Baked In Heaven Bakery

- 4 Martine Ave, White Plains, NY 10606

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers with a serious sweet tooth, especially those in Westchester County, Baked In Heaven Bakery is not your typical neighborhood bake shop—it's a destination for true dessert indulgence. Operating out of the White Plains area, this specialized bakery has built a reputation on its unique, signature creation: the “Mega-Stuffed Cookie.” Moving beyond standard chocolate chip or oatmeal raisin, Baked In Heaven has elevated the humble cookie to a spectacular dessert experience, combining oversized cookie bases with decadent, flavorful fillings and impressive toppings.

Founded by a local White Plains-based couple, the bakery has channeled a passion for innovative sweets into an online-first business model that serves dessert lovers throughout the region and nationwide. This approach allows them to focus intensely on perfecting their specialty cookies, ensuring every treat delivered is a fresh, oversized package of sweet goodness. Their concept taps directly into the New York desire for bold, high-quality, and Instagrammable food, offering flavors that are anything but ordinary. It is a modern take on the classic bakery, concentrating their efforts on a truly standout product that customers consistently rave about, calling them the "Best cookies you’ll ever try."

Baked In Heaven Bakery is a testament to the thriving small business scene in White Plains, proving that an online-based specialty can capture the hearts (and stomachs) of local dessert aficionados. By focusing on a single, masterful product category—gourmet, stuffed cookies—they offer a refreshingly singular experience in a market often saturated with traditional bakeries.

Location and Accessibility

Baked In Heaven Bakery is primarily an online-based operation that services customers from its base in White Plains, NY. While the provided address—4 Martine Ave, White Plains, NY 10606, USA—serves as their hub, it is important for New York-based customers to understand the specific nature of their service.

As a specialty business focused on innovative mega-stuffed cookies, the bakery's primary interaction with customers is through online ordering, catering, and local pickup or delivery arrangements. This online model is designed for maximum convenience and minimal friction for the local Westchester community.

Key accessibility details for this White Plains-based online bakery include:

• The business is White Plains-based but operates predominantly online, allowing customers to place orders from anywhere in the New York region.
• Service options are focused on convenience, namely Takeout (via pre-arranged pickup at the White Plains base) and delivery options (where available).
• The 'Quick visit' planning note emphasizes the fast and streamlined process once an order is placed, whether for pickup or immediate takeout.

Customers are encouraged to visit their website or contact the bakery directly to coordinate pickups or discuss local delivery for a seamless experience. This model is perfectly suited for busy New Yorkers who appreciate the convenience of ordering unique, high-quality desserts from the comfort of their home.

Services Offered

Baked In Heaven Bakery’s service model is tailored to deliver their specialized product efficiently, focusing on custom orders, packs, and quick pickup options. The main services available to customers in the New York area include:

• Specialty Cookie Creation: The core offering is the creation of unique, Mega-Stuffed Cookies in over a dozen distinct flavors.
• Online Ordering: Customers can easily browse the full menu of "Heaven" flavors and place orders for individual cookies or variety packs directly through the bakery's website.
• Variety Packs: Options like the "Build Your Own Heaven – 4 Pack" and "Complete Heaven" offer curated or customizable assortments of their best-selling cookies.
• Takeout / Pickup: Pre-arranged order pickups are available at their White Plains base for local customers.
• Special Orders and Catering: The bakery handles custom and large-volume orders for events, parties, and corporate gifting in the Westchester County area and beyond.
• Nationwide Shipping: While primarily serving the local New York community, the bakery’s online model allows them to ship their heavenly mega-stuffed cookies to dessert lovers across the United States.

Features / Highlights

Baked In Heaven Bakery is not defined by foot traffic, but by the truly exceptional nature of its unique, mega-stuffed cookies. These qualities are what have earned them a dedicated following among local New Yorkers:

• The Mega-Stuffed Cookie Specialization: This is the bakery's primary claim to fame. Each cookie is a dessert masterpiece, featuring a giant cookie base, stuffed to the brim with a flavorful filling (like buttercream or edible cookie dough), and crowned with a decadent topping.
• Innovative and Decadent Flavor Profiles: The bakery offers creative and indulgent flavors that go far beyond the norm. Popular choices include:
  • Cookies & Cream Heaven: Vanilla base with crushed Oreo's, stuffed with homemade cookies 'n cream buttercream.
  • Birthday Heaven: Funfetti base with sprinkles, stuffed with vanilla buttercream, and topped with a piece of homemade birthday cake.
  • Slutty Brownie Heaven: Chocolate base with chocolate chip cookies and Oreos, stuffed with edible chocolate chip cookie dough, and topped with a homemade slutty brownie.
  • Peanut Butter Heaven: Chocolate base with peanut butter chips, stuffed with peanut butter, and topped with a mini Reese's PB cup.
• Commitment to Quality: The emphasis is on home-baked quality, with all products prepared in-house, ensuring rich, fresh flavors and a distinctive, comforting taste that harkens back to traditional baking while offering a modern twist.
• Online-First Convenience: The highly efficient online ordering system is a perfect fit for the busy New York lifestyle, allowing customers to secure their premium desserts quickly without the uncertainty of an in-store bakery visit.
• Strong Local Reputation: The customer feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with local reviewers confirming the exceptional quality and size of the cookies, often describing them as the "Best cookies you’ll ever try."

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about catering, or coordinate a pickup for your next heavenly dessert experience, please use the following contact information. Note that all visits for pickup should be pre-arranged via phone or the online system.

Address (Base of Operations): 4 Martine Ave, White Plains, NY 10606, USA

Phone: (845) 641-6749

Mobile Phone: +1 845-641-6749

What is Worth Choosing

Baked In Heaven Bakery is the essential choice for New Yorkers in Westchester County when a standard cookie simply won't do. What truly makes this bakery worth choosing is its unwavering focus on a single, show-stopping product that delivers a truly memorable dessert moment. In a region where bakeries often offer a sprawling, generalized menu, Baked In Heaven provides a specialist's perfection.

If you are hosting an event, celebrating a milestone, or simply looking to treat yourself after a long week navigating the pace of New York, their Mega-Stuffed Cookies offer unparalleled decadence and novelty. The sheer size and innovative fillings ensure a maximum satisfaction level. New York consumers value both quality and unique experiences, and Baked In Heaven delivers on both fronts. Their Birthday Heaven or the Slutty Brownie Heaven are perfect examples of the kind of playful, rich dessert that creates a buzz at any gathering.

For residents and businesses in White Plains and the surrounding New York area, choosing Baked In Heaven means supporting a local, innovative business that prioritizes making one thing absolutely perfectly. The convenience of their online ordering system, combined with the guarantee of a spectacular, highly-rated product, makes them the premier choice for gourmet, oversized cookies. Forget the generic grocery store dessert—Baked In Heaven offers a "Heaven" of a cookie that is worth every effort to order. Their operation is built for a quick, efficient interaction ('Quick visit'), meaning you can get your gourmet treats without sacrificing your precious New York minute. This is the place to go when you crave an unforgettable cookie experience.

Baked In Heaven Bakery

4 Martine Ave, White Plains, NY 10606, USA