Bagels and Cream: A New Bagel Shop with Classic New York Flavor on the Upper West Side

Bagels and Cream Introduce

There's nothing quite like a fresh, authentic bagel to start a New York day, and on the Upper West Side, a new spot is quickly making a name for itself. Bagels and Cream is a welcome addition to the neighborhood, bringing a fresh take on a classic New York staple. This bagel shop is more than just a place to grab a bagel with cream cheese; it’s a comprehensive breakfast and lunch destination that offers an extensive menu of handcrafted items. From classic spreads to unique egg sandwiches and a variety of freshly squeezed juices and coffees, Bagels and Cream is a one-stop shop for all your morning cravings. The warm and inviting atmosphere, paired with the friendly staff, makes it feel like a genuine part of the community, even as a new establishment. Its commitment to quality and classic New York flavors is a testament to the family's long-standing history in the city's bagel scene, making it a must-visit for locals and visitors alike.

What sets Bagels and Cream apart is its incredible variety and attention to detail. While bagels are the star of the show, the menu extends far beyond, offering a truly diverse range of options for breakfast, lunch, and a quick snack. The menu includes a variety of egg sandwiches, fresh fruit smoothies, and a vast selection of hot and iced coffee drinks. The dedication to making many of their items in-house, including their cream cheese spreads, ensures a freshness and quality that is hard to find. This attention to detail and a broad menu caters to the diverse tastes of the Upper West Side clientele, from those who want a simple bagel with butter to those seeking a full omelet platter or a healthy acai bowl. The combination of classic New York fare with a modern, health-conscious twist makes Bagels and Cream a versatile and appealing choice for any time of day.

Location and Accessibility

Bagels and Cream is conveniently located at 924 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025. This prime spot in the Upper West Side makes it easily accessible for a wide range of patrons. The area is well-served by public transportation, with several subway and bus lines nearby, allowing for a quick and easy visit for commuters and local residents. The location is perfect for a grab-and-go morning routine or a leisurely brunch on the weekend. While the provided information does not specify accessibility features, the nature of a modern establishment in a well-developed urban area often suggests a focus on accommodating all customers. Its central location on Amsterdam Avenue makes it a visible and convenient landmark for anyone in the neighborhood seeking a top-tier bagel experience.

Services Offered

Takeout: Ideal for the on-the-go New Yorker, Bagels and Cream offers a quick and efficient takeout service.
In-Person Ordering: The staff is known for being extremely friendly and welcoming, making the in-person ordering experience a pleasant one.

Features and Highlights

Extensive Menu Beyond Bagels: While a bagel shop at its core, Bagels and Cream offers a surprisingly wide array of food options. The menu includes egg sandwiches, omelet platters, sandwiches and paninis, and even Açaí & Pitaya Bowls. This variety ensures there is something for everyone.
Freshly Squeezed Juices and Smoothies: A key highlight is the extensive selection of fresh, made-to-order juices and smoothies, offering a healthy and refreshing option to pair with your meal.
Classic and Flavored Coffees: The hot and iced coffee menu is diverse, featuring classic coffees and lattes as well as unique flavors like Lavender & Honey and Nutella Latte.
High-Quality Ingredients: Patrons praise the quality of the food, noting that items like the bacon and cream cheese are prepared to perfection. The fact that their spreads are made in-house is a significant point of pride and a key feature.
Welcoming and Friendly Staff: New customers consistently highlight the owner and staff's kindness and welcoming nature, which contributes to a positive and memorable experience.

Contact Information

Address: 924 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025

Phone: (212) 457-9328

What is Worth Choosing

In a city famous for its bagels, Bagels and Cream quickly proves its worth as a top contender, especially on the Upper West Side. What makes this establishment truly special and worth choosing is its blend of classic tradition and modern variety. The core of their business is a fresh, well-made bagel that lives up to the New York standard. However, they go above and beyond by offering an expansive menu that turns a simple bagel shop into a full-fledged culinary destination. This is particularly valuable for the discerning New York consumer who values quality and a broad selection.

The positive feedback from customers, particularly about the deliciousness and perfection of their food, is a strong indicator of their quality. The fact that they are a brand new establishment with a historic family tie to the neighborhood adds a layer of authenticity and trust. It feels like a place that understands what a good bagel means to a New Yorker. Furthermore, the exceptional service, from the kind owner to the friendly staff, creates an atmosphere that encourages repeat visits. In a city that can sometimes feel impersonal, a place that makes you feel welcome is a true gem. For those seeking a delicious, high-quality bagel and much more, all served with a smile, Bagels and Cream is a fantastic and worthy choice on the Upper West Side.

Bagels and Cream Bagel

Treats
Muffins $4.90
A moist treat with your choice of Banana Nut, Cranberry Nut, Blueberry, Corn, Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, Lemon Poppy, or Raisin Bran flavors.
Apple Danish $5.00
Flaky pastry with rich cheese filling, topped with sweet apple slices.
Pancakes $10.00
Three pancakes served with syrup.
French Toast $13.00
Cherry Danish $5.00
Flaky pastry with rich cheese filling, topped with sweet cherry slices.
Cheese Danish $5.00
Flaky pastry filled with rich cheese filling, topped with a hint of sweetness.

Egg Sandwiches
Bacon Or Sausage Egg $9.00
Bacon or sausage with egg.
Bacon Or Sausage Egg & Cheese $9.50
Savory bacon or sausage paired with fresh egg and your choice of American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Provolone, Feta, or Muenster cheese.
Egg & Cheese $8.75
Scrambled eggs paired with your choice of American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Provolone, Feta, or Muenster cheese.
Eggs On A Bagel $8.00
Scrambled eggs with your choice of bagel including plain, poppy, sesame, onion, garlic, whole wheat, multigrain, cinnamon raisin, egg, French toast, pumpernickel, everything bagel, roll, wrap, or panini.

Hot Drinks
Coffee $2.75
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Lavender & Honey Latte $5.25
Caffeine-free.
Latte $4.50
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Macchiato $4.50
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Hot Chocolate $4.50
Turmeric Latte $5.25
Caffeine-free.
Lavender Vanilla Latte $5.25
London Fog-Earl Grey Latte $5.25
Tea $2.65
Black, breakfast, chamomile, Earl Grey, lemon zinger, mint, jasmine.
Nutella Latte $5.50
Chai Latte $5.25
Cappuccino $4.50
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Cafe Mocha $5.25
Matcha Latte $5.25

Iced Drinks
Iced Lavender Honey $5.75
Caffeine-free.
Iced Matcha Latte $5.75
Iced Chai Latte $5.75
Iced Lavender Vanilla $5.75
Latte $5.25
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Iced Tea $4.00
Black, green, hibiscus.
Iced Nutella Latte $5.75
Cold Brew $4.75
Flavored: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Iced Coffee $4.00
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Macchiato $5.25
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.
Iced Tea Lemonade $4.00
Iced Cappuccino $5.25
Flavor options: hazelnut, caramel, vanilla, lavender.

Fresh Squeezed Juices
Pineapple Zinger $9.00
Pineapple, apple, lemon, ginger.
Sweet Carrot $9.00
Apple & carrot.
Beachy Greens $9.00
Pineapple, apple, cucumbers, kale, spinach.
Sweet Immunity $9.00
Beets, orange, pineapple, ginger, honey.
No Pain $9.00
Pineapple, carrot, kale, turmeric.
Sunny Day $9.00
Carrot, apple, mango, lemon, ginger.
Sunrise $9.00
Grapefruit, carrot, apple.
Heartbeat $9.00
Beet, ginger, carrot, chia seeds.
Zinger $9.00
Carrot, apple, lemon, ginger.
Immune Booster $9.00
Orange, apple, lemon, ginger.
Shine On $9.00
Mango, orange, pineapple.
20 Vision $9.00
Mango, & carrot.
Super Vision $9.00
Carrot, orange, turmeric.
Citrus Explosion $9.00
Grapefruit, orange, lemon.
Sweet Green $9.00
Apples, kale, cucumber, spinach, lemon.
Super Healthy Green $9.00
Spinach, kale, celery, cucumber, lemon, apple, ginger.
Detox $9.00
Apple, beets, carrots, lemon, ginger.
Light & Green $9.00
Apple, cucumber, celery.

Smoothies
Mixed Berry $9.00
Mixed berries & milk.
Island Breeze $9.00
Pineapple, banana, yogurt, orange juice & honey.
Nutty Yummy $9.00
Mango, banana, almond butter, honey.
Tropical Vacation $9.00
Piña colada, mango, milk.
Morning Cleanse $9.00
Banana, berries, flax seeds, chia seeds.
Banana Berry $9.00
Mixed berries, banana & milk.
Strawberry Banana $9.00
Strawberry, banana & milk.
PB & Chocolate $9.00
Peanut butter, chocolate, banana & oat milk.
Kale Crush $9.00
Kale, avocado, pineapple, mango & almond milk.
Grape Goodness $9.00
Grapes, peanut butter, yogurt, & banana.
Zoomer $9.00
Banana, pineapple, milk, oats, protein, honey.
Berry Peachy $9.00
Mixed berries, peach & milk.
Mango Strawberry $9.00
Mango, strawberry with milk.
Mango Madness $9.00
Mango, banana, orange juice, & milk.
Feel Good $9.00
Banana, avocado, chia seeds, peanut butter, almond milk.

Avocado Toast
Avocado Toast $8.00
Choice of bread or bagel, served with tomatoes & everything seeds.

Omelette Platters
Western Omelette $11.00
Ham, onions, peppers.
Garden Omelette $11.00
Broccoli, mushroom, tomato, peppers.
Nova Omelette $12.00
Nova lox, onions, scallion.
Spicy Omelette $9.75
Spicy. Jalapeño, tomato, cheddar cheese.
Steak Omelette $13.00
Steak, onion, peppers, mushroom, tomato, cheddar.
Avocado Omelette $11.00
Tomato, pepper jack and avocado.
Healthy Omelette $11.00
Egg whites, broccoli, mushroom.
Italian Omelette $10.00
Tomato, pesto & mozzarella cheese.
The Bronx Omelette $11.00
Bacon, onion, peppers, American.
Cheese Omelette $8.50
American, cheddar, Swiss & mozzarella.
Greek Omelette $10.00
Olives, tomato, spinach, feta.
Three Eggs Any Style $7.50
Three eggs, plain or with your choice of poppy, sesame, onion, garlic, whole wheat, multigrain, cinnamon raisin, egg, French toast, pumpernickel, or everything.

Sandwiches & Panini
Pastrami $15.00
Pastrami, red onions, pickles, mustard.
Tunacado $14.00
Tuna, pesto, cheddar, avocado, tomato.
Chicken & Avocado $14.00
Grilled chicken, peppers, onion, avocado, lettuce, tomato.
Eastchester $14.00
Grilled chicken, turkey bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
California $14.00
Grilled chicken, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, avocado, ranch.
Caprese $13.00
Mozzarella, roasted pepper, tomato, pesto. Add chicken for an additional charge.
Precinct $13.00
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Veggie $12.00
Spinach, broccoli, tomato, olives, mushroom, peppers, red onion, mozzarella, avocado, balsamic.
Mediterranean $11.00
Hummus, lettuce, peppers, onion, cucumber, feta & honey mustard. Add chicken for an additional charge.
Tuna Melt $12.00
Tuna, cheddar, onion, tomato.
Grandpa $12.00
Turkey, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Blondell $14.00
Chicken cutlet, marinara, mozzarella, tomato.
Chicken Caesar $14.00
Grilled chicken, Parmesan, mozzarella, romaine, tomato, Caesar.
BLT $11.00
Turkey bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Bagels & Cream Classic $16.00
Lox, scallion cream cheese, onion, tomato, capers. Choose from various bagel options like plain, poppy, sesame, onion, garlic, whole wheat, multigrain, cinnamon raisin, egg, French toast, pumpernickel, everything.
Supreme $13.00
Chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo.
Italian $13.00
Grilled chicken, mozzarella, tomato pesto.
Just Cheese $12.00
Mozzarella, cheddar, American, Swiss.
Bagels And Cream Special $15.00
Sliced lox, scallion cream cheese, avocado, onions, tomato & everything seeds.
Spicy Chicken $13.00
Spicy. Grilled chicken, pepper jack, hot sauce.

Cheese
Grilled Cheese $6.00
Choose from American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Feta, Muenster, Pepper Jack, Provolone, or Swiss cheese.
Mozzarella, Tomato, Pesto $7.95

Bagels with Spreads
Bagel With Smoked Salmon (Lox) $14.00
Create your own Sandwich. Bagel topped with smoked salmon (lox). Add additional options
Butter Or Jelly $2.00
Bagel with butter or jelly.
Bagel With Tuna Salad $8.00
Plain bagel topped with tuna salad. Choose toasted or not toasted.
Bagel With White Fish Salad $11.00
Create your own Sandwich. Bagel topped with smoked salmon (lox). Add additional options
Bagel With Chicken Salad $9.00
Bagel topped with chicken salad. Choose toasted or not toasted.
Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese $4.75
Bagel with your choice of flavored cream cheese, including scallion, veggie, lox spread, garlic & herb, jalapeno, walnut raisin, bacon & cheddar, peanut butter, or Nutella.
Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese $4.00
A plain bagel with creamy, smooth cheese spread. Choose between toasted or not toasted.

Açaí & Pitaya Bowls
Nutella $9.50
With banana, strawberries, granola, coconut & Nutella.
Chia $8.50
Banana, coconut flakes, granola, chia, almond butter.
Power $8.50
With strawberry protein, banana, granola, peanut butter.
Supreme Açaí & Pitaya $12.95
Mixture of acai & pitaya, topped with banana, strawberries, granola, chia, coconut flakes.
Peanut Butter $8.50
Banana, granola, peanut butter.
Wake Me Up $8.50
With banana, coconut flakes, honey.

Bagels
Half Dozen $9.00
A selection of 6 bagels: Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Onion, Garlic, Whole Wheat, Multigrain, Cinnamon Raisin, Egg, French Toast, Pumpernickel, Everything.
Baker's Dozen $18.00
A selection of 13 bagels: Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Onion, Garlic, Whole Wheat, Multigrain, Cinnamon Raisin, Egg, French Toast, Pumpernickel, Everything.
Single Bagel $2.00
Choose from Plain, Poppy, Sesame, Onion, Garlic, Whole Wheat, Multigrain, Cinnamon Raisin, Egg, French Toast, Pumpernickel, or Everything.

Bagels and Cream Photos

Bagels and Cream Location

Bagels and Cream

New York New York County New York Amsterdam Avenue

924 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA

Bagels and Cream Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 32 user reviews.

eggturkey sausagecinnamon raisin bagellattelox

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

My partner and I had a fantastic breakfast this morning! He got a turkey sausage, egg, and cheese on an onion bagel, and I got an onion bagel with cream cheese—it was delicious!! We’ve been ordering from another bagel place further downtown on uber eats, but with prices soaring, we need something yummy and local and this hit the spot. We will definitely be back again!
April 16 · Bennett P
This place is AMAZING! The owner isextremely kind and the staff is very nice also. The food is amazing they cooked my Bacon or Sausage Egg & Cheese perfect. If I could give this place 10 stars I would. It is extremely clean and they told me they are brand new an had just opened. I will definitely be returning here. I would recommend this place to anyone.
May 05 · courtney hauser
I recommend giving their bagels a try - I stopped here 3 times this week! Everything bagel turkey bacon, egg, and cheese; (turkey?) sausage egg and cheese; and a veggie cream cheese.
April 26 · Adriana P
Friendly new place to grab a delicious and fairly priced bagel sandwich. Start with the Classic. They don't skimp on the lox! Bagel has a chewy but not too dense inside. Variety of house-made cream cheese. The owner is also super friendly and excited to be new in the neighborhood.
July 09 · Prof. Dr. J
I just moved into the neighborhood and this is the perfect welcome spot! The staff is so friendly and even remade my latte after I accidentally ordered it hot instead of iced. Highly recommend!
September 06 · Aislinn Cain