16 Handles

- 300 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Welcome to the sweetest spot in Brooklyn! For New Yorkers craving a custom-made, refreshing treat, 16 Handles in Cobble Hill is an essential destination. Situated on Court Street, this locally cherished dessert shop is more than just an ice cream parlor; it’s a full-fledged self-serve frozen dessert experience. Since its founding in 2008 as New York City's first self-serve frozen dessert shop, 16 Handles has grown to be a leading soft-serve and frozen yogurt brand in the city, beloved for its quality, variety, and fun, expressive atmosphere. It’s where quality meets creativity, offering a rotating selection of 16 innovative soft-serve flavors, including traditional frozen yogurt, rich ice cream, and cutting-edge vegan options, all complemented by an endless toppings bar with over 50 premium choices. Whether you're a long-time Brooklyn resident or just visiting the Cobble Hill area, 16 Handles provides the perfect environment for a family outing, a casual date night, or a solo sweet indulgence.

The brand’s commitment to self-expression and community engagement is clear in every aspect of the shop, making it a true neighborhood cornerstone. Patrons consistently praise the clean, inviting environment and the friendliness of the staff and managers, all of which contribute to a top-tier dessert experience. In a city where dessert options abound, 16 Handles distinguishes itself by catering to all preferences and dietary needs—from nonfat and no-sugar-added frozen yogurt to all-natural ice cream and top-tier plant-based soft serve, often in partnership with brands like Oatly. This Cobble Hill location continues that tradition, offering a modern, enjoyable space where every customer can "swirl" their own perfect creation. If you are searching for a high-quality dessert with options for everyone, your search ends at 300 Court Street.

Location and Accessibility

The Cobble Hill 16 Handles location is conveniently situated in the heart of Brooklyn, serving as an easily accessible oasis for frozen yogurt enthusiasts. You’ll find this inviting small business at 300 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA. This prime spot on Court Street makes it a perfect stop after catching a movie at the Cobble Hill Cinemas or a pleasant treat while strolling through the charming neighborhood. Its central placement aims to be a community-driven destination, providing a warm and energetic vibe that encourages neighbors and friends to gather. The shop is designed with the comfort and convenience of all guests in mind, featuring a modern store aesthetic with lounge-style seating, perfect for relaxing.

For New York locals concerned with accessibility, this location goes above and beyond to ensure a pleasant visit for everyone. Amenities include a wheelchair accessible restroom and designated wheelchair accessible seating, demonstrating a commitment to inclusion. The location is easily reachable by various means of transportation and offers street parking options. Visitors can look for free street parking or paid street parking in the vicinity, which is a great convenience in this popular Brooklyn area. The combination of a fantastic product and thoughtful, accessible design cements 16 Handles as a community hub in Cobble Hill, ready to welcome patrons throughout the week.

Services Offered

16 Handles offers a comprehensive suite of services designed for maximum customer convenience, whether you prefer to enjoy your treat on-site or from the comfort of your home. They have adapted their service model to fit the dynamic life of New Yorkers, ensuring a high-quality experience across all touchpoints.

• Dine-In: Enjoy the inviting, modern store design and lounge-style seating for a relaxed dessert experience.
• Takeout: Quickly grab your self-serve creation and enjoy it on the go as you explore Cobble Hill.
• Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Order your favorite frozen treats right to your door through popular online ordering platforms, perfect for a late-night craving or a party.
• Curbside Pickup and In-Store Pickup: Place your order ahead of time and choose the most convenient way to receive it, minimizing wait times.
• Onsite Services: The store provides restrooms and Wi-Fi for customer comfort.
• A Small Business Focus: Operating as a small business, the location emphasizes quality service and a deep connection to the local Cobble Hill community.
• Milkshakes: In addition to soft serve, they craft delicious milkshakes in popular flavors like Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, and Cookies & Cream.
• Bottled Beverages: A selection of thirst-quenchers is available, including Can of Coke, Can of Diet Coke, Can of Sprite, and various sizes of bottled water.

Features / Highlights

What makes 16 Handles a New York City staple and a premier dessert shop? The brand has consistently innovated and focused on the customer experience, making it stand out among the crowded dessert landscape. This Cobble Hill location perfectly embodies the core values and popular features that New Yorkers love.

• Self-Serve Customization: The cornerstone of the 16 Handles experience, allowing guests to control their portion size and mix and match from 16 rotating soft-serve flavors and over 50 toppings.
• Extensive Flavor Variety: The menu includes an impressive range of soft-serve types, including nonfat, low-fat, no-sugar-added, sorbets, and rich, all-natural ice cream.
• Vegan and Plant-Based Excellence: Consistently offering high-quality, industry-leading vegan soft serve options, such as Oat Milk Vanilla Soft Serve and Fresh Mango Sorbet, catering to a growing demand for dairy-free treats. Customers often rave about the unique vegan flavors available.
• Signature and Seasonal Flavors: The shop keeps the menu exciting with both classic staples—like Original Tart Frozen Yogurt, Classic Vanilla Frozen Yogurt, and Chocolicious Frozen Yogurt—and seasonal hits like the Oh My, Pumpkin Pie Frozen Yogurt.
• Artisan Ingredients: A commitment to quality is evident in proprietary flavors made with real ingredients, such as frozen yogurt made with real cocoa or ice cream folded with real OREO® cookies. The addition of Peanut Butter Cup Frozen Yogurt and Birthday Cake Frozen Yogurt ensures crowd-pleasing options are always on tap.
• Customer Praise for Service: Reviews highlight the great staff and friendly, polite managers, contributing to the store's reputation as a happy and welcoming place.
• Flexible Payment Options: Accepts a variety of modern payment methods, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and easy.

Contact Information

For New Yorkers looking to visit, order, or inquire about catering options for their next event, here is the essential contact information for the Cobble Hill 16 Handles location:

Address: 300 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

Phone: (347) 384-2000

Mobile Phone: +1 347-384-2000

What is Worth Choosing

At 16 Handles, the freedom of choice is the ultimate indulgence. While every swirl is a personal journey, a few standout items and approaches make this shop a must-try for any New Yorker. Given the sheer variety, starting with the core offerings is always a safe bet.

The Original Tart Frozen Yogurt is a timeless classic that balances tartness and sweetness, perfect for the purist. For those who enjoy rich, decadent flavors, the Chocolicious Frozen Yogurt and the Cookies & Cream Ice Cream are consistently praised. The Cookies & Cream is a delightful, silky sweet cream base folded with real OREO® cookies—an absolute dream for cookie lovers.

However, what truly sets 16 Handles apart are the options that cater to specific dietary needs and adventurous palates. The commitment to plant-based desserts is outstanding. The Oat Milk Vanilla Soft Serve (V) is a creamy, dairy-free triumph that many claim is so good you wouldn’t know it was oat milk. Similarly, the Fresh Mango Sorbet (V) is a light, refreshing, and authentic fruit-flavored treat. Seasonal and specialty offerings, such as the cozy and spice-filled Oh My, Pumpkin Pie Frozen Yogurt (when available), or fun, unique flavors like Shirley Temple Sorbet, showcase the shop's innovative spirit.

Don't overlook the mix-ins. Since this is a self-serve format, you are the artist. Customers consistently love the quality and quantity of toppings available, from fresh fruit to crunchy candies and various syrups. As one happy customer noted, the ability to choose your own frozen yogurt and toppings makes the experience truly unique and enjoyable.

Finally, for a complete experience, consider one of their thick, creamy milkshakes. The Cookies & Cream Milkshake, made with crushed OREOs, offers a convenient, slurpable version of one of their most popular soft-serve bases. Whether you are creating a complex, multi-layered masterpiece or sticking to a single, perfect flavor, 16 Handles in Cobble Hill delivers a dessert experience that is high in quality, full of community spirit, and completely customized by you. It's truly "dessert for the people—all the people."

16 Handles

300 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA