Benny's Luncheonette

- 11-04 Saddle River Rd, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410

Introduction / Overview: Benny's Luncheonette – A Fair Lawn Legend for Hearty Comfort

For anyone in North Jersey seeking that perfect blend of classic diner comfort, legendary sandwiches, and a truly welcoming atmosphere, Benny's Luncheonette in Fair Lawn is a destination worth knowing. This beloved neighborhood staple is far more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it represents the best of local, family-friendly dining in New Jersey, offering an extensive menu that covers everything from sunrise breakfasts to satisfying midday lunches.

Benny's has earned its reputation over decades, with locals frequently praising its commitment to quality, generous portions, and exceptional customer service. It holds a distinct, old-school diner vibe, complete with cozy booths and walls adorned with vintage memorabilia, instantly transporting guests to a simpler, more relaxed time. Upon entering, the "aroma of great-smelling food just SMACKS one right in the face," as one new customer enthusiastically noted.

While the restaurant’s lineage as a dedicated breakfast and lunch spot is well-known, its fame is anchored in serving up a renowned local specialty: the Pastrami Sandwich. This deli-style expertise, combined with a vast offering of American and classic comfort foods—including incredible omelettes, creative quesadillas, and all-day breakfast items—ensures that every visit yields a satisfying and delicious experience. The commitment to value is clear, with patrons consistently highlighting the excellent combination of affordable prices, generous portions, and consistently fresh, well-seasoned food. It’s an easy choice for solo diners, groups, and families looking for high-quality comfort food without the high-end price tag.

Location and Accessibility in Fair Lawn, NJ

Benny's Luncheonette is conveniently situated at 11-04 Saddle River Rd, placing it in a busy, easily accessible commercial area of Fair Lawn, New Jersey. Its location is a major asset, providing high visibility and convenience for both daily commuters and local residents.

The restaurant's position off a main thoroughfare means it enjoys substantial foot traffic and is a natural stop for those in the North Jersey region. Critically for the Garden State, Benny's makes parking easy by providing both a free parking lot and the option for free street parking, eliminating a common hassle for dining out.

Commitment to Accessibility:

Benny's Luncheonette is dedicated to ensuring that all guests can enjoy their dining experience comfortably and safely. The establishment features comprehensive accessibility amenities:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating

This attention to detail ensures that the cozy, welcoming atmosphere is truly available to everyone in the Fair Lawn community.

Services Offered

Benny's Luncheonette provides a full array of services to meet the diverse needs of the local North Jersey crowd, from those grabbing a quick coffee to those hosting a group lunch.

• Dine-in Service with Table Seating: Enjoy the classic, cozy, and casual atmosphere with full table service. Note that no reservations are allowed, maintaining the traditional first-come, first-served luncheonette style.
• Takeout: Perfect for busy mornings or lunch breaks; place your order ahead of time for quick and convenient pickup.
• Delivery: For those days when you can't get to the luncheonette, delivery service is available, bringing the full menu right to your door.
• Catering: The menu's extensive options for American and deli classics make Benny's a great choice for local event and office catering.
• Breakfast, Brunch, and Lunch: Serving a wide variety of meals throughout the day, the menu caters to early birds, brunch fans, and the lunchtime crowd.
• Payment Options: The restaurant accepts Checks, Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments, ensuring convenient transaction methods for all patrons.
• Amenities and Atmosphere: Features a gender-neutral restroom, free Wi-Fi, and a relaxed, casual atmosphere that is LGBTQ+ friendly and a recognized transgender safe space.
• Family-Focused: The establishment is good for kids, offering high chairs and a dedicated kids' menu.

Features / Highlights

Benny's Luncheonette distinguishes itself in the highly competitive North Jersey restaurant market through several key features that draw a loyal, multi-generational crowd:

• The Famous Pastrami: The restaurant serves a local specialty that has truly put it "on the map": the renowned Hot Pastrami sandwich, which is a must-try for any deli aficionado. The Hot Corned Beef and the Reuben Quesadilla are also high-quality, meat-centric offerings.
• Classic Diner Atmosphere: The interior features an "old-school diner vibe" with a cozy setup, old memorabilia, and a friendly environment that fosters a strong sense of community and nostalgia.
• Great Value Proposition: Customers consistently rave about the cost vs. quality and portion ratios. The prices are affordable, and the portions are generous, ensuring a fully satisfying meal every time.
• Exceptional Customer Service: The staff is frequently described as "AWESOME" and "amazing and attentive." This high level of service is a major factor that patrons cite as pushing their experience "over the top."
• Menu Depth and Variety: The extensive menu covers a wide range of needs, from hearty omelettes and pancakes for breakfast to fresh salads, deli sandwiches, and even unique items like house-made, non-greasy baked empanadas.
• Complimentary Extras: The offering of complimentary mini Chocolate Chip muffins at the start of the meal adds a thoughtful, personal touch that enhances the dining experience.
• Beverage Quality: Benny's is specifically highlighted for serving "Great coffee," providing that essential, quality kick-start to any day.

Contact Information

To plan your visit, call ahead for takeout, or arrange delivery, here is the official contact information for Benny's Luncheonette:

Address: 11-04 Saddle River Rd, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410, USA

Phone: (201) 791-0730

Mobile Phone: +1 201-791-0730

What is Worth Choosing at Benny's Luncheonette

The menu at Benny's Luncheonette is large and inviting, but for both first-timers and regulars, certain dishes stand out as quintessential choices that capture the essence of what this Fair Lawn gem does best.

The Deli Classics: You simply must try the Hot Pastrami ($10.95 / $13.95) or the Hot Corned Beef ($10.95 / $13.95). These are the sandwiches that have cemented the luncheonette's reputation. For a twist, the Pastrami Quesadilla ($11.95) offers a truly unique fusion of the local specialty with a satisfying comfort food format. The Brisket Sandwich with gravy ($13.95) is also a rich, hearty choice for meat lovers.

For a Delicious Breakfast: The omelettes are a central part of the breakfast experience. The Florentine Omelette ($11.95) is a delicious vegetarian choice, and the signature Benny’s Omelette ($11.95) is a popular favorite. For those craving a sweet start, the Stuffed challah French toast ($10.95) or the decadent Almond joy pancakes ($10.95) come highly recommended for their generous size and unique flavor profiles.

Comfort Sides and Starters: Don’t overlook the sides and appetizers. The French fries with cheese and Gravy ($5.25 / $8.25), often known as 'Disco Fries' in New Jersey, are a local favorite. The customer-reviewed baked empanadas (a unique offering not listed with a price, but noted as "absolutely delicious, not greasy") make for a great starter if available. Finally, be sure to grab a cup of the highly-praised Great coffee to complete your cozy dining experience.

Benny's Luncheonette is a true pillar of the Fair Lawn dining community, successfully marrying the nostalgia of a classic New Jersey diner with a consistently high-quality, generously portioned, and diverse menu. It is an establishment where you can expect excellent food and leave with the assurance that your business is deeply appreciated.

Benny's Luncheonette

11-04 Saddle River Rd, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410, USA