Black Horse Pub

- 568 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

For New Yorkers searching for that perfect mix of an authentic, comfortable pub atmosphere, exceptional comfort food, and the thrill of watching a live match, the Black Horse Pub in Brooklyn stands out as a genuine neighborhood institution. More than just a bar, this establishment proudly blends the best elements of a New American restaurant, a classic English pub, and a high-energy sports bar into one cozy, trendy location. While it’s renowned for its traditional pub fare, its menu also features a selection of hearty sandwiches and paninis that easily qualify it as a must-visit for anyone craving a satisfying midday or evening bite in the Park Slope/South Slope area.

Stepping inside, you’ll find a casual, cozy, and trendy environment where you can unwind, catch up with friends, or simply enjoy a great meal. The pub is known for its stellar, attentive service—a welcome highlight in the city—and an impressively curated list of draft beers, cocktails, and wine. Whether you're a local resident or a tourist exploring the borough, Black Horse Pub offers a uniquely vibrant experience that feels both genuinely New York and traditionally British.

One particularly praised aspect of the Black Horse Pub is its commitment to quality food. Patrons rave about the traditional English dishes, noting that it’s one of the rare places in Brooklyn attempting—and nearly perfecting—a proper Full English breakfast. But for those focused on a filling sandwich, the menu delivers with satisfying options that cater to various tastes.

The Black Horse Pub is conveniently situated in the heart of one of Brooklyn’s most charming and accessible neighborhoods.

The exact location is: 568 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA (at 16th St.).

Its spot on 5th Avenue—a main thoroughfare—makes it an easy destination for locals and a simple trip for visitors. For those driving, paid street parking is typically available nearby. Critically for all New Yorkers, the pub strives for full accessibility, offering a wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible restroom. The atmosphere is welcoming to all, easily accommodating groups for a celebratory outing or even solo dining for a quiet meal and a pint.

The Black Horse Pub offers a robust range of services and dining options designed to cater to a diverse urban crowd.

• Dining Service: Patrons can choose between traditional Dine-in service with comfortable Seating and Table service, or opt for casual dining at the bar.
• Off-Premise Options: For convenience, Takeout and Delivery are available, ensuring you can enjoy their food and drinks at home.
• Al Fresco Dining: Enjoy the Brooklyn air with their popular Outdoor seating.
• Group Accommodations: The pub Accepts reservations, making it a great venue for planning ahead, especially for larger gatherings or during busy sports events.
• Payment Flexibility: They accept all modern payment methods including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

What truly sets Black Horse Pub apart are its highlights, which create a consistently enjoyable and popular experience for the community.

• Great Beer Selection: The pub boasts an impressive list of Drafts and Bottles, ranging from classic imports like Guinness and Peroni ($7.00) to craft options like Ballast Sculpin IPA ($8.00) and Bells Two Hearted ($8.00), alongside a variety of wines and hard liquor.
• Live Sports Viewing: As a dedicated Sports bar, it's known as an ideal spot to catch live soccer matches and other key games, with a spacious interior that easily hosts a large, energetic crowd.
• Fast Service: Customers frequently praise the Fast service and attentive staff, even when the pub is packed.
• Happy Hour: They offer both Happy hour drinks and Happy hour food, providing great value for after-work crowds.
• Entertainment: Don't miss their popular Trivia night for a fun, competitive evening.
• Signature Sandwiches/Paninis: The menu features satisfying selections like the BALT (Bacon, Avocado, Lettuce, Tomato, Garlic Aioli), the Grilled Chicken Sammy, and the comforting Nonna's Meatball Panini, ensuring a high-quality sandwich shop experience is always on offer.
• Cocktails and Wine: Beyond beer, the selection of Great cocktails and Wine (Pinot Noir, Cabernet, Chardonnay, etc., all available for $8.00) rounds out the extensive beverage program.

Ready to plan your visit or place an order?

Address: 568 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA (at 16th St.)

Phone: (718) 788-1975

When visiting Black Horse Pub, the choice can be tough given the menu's variety. However, the experience itself is a main attraction. You’re not just going out for food or a drink; you’re immersing yourself in a vibrant, friendly atmosphere that has made it a community favorite.

For the true enthusiast, the pub’s famous take on traditional English fare is a must-try. The Full English breakfast, even with a slight variation on the sausage, is considered a local triumph, especially the "absolutely nailed" black pudding. For savory comfort, the Blackhorse Bangers and Mash served with Guinness beer-beef au jus gravy, and the rich Shepherd's Pie are quintessential pub choices.

However, if you came specifically for the sandwich shop experience, two items stand out:

• The BALT ($14.00): This is a sophisticated twist on a classic, adding creamy avocado and flavorful garlic aioli to the standard bacon, lettuce, and tomato on a soft potato bun. It’s a perfect, fresh, and filling choice.
• Nonna's Meatball Panini ($12.00): A warm, hearty, and satisfying panini featuring housemade Italian meatballs, provolone cheese, mushrooms, and sauce, pressed until perfectly crisp. This is an ideal comfort sandwich.

Pair your food with one of their celebrated beverages. A cold pint of Guinness on tap is the classic pub choice, or explore their extensive beer list. If you're a cocktail person, you’ll find that their drink offerings are praised by customers. Ultimately, whether you are stopping by for a casual lunch, meeting a group to watch a match, or enjoying a full evening dinner, Black Horse Pub provides a high-quality, memorable, and welcoming experience that keeps Brooklynites coming back for more.

Black Horse Pub

568 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA