Best Pizza

- 1 American Dream Wy, East Rutherford, NJ 07073

Welcome to the Garden State's premier destination for entertainment, shopping, and dining—the American Dream Mall in East Rutherford. As New Jersey locals, we know a great slice of pizza is not just a meal; it's a necessity. That's why we're shining a spotlight on one of the mall's popular casual dining options: Best Pizza. Nestled within the expansive complex, this spot offers a taste of classic pizza that is celebrated by visitors looking for a comforting and quick bite while enjoying all the attractions the mall has to offer.

Best Pizza has a history rooted in the East Coast pizza tradition. The original concept was established in 2010 by Frank Pinello in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, and is celebrated for bringing a distinctive approach to the classic New York-style slice. Its presence in the American Dream Mall brings this celebrated style of pizza directly to a convenient location for North Jersey residents and visitors. While the name boldly suggests a high standard, the establishment focuses on delivering a reliable, straightforward, and satisfying pizza experience that hits the spot when you need a refuel. It serves as a great stop for families, solo diners, and anyone needing some comfort food in a hurry.

The location within a major entertainment and retail hub like American Dream means Best Pizza caters to a high-traffic, fast-paced environment. This means the service model is centered around efficiency, providing hot and fresh slices and pies quickly, which is perfect for a lunch or dinner break between shopping or visits to the water park and amusement park rides. For locals in the East Rutherford area, or those passing through for a day of fun, Best Pizza offers a familiar and comforting option amid the many choices at the mall's food courts.

Location and Accessibility

Finding Best Pizza is easy for anyone navigating the vast layout of the American Dream Mall. The restaurant is strategically located within the complex, making it a convenient pit stop.

Address: 1 American Dream Wy, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA

Accessibility is a key factor for any business in a major complex, and Best Pizza ensures all guests can easily enjoy their offerings. The restaurant is situated in an area of the mall that features a wheelchair accessible entrance, making it welcoming for all patrons. For those driving to the mall, the location benefits from the general mall infrastructure, including a paid parking lot that offers wheelchair accessible parking, ensuring a smoother visit from arrival to departure. Its spot within the mall's food court or dining area is designed for casual access and quick service, keeping up with the flow of mall traffic.

Services Offered

Best Pizza is set up as a classic casual pizza restaurant, focused on providing quick and satisfying meals. Their service model is tailored for the high-volume environment of the American Dream Mall, emphasizing convenience and speed without sacrificing the core appeal of a fresh slice.

• Takeout: Perfect for grabbing a slice or a pie to enjoy elsewhere in the mall or to take home after a long day of activities.
• Dine-in: Available for patrons who wish to sit and enjoy their meal in the casual, family-friendly atmosphere.
• Lunch Service: A popular option for a midday meal, catering to both mall employees and visitors.
• Dinner Service: Provides a quick and easy option for evening dining.
• Comfort Food & Quick Bites: The entire menu is structured to offer classic comfort food and fast 'quick bite' options, ideal for refuelling.
• Small Plates: Certain menu items are available in smaller servings, perfect for a quick snack or for sharing.
• Payments: Accepts both traditional debit cards and modern NFC mobile payments for a seamless transaction experience.

Features / Highlights

When you're looking for a specific type of experience at the American Dream Mall, knowing the highlights of Best Pizza can help you make a choice. It aims to deliver a focused and enjoyable pizza-eating experience.

• New York-Style Slices: The fundamental highlight is their dedication to the classic New York-style slice, a beloved format known for its foldable crust and balance of sauce and cheese.
• Variety of Slices and Pies: The menu offers a focused but satisfying selection of slices, including Cheese, Pepperoni, White, Grandma, Veggie, Vodka, Sicilian, and Buffalo, alongside full Cheese and Grandma pies.
• Popular for Quick Meals: Given its location and concept, the establishment is exceptionally popular for both lunch and dinner, making it a reliable spot for a meal during a busy day.
• Casual and Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The vibe is relaxed and casual, making it an excellent choice for families with children and groups of friends.
• Solo-Diner Friendly: The quick service and slice format make it an ideal stop for individuals dining alone.
• Classic Beverage Pairings: In addition to the pizza, they offer classic beverage choices like Bottle Soda, Homemade Lemonade, and Bottle Water, which perfectly complement the meal.
• Dedicated Customer Service: Based on customer feedback, the staff is known for being nice and welcoming, adding a pleasant personal touch to the quick-service model.

Menu Deep Dive: What’s on Offer

Best Pizza keeps its menu straightforward, focusing on quality variations of classic pizza. This approach simplifies the decision-making process for busy shoppers and ensures speed in service.

Slices (A Great Quick Bite):

• Cheese ($5.25): The quintessential New York-style slice, perfect for a classic fix.
• Pepperoni ($6.25): A popular choice featuring savory pepperoni.
• White ($6.25): A cheese-lover's favorite, typically made with ricotta and mozzarella without red sauce.
• Grandma ($6.25): A denser, square-cut slice often noted for its robust, fresh tomato sauce and layered cheese.
• Veggie (Price N/A): A good option for those seeking a fresh, vegetable-topped slice.
• Vodka ($6.50): A rich, creamy, and unique slice featuring the popular vodka sauce.
• Sicilian ($6.50): Known for its thick, spongy crust and square shape.
• Buffalo ($6.25): Likely a slice featuring a buffalo chicken or buffalo sauce base, offering a spicy kick.

Pies (For Sharing or Larger Appetites):

• Cheese (Price N/A)
• Grandma (Price N/A)

Others:

• Garlic Knots: Customer reviews highlight the "top notch" quality of the garlic knots, noting they are "very flavorful" and come with a delicious accompanying sauce. They are highly recommended for an appetizer or side.
• Drinks: Bottle Soda, Homemade Lemonade, Bottle Water.

Contact Information

For any inquiries about the menu, services, or location, you can reach Best Pizza directly.

Address: 1 American Dream Wy, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA

Phone: (551) 248-4961

Mobile Phone: +1 551-248-4961

What is Worth Choosing at Best Pizza?

For New Jersey residents and visitors, Best Pizza is worth choosing primarily for its convenience and specific style of offering. It’s an essential, quick option within the sprawling American Dream complex. When you are done with a thrilling ride, a successful shopping trip, or an exciting day at the water park, you often need a meal that is fast, familiar, and satisfying. Best Pizza delivers on that promise with its classic New York-style slices.

One of the most valuable takeaways from customer experiences is the recommendation for the Garlic Knots. While pizza quality in a high-traffic mall food court can be hit or miss—as some reviews suggest a focus on efficiency over intricate quality—the garlic knots consistently receive high praise for being "top notch" and "very flavorful." They are a must-try side dish that adds significant value to the meal.

Furthermore, the establishment’s dedication to providing a family-friendly, casual atmosphere, coupled with quick service for both lunch and dinner, makes it a reliable choice. For parents, a restaurant that is "Good for kids" and has a short line is often the 'best' choice in a busy environment.

The variety of slice offerings, from the traditional Cheese and Pepperoni to more unique options like Grandma and Vodka slices, ensures there is a flavor profile for almost everyone in your party. If you are a fan of thin, crispy crusts and classic New York-style preparation, this spot provides one of the few dedicated options within the American Dream Mall itself. While some customers note the price and a slight variation from what they might consider the absolute 'best' pizza in a region spoiled by great pizza, the value of a quick, hot, and classic slice in this prime location is undeniable. It's the perfect choice for a quick, comforting, and kid-approved meal, especially when you pair your slice with their standout garlic knots and a refreshing homemade lemonade.

In summary, if you’re at American Dream in East Rutherford and craving a fast, casual, and reliably classic slice of pizza—and especially some excellent garlic knots—Best Pizza is a highly convenient and solid choice for your New Jersey outing.

Best Pizza

1 American Dream Wy, East Rutherford, NJ 07073, USA