Buttermilk Bar

- 577 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

The Buttermilk Bar: A South Slope Neighborhood Classic

In a city always moving at a breakneck pace, finding a genuine, laid-back local bar is a true gem. For Brooklynites, the Buttermilk Bar in the South Slope neighborhood is exactly that place. Far from the high-gloss cocktail lounges or pretentious hotspots, Buttermilk Bar stands out as a quintessential New York City dive bar, blending retro charm with a decidedly unpretentious, welcoming atmosphere. It's the kind of spot where locals and newcomers alike can settle in for a night of affordable drinks, vintage entertainment, and easy conversation.

The bar’s vibe is consistently described as chill, cozy, and casual, making it a fantastic destination whether you're catching up with a group of friends or enjoying a relaxed first date. It’s a place that doesn’t take itself too seriously, prioritizing fun and a sense of community. Its enduring popularity confirms its status as a beloved institution in the Brooklyn nightlife scene, offering a comforting and authentic experience that many Manhattan spots simply can't match. Named for the channel that separates Brooklyn and Governors Island, this spot may be spartan, but its spirit is anything but small.

Location and Accessibility

The Buttermilk Bar is centrally located in the vibrant South Slope neighborhood of Brooklyn, making it easily accessible for residents across the borough and those coming from other parts of NYC. You'll find this local haven at the following address:

Address: 577 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

The bar is situated near the corner of 5th Avenue and 16th Street, an area bustling with other local businesses and eateries. For those utilizing public transportation, the bar is conveniently located near major subway lines. You can take the F or G train to Fourth Ave–9th St or the R train to Prospect Ave.

For visitors driving to the neighborhood, free street parking is often available, a welcomed convenience in a busy Brooklyn area. A key factor in Buttermilk Bar's commitment to hospitality is its excellent accessibility. The venue is designed to be inclusive, with a wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible restroom, ensuring a comfortable visit for all patrons.

Services Offered

Buttermilk Bar is a full-service establishment focused on providing a quality, affordable, and entertaining nightlife experience. They offer a diverse selection of beverages and a relaxed approach to dining and socializing.

Full Bar Service: The bar offers a wide range of alcoholic beverages including a great selection of Beer, Cocktails, Hard Liquor, and Wine.Happy Hour Specials: Patrons can take advantage of attractive Happy Hour drinks deals, which historically have run from Tuesday through Sunday, typically from 5 pm to 9 pm. Specials often include discounts on draft beers, well drinks, and bottled beers.Outside Food Allowed: While the bar does not serve a food menu, it has an incredibly accommodating policy: outside food is allowed. This means you can order from a nearby restaurant, like the pizzeria across the street, and enjoy your meal right at the bar—a major perk for a casual hangout.Payment Flexibility: Customers can pay using modern convenience options, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.Clean Amenities: A well-maintained restroom is available for all guests.

Features and Highlights

What truly sets Buttermilk Bar apart is its impressive array of entertainment options and its dedication to a fun, low-key atmosphere. It's a true "classy dive bar," as some patrons have affectionately called it, where the focus is on camaraderie and classic fun.

Classic Bar Games: Buttermilk Bar is famous for its collection of engaging entertainment. You can easily spend an entire night challenging friends with pool, darts, pinball machines, air hockey, and even arcade bowling machines. A variety of board games are also kept behind the bar, perfect for a cozy, low-key night.Great Beer Selection: The bar is known for offering a quality, diverse selection of beers on tap and in bottles/cans, catering to all tastes, from craft enthusiasts to those who prefer classic domestics.Drafts include: Sixpoint Bengal IPA, Coney Island Pilsner, Sixpoint Sweet Action, Brooklyn Oktoberfest, Lagunitas IPA, Stella, Guinness, and Bell's Amber.Bottled/Canned options feature: High Life, Bud, Bud Light, Blue Moon, Corona, Heineken, Red Stripe, Amstel, Coors Banquet, Tecate, White Claw, and Peroni.Friendly and Fast Service: A major highlight for customers is the fast service provided by the friendly and professional bartenders, contributing to the bar's warm and welcoming ambiance.Killer Jukebox: The music is an essential part of the vibe, featuring a killer jukebox with tunes that are pleasant and lively without being too loud, allowing for easy conversation.Photo Booth: A popular feature for dates and groups is the in-house photo booth, providing a fun, retro way to capture the night.Cozy and Casual Atmosphere: The bar exudes a laid-back charm with its retro decor, making it a comfortable, intimate setting ideal for groups to gather and make unforgettable memories. The overall vibe is casual and cozy, attracting a local crowd.

Contact Information

Getting in touch with Buttermilk Bar or locating it for your next outing is simple.

Address: 577 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

Phone: (718) 788-6297

Operating Hours: The bar generally operates late into the night, often until 4:00 AM or 5:00 AM daily, accommodating night owls and those looking for a final stop in their evening.

What Is Worth Choosing Buttermilk Bar

For New Yorkers in search of a bar that truly understands the meaning of unpretentious fun and local charm, Buttermilk Bar is an absolute must-visit. The entire experience is built around relaxation, good company, and great value.

You should choose Buttermilk Bar for its unparalleled combination of entertainment and affordability. It manages to be a true dive bar—with its relaxed rules, affordable prices, and retro decor—while still maintaining a classy, welcoming edge. The diverse selection of games, including pinball, pool, and darts, provides the perfect pleasant distraction and a built-in activity for dates or group hangouts. Coupled with a vast and varied beer selection, including several local Brooklyn drafts, and attractive Happy Hour specials, your budget is sure to stay intact.

Furthermore, the outside food allowed policy gives you complete freedom in your dining choice, setting it apart from bars with restrictive menus. In short, Buttermilk Bar is not just a place to grab a drink; it's a social hub and a core part of the South Slope community, offering a chill, friendly, and lively atmosphere that embodies the best of Brooklyn's neighborhood bar culture. If you’re looking for a comfortable spot where you can easily strike up a conversation, challenge a friend to a game, and enjoy a quality drink without the fuss, this is your place.

Buttermilk Bar

577 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA