside.

• Catering: With a variety of large pizza pies and other items, the restaurant is well-equipped to handle catering orders, making it a great choice for events, parties, and office lunches.

• Authentic New York-Style Pizza: Customers consistently praise the pizza for being a "proper pizza joint" with "great NY style" pies. The hand-made dough and flavorful ingredients are key highlights, proving its authenticity and quality.

• Specialty Pizza Pies: The menu features an impressive list of specialty pies, each with a unique and creative name, such as The Harlem Truffle Pizza, The Apollo Pizza, and The Westies Pizza. This variety ensures there's always a new flavor to explore beyond the classic options.

• Community Focus: The restaurant is more than just a business; it's a positive force in the community. The owner’s initiative to reward children with free pizza for book reports and the use of tips for art supplies for kids at a cancer hospital are powerful examples of its commitment to giving back, making it a place you can feel good about supporting.

• LGBTQ+ and Transgender Safe Space: The restaurant identifies as an LGBTQ+ friendly and transgender safe space, highlighting its inclusive and welcoming atmosphere for all members of the community. This feature is a testament to its open and accepting nature.

• Variety of Offerings: Beyond pizza, the menu includes a wide range of offerings, including "award-winning" overstuffed heroes like the Joe's Sliced Steak Hero, classic Italian appetizers, and decadent desserts. This diversity ensures that there's something for every craving.

• Vegan and Vegetarian Options: The menu includes specific options for plant-based diners, such as The Vegan Margherita and The Veggie Pizza, making it a great choice for those with different dietary preferences.

For orders or inquiries, you can contact 125th Street Pizza of Harlem ™ at the following:

Address: 256 E 125th St, New York, NY 10035, USA

Phone: (929) 470-4748

When you visit 125th Street Pizza of Harlem ™, the menu is a feast of delicious options, but a few items are particularly worth choosing for a truly authentic and satisfying experience. The restaurant’s specialty is its pizza, and that's where you should start your culinary journey.

For a true taste of New York, the Classic Brooklyn Born Pizza is a non-negotiable choice. This large pizza pie, known for its classic flavor and handmade dough, provides a perfect baseline for what makes this place special. For those who love a bit of a kick, the Cotton Club Pepperoni Pizza is another top choice, loaded with flavorful pepperoni.

However, what truly sets this place apart are the specialty pies. The Harlem Truffle Pizza is a standout, and a must-try for those who enjoy a richer, more sophisticated flavor. Customers have specifically praised this pie, noting that it "didn't disappoint." The Porcini Mushroom Pizza is another excellent choice for mushroom lovers, offering a deep, earthy flavor. The Vegan Margherita is a great option that proves you don't need dairy to enjoy a delicious, cheesy pizza experience.

Beyond the pizza, the Award-Winning Overstuffed Sandwiches are also a popular choice. The Joe's Sliced Steak (Filet Mignon) Hero is a luxurious and highly-recommended item, promising a truly decadent meal. Finally, don't forget to save room for dessert. The Cannoli and Tiramisu Slice are classic Italian desserts that provide a perfect, sweet end to a savory meal. Choosing a classic pie alongside a specialty one is the best way to fully appreciate the range and quality of what 125th Street Pizza of Harlem has to offer.

125th Street Pizza of Harlem ™

256 E 125th St, New York, NY 10035, USA