Amy deli & grocery

- 1722 Bath Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214

In New York City, the term "deli" conjures images of pastrami towers and breakfast sandwiches. However, the beauty of Brooklyn lies in its diversity, and **Amy Deli & Grocery** on Bath Avenue is a perfect example of a neighborhood spot that goes above and beyond the typical corner store model. It’s a genuine fusion of a quick-stop grocery, a friendly community hub, and, most notably, the source of some of the **best Central American food** you can find in the Bensonhurst area.

What truly sets this establishment apart is its incredible, undeniable focus on authentic Salvadoran cuisine—specifically, the **pupusas**. These thick, stuffed griddle cakes (a national dish of El Salvador and Honduras) have cemented Amy Deli & Grocery's reputation among locals. Customers rave that the pupusas here are simply the **"best in Bensonhurst,"** praising everything from the flavor and texture of the corn cake to the perfect combination of fillings, such as cheese or chicharrón (pork rinds), all served alongside the essential, tangy **encurtido with jalapeño** (a pickled cabbage slaw).

Beyond the hot food counter, Amy Deli & Grocery also serves its role as a local market. While still **"starting off"** and expected to expand its inventory, it already stocks a specialized selection of **Central American products**, including a great assortment of **Hispanic candy and chips**, ice cream, and even unexpected items like **piñatas**. The combination of a friendly, accommodating staff and its unique culinary offering makes Amy Deli & Grocery an essential, must-visit destination for those in the 11214 area looking for authentic flavor and local charm. It provides quick service and a slice of Central American culture right here in Brooklyn.

Amy Deli & Grocery is centrally located in the Bath Beach section of Brooklyn, making it highly accessible for residents of Bensonhurst and surrounding neighborhoods. The store is situated in a busy commercial area, offering maximum convenience for a quick stop.

The full address is:

1722 Bath Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA

The location on Bath Avenue is positioned to cater to those needing a fast meal or quick groceries. The shop is designed for maximum convenience, categorized primarily for a **Quick visit**. For those who cannot make it to the store, the deli offers multiple options for accessing their delicious food without leaving home. The availability of an **ATM** on-site is a noteworthy point, especially given the current payment status, as detailed in the features section below.

Amy Deli & Grocery has tailored its services to meet the modern demands of New Yorkers, focusing on speed and various methods of purchase for both their deli items and groceries.

• **Pupuseria and Deli:** The core service is providing freshly prepared food, with a heavy emphasis on their highly-rated pupusas, alongside standard deli and grocery items.
• **Delivery:** For the ultimate convenience, customers can order their meals and groceries to be delivered directly to their homes or workplaces.
• **In-store pickup & Takeout:** Perfect for busy individuals, this allows patrons to quickly grab their prepared food or items with minimal waiting. The deli prioritizes the experience of a **Quick visit**.
• **Local Grocery:** The shop functions as a small-scale grocery, currently stocking **lots of Central American products**, including specialized candies and chips, fulfilling a niche market need in the neighborhood.
• **ATM Availability:** An important added amenity, the store provides an **ATM** for quick cash withdrawals, catering to all local patrons.
• **Digital Payment Options:** The store accepts various forms of non-cash payment, including **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments**, offering flexibility, though customers should be aware of a possible cash-only status (see Highlights).

Amy Deli & Grocery stands out not just as a store, but as a cultural destination for authentic Salvadoran cuisine in Brooklyn.

• **Home of Brooklyn’s Best Pupusas:** The most significant highlight is the quality of their pupusas, which are hailed by customers as the **"best in Bensonhurst."** They are made with various fillings, including chicharrón (pork) and cheese, and are served with the perfect accompanying **encurtido with jalapeño**.
• **Central American Grocery Selection:** The store offers a unique, specialized grocery stock, providing access to **lots of Central American products**, Hispanic candy, chips, and ice cream that are often hard to find in standard delis.
• **Friendly and Welcoming Staff:** Reviewers consistently mention the **very friendly service and staff**, which contributes to the positive, community-focused atmosphere of the deli.
• **Cash Only Warning (Contextual):** While the deli accepts digital payments, a recent customer noted a transition to a **“Cash only now”** status. This is a critical feature that customers should be prepared for, though the on-site ATM mitigates this need.
• **Unique Inventory Items:** The deli surprises patrons by selling **piñatas**, which further solidifies its role as a local source for Latin American cultural and party goods.
• **Quick-Stop Efficiency:** The business model is focused on the **Quick visit**, ensuring customers get their hot food and essential items without delay.

To place a pickup order, inquire about their specialized grocery stock, or simply get in touch with the friendly staff, you can use the following information:

Address: 1722 Bath Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA

Phone: (347) 458-2151

Mobile Phone: +1 347-458-2151

If you are a New Yorker living in or visiting the Bensonhurst area, Amy Deli & Grocery should be at the top of your list for a meal, and the reason is overwhelmingly clear: the **Pupusas**. These are Salvadoran **stuffed corn cakes** and are far from the average deli sandwich—they are a cultural staple and comfort food that Amy Deli & Grocery has perfected.

What makes the **Pupusas** here so exceptional is the combination of **size, price, and quality**. Customers who have tried pupusas elsewhere in the area declare Amy's version to be the best, particularly due to the perfect taste of the pupusa itself and the crucial accompaniment: the **encurtido with jalapeño**. This slightly tangy, spicy slaw cuts through the rich, cheesy filling, creating a balanced and addictive experience. We recommend trying the **Chicharrones (pork) or cheese** varieties. When local Brooklynites declare a food item is the **"best in town,"** that's a statement that needs to be explored.

Beyond the food, this deli is worth choosing for its unique role in the community. If you need authentic **Central American grocery items**, unique **Hispanic chips and candies**, or even a **piñata** for a celebration, this is your local go-to spot. The proprietors run the store with a **very friendly and accommodating spirit**, making the entire experience pleasant. Just remember the local advice: while they accept cards, bringing cash or using the on-site **ATM** might be the fastest way to transact and ensure you get your hands on those incredible pupusas without delay.

Amy deli & grocery

1722 Bath Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA