Benny’s Brown Bag

- 1100 Elm St, Peekskill, NY 10566

For New Yorkers craving a truly exceptional sandwich experience north of the city, look no further than **Benny's Brown Bag** in Peekskill, NY. This spot has quickly established itself as a must-visit destination for anyone who appreciates creative, high-quality, and generously-sized sandwiches. Combining the warm, inviting atmosphere of a local favorite with a truly innovative menu, Benny’s Brown Bag is more than just a sandwich shop—it’s a culinary landmark in the Hudson Valley region that’s worth the drive from anywhere in the NYC metro area.

The shop specializes in elevating the humble sandwich to an art form. It's a place where comfort food gets a gourmet twist, perfect for a satisfying lunch, a convenient dinner, or a quick, delicious bite. Whether you’re a local Peekskill resident, a college student looking for a great meal, or a tourist exploring the beauty of the Hudson River Valley, Benny's Brown Bag promises a friendly face, fast service, and a memorable meal that captures the best of local specialty flavors.

The shop’s reputation precedes it, often drawing praise for its excellent service and delicious offerings. As one satisfied customer put it, "Believe the hype. I'm an always looking for a 'good deli, good lunch sandwich guy'. Tried BBB one day. Ordered The Rachel turkey sandwich. One of the best turkey sandwiches I've ever had." Another diner noted that their sandwiches are "built to share," highlighting the incredible value and size of the portions.

---

Benny's Brown Bag is conveniently situated at **1100 Elm St, Peekskill, NY 10566**. Its location in Peekskill makes it easily accessible for residents across Westchester County and visitors coming from New York City or other parts of the Hudson Valley. This placement allows it to be a perfect stop for those heading to or from the Bear Mountain area, making it an ideal pit stop for tourists and hikers.

For visitors, the sandwich shop prioritizes convenience. Accessibility for vehicles is excellent, as the location offers both a **free parking lot** and **free street parking**. This makes grabbing a quick meal incredibly hassle-free, whether you're taking your sandwich to go or planning to dine in. The shop is designed for ease of use and welcomes a steady crowd of **college students** and **tourists**, reflecting its broad appeal.

---

Benny's Brown Bag provides a range of services designed to make enjoying their food as convenient as possible for a busy New York crowd:

• **Takeout Service:** A fast and efficient option for customers who want to grab their meal and enjoy it elsewhere, ideal for a quick lunch break or a meal on the go.
• **Catering:** Perfect for local businesses, parties, and events, allowing you to bring their highly-rated specialty sandwiches and sides to a group.
• **Dining Options:** Available for both **Lunch** and **Dinner**, making it a reliable spot throughout the day.
• **Dessert:** While the focus is on savory delights, dessert options are available to complete your meal.
• **Payment Flexibility:** They accept various modern payment methods, including **Credit cards, Debit cards,** and **NFC mobile payments**, ensuring a smooth transaction.

---

Benny's Brown Bag distinguishes itself from a standard deli with several key features that enhance the overall dining experience:

• **Creative & Generous Menu:** The shop is renowned for its selection of specialty sandwiches, which are not only delicious but also large enough to be considered a full meal or even shared. Fan favorites include the savory **Chili Crisp Turkey**, the flavorful **Chimi Chimi Ya Roast Beef**, and the decadent **Prosciutto Paisan ($17.00)**.
• **Focus on Local Specialty:** They proudly serve local specialties, giving customers a taste of regional flavors and supporting the area's food culture.
• **Dietary Inclusivity:** The menu offers excellent options for various diets, including dedicated **Vegan options** and **Vegetarian options**, such as the popular **Sky High Veggie Stack** and **Falafeeling This**.
• **Beverage Selection:** The shop offers a selection of drinks beyond the usual sodas, including **Alcohol** and **Beer**, allowing patrons to pair their delicious sandwich with a refreshing adult beverage. **Coffee** is also available.
• **Atmosphere & Vibe:** The environment is described as **Casual, Cozy,** and **Trendy**. The atmosphere is friendly, with staff consistently praised for their excellent service, often treating customers "with friendliness and a smile," as noted in reviews.
• **Pet-Friendly:** Customers can bring their furry friends, as **Dogs are allowed outside**.

---

For inquiries, placing an order, or checking their latest specials, you can reach Benny's Brown Bag using the following contact details:

Address: 1100 Elm St, Peekskill, NY 10566

Phone: (914) 600-8848

Mobile Phone: +1 914-600-8848

---

When you visit Benny's Brown Bag, you are choosing an elevated comfort food experience rooted in quality and creativity. What makes this sandwich shop truly worth choosing, especially for a New York palate, is the combination of **bold flavors, substantial portions, and genuinely warm service**.

The shop’s menu goes far beyond typical deli fare. For meat lovers, the **The Bear Mountain Hot Roast Beef** ($14.50) is a standout, celebrated for its deliciousness. For those who enjoy a twist on a classic, the **Chili Crisp Turkey** ($15.00) or the **Thai Fried Chicken Sandwich** ($13.75) offer an exciting fusion of flavors. Even a simple dish like the **Forever Young Grilled Cheese ($5.50)** is executed with care, offering pure comfort.

The customer experience is consistently rated highly. One patron noted, "Counter folks are super friendly as well," reinforcing that the excellent food is matched by a welcoming environment. They are "Popular for, Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining," demonstrating their versatility as a reliable spot for any occasion.

Moreover, the commitment to providing options like **Vegan and Vegetarian choices** ensures that everyone in your group can find something satisfying, distinguishing it from many traditional sandwich shops. The fast service and the availability of **Hawaiian Macaroni Salad** as a side add unique touches that contribute to its local charm and excellent reputation. If you're near Peekskill and in the mood for a fantastic, generously-sized sandwich, Benny's Brown Bag delivers a truly high-value and delicious meal.

Benny’s Brown Bag

1100 Elm St, Peekskill, NY 10566, USA