Bagels & Co: A New York Staple for Bagels, Kosher Food, and More

Bagels & Co Introduce

Welcome to our comprehensive guide to Bagels & Co, a true neighborhood gem located at 391 Amsterdam Ave in the heart of New York's Upper West Side. In a city where the bagel is a culinary icon, finding a spot that consistently delivers a fresh, authentic, and satisfying experience is a daily ritual for many New Yorkers. Bagels & Co has earned its place as a reliable and beloved destination, offering more than just bagels to its loyal patrons.

This article is crafted to provide you, a fellow New Yorker, with an in-depth and factual overview of what makes Bagels & Co a standout choice. We will explore everything from its convenient location and accessibility to its incredibly diverse menu and unique features. Our goal is to give you a clear and engaging look at this establishment, helping you decide if it's the right place for your morning coffee, a quick lunch, or a full meal with friends. The tone will be friendly and professional, highlighting the strengths of the business based on available public data.

Bagels & Co is not your average bagel shop. It's a full-fledged kosher restaurant that offers an extensive menu catering to a wide range of tastes and meal times. While it excels at the basics—freshly baked bagels and a vast selection of spreads—it also provides an impressive array of other food options, from pizzas and Israeli specialties to paninis, salads, and even baked goods. This versatility makes it a go-to spot for breakfast, lunch, or a quick bite at any time of day.

The commitment to being a kosher restaurant is a significant part of its identity, making it a vital and trusted resource for those who observe kashrut in the Upper West Side and beyond. This dedication to tradition and quality is reflected in the freshness of their ingredients and the care taken in preparing each item on their menu.

Bagels & Co is situated at a prime location at 391 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024. This spot is in the vibrant and bustling Upper West Side, a neighborhood known for its residential charm, lively commercial streets, and proximity to major attractions like Central Park and the Museum of Natural History.

Accessibility is a key advantage of the location. The shop is a short walk from the 1, 2, and 3 subway lines at the 72nd Street station, making it incredibly easy to get to from almost anywhere in Manhattan. Multiple bus routes also run along Amsterdam Avenue and nearby Columbus Avenue, offering additional transportation options. For those with mobility needs, the establishment features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring a smooth entry for all patrons.

The convenient location makes Bagels & Co an ideal stop for a quick bite before work, a leisurely weekend breakfast, or a place to grab lunch while exploring the neighborhood. The ease of access, combined with its central position, makes it a true staple for the local community and visitors alike.

Bagels & Co offers a wide range of services and dining options to meet the needs of its diverse clientele.

Service Options: Customers can choose from several convenient service options. The restaurant provides dine-in seating for those who want to enjoy their meal on-site. For those on the go, takeout and in-store pickup are available. The shop also offers delivery services, allowing you to enjoy their delicious food from the comfort of your home or office.
Dining Options: While it is most popular for breakfast and brunch, the "All Day Menu" indicates that its offerings extend beyond the morning. You can find everything from bagels and omelets to paninis and pizzas, making it suitable for lunch and a quick dinner.
Offerings: The menu is extensive and features a variety of options. In addition to a wide selection of bagels and spreads, they offer a full coffee menu, Israeli specialties, wraps, and a variety of baked goods and desserts. The menu also includes a range of vegetarian options.
Catering: Bagels & Co provides a comprehensive catering service with platters of bagels, smoked fish, cream cheese, wraps, and more, making it a great option for office meetings, family gatherings, or events.

These services demonstrate a commitment to convenience and a desire to serve the community in various capacities, whether for a quick, individual meal or a large group event.

Bagels & Co has several highlights that make it a local favorite and a standout in a competitive market.

Vast Menu & Variety: The most notable feature is the sheer size and variety of the menu. From a huge selection of cream cheese spreads, including unique flavors like Rainbow and Kalamata Olive, to a full-service menu that includes pizza, Belgian waffles, and Israeli dishes like Shakshuka and Falafel, there is truly something for everyone. This variety means you can visit multiple times and always try something new.
Fresh Bagels & Lox: As the name suggests, the bagels are a core strength. The "out of this world" Nova Lox, as noted by a customer, is a particular highlight. The quality of the smoked fish and the wide array of cream cheese spreads make for an exceptional bagel sandwich experience.
Kosher and Inclusive: As a kosher restaurant, Bagels & Co serves a crucial segment of the New York population, providing delicious food that meets specific dietary requirements. This focus also speaks to their dedication to quality and tradition.
Seating Availability: While many bagel shops are takeout-only, Bagels & Co offers seating inside, as noted by a reviewer. This makes it a great spot to sit down, relax, and enjoy your meal, whether you're meeting a friend or just taking a break.
"Quick Visit" Friendly: The planning information notes that the spot is ideal for a "quick visit," which is essential in a fast-paced city like New York. The efficiency of the service allows you to get in, get your food, and get on with your day without a long wait.

These features collectively create a place that is versatile, reliable, and deeply integrated into the Upper West Side community.

For those planning a visit or needing to get in touch, here is the contact information for Bagels & Co.

Address: 391 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Phone: (212) 496-9400

Mobile Phone: +1 212-496-9400

When you’re looking for a bagel shop in New York's Upper West Side, Bagels & Co is an excellent choice for several compelling reasons. What makes it truly worth choosing is its ability to be a one-stop-shop for a wide variety of meals, not just bagels. The extensive menu, which includes everything from fresh bagels and a massive selection of spreads to Israeli dishes, paninis, and pizza, means you can satisfy almost any craving. The quality of the bagels and the fresh lox and cream cheese spreads are a major draw, living up to the high standards of a true New York bagel. Furthermore, its identity as a kosher restaurant is a significant highlight, providing a trusted and delicious dining option for a specific community. The convenience of its location, the availability of both dine-in and takeout options, and the general efficiency of the service make it a perfect spot for a quick bite or a relaxed meal. While some might find certain items to be "just bagels" or "just croissants," the sheer variety, quality of the core offerings, and the overall welcoming atmosphere make Bagels & Co a reliable and cherished part of the neighborhood’s culinary scene.

Bagels & Co Menu

10 AM + All Day Menu - Belgian Waffles, French Toast & Pancakes
French Toast $5.00
French Toast With Fruit Salad $9.95
Nutty Swirl $11.00
Banana, walnuts, whipped cream.
Pancakes (3) $8.75
3 large, plain pancakes.
Romeo & Juliet $13.50
Strawberry, banana and Nutella.
2 Pancakes With 2 Eggs Any Style $10.50
3 Pancakes & Banana $9.95
Cookies N Cream $11.00
Oreos and whipped cream.
2 Pancakes With Fruit Salad $10.50
Belgian Waffles $9.00
Double Decker $13.00
Waffle with egg omelet.
2 Pancakes, 2 Eggs & Home Fries $10.75

10 AM + All Day Menu - Salads
Create Your Own Salad $8.00
Bowl of greens, cucumbers, carrots and onions.
Caesar Salad $7.95
Fruit Salad
Israeli Salad
Greek Salad

10 AM + All Day Menu - Israeli Menu
Israeli Panini $8.95
Mozzarella, plain Cream Cheese & 3 veg toppings
Hummus Plate $8.00
Hummus, tahini and pita.
Falafel In Pita $7.00
Egg Salad In Pita $7.75
Falafel Plate $10.50
Hummus, tahini, Israeli salad, pickles and pita.
Tuna In Pita $9.00
Malawach $8.00
Israeli filo dough filled with hard boiled egg, tomato sauce and veggies.
Shakshuka $13.95
2 eggs sunny side in special tomato sauce with bread and Israeli salad.
Sabih $7.95
Boiled egg, fried eggplant, Israeli salad, hummus, pickle & tahini

10 AM + All Day Menu - Catering | Drinks
Soda | 1.5L $5.00
Orange Juice | Half Gallon $8.00
Tea $35.00
Coffee $35.00
Water | 1.5L $4.00
Hot Chocolate

10 AM + All Day Menu - Fresh Wraps
Grilled Salmon Wrap $14.75
Avocado Wrap $9.00
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Breakfast Wrap $8.75
Home fries, eggs, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Falafel Wrap $8.00
Tuna, Lettuce & Tomato Wrap $10.75
Egg Salad Wrap $8.50
With lettuce and tomatoes.
Quesadilla Wrap $9.00
American and Mozzarella cheese with vegetables, melted together.
Caesar Salad Wrap $7.50
Fresh Mozzarella Wrap $8.50
Lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Greek Salad Wrap $7.50
Grilled Vegetable Wrap $8.50

10 AM + All Day Menu - Spreads
Rainbow Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Nova Lox Spread Cream Cheese On A Bagel $7.50
Vegetable Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Strawberry Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Tofu Scallion Spread On A Bagel $6.50
Jalapeno Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Scallion Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Tofu Plain Spread On A Bagel $6.00
Jelly On A Bagel $2.75
Blueberry Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Kalamata Olive Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Plain Cream Cheese On A Bagel $4.25
Tofu Vegetable Spread On A Bagel $6.50
Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Walnut & Raisin Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Peanut Butter On A Bagel $4.25
Butter On A Bagel $2.75

10 AM + All Day Menu - Calzone
Cheese Calzone With Toppings $10.00
Pizza Bagel $8.00
Cheese Calzone $8.00

10 AM + All Day Menu - Panini
Triple Cheese Deluxe Panini $9.50
Mozzarella, Feta and American cheese with tomatoes and sauteed red onions.
Greek Supreme Panini $9.50
Feta cheese, tomatoes, mixed olives and roasted peppers.
Tuna Melt Open Faced $12.00
Tuna, mozzarella, lettuce and tomatoes.
Napolitano Panini $9.50
Mozzarella, pesto, Romaine, fresh tomatoes, balsamic vinegar.
French Connection Panini $9.50
Grilled vegetables, zucchini, onions, mushrooms, peppers and tomatoes with melted cheese.
Eggplant Parmesan Panini $9.50
Breaded eggplant, marinara sauce, Parmesan and fresh Mozzarella.

10 AM + All Day Menu - Breakfast Menu
Eggs On Bagel $7.00
Muscle Man $13.50
Egg whites, peppers, tomato and onion. Served with home fries and Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Spanish Omelet $13.99
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Lox, Egg & Onion Omelet $17.99
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Greek Omelet $13.99
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Egg Whites On Bagel $8.00
Mushroom Omelet $11.95
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Eggs With Grilled Veggies $14.00
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
2 Eggs Any Style $12.95
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Spinach & Feta Omelet $12.95
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Egg Whites & Cheese On Bagel $9.00
Grilled Cheese $5.50
Egg & Cheese On Bagel $8.00

10 AM + All Day Menu - Bagels
Bakers Dozen Mini Bagel $12.00
Receive a free mini bagel with this order
French Toast Bagel $1.50
Flat Bagel $2.50
Bakers Dozen Bagels $19.20
Receive a free bagel with this order
Bakers Dozen Flat Bagel $30.00
Receive a free flat bagel with this order
Mini Bagels $1.00
Bagel $1.65

10 AM + All Day Menu - Catering | Baked Items
Homemade Pancakes
Banana, Blueberry or Plain
Burekas
Assorted Burekas Filled with Cheese, Spinach, Potato, Peppers and Mushrooms
Bagel And Bialy
Assorted Bagels Cut into Quarters
Homemade Blintzes
Filled with Soft Sweet Cream Cheese
Bakery Basket
Homemade Baked Cookies, Danishes or Muffins

10 AM + All Day Menu - Sandwiches | Mini & Flat Bagel Sandwiches
White Fish Salad Sandwich
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Smoked Kipper Salmon Sandwich
Gravlax Salmon Sandwich
Hummus Sandwich
Baba Ganoush Sandwich
Tuna A La Chef Sandwich
Veggie Tuna Salad Sandwich
Pastrami Style-Smoked Salmon Sandwich
Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich
Sable Sandwich
Spanish Eggplant Sandwich
Egg Salad Sandwich

10 AM + All Day Menu - Chef's Daily Specials
Hot Pasta Dish $9.99
Coleslaw
Vegetable Lasagna $9.99
Baked Ziti $9.99
Filet Of Fish $8.25
Eggplant Parmesan $9.99
Soup Of The Day $7.00
With free bagel. Please call the restaurant for today's selection.
Baked Ziti With Vegetables $9.99
Filet Of Fish Platter $13.00
Served with 2 sides.
Fish & Chips $11.99
Home Fries
Lasagna $9.99
Fish Of The Day Platter $18.50
Served with 2 sides.
Veggie Burger Platter $11.50
Served with 2 sides.
Fish Of The Day $13.00
Veggie Burger $7.75
Rice
Pasta Salad $9.99

10 AM + All Day Menu - Catering | Platters
Vegetable Platter
Stick or Sliced: Cucumber, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Carrots and Peppers
Fruit Platter
Assorted Seasonal Fruits
Smoked Fish Platter
Whole White Fish, Sable and Lox (Only Small Platter Has Lox and Sable)
Cream Cheese Platter
Assorted Cream Cheeses: Plain, Vegetable, Scallion, Olive or Lox Spread
Combo Platter
Egg Salad, Tuna Salad and White Fish Salad
Assorted Wraps Platter
Assorted Wraps: Egg Salad, Tuna Salad, White Fish Salad, Baked Salmon Salad, Grilled Vegetable & Hummus, Hard Cheese
Mediterranean Salad Platter | Pick 3
Tahini, Hummus, Babaganush, Turkish Salad, Matbucha or Spanish Eggplant
Omelet Wraps Platter
Spinach, Cheese, Scallion, or Vegetable (Wrapped with Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion and Home Fries)
Hard Cheese Platter
Mozzarella, American, Muenster and Swiss

10 AM + All Day Menu - Appetizers & Side Dishes
Garlic Knots $2.50
4 pieces.
Quiche $20.00
9" broccoli, spinach, mushroom and cheese.
Cheese Garlic Knots $7.50
10 knots with cheese and sauce.
Cheese Fries $6.75
Potato Cigars $6.50
6 pieces of fried filo dough filled with potato.
Spicy Fries $5.75
Mozzarella Sticks $7.50
6 pcs.
Large Turkish Style Borekas $5.00
Cheese, spinach cheese and potatoes.
French Fries $5.25
Nachos With Melted Cheese $7.50
Mini Borekas $1.75
Cheese, spinach cheese, potato and mushrooms.
Sweet Potato Fries $5.50
Onion Rings $5.75
10 pieces.

10 AM + All Day Menu - Sandwiches | Bagel Sandwiches
Spanish Eggplant Sandwich $6.50
Baba Ganoush Sandwich $6.50
White Fish Salad Sandwich $11.75
Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich $14.25
Pastrami Style-Smoked Salmon $14.25
Vegetable Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.00
Hummus Sandwich $6.50
Egg Salad Sandwich $9.50
Gravalax Salmon Sandwich $14.25
Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.00
Smoked Kipper Salmon $14.25
Tuna A La Chef Sandwich $9.50
Vinaigrette dressing, no mayo.
Sable Sandwich $14.75

10 AM + All Day Menu - Baked Goods & Desserts
Apple Strudel $4.25
Pecan Pie $6.00
Variety Of Cookies $16.00
1lb.
Cherry Cheese Knishes $7.00
Cheesecake $6.00
Black & White Cookie $4.50
Chocolate Zebra Cake $6.00
Cheese Danish $4.75
Apple Turnover $4.25
Whole Wheat Challah $7.00
Plain Challah $7.00
Croissant $4.50
Muffin $4.50
Cinnamon Twist Danish $4.25
Blueberry Cheese Knishes $7.00
Tiramisu Cake $5.00
Vanilla Yogurt, Fruit & Granola Cup $5.50
Potato & Spinach Knish $6.00
Kasha Knish $6.00
Raisin Challah $7.50
Cheese Blintz $3.25
Challah Roll $2.25
Rugelach $6.95

10 AM + All Day Menu - Pizza
Tonno Pizza $29.00
Tuna, peppers, scallions, fresh basil and cilantro.
Whole Wheat Pizza $30.00
Mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Olimato Pizza $29.00
Kalamata olives, plum tomato and fresh basil.
Wild Mushrooms Pizza $29.00
Portobello, shiitake and cremini mushrooms.
Onion & Peppers Pizza $29.00
Caramelized red onions and roasted peppers.
Spinach & Ricotta Pizza $29.00
Fresh spinach, ricotta cheese and plum tomato.
Caesar Salad Pizza $29.00
Romaine lettuce, croutons and caesar dressing.
Gluten Free Plain Pizza $12.00
Marinara Pizza $22.00
Mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Personal Pie | 10" $10.00
Hawaiian Pizza $29.00
Grilled fresh pineapple.
Caponata Pizza $29.00
Roasted eggplant, garlic and fresh herbs.
Savory Tomato Pizza $29.00
Caramelized onions, plum tomato and mixed fresh herbs.
Slice Of Pizza $2.75
Pomodoro Pizza $29.00
Penne pasta, tomato sauce and mixed fresh herbs.
Margarita Pizza $29.00
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato and fresh basil.
White Pizza $29.00
Mozzarella and Ricotta cheese.
Pesto & Tomato Pizza $29.00
Ricotta pesto and plum tomato.

10 AM + All Day Menu - Beverages
Herbal Tea
Coffee
Iced Tea
Tropicana Juice $3.50
Flavored Latte
Tea
Flavored Coffee
Hot Chocolate
Latte
Espresso
Smoothie
Iced Flavored Coffee
Bottle Of Soda $2.50
Iced Coffee
Iced Latte
Poland Spring Water
Snapple $2.75
Can Of Soda $2.00
Flavored Iced Latte

10 AM + All Day Menu - Spreads by the Lb.
Tofu Vegetable Spread
Tuna A La Chef
Herring
Strawberry Cream Cheese
Tofu Scallion Spread
Sable
Low-Fat Plain Cream Cheese
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Walnut & Raisin Cream Cheese
Veggie Tuna Salad
Nova Scotia Salmon
Tuna Salad
Smoked Kipper Salmon
Butter
Blueberry Cream Cheese
Low-Fat Scallion Cream Cheese
Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese
Peanut Butter
Kalamata Olive Cream Cheese
Pastrami Style-Smoked Salmon
Jelly
Jalapeno Cream Cheese
Tofu Plain Spread
White Fish Salad
Scallion Cream Cheese
Hummus
Spanish Eggplant
Plain Cream Cheese
Nova Lox Spread
Egg Salad
Low-Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese
Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese
Babaganoush
Gravlax Salmon

10 AM + All Day Menu - Catering | Sandwiches, Pastas, Etc.
Salad Bowl
Greek, Israeli, Caesar, Israeli Tuna, Garden
Coleslaw
Pizza | 20" Whole Wheat Plain $30.00
Pizza | 20" Topping $29.00
Pizza | 20" Whole Wheat Topping $34.00
Homemade Fries
Baked Potato with Our Special Spices, Onions & Peppers
Shakshuka
Eggs Cooked with Tomatoes, Garlic, Herbs & Peppers
Stuffed Sandwiches
Homemade Foccacia Bread Filled with Pesto Sauce, Mozzarella, Melanzane Sauce, Eggplant, Avocado or Tuna
Omelets
Mushrooms, Cheese, Spinach, Vegetable
Lasagna
Marinara Sauce & Cheese, Vegetable, Spinach or Eggplant
Pizza | 20" Plain $22.00
Pasta
Pesto Sauce, Vodka, Primavera, Marinara, Funghi, Aglio Olio, Alfredo
Homemade Quiche
Mushroom & Spinach, Zucchini & Yellow Squash, Broccoli & More

10 AM + All Day Menu - Sandwich Platters
Smoked Kipper Salmon Sandwich Platter $20.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Sable Sandwich Platter $20.75
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Vegetable Tuna Salad Sandwich Platter $16.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Gravalax Salmon Sandwich Platter $20.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Baba Ganoush Sandwich Platter $17.75
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Egg Salad Sandwich Platter $13.75
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
White Fish Salad Sandwich Platter $17.75
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Herring Sandwich Platter $13.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Pastrami Style-Smoked Salmon Sandwich Platter $20.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Tuna Salad Sandwich Platter $16.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Tuna A La Chef Sandwich Platter $16.25
Vinaigrette dressing, no mayo. Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Spanish Eggplant Sandwich Platter $17.75
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich Platter $20.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.

All Day Menu - Belgian Waffles, French Toast & Pancakes
French Toast $5.00
French Toast With Fruit Salad $9.95
Nutty Swirl $11.00
Banana, walnuts, whipped cream.
Pancakes (3) $8.75
3 large, plain pancakes.
Romeo & Juliet $13.50
Strawberry, banana and Nutella.
2 Pancakes With 2 Eggs Any Style $10.50
3 Pancakes & Banana $9.95
Cookies N Cream $11.00
Oreos and whipped cream.
2 Pancakes With Fruit Salad $10.50
Belgian Waffles $9.00
Double Decker $13.00
Waffle with egg omelet.
2 Pancakes, 2 Eggs & Home Fries $10.75

All Day Menu - Salads
Create Your Own Salad $8.00
Bowl of greens, cucumbers, carrots and onions.
Caesar Salad $7.95
Fruit Salad
Israeli Salad
Greek Salad

All Day Menu - Israeli Menu
Israeli Panini $8.95
Mozzarella, plain Cream Cheese & 3 veg toppings
Hummus Plate $8.00
Hummus, tahini and pita.
Falafel In Pita $7.00
Egg Salad In Pita $7.75
Falafel Plate $10.50
Hummus, tahini, Israeli salad, pickles and pita.
Tuna In Pita $9.00
Malawach $8.00
Israeli filo dough filled with hard boiled egg, tomato sauce and veggies.
Shakshuka $13.95
2 eggs sunny side in special tomato sauce with bread and Israeli salad.
Sabih $7.95
Boiled egg, fried eggplant, Israeli salad, hummus, pickle & tahini

All Day Menu - Catering | Drinks
Soda | 1.5L $5.00
Orange Juice | Half Gallon $8.00
Tea $35.00
Coffee $35.00
Water | 1.5L $4.00
Hot Chocolate

All Day Menu - Fresh Wraps
Grilled Salmon Wrap $14.75
Avocado Wrap $9.00
With lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Breakfast Wrap $8.75
Home fries, eggs, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Falafel Wrap $8.00
Tuna, Lettuce & Tomato Wrap $10.75
Egg Salad Wrap $8.50
With lettuce and tomatoes.
Quesadilla Wrap $9.00
American and Mozzarella cheese with vegetables, melted together.
Caesar Salad Wrap $7.50
Fresh Mozzarella Wrap $8.50
Lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Greek Salad Wrap $7.50
Grilled Vegetable Wrap $8.50

All Day Menu - Spreads
Rainbow Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Nova Lox Spread Cream Cheese On A Bagel $7.50
Vegetable Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Strawberry Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Tofu Scallion Spread On A Bagel $6.50
Jalapeno Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Scallion Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Tofu Plain Spread On A Bagel $6.00
Jelly On A Bagel $2.75
Blueberry Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Kalamata Olive Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Plain Cream Cheese On A Bagel $4.25
Tofu Vegetable Spread On A Bagel $6.50
Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Walnut & Raisin Cream Cheese On A Bagel $5.50
Peanut Butter On A Bagel $4.25
Butter On A Bagel $2.75

All Day Menu - Panini
Triple Cheese Deluxe Panini $9.50
Mozzarella, Feta and American cheese with tomatoes and sauteed red onions.
Greek Supreme Panini $9.50
Feta cheese, tomatoes, mixed olives and roasted peppers.
Tuna Melt Open Faced $12.00
Tuna, mozzarella, lettuce and tomatoes.
Napolitano Panini $9.50
Mozzarella, pesto, Romaine, fresh tomatoes, balsamic vinegar.
French Connection Panini $9.50
Grilled vegetables, zucchini, onions, mushrooms, peppers and tomatoes with melted cheese.
Eggplant Parmesan Panini $9.50
Breaded eggplant, marinara sauce, Parmesan and fresh Mozzarella.

All Day Menu - Breakfast Menu
Eggs On Bagel $7.00
Muscle Man $13.50
Egg whites, peppers, tomato and onion. Served with home fries and Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Spanish Omelet $13.99
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Lox, Egg & Onion Omelet $17.99
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Greek Omelet $13.99
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Egg Whites On Bagel $8.00
Mushroom Omelet $11.95
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Eggs With Grilled Veggies $14.00
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
2 Eggs Any Style $12.95
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Spinach & Feta Omelet $12.95
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Egg Whites & Cheese On Bagel $9.00
Grilled Cheese $5.50
Egg & Cheese On Bagel $8.00

All Day Menu - Bagels
Bakers Dozen Mini Bagel $12.00
Receive a free mini bagel with this order
French Toast Bagel $1.50
Flat Bagel $2.50
Bakers Dozen Bagels $19.20
Receive a free bagel with this order
Bakers Dozen Flat Bagel $30.00
Receive a free flat bagel with this order
Mini Bagels $1.00
Bagel $1.65

All Day Menu - Catering | Baked Items
Homemade Pancakes
Banana, Blueberry or Plain
Burekas
Assorted Burekas Filled with Cheese, Spinach, Potato, Peppers and Mushrooms
Bagel And Bialy
Assorted Bagels Cut into Quarters
Homemade Blintzes
Filled with Soft Sweet Cream Cheese
Bakery Basket
Homemade Baked Cookies, Danishes or Muffins

All Day Menu - Sandwiches | Mini & Flat Bagel Sandwiches
White Fish Salad Sandwich
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Smoked Kipper Salmon Sandwich
Gravlax Salmon Sandwich
Hummus Sandwich
Baba Ganoush Sandwich
Tuna A La Chef Sandwich
Veggie Tuna Salad Sandwich
Pastrami Style-Smoked Salmon Sandwich
Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich
Sable Sandwich
Spanish Eggplant Sandwich
Egg Salad Sandwich

All Day Menu - Chef's Daily Specials
Hot Pasta Dish $9.99
Coleslaw
Vegetable Lasagna $9.99
Baked Ziti $9.99
Filet Of Fish $8.25
Eggplant Parmesan $9.99
Soup Of The Day $7.00
With free bagel. Please call the restaurant for today's selection.
Baked Ziti With Vegetables $9.99
Filet Of Fish Platter $13.00
Served with 2 sides.
Fish & Chips $11.99
Home Fries
Lasagna $9.99
Fish Of The Day Platter $18.50
Served with 2 sides.
Veggie Burger Platter $11.50
Served with 2 sides.
Fish Of The Day $13.00
Veggie Burger $7.75
Rice
Pasta Salad $9.99

All Day Menu - Catering | Platters
Vegetable Platter
Stick or Sliced: Cucumber, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Carrots and Peppers
Fruit Platter
Assorted Seasonal Fruits
Smoked Fish Platter
Whole White Fish, Sable and Lox (Only Small Platter Has Lox and Sable)
Cream Cheese Platter
Assorted Cream Cheeses: Plain, Vegetable, Scallion, Olive or Lox Spread
Combo Platter
Egg Salad, Tuna Salad and White Fish Salad
Assorted Wraps Platter
Assorted Wraps: Egg Salad, Tuna Salad, White Fish Salad, Baked Salmon Salad, Grilled Vegetable & Hummus, Hard Cheese
Mediterranean Salad Platter | Pick 3
Tahini, Hummus, Babaganush, Turkish Salad, Matbucha or Spanish Eggplant
Omelet Wraps Platter
Spinach, Cheese, Scallion, or Vegetable (Wrapped with Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion and Home Fries)
Hard Cheese Platter
Mozzarella, American, Muenster and Swiss

All Day Menu - Appetizers & Side Dishes
Garlic Knots $2.50
4 pieces.
Quiche $20.00
9" broccoli, spinach, mushroom and cheese.
Cheese Garlic Knots $7.50
10 knots with cheese and sauce.
Cheese Fries $6.75
Potato Cigars $6.50
6 pieces of fried filo dough filled with potato.
Spicy Fries $5.75
Mozzarella Sticks $7.50
6 pcs.
Large Turkish Style Borekas $5.00
Cheese, spinach cheese and potatoes.
French Fries $5.25
Nachos With Melted Cheese $7.50
Mini Borekas $1.75
Cheese, spinach cheese, potato and mushrooms.
Sweet Potato Fries $5.50
Onion Rings $5.75
10 pieces.

All Day Menu - Sandwiches | Bagel Sandwiches
Spanish Eggplant Sandwich $6.50
Baba Ganoush Sandwich $6.50
White Fish Salad Sandwich $11.75
Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich $14.25
Pastrami Style-Smoked Salmon $14.25
Vegetable Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.00
Hummus Sandwich $6.50
Egg Salad Sandwich $9.50
Gravalax Salmon Sandwich $14.25
Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.00
Smoked Kipper Salmon $14.25
Tuna A La Chef Sandwich $9.50
Vinaigrette dressing, no mayo.
Sable Sandwich $14.75

All Day Menu - Baked Goods & Desserts
Apple Strudel $4.25
Pecan Pie $6.00
Variety Of Cookies $16.00
1lb.
Cherry Cheese Knishes $7.00
Cheesecake $6.00
Black & White Cookie $4.50
Chocolate Zebra Cake $6.00
Cheese Danish $4.75
Apple Turnover $4.25
Whole Wheat Challah $7.00
Plain Challah $7.00
Croissant $4.50
Muffin $4.50
Cinnamon Twist Danish $4.25
Blueberry Cheese Knishes $7.00
Tiramisu Cake $5.00
Vanilla Yogurt, Fruit & Granola Cup $5.50
Potato & Spinach Knish $6.00
Kasha Knish $6.00
Raisin Challah $7.50
Cheese Blintz $3.25
Challah Roll $2.25
Rugelach $6.95

All Day Menu - Beverages
Herbal Tea
Coffee
Iced Tea
Tropicana Juice $3.50
Flavored Latte
Tea
Flavored Coffee
Hot Chocolate
Latte
Espresso
Smoothie
Iced Flavored Coffee
Bottle Of Soda $2.50
Iced Coffee
Iced Latte
Poland Spring Water
Snapple $2.75
Can Of Soda $2.00
Flavored Iced Latte

All Day Menu - Spreads by the Lb.
Tofu Vegetable Spread
Tuna A La Chef
Herring
Strawberry Cream Cheese
Tofu Scallion Spread
Sable
Low-Fat Plain Cream Cheese
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Walnut & Raisin Cream Cheese
Veggie Tuna Salad
Nova Scotia Salmon
Tuna Salad
Smoked Kipper Salmon
Butter
Blueberry Cream Cheese
Low-Fat Scallion Cream Cheese
Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese
Peanut Butter
Kalamata Olive Cream Cheese
Pastrami Style-Smoked Salmon
Jelly
Jalapeno Cream Cheese
Tofu Plain Spread
White Fish Salad
Scallion Cream Cheese
Hummus
Spanish Eggplant
Plain Cream Cheese
Nova Lox Spread
Egg Salad
Low-Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese
Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese
Babaganoush
Gravlax Salmon

All Day Menu - Catering | Sandwiches, Pastas, Etc.
Salad Bowl
Greek, Israeli, Caesar, Israeli Tuna, Garden
Coleslaw
Pizza | 20" Whole Wheat Plain $30.00
Pizza | 20" Topping $29.00
Pizza | 20" Whole Wheat Topping $34.00
Homemade Fries
Baked Potato with Our Special Spices, Onions & Peppers
Shakshuka
Eggs Cooked with Tomatoes, Garlic, Herbs & Peppers
Stuffed Sandwiches
Homemade Foccacia Bread Filled with Pesto Sauce, Mozzarella, Melanzane Sauce, Eggplant, Avocado or Tuna
Omelets
Mushrooms, Cheese, Spinach, Vegetable
Lasagna
Marinara Sauce & Cheese, Vegetable, Spinach or Eggplant
Pizza | 20" Plain $22.00
Pasta
Pesto Sauce, Vodka, Primavera, Marinara, Funghi, Aglio Olio, Alfredo
Homemade Quiche
Mushroom & Spinach, Zucchini & Yellow Squash, Broccoli & More

All Day Menu - Sandwich Platters
Smoked Kipper Salmon Sandwich Platter $20.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Sable Sandwich Platter $20.75
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Vegetable Tuna Salad Sandwich Platter $16.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Gravalax Salmon Sandwich Platter $20.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Baba Ganoush Sandwich Platter $17.75
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Egg Salad Sandwich Platter $13.75
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
White Fish Salad Sandwich Platter $17.75
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Herring Sandwich Platter $13.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Pastrami Style-Smoked Salmon Sandwich Platter $20.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Tuna Salad Sandwich Platter $16.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Tuna A La Chef Sandwich Platter $16.25
Vinaigrette dressing, no mayo. Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Spanish Eggplant Sandwich Platter $17.75
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.
Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich Platter $20.25
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad and a bagel.

Bagels & Co Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Bagels & Co Photos

Bagels & Co Location

Bagels & Co

New York New York County New York Amsterdam Avenue

391 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Bagels & Co Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 944 user reviews.

pizzakosherspreadsnew york bagelsquick servicecroissantswhitefish saladbaked goodstunascallion cream cheese

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

My go to bagel store when I’m in the city.Love their bagelsA lot of options !Especially with spreads .And the nova lox is out of this world !!Pizza is great too !
September 09 · Nicole pinkhas
Nice variety of bagels and baked goods. The bagels were… just bagels, and the croissants were… just croissants. Nothing bad—just nothing that stood out. It was a plus to have seating available inside the shop. Not disappointed, just a bit underwhelmed.
July 27 · K Rhodes
I absolutely love this bagel shop! The bagels are always fresh, warm, and perfectly chewy — exactly how real bagels should be. They have a great variety of flavors and toppings, and their cream cheese spreads are delicious (the veggie one is my favorite!).The staff is friendly and quick, even during busy mornings, and the place has a cozy, welcoming vibe. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast on the go or sitting down for a quick bite, it’s always a treat. Highly recommend to any bagel lover! 🥯✨ Also the place SO CLEAN IT FEELS LIKE HOME
June 30 · Adel Djouraev
I spent a few days in NYC and wanted to eat as many bagels as I could. Bagels & Co did not disappoint. I had the rainbow bagel and loved it! Cream cheese was good, as was the iced latte.
May 17 · Misty K
Great breakfast sandwiches. Bagel was outstanding and the Kaiser roll was perfect. Looking forward to returning for breakfast again.
April 03 · Albert Gerrity