Bagelry: Rockville Centre's Top Bagel Shop, Coffee Bar, and Catering Specialist

Bagelry Introduce

In the fiercely competitive world of New York bagels, the **Bagelry** in Rockville Centre, Long Island, has established itself as a cornerstone of the community. More than just a traditional **Bagel shop**, it operates as a full-service **Breakfast restaurant**, **Brunch restaurant**, and **Coffee shop**, all rolled into one convenient location. For busy New Yorkers, this establishment is the go-to spot for starting the day right, offering quick, delicious meals and high-quality coffee.

As a **women-owned, small business** that proudly identifies as **LGBTQ+ friendly** and a **Transgender safespace**, Bagelry offers a welcoming environment for everyone, prioritizing community and inclusivity alongside its diverse menu. Patrons visit not only for the classic **Bagel** and rich array of specialty cream cheeses (like **Lox Spread** or **Walnut Raisin**), but also for their extensive offerings of **Egg Sandwiches**, bakery items like the **Chocolate Croissant**, and healthy choices such as the **Low Fat Yogurt Parfait**. Furthermore, its comprehensive **Catering** service makes it a vital partner for offices and events throughout Nassau County.

While the competitive nature of the bagel business means that customers occasionally voice strong opinions on product consistency, the Bagelry’s wide scope of services and commitment to community make it an indispensable local resource. They cater to a **Quick visit** crowd, proving to be the ideal morning stop before catching the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) or heading to work.

Location and Accessibility in Rockville Centre, Long Island

The **Bagelry** is strategically positioned at **1 N Park Ave, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA**. This address is highly advantageous, placing the shop right near the intersection of North Park Avenue and the core commercial area of Rockville Centre. Its location is highly convenient for local residents and commuters alike, often serving as a necessary stop on the way to the nearby LIRR station.

The shop ensures good access for all customers, featuring a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating**. While the area is busy, Bagelry is located where New Yorkers have access to various parking options, including both **Paid parking lot** and **Paid street parking**, allowing for a quick pop-in or a more leisurely dine-in experience.

Services and Comprehensive Offerings

The Bagelry distinguishes itself through the breadth and depth of its product and service offerings, extending far beyond the traditional New York **Bagel shop**.

**Full Breakfast & Brunch Menu:** Offers a complete range of morning meals, including multiple styles of **Egg Sandwiches** on bagels, rolls, or croissants, **Oatmeal**, **Yogurt Parfaits**, and various **Bakery** items like muffins and scones.
**Specialty Bagel Products:** Provides traditional bagels, a **Baker’s Dozen**, and unique items like the **Flat Bagel** and **Mini Bagel**, catering to different tastes and portion preferences.
**Lunch and Sandwich Shop Services:** Functions as a robust **Sandwich shop** with a variety of wraps and classic deli sandwiches, including specialty salads like **Tuna Salad** and **Whitefish Salad**, which can also be purchased **By the Pound**.
**Extensive Coffee Bar:** Features a wide selection of **Hot Coffee**, **Flavored Hot Coffee**, and various sized **Iced Coffee** options, including **Flavored Iced Coffee**, **Iced Green Tea**, and specialty drinks. A **Box Of Coffee** is available for group gatherings.
**Full-Scale Catering:** As a prominent **Caterer**, the Bagelry offers comprehensive catering menus for eggs, egg mini bagels, sandwiches, salads, fish, and by-the-pound deli items, making it ideal for office lunches or large family breakfasts in Nassau County.
**Flexible Service Options:** Customers can utilize **Delivery**, **In-store pickup**, **In-store shopping**, and **Takeout** for a seamless experience. **Dine-in** service is also provided.
**Community-Focused Amenities:** Features a **Gender-neutral restroom** and is recognized as an **LGBTQ+ friendly** and **Transgender safespace**.

Features and Highlights of the Bagelry

The Bagelry’s identity is built upon several defining features that make it a favorite local spot for New Yorkers.

**Community and Inclusivity:** The business proudly identifies as **women-owned**, a **small business**, and is recognized as an **LGBTQ+ friendly** and **Transgender safespace**, fostering a welcoming and safe environment for all customers.
**Diverse Cream Cheese Selection:** Offers an impressive variety of house-made cream cheese flavors, including savory options like **Scallion**, **Jalapeno**, and **Olive**, as well as sweet choices like **Walnut Raisin**, catering to the sophisticated tastes of Long Island bagel aficionados.
**Specialty Mini Bagel Products:** The option for **Mini Bagel** and **Mini Egg Sandwiches** provides perfect, smaller-portioned options for kids, light eaters, or as a cost-effective choice for catering.
**Full Bakery Options:** Going beyond the bagel, the shop offers a range of high-quality baked goods, such as **Chocolate Croissant**, **Raspberry Crumb Cake**, and the large **Black And White Cookies**, diversifying their quick breakfast offerings.
**Comprehensive Deli and Salad Menu:** Functions effectively as a **Sandwich shop**, offering unique deli salads like **Craisin Chicken Salad** and **Curry Mango Chicken Salad**, which appeal to those looking for a gourmet lunch option.
**Extensive Catering Capabilities:** The highly detailed and expansive catering menu for bagels, egg sandwiches, and deli meats makes the Bagelry a reliable and efficient choice for feeding large parties or corporate events in the local area.

Contact Information

To place a catering order, call ahead for a quick pickup, or inquire about their daily specials, please use the following contact information:

**Address:** 1 N Park Ave, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA

**Phone:** (516) 766-9207

**Mobile Phone (Alternate):** +1 516-766-9207

What is Worth Choosing at Bagelry

Choosing the **Bagelry** in Rockville Centre is choosing convenience, variety, and community support in one essential Long Island location. For New Yorkers on the move, this is the most flexible choice for a morning or mid-day meal.

What is most worth choosing is the **Specialty Cream Cheese and Fish Selection**. While opinions on bagel texture can vary among local connoisseurs, the fresh **Hand Sliced Nova** and the wide array of unique, house-made cream cheese flavors—especially the **Lox Spread Cream Cheese**—are the true highlights. Combining a fresh bagel (or the unique **Flat Bagel**) with one of their specialty cream cheeses offers a classic, customizable New York experience.

For those looking for a hearty start to the day, the comprehensive **Egg Sandwiches** menu provides endless combinations, with the **Bacon, Egg, And Cheese On A Croissant** being an elevated, satisfying choice. Finally, the **Catering** service deserves special mention. For businesses or large family gatherings in Nassau County, the Bagelry’s detailed, expansive catering options, including the convenient **Box Of Coffee**, make them the most practical and efficient choice for feeding a crowd quickly and affordably.

Bagelry Vibe

Drinks
Hot Coffee
Freshly Brewed Coffee
Flavored Hot Coffee
Freshly Brewed Flavored Hot Coffee
Hot Tea
Flavored Hot Tea
Freshly Brewed Tea
Hot Chocolate
24 Oz. Iced Coffee $3.00
Freshly Brewed Iced Coffee
24 Oz. Flavored Iced Coffee $3.75
Freshly Brewed Iced Coffee
32 Oz. Iced Coffee $3.50
Freshly Brewed Iced Coffee
32 Oz. Flavored Iced Coffee $4.00
Freshly Brewed Iced Coffee
Iced Green Tea
Iced Lemonade
Iced 1/2 Lemonade 1/2 Tea
Freshly Brewed Iced Tea with Lemonade
Canned Drink $1.50
20 Oz. Soda $3.00
Poland Spring Bottled Water $1.50
Tropicana Juice $3.00
Snapple $3.00
Naked Juice $4.50
Nesquick $3.00
Vitamin Water $3.00
Vitamin Water Zero $3.00
Box Of Coffee $29.00
Served 12 To 15 coffee cups. Comes with milk, sweetness and cups
Low Fat Yogurt Parfait With Chia Seeds/Granola Topped With Fresh Fruits $6.00
Low fat Yogurt Parfait mixed with Chia Seeds/Granola topped with Fresh Fruit

Bagels and Oatmeal
Baker’s Dozen $21.00
Made fresh and baked daily! Please choose flavors below.
Bagel *Only $1.75
Dozen Flat Bagels $30.00
Flat Bagel *Only $2.50
Mini Bagel *Only $1.25
12 Oz. Oatmeal $6.50
Daily Fresh Rolled Oats Oatmeal Option to be served with fresh fruits, dried fruits, nuts, brown sugar, organic honey, passion fruit honey
16 Oz. Oatmeal $7.50

Bakery
Muffin $3.50
Apple Turnover $3.50
Cheese Danish $3.50
Plain Croissant $3.50
Chocolate Croissant $3.50
Strawberry Cheese Croissant $3.50
Small Chocolate Chip Cookie $1.00
Large Black And White Cookies $3.25
Raspberry Crumb Cake $3.50
Cinnamon Bun $3.50
Raisin Scone $3.50
Blueberry Scone $3.50
Chocolate Chip Scone $3.50
Pound Cake $3.50

Egg Sandwiches
Brown Hard Boiled Eggs $1.75
2 Eggs On Platter $5.50
2 Egg Whites Platter $6.00
2 Eggs On A Flat Bagel $5.75
2 Eggs On A Roll $5.75
2 Eggs On A Croissant $6.50
Egg And Cheese On A Bagel $6.75
Egg And Cheese On A Flat Bagel $7.25
Egg And Cheese On A Roll $7.50
Egg And Cheese On A Croissant $8.00
Bacon On A Bagel $5.50
Bacon On A Flat Bagel $6.00
Bacon On A Roll $6.00
Bacon On A Croissant $6.50
Bacon And Egg On A Bagel $7.25
Bacon And Egg On A Flat Bagel $7.75
Bacon And Egg On A Roll $8.00
Bacon And Egg On A Croissant $9.00
Bacon And Cream Cheese On A Bagel $6.25
Bacon, Egg, And Cheese On A Bagel $8.75
Bacon, Egg, And Cheese On A Flat Bagel $9.00
Bacon, Egg, And Cheese On A Roll $9.50
Bacon, Egg, And Cheese On A Croissant $8.50
Bacon, Lettuce And Tomato On A Bagel $8.00
Ham And Egg On A Bagel $6.49
Ham And Egg On A Flat Bagel $6.49
Ham And Egg On A Roll $6.99
Ham And Egg On A Croissant $7.49
Ham, Egg & Cheese On A Bagel $8.50
Ham, Egg, & Cheese On A Flat Bagel $9.00
Ham, Egg & Cheese On A Roll $6.50
Ham, Egg & Cheese On A Croissant $10.50
Freshly Baked Croissant with warmed Ham your choice of any styled Eggs and choice of Cheese

Mini Egg Sandwiches
Egg On A Mini Bagel $2.00
Egg White On A Mini Bagel $2.50
Egg And Cheese On A Mini Bagel $3.00
Bacon, Egg And Cheese On A Mini Bagel $4.00
Egg, Cheese And Ham On A Mini Bagel $4.25
Egg, Bacon And Lettuce On A Mini Bagel $5.00

Sandwiches
Low Fat Vegetable Tuna Sandwich $9.00
Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.00
Egg Salad Sandwich $7.00
Egg White Salad With Spinach Sandwich $8.00
Whitefish Salad Sandwich $12.00
Chicken Salad Sandwich $9.00
Turkey Breast Sandwich $9.00
Ham Sandwich $9.00
Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich $12.00
Nova And Cream Cheese Sandwich $12.00
Butter Sandwich $3.25
Jelly Sandwich $3.25
Butter And Jelly Sandwich $4.00
Butter And Cream Cheese Sandwich $4.50
Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich $5.00
Olive Cream Cheese Sandwich $5.00
Cream Cheese And Jelly Sandwich $5.00
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese Sandwich $5.00
Vegetables Cream Cheese Sandwich $5.00
Pepper And Garlic, Cream Cheese Sandwich $5.00
Cream Cheese Sandwich $4.25
Lox Spread Cream Cheese Sandwich $7.00
Peanut Butter Sandwich $5.00
Peanut Butter And Jelly Sandwich $5.50
Cheese Sandwich $4.25
Jalapeno Cream Cheese Sandwich $5.00

Wraps
Tuna Salad Wrap $10.50
Chicken Salad Wrap $10.50
Turkey Wrap $8.00

Salads
Garden Salad $7.00
Fruit Salad
Low Fat Yogurt Parfait With Granola $6.00
Hummus Spread And Vegetables $7.00
Tuna Mish $8.00
Served with a bagel.
Chicken Mish $8.00
Served with a bagel.
Turkey Mish $8.00
Served with a bagel.
Bagelry Combo Salad $8.00
Salad with tuna and egg salad. Served with a bagel.
Chopped Salad $7.00

Fresh Fish
1/4 Hand Sliced Nova $12.50

By the Pound
1/2 Pound Of Egg Salad $7.00
1/2 Pound Of Chicken Salad $8.00
1/2 Pound Of Craisin Chicken Salad $9.50
1/2 Pound Curry Mango Chicken Salad $9.50
New!!
1/2 Pound Of Tuna Salad $8.00
1/2 Pound Of Low Fat Vegetable Tuna $8.50
1/2 Pound Of Whitefish Salad $12.00
1/2 Pound Of Baked Salmon Salad $12.00
1/2 Pound Of Lox Spread Cream Cheese $9.00
1/4 Fresh Sliced Lox $13.00
1/2 Pound Of Butter $6.00
1/2 Pound Of Plain Cream Cheese $7.00
1/2 Pound Of Olive Cream Cheese $7.50
1/2 Pound Of Scallion Cream Cheese $7.50
1/2 Pound Of Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese $7.50
1/2 Pound Jalapeno Cream Cheese $7.50
1/2 Pound Of Vegetable Cream Cheese $7.50
1/2 Pound Of Sliced Ham $9.00
1/2 Pound Of Sliced Turkey $9.00
1/2 Pound Of American Cheese $8.00
1/2 Pound Of Swiss Cheese $8.00
1/2 Pound Of Muenster Cheese $8.00

Catering Eggs and Egg Sandwiches
Catering 2 Eggs $2.75
Catering 2 Egg Whites $3.00
Catering Egg On A Flat Bagel $3.00
Catering Egg On A Roll $3.00
Cateirng Egg And Cheese On A Bagel $3.75
Catering Egg And Cheese On A Flat Bagel $4.00
Catering Egg And Cheese On A Roll $4.00
Catering Egg, Cheese And Bacon On A Bagel $5.00
Catering Egg, Cheese And Bacon On A Flat Bagel $5.50
Catering Egg, Cheese And Bacon On A Roll $5.50
Catering Egg And Ham On A Bagel $4.50
Catering Egg And Ham On A Flat Bagel $4.75
Catering Egg And Ham On A Roll $4.75
Catering Egg And Bacon On A Bagel $4.50
Catering Egg And Bacon On A Flat Bagel $4.75
Catering Egg And Bacon On A Roll $4.75
Catering Egg, Ham And Cheese On A Bagel $6.00
Catering Egg, Ham And Cheese On A Flat Bagel $6.50
Catering Egg, Ham And Cheese On A Roll $6.50
Catering Bacon On A Bagel $4.00
Catering Bacon On A Flat Bagel $4.50
Catering Bacon On A Roll $4.50
Catering Bacon, Lettuce And Tomato On A Bagel $6.50
Catering Bacon And Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.00
Catering Brown Hard Boiled Eggs $1.00

Catering Egg Mini Bagels
Catering Egg On A Mini Bagel $2.00
Catering Egg White On A Mini Bagel $2.50
Catering Egg And Cheese On A Mini Bagel $3.00
Catering Egg, Cheese And Bacon On A Mini Bagel $4.00
Catering Egg, Cheese And Ham On A Mini Bagel $4.25
Catering Egg, Bacon And Lettuce On A Mini Bagel $5.00

Catering Sandwiches
Catering Low Fat Vegetable Tuna Sandwich $8.00
Catering Tuna Salad Sandwich $8.00
Catering Egg Salad Sandwich $6.00
Catering Egg White Salad With Spinach Sandwich $6.00
Catering Whitefish Salad Sandwich $8.00
Catering Chicken Salad Sandwich $8.00
Catering Turkey Breast Sandwich $7.00
Catering Ham Sandwich $7.00
Catering Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich $8.00
Catering Nova With Cream Cheese Sandwich $9.00
Catering Butter Sandwich $2.50
Catering Jelly Sandwich $2.50
Catering Butter And Jelly Sandwich $2.75
Catering Butter And Cream Cheese Sandwich $3.25
Catering Cream Cheese And Scallions Sandwich $3.75
Catering Cream Cheese And Olives Sandwich $3.75
Catering Cream Cheese And Jelly Sandwich $3.25
Catering Cream Cheese, Walnuts And Raisins Sandwich $3.75
Catering Cream Cheese And Vegetables Sandwich $3.75
Catering Cream Cheese, Pepper And Garlic Sandwich $3.75
Catering Cream Cheese Sandwich $3.00
Catering Lox Spread Sandwich $5.25
Catering Peanut Butter Sandwich $3.25
Catering Peanut Butter And Jelly Sandwich $3.25
Catering Cheese Sandwich $3.25
Catering Jalapeno Cream Cheese Sandwich $3.75

Catering Salads
Catering Garden Salad $7.00
Vegetarian.
Catering Fruit Salad
Vegetarian.
Catering Low Fat Yogurt Frappe With Granola $5.00
Catering Hummus Spread And Vegetables $7.00
Catering Tuna Mish $8.00
Served with a bagel.
Catering Chicken Mish $8.00
Served with a bagel.
Catering Turkey Mish $8.00
Served with a bagel.
Catering Bagelry Combo Salad $8.00
Salad with tuna and egg salad. Served with a bagel.
Catering Chopped Salad $7.00
Add a proteins for an additional charge.
Catering Master Slicer $39.00
The best vegetable ever. Get your meal, vegetables prepared in no time with the Original Master Slicer.

Catering Fresh Fish
Catering 1/4 Hand Sliced Nova $12.50
Individually wrapped option available.

Catering Wraps
Catering Tuna Salad Wrap $8.00
Catering Chicken Salad Wrap $8.00
Catering Turkey Wrap $8.00

Catering by the 1/2 Pound
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Sliced Turkey $6.50
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Sliced Ham $6.50
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Tuna Salad $7.00
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Low Fat Vegetable Tuna $7.25
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Chicken Salad $7.00
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Whitefish Salad $7.50
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Baked Salmon Salad $8.50
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Craisin Chicken Salad $8.50
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Egg Salad $5.50
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Cream Cheese $5.00
Make it low fat cheese for an additional charge. Vegetarian.
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Cream Cheese And Nova Spread $6.50
Make it low fat cheese for an additional charge. Vegetarian.
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Cream Cheese And Olives $6.00
Make it low fat cheese for an additional charge. Vegetarian.
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Cream Cheese And Scallions $6.00
Make it low fat cheese for an additional charge. Vegetarian.
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Cream Cheese, Walnuts And Raisins $6.00
Vegetarian.
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Swiss Cheese $6.00
Vegetarian.
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Muenster Cheese $6.00
Vegetarian.
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of American Cheese $6.00
Vegetarian.
Catering 1/2 Lb. Jalapeno Cream Cheese $6.00
Make it low fat cheese for an additional charge. Vegetarian.
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Vegetable Cream Cheese $6.00
Catering 1/2 Lb. Of Butter $5.00
Catering 1/2 Lb. Curry Mango Chicken Salad $8.00
New!!

Catering Master Slicer
Catering Master Slicer $39.99
Get your meal/vegetable prepared with the original Master slicer. Individually wrapped option available. Vegetarian.

Catering Bakery
Catering Muffin $3.00
Vegetarian.
Catering Small Chocolate Chip Cookie $0.75
Vegetarian.
Catering Apple Turnover $3.00
Vegetarian.
Catering Cheese Danish $3.00
Vegetarian.
Catering Cinnamon Bun $3.00
Vegetarian.
Catering Raspberry Crumb Cake $3.00
Vegetarian.
Catering Raisin Scone $3.00
Vegetarian.
Catering Mini Raisin Scone $1.50
VAgetarian.
Catering Black And White Cookies $3.00

Catering Drinks and Smoothies
Catering Coffee
Milk and sugar options available.
Catering Tea
Milk and sugar options available.
Catering Flavored Coffee
Choice of flavor. Milk and sugar options available.
Catering Flavored Tea
Milk and sugar options available.
Catering Hot Chocolate
Catering 24 Oz. Iced Coffee $2.75
Milk and sugar options available.
Catering 24 Oz. Flavored Iced Coffee $3.25
Choice of flavor. Milk and sugar options available.
Catering Canned Drink $1.35
Catering Tropicana Juice $2.75
Choice of flavor.
Catering Snapple $2.75
Catering Naked Juice $4.50
Choice of flavor.
Catering Nesquick $2.75
Choice of flavor.
Catering Vitamin Water $2.75
Catering Vitamin Water Zero $2.75
Catering 20 Oz. Soda $2.75
Catering Poland Spring Bottled Water $1.50
Catering Iced Green Tea
Catering Iced Lemonade
Catering Iced 1/2 Lemonade 1/2 Tea
Catering Chia Seeds With Low Fat Yogurt $5.00
Low fat vanilla, strawberry, blueberry mixed with chia seeds granola and fruits.
Catering Box Of Coffee $20.00
Served 12 To 15 coffee cups. Comes with milk, sweetness and cups.

Miscellaneous
Napkins, Plates, And Utensils $0.00
Catering Spoons And Tongs $0.00

Bagelry Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned
Small business

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safespace

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards

Parking
Paid parking lot
Paid street parking

Bagelry Photos

Bagelry Location

Bagelry

New York Nassau County Rockville Centre North Park Avenue

1 N Park Ave, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA

Bagelry Reviews

An average rating of ★3.8 from 209 user reviews.

cream cheeseeggbaconloxdeliverymoneyphonechicken saladsaturdayscallion

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

One star – Extremely disappointed this time.I’ve been a regular customer here for a long time — we always get our bagels from this place. But today was a whole different story. The guy in the red shirt (staff) was rude, clearly in a bad mood, and made the whole experience super uncomfortable. No smile, no basic courtesy, just attitude. Honestly, I don’t come here to deal with someone else’s bad day. Totally unprofessional. I won’t be coming back after this.
July 16 · Mesut Yilmaz
They went downhill. The bagels used to shatter on the outside. Definitely were some of the best bagels in the area. I was shocked when I had the bagels recently. They are akin to 711 bagels. Like they opted out of making their own bagels and went with one of those mass production bakeries to save money. Truly the end of an era. Won't be going back.
August 24 · Chris Koehler
My favorite bagel shop on Long Island. I am addicted to their egg and cheese on a bagel. And their coffee is so good too. The staff are very friendly and are the most efficient of any bagel place. I love coming here because I know it’s always going to be good, and the staff is always going to be friendly. It’s like coming home.
August 17 · Scuba Divemaster
Food was good, usually order for pickup which is a better experience in my opinion. Going in to order was very disorganized and we kept getting skipped for ordering and for paying... I wouldn’t recommend unless you have a lot of time to kill. Order online if anything.,
September 16 · Sherry DeSouza
Interesting way to rate this place but the food is great. Service is horrible. Still order breakfast from here but if they get the order right it is a bonus. Order bacon and eggs every weekend. Usually get it wrong. Today was egg whites and cheese on a croissant.
June 07 · Joseph