Boniello's: Riverdale, NJ's Home for Authentic Italian Comfort Food and Catering

Boniello's Introduce

Boniello's, located at 72 Hamburg Turnpike in Riverdale, NJ 07457, is a deeply-rooted, family-owned Italian restaurant and Caterer that has been serving Northern New Jersey for decades. Starting its tradition over 50 years ago with founder Cosmo Boniello, the establishment today continues to operate with the same commitment to Old-World classics and genuine hospitality, now under the care of Tony Boniello, his wife, and daughters. This Italian restaurant is much more than a dining spot; it is a community staple that makes every visitor feel like "a part of the Boniello Family."

The atmosphere is a perfect blend of Casual, Cozy, and surprisingly Trendy, offering a comfortable backdrop for family dinners, group gatherings, and romantic meals. The restaurant is particularly known for its generous portions—a true mark of New Jersey hospitality—which ensure that leftovers are often part of the routine. The menu is a comprehensive tour of Italian-American comfort food, expertly balancing traditional recipes, like Lasagna ($26.00) and Stuffed Clams ($15.00), with unique house specialties and modern creations.

The vast and tempting menu includes distinct categories, offering something for every palate:

Signature Entrees (Chicken or Veal): Highlighting the kitchen's mastery are dishes such as the famous Chicken ala Boniello ($26.00), a lightly breaded cutlet sautéed with mushrooms in a pink sauce, and classic preparations like Parmigiana, Francese, and Marsala ($22.00 each).
Homemade Pasta: A point of pride for Boniello's, the menu features freshly made pasta in dishes like Manicotti ($24.00), Lasagna ($26.00), and various Ravioli.
Specialty Pies and Baked Goods: A wide selection of pizzas, including the Large Cheese Pie ($17.00), Thin Sicilian ($23.00), and unique creations like the Garbage Pie ($30.00), along with Strombolis and Calzones. Gluten Free Pie ($17.00) and Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pie ($17.00) options are also available.
Seafood and Shellfish: Fresh and expertly prepared dishes like Zuppa di Pesce ($36.00), Linguini Clam Sauce ($25.00), and unique items such as Shrimp Boniello ($29.00).
Appetizers and Small Plates: Highly praised starters include Vikki's Rice Ball ($9.00), Meatballs ($12.00), Buffalo Knots ($7.00), and the trending Chicken Vodka Sliders ($17.00).
Innovative Offerings: The menu features modern twists and items inspired by regulars, such as the Gnocchi Flight ($28.00), the Fat Boy Specialty Pie ($35.00), and the Caesar Milanese ($21.00).

Location and Accessibility

Boniello's is conveniently located on Hamburg Turnpike in Riverdale, making it an accessible and well-known fixture in the 07457 community and for travelers on Route 23.

Address: 72 Hamburg Turnpike, Riverdale, NJ 07457

The restaurant provides excellent accessibility features for patrons in New Jersey:

Accessibility is a priority, offering a Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible seating, and a Wheelchair accessible restroom.
Parking is ample and convenient, with a Free parking lot and Free street parking available, even if the lot access can be tricky during peak hours.
The establishment is highly Family-friendly, with dedicated amenities including High chairs and a Kids' menu.
For those with pets, Dogs are allowed outside in the Outdoor seating area.

Services Offered

Boniello's commitment to hospitality is evident in its comprehensive range of services, designed to accommodate almost any dining preference or event need.

Dining Options: Patrons can enjoy their meal through Dine-in, Takeout, Delivery, Curbside pickup, and seasonally available Outdoor seating.
Full Service and Seating: Both Table service and general Seating are provided, along with a Restroom for customer convenience.
Catering Specialist: Recognized as a Caterer, Boniello's offers extensive Hot Buffet options, full-tray Starters, and Entrees for gatherings, including packages like The Feast ($25.00 per person) and the Hot Buffet (20 Person Minimum).
Reservation Flexibility: The restaurant Accepts reservations, with Dinner reservations recommended due to the venue’s popularity, especially for Groups.
Beverage Policy: Boniello's is a BYOB (Bring Your Own Beverage) establishment, allowing guests to enjoy their preferred Alcohol and Wine with their meal, while the restaurant provides Coffee.
Menu Diversity: Offerings include Comfort food, Healthy options, Quick bite selections, and a Great dessert menu, ensuring all dietary preferences are addressed.
Payment Methods: All modern payment types are accepted, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features / Highlights

Boniello's stands out in the Northern New Jersey dining landscape for several key features that drive its strong local reputation:

Authentic Family Legacy and Recipes: The business is anchored in a 50-year family tradition, featuring homemade sauces and pasta based on recipes passed down through generations, ensuring a truly authentic taste of Old-World Italian-American cooking.
Signature Local Specialty Dishes: Key features include the Chicken ala Boniello, famous for its pink mushroom sauce, and their "Gargantuan" Strombolis, which local reviewers consider a must-try item.
BYOB Policy: The "Bring Your Own Beverage" model provides significant value and personal choice for New Jersey diners, allowing them to enjoy their favorite wine or alcohol pairing without restaurant markups.
Exceptional Hospitality and Ambiance: The combination of a Cozy and Trendy atmosphere with genuinely attentive and amiable service makes the dining experience feel personal, earning high praise from repeat customers.
Generous Portions and Value: The restaurant is known for its large, filling portions, which regulars consider "hospitality measured in ounces," ensuring that patrons feel satisfied and often have leftovers for the next day.
Dessert and Unique Items: Despite some mixed reviews on traditional items like cannoli, the menu boasts unique offerings such as Pumpkin Ravioli, Italian Sushi, and specialty items like the Pizza Cone, adding an element of culinary adventure.

Contact Information

To make a reservation for Dinner or to place a catering order for your next event, please contact Boniello's using the information below:

Address: 72 Hamburg Turnpike, Riverdale, NJ 07457

Phone: (973) 831-0222

What Is Worth Choosing

Boniello's is worth choosing for New Jersey users seeking high-quality, authentic, and generously portioned Italian-American Comfort food in a warm, family-friendly environment. The true value proposition is the combination of decades-old family recipes, such as the celebrated Chicken ala Boniello and Homemade Pasta, with the money-saving convenience of the BYOB policy. This makes it an ideal spot for a moderately priced, yet high-quality, night out for families and Groups.

Patrons should visit for the unique local specialties and the vibrant, Cozy atmosphere. The availability of diverse menu items, including Gluten Free options and specialty pies like the 'Rafael personal margarita' with ricotta-stuffed crust and sesame seeds, shows a commitment to culinary innovation alongside tradition. With Fast service, full accessibility features, and a staff that treats customers like "dear friends," Boniello's remains a highly recommended and essential stop on the Northern New Jersey dining map.

Boniello's Food & drink

Appetizers
Meatballs $12.00
2 per Order
Vikki's Rice Ball $9.00
Homemade with Ground Beef, Peas & Mozzarella or Simply Mozzarella with a side of Marinara Sauce (1 Per Order)
Meatball Sliders $15.00
A Slice of Meatball & Marinara on a Garlic Knot Bun (4 Per Order)
Buffalo Knots $7.00
Side of Ranch or Blue Cheese
Garlic Knots $6.00
Side of Marinara
Chicken Vodka Sliders $17.00
Breaded Chicken in our House Vodka Sauce (Ham, Chicken & Olives) on a Garlic Knot Bun (4 Per Order)
Bruschetta $12.00
Fried Calamari $17.00
Hand Battered & Deep Fried Tubes & Tentacles with a Side of Marinara
Buffalo Calamari $18.00
Fried Calamari Tossed in a Spicy Buffalo Sauce Topped with Blue Cheese Crumbles (HOT, HOT, HOT)
Mussels or Clams $18.00
White Wine Lemon Sauce or a Red Sauce (Sweet, Medium, Hot)
Stuffed Clams $15.00
Four large Clams Stuffed with Cheesy Filing Baked in the Oven & Served with Lemon
Wings Battered or Naked $21.00
Atomic, Traditional Nuclear, BBQ, Buffalo- Garlic, Garlic Ranch, Garlic Parm Tony's Brigade, Chipotle, Teryaki, Mango Habanero
Stuffed Mushrooms $13.00
Filled with Veggies & Breadcrumbs topped with Francese Sauce
Garlic Bread $8.00
Add Mozzarella + $2
Mozzarella Sticks $12.00
Fried Pickles $15.00
Served on a Stick! Hand-Battered & Deep Fried with a Touch of Spice & a side of Spicy Boom Boom Sauce
Chicken Tenders $12.00
Side of Honey Mustard
Fries $8.00

Salads
House Salad $14.00
Romaine, Iceberg, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Cucumbers, Carrots, Red Roasted Peppers, Artichoke Hearts, Green & Black Olives with Homemade Balsamic
Jodi's Grilled Peach Salad $17.00
Grilled Peaches, Candied Wahuts, Croutons & Fresh Mozzarella over Romaine with Homemade Balsamic
Grilled Portobello Salad $15.00
Gilled Portobello Mushrooms marinated in Balsamic Vinegar over Arugula with Fresh Tomatoes with Balsamic Vinegar
Vikki's Beet Salad $14.00
Baby Arugula, Crumbled Feta, Fresh Sweet Beets & Candied Walnuts with Raspberry-Walnut Vinaigrette
Bruschetta Salad $18.00
Fresh Spinach, Fresh Mozzarella, Croutons, Fresh Bruschetta & Grilled Chicken with Balsamic & Oil
Antipasto $18.00
Our House Salad with at the fixings as well as Ham & Provolone Roll-Ups, Salami Flowerets with Red-Wine Vinaigrette
Caesar Salad $14.00
Romaine, Black Olives, Grated Parmesan, Shredded Mozzarella & Croutons tossed in our Caesar Dressing
Greek Salad $16.00
Romaine, Kalamata Olives, Crumbled Feta, Cucumbers, Red Onions, Tomatoes & Grape Leaves with Greek Feta Dressing
Seafood Salad $24.00
A Crowd Favorite! Calamari, Clams, Mussels, Shrimp & Scungilli with Chopped Red Onion, Capers & Celery in a Red-Wine Lemon Vinaigrette
Caprese Salad $15.00
House-Puled Fresh Mozzarella topped with Sliced Tomato & Fresh Basil Drizzled with EVOO over Arugula. Add Chicken + $5, Breaded or Grilled (Blackened + $1) | Add Shrimp + $9, Grilled (Blackened + $1)

Sandwiches
Meatball Parmigiana $14.00
Chicken Parmigiana $14.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $14.00
Veal Parmigiana $16.00
Italian Hot Dog $15.00
Topped with Sauteed Peppers, Onions & Potatoes
Sausage, Peppers, Onions $14.00
Boardwalk Style or with Marinara
Cheesesteak $13.00
Request to Add Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms & Potatoes
Chicken Cheesesteak $13.00
Request to Add Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms & Potatoes
Pizza Dough Sub $18.00
Crowd Favorite! Ham, Provolone, Salami, Capicola, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Oil & Vinegar Baked in the oven in our Calzone Dough
Pepper & Egg $12.00
Italian Sub $13.00
Ham, Provolone, Salami, Capicola, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Oil & Vinegar
Breaded/Grilled Chicken $13.00
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Oil & Vinegar
Chicken Italiano $15.00
Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella, Red Roasted Peppers, Arugula, Balsamic Vinegar

Soups
Pasta Fagioli $9.00
With Sausage
Escarole & Bean $9.00
With Potatoes
Tortellini en Brodo $9.00
Cheese Tortellini in a Chicken Broth with Spinach, Peas & Onions
Chicken Tortilla $12.00
Topped with Avocado, Cilantro, Tortilla Strips & Feta
Cream of Mushroom $9.00
French Onion $9.00

Homemade Pasta
Manicotti $24.00
3 Crepes filled with Ricotta topped with Tomato Basil & Melted Shredded Mozzarella
Lasagna $26.00
Cheese Lasagna (Add Bolognese + $4)
Cheese Ravioli $24.00
Choice of Sauce: Marinara, Tomato, Basil, Garlic & Oil Parmed (+ $2)
Spinach Ravioli $24.00
Choice of Sauce: Marinara, Tomato, Basil, Garlic & Oil Parmed (+ $2)
Homemade Pasta
Served with a side salad!

Chicken or Veal
Ala Boniello $26.00
Crowd Favorite' Sautéed in a Pink Sauce with Button Mushrooms
Parmigiana $22.00
Breaded & Fried topped with Marinara Sauce & Melted Shredded Mozzarella (Pink Sauce + $2)|
Francese $22.00
Egg-Battered & Fried in a Thickened Lemon White Wine Sauce
Marsala $22.00
Sauteed with Mushrooms in a sweet Marsala Wine Sauce
Pizzaiola $23.00
Sautéed in a Tomato Basil Sauce with Melted House-Puled Fresh Mozzarella
Cacciatore $22.00
Sauteed with Chopped Onions & Mushrooms in a Red-Wine Tomato Basil Sauce
Piccata $22.00
Sauteed in a White Wine Lemon Sauce with Capers
Lemon $22.00
Sauteed with Mushrooms in a White Wine Lemon Sauce
Saltimbocca $27.00
Sauteed in Herb White Wine Lemon Sauce with Prosciutto, Spinach & House-Pulled Fresh Mozzarella
Unstuffed $27.00
Sauteed in White Wine Lemon Sauce with Prosciutto, Broccoli Rabe & House-Puled Fresh Mozzarella
Valdostana $27.00
Sauteed with Prosciutto, Fontina Cheese & Spinach in a White Wine Sauce with a Drizzle of Tomato Basil
Chicken or Veal
Served over pasta! If you would like a salad instead, it is a 1$ upcharge!

Pasta
Spaghetti $16.00
(Marinara, Tomato Basil, Garlic & Oil)
Cavatelli & Broccoli $21.00
Tortellini or Fettuccini Alfredo with Ham $21.00
Baked Ziti or Spaghetti $21.00
In Pink Sauce + $2
Penne Arribiatta $20.00
Spicy Tomato Basil, Bacon, Mushrooms
Gnocchi Pesto $24.00
Grandma's Homemade Creamy Pesto
Penne Vodka $19.00
Chopped Ham, Chicken & Olives in a Creamy Pink Sauce
Penne Pink $19.00
Penne Tartufo $21.00
Peas, Mushrooms & Prosciutto in a Creamy Pink Sauce
Spaghetti Carbonara $21.00
Bacon, Parmesan & Heavy Cream
Rigatoni Bolognese $23.00
Authentic Italian Recipe! Ground Pork & Beef, Chopped Celery & Carrots
Grilled Spaghetti & Veggies $24.00
Teriyaki or Marsala
Angel Hair Primavera $22.00
A mix of Vegetables in your choice of Red Alfredo, Pink or Garlic & Oil Sauce
Spaghetti Puttanseca $20.00
Capers, Olives & Anchovies, Tomato Basil
Gnocchi Verdi $23.00
Pink Sauce with Spinach
Upcharges
$2 Cavatelli, Gnocchi, Stuffed Rigatoni, Tortellini | $3 (GF) Penne/Spaghetti & Whole Wheat Penne/Spaghetti

Seafood
Linguini Clam Sauce $25.00
White or Red & a Side Salad
Zuppa di Pesce $36.00
Shrimp, Mussels. Clams & Calamari over Linguini & a Side Salad
Shrimp $26.00
Marinara, Parmigiana, Francese, Fra Diavolo or Scampi over Pasta & a Side Salad
Shrimp Boniello $29.00
Sautéed Shrimp & Sliced Button Mushrooms in a Pink Sauce with Fettuccini & a Side Salad
Shrimp Rosa $29.00
Sautéed Shrimp, Prosciutto, Peas & Mushrooms in a Pink Sauce with Angel Hair & a Side Salad
Salmon $29.00
Broiled, Blackened (Spicy), or Grilled with a side of Sautéed Veggies & Rice. Choice of White Wine Lemon or a Creamy Horseradish Sauce
Calamari Marinara or Fra Diavolo $27.00
Broiled over Pasta & a Side Salad
Flounder $27.00
Broiled or Fried. Choice of Marinara, Francese, or White Wine Lemon with a Choice of 2: Spinach , Pasta or Side Salad
Flounder Boniello $30.00
Panko-Crusted & Fried topped with Boniello Sauce & Spinach over Fettuccini & a Side Salad

Eggplant
Parmigiana $21.00
Lightly Floured & Fried Eggplant topped with Marinara & Shredded Mozzarella
Rollatini $23.00
3 Thinly-Sliced Flourless Eggplant pieces filled with Ricotta, topped with Tomato Basil & Shredded Mozzarella
Eggplant Entrees
Served Over Pasta, if you would prefer a side salad it is just a 1$ up-charge!

Pizza
Large Cheese Pie $17.00
Personal Cheese Pie $12.00
Thick Sicilian $15.00
Thin Sicilian $23.00
Seasoned Crust $27.00
Pan Pie $25.00
Toppings $1.50
Extra Cheese, Pepperoni, Meatball, Crumbled Sausage, Sliced Sausage, Mushrooms, Garlic, Peppers, Tomatoes, Ham, Onions, Black Olives, Pineapple, Eggplant, Anchovies

Calzones
Baked or Fried $16.00
Ricotta Ham & Shredded Mozzarella with a side of Marinara or Create Your Own with any of our Pizza Toppings!

Strombolis
Classic $16.00
(Meat Lovers with Shredded Mozzarella & American Cheese)
Pepperoni $16.00
Crumbled Sausage, Peppers & Onions $16.00
Cheesesteak $16.00
Chicken Parm $16.00
Buffalo Chicken $16.00
Veggie $16.00
Create Your Own with any of our Toppings! $16.00
Toppings: Extra Cheese, Pepperoni, Meatball, Crumbled Sausage, Sliced Sausage, Mushrooms, Garlic, Peppers, Tomatoes, Ham, Onions, Black Olives, Pineapple, Eggplant, Anchovies

Specialty Pies
Gluten Free Pie $17.00
Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pie $17.00
Margherita $21.00
House Pulled Fresh Mozzarella, Sliced Basil with a Tomato Basil Base
Fra Diavolo $23.00
Our Spicy Tomato Basil Pie, topped with Shredded Mozzarella (Add Shrimp +8)
Salad (House or Caesar) $25.00
Choose from any of our salads! We chop up all the goods & put it on our fresh pizza dough!
Garbage $30.00
Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Ham, Pepperoni, Meatballs & Bacon, Sausage
Meat/Veggie Lovers $26.00
Hawaiian $23.00
Cheesesteak $25.00
Cheesesteak & Shredded Mozzarella, request to add Peppers, Onions & Potatoes!
Fat Boy $35.00
Chicken Tenders, Fries, Pepperoni, Bacon, Chipotle, BBQ, Ranch
Buffalo Chicken $27.00
Breaded Chicken, Buffalo Sauce, Blue Cheese
Breaded Chicken, Bacon & Ranch $29.00
White Pie $25.00
Shredded Mozzarella & Ricotta Cheese
Napoli $30.00
Kalamata Olives Capers & Sauteed Spinach on a white Pie
Shrimp Scampi $35.00
Sauteed Shrimp in a Garlic White- Wine Lemon Sauce, Topped with Shredded Mozzarella
Caramelized Onion & Crumbled Sausage $23.00

Appetizers
Stuffed Artichoke $15.00
Homemade Stuffed Artichoke with Seasoned Breadcrumbs topped with a Wine Wine Lemon Sauce
HugoNeto Bruschetta $15.00
Toast Points with Ricotta topped with Bruschetta made with Cherry Tomatoes, White Onion, Basil & Oil & Balsamic Vinegar
Thai Chili Calamari $19.00
Hand Battered & Deep Fried Tubes & Tentacles Tossed in our New Spicy & Sweet Thai Chili Sauce with Lemon & Side of Ranch
Italian Sushi $15.00
Prosciutto, House- Pulled Fresh Mozzarella, Basil & Sundried Tomatoes, Roasted Red Pepper & Arugula wrapped in Prosciutto cut like Sushi served with a side of Balsamic Vinegar to dip!
Pina Colada Shrimp* $16.00
Coconut Battered & Fried Shrimp with a Pina Colada-inspired Dipping Sauce
Pumpkin Ravioli* $18.00
with Pumpkin Sauce, or Brown Butter Sage, Alfredo, Pesto
The Bons Meatball & Ricotta Bowl $16.00
Our Homemade Meatball in Boniello Sauce topped with Ricotta Cheese & 4 pieces of of Garlic Bread

Soups
Classics $7.00
Pasta Fagioli | Escarole & Bean (with potatoes) | French Onion | Cream of Mushroom
Tortellini in Brodo $8.00
Cheese Tortellini in Chicken Broth with Spinach, Peas & Onions
Chicken Tortilla $12.00
A chipotle tomato base with avocado & shredded chicken topped with cheese & tortilla strips
Pumpkin Soup $9.00
Homemade Smooth & Creamy Pumpkin Soup

Salad
Misto Mango Salad* $17.00
Grilled Shrimp, Avocado, Fresh Mango, Red Onion, Mixed Bell Peppers, Tomato, Cucumber, and Cilantro tossed in Zesty Italian Dressing
Bon Explosion Salad $15.00
Blackened Chicken, Avocado, Red Onion, Boiled Egg, Tomato, Bacon Crumbles, Croutons, Cheddar Cheese & Mixed Lettuce with Ranch Dressing
Chipotle Pasta Salad $17.00
Grilled Chicken in Chipotle, Breaded Avocado, Fusilli Pasta, Roasted Peppers, Cucumbers, Feta Cheese, Romaine Lettuce with Blue Cheese Dressing

Entrees
Caesar Milanese $21.00
2 Pieces of Hand-Breaded & Fried Chicken Cutlet with Romaine, Shredded Mozzarella & Parmesan Cheese with Caesar Dressing
Stuffed Salmon Ripieni $34.00
Nonna's Shrimp & Crabmeat Stuffing topped with Grilled Salmon in a White Wine Lemon Sauce with Rice & Veggies
Flounder Boniello* $30.00
The Crowd Fave! Panko-Battered & Fried Flounder with Boniello sauce with Spinach Over Pasta & a House Salad to Start
Nonna's Stuffed Flounder* $34.00
Filet of Flounder Stuffed with Crabmeat & Shrimp in a White Wine -Lemon Sauce with a side of Rice & Veggies
Luci Scallops & Shrimp* $36.00
Sauteed Scallops & Shrimp in a Garlic White Wine Lemon Sauce with Rice & Mixed Veggies
Blackened Scallops & Shrimp* $36.00
Blackened Scallops & Shrimp with a side of Rice & Mixed Veggies with a side of our Creamy Horseradish Sauce
Shrimp Basilico $30.00
Sauteed Shrimp & Broccoli Rabe in a Tomato Basil Sauce over Pasta & with a Side House Salad to Start
Juan's Bowl $23.00
Choice of Grilled, Blackened or Breaded Chicken, Avocado, Red Onion, Tomato, Corn, Lettuce & Feta Cheese over Rice topped with Chipotle Mayo
Zuppa di Clams $34.00
Clams in a Spicy Tomato Basil Sauce over Broccoli Rabe with a House or Caesar Salad
The Moroney $28.00
Chicken or Veal Parmesan Breaded & LightlyFried in a Pink Sauce with Roasted Red Peppers, Spinach & Melted Fresh Mozzarella over Pasta
Zuppa Bianca $36.00
Shrimp, New Zealand & PEI Mussels, Whole Clams & Calamari over Linguini in a Garlic White Wine Lemon Sauce & a House Salad with Homemade Balsamic to Start
Gnocchi Flight $28.00
A taste of all 3! 3 variations of gnocchi on one plate. Pink sauce, creamy pesto sauce & Alfredo sauce
The Bon Milanese $21.00
2 Pieces of Hand-Breaded & Fried Chicken Cutlet with Arugula, Fresh Mozzarella & Bruschetta with a side of Balsamic Vinagrette
Crema Cilantro $28.00
Lightly floured & Sauteed Chicken or Veal in a Creamy Cilantro Sauce served over Pasta

Sandwiches
Roschetta $12.00
Grilled Chicken, Bruschetta & Melted Fresh Mozzarella with a drizzle of Homemade Balsamic, on a Toasted Italian Sub
Left it to us "LTU" $12.00
Capicola, Prosciuttini, Salami, Sauteed Sweet & Hot Cherry Peppers & Melted Provolone on toasted bread. Our Friends from Bella Casa "Left it to Us
Italian Grilled Cheese* $10.00
Thick slices of Italian Bread Seasoned & Toasted with Your Choice of Fresh Mozzarella, Shredded Mozzarella, American or Provolone. Try all 4 for +$2
The Great Gambino $16.00
A Garlic Seasoned Whole Wheat Wrap with Tomatoes, House-Pulled Fresh Mozzarella, Grilled Chicken tossed in Pesto Sauce, Hot Cherry Peppers, Sauteed Spinach, Bacon Crumbles & Blue Cheese Dressing
Norberto Sub $15.00
Italian Bread, Breaded CHicken, Prosciutto, Ricotta, Fresh Mozzarella, Hot Cherry Peppers, Tomatoes & Oil Pesto Sauce
The Volpe Wrap Panini $16.00
A White Wrap with Breaded Chicken Cutlet tossed In our Homemade Chipotle Mayo with Sundried Tomatoes, Cheddar Cheese, Banana Peppers, Fried Eggplant with a side of Ranch
The Arnold Wrap $16.00
Whole-wheat wrap with Blackened Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers, Tomatoes, Red Onion & Romaine with sides of Chipotle & Ranch
Paisano Grilled Cheese $15.00
Thick slices of Italian Bread Seasoned & toasted with Fresh Mozzarella, Ricotta, Spinach & Tomato with Pesto Sauce

From the Oven
Pizza Cone $11.00
Our Pizza Dough is in the shape of a cone, fill it with any Pizza Topping, Salad, Sandwich, or Pasta!**Certain toppings +$**
Cheesy Knots $15.00
A Dozen of our House Garlic Knots Smothered with Mozzarella Cheese with Marinara or Pink Sauce to Dip
Pasta Bowl $22.00
Our Homemade Bread Bowl filled with Fusilli Pasta tossed in our House Pink Sauce with Breaded Chicken Cutlets
Jumbo Garlic Knot Slider $18.00
Breaded Chicken Cutlet in our House Vodka Sauce with finely chopped chicken, ham & olives on a jumbo garlic knot slider!

Hot Buffet
Hot Buffet (20 Person Minimum) $18.00
Select 4 Entrees (with an asterisk next to it) and either a House or Caesar Salad. Served with Bread!
The Gathering (20 Person Minimum) $15.00
House or Caesar Salad, Choice of 1 Pasta*, 1 Protein*, 1 Eggplant or Stuffed Mushrooms - A light lunch!
The Grazers
Stromboli Platter, Garlic Knots, Mini Meatballs, Mini Riceballs, Caprese Salad - For a Cocktail Hour Party!
The Feast $25.00
Any Salad (Seafood Salad Additional Charge), Stromboli Platter, 4 Entrees Notated with *, Garlic Knots - Not for the Faint of Heart!

Starters
Garlic Knots $55.00
Buffalo Knots $65.00
Rice Balls $100.00
Large Meat, Peas & Cheese or Simply Cheese. Also available in Mini Cheese (2 dozen Minimum)
Mussels $95.00
Stuffed Clams $100.00
Chicken Fingers $100.00
Fried Calamari $115.00
Mac & Cheese $85.00
Stromboli Platter $75.00
Stuffed Mushrooms* $90.00
Wings $95.00
Chicken Vodka Sliders $125.00
Meatball Sliders $125.00
Sandwich Platter $75.00

Salads
Antipasto $85.00
Caesar $70.00
House $70.00
Grilled Peach $85.00
Caprese $95.00
Seafood Salad $0.00

Chicken & Veal
Francese, Marsala, Lemon, Parmigiana, Cacciatore* $120.00
Chicken $120.00 | Veal $150.00
Unstuffed: Broccoli Rabe, Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, White Wine Lemon $140.00
Chicken $140.00 | Veal $170.00
Saltimbocca: Spinach, Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, White Wine Lemon $140.00
Chicken $140.00 | Veal $170.00
Bella: Spinach, Tomato, Onions, White Wine, Tomato Basil Sauce $140.00
Chicken $140.00 | Veal $170.00
Boniello: Pink Sauce with Mushrooms $140.00
Chicken $140.00 | Veal $170.00

Entrees
Meatballs* $120.00
Sausage, Peppers, Onions* $120.00
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage $125.00
Eggplant Parm* $110.00
Eggplant Rollatini* $115.00
Homemade Lasagna $135.00
Homemade Manicotti $125.00
Baked Ziti* $110.00
Pasta Marinara* $85.00
Pasta Pink Vodka $100.00
Pasta* $105.00
Bolognese, Tartufo, Arribiatta, Carbonara, Alfredo
Cavatelli & Broccoli $100.00
Roast Beef with Gravy $125.00

Seafood
Zuppa di Pesce $0.00
Shrimp $160.00
Marinara, Fra Diavolo, Scampi
Shrimp $170.00
Francese, Parmigiana
Flounder $140.00
Bella, Marinara, Francese, Cacciatore, White Wine Lemon
Salmon $175.00
Grilled, Blackened or Broiled in White Wine Lemon Sauce

Boniello's Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great dessert
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Coffee
Comfort food
Healthy options
Quick bite
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Boniello's Photos

Boniello's Location

Boniello's

New Jersey Morris County Riverdale Hamburg Turnpike

72 Hamburg Turnpike, Riverdale, NJ 07457, USA

Boniello's Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 740 user reviews.

calamariBYOBmeatballsrice ballsvealcateringgarlic knotsmarinarawingsvodka sauce

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

So many tempting dishes on the menu, plus the secret menu, make it hard to decide what to try. They have angel hair pasta, a personal fav, cooked al dente with a nice marinara. The Rafael personal 12" margarita (sp?) with ricotta stuffed crust sprinkled with toasty sesame seeds was worth the wait, crusty on the outside, melted mozzarella, fresh basil on top. Canoli tasted weird though, and the tiramisu could be boozier. BYOB. Service was attentive and amiable.
September 28 · Tracy Manning
i love boniellos. service is amazing and big portions. always my go to i got 2 ron and sammi pies and a margarita personal pie they were beautiful and very filling. if your not at boniellos then where you at!!!!
August 01 · ari elezi
The Caesar Milanese is amazing! Get it while they still have it as a special. One of my favorite menu items at the moment! 😋
July 30 · Kayla Daddis
Tried this local pasta and pizza spot for dinner and unfortunately, it was a letdown from start to finish.We arrived around 5:30 PM and were immediately asked if we had a reservation—odd considering the place was not full. We were seated outside, where we were forgotten for at least 15 minutes. No water, no check-in, nothing. We had to flag down the host just to get someone to take our order.Eventually, a waitress came out and took our order. It took quite a while to receive our appetizer (ricotta with meatballs, which was tasty), but that was where the positives ended. Over 35 minutes later, we were still waiting for our entrees when another waitress appeared to ask if we’d like dessert menus—despite the fact that our appetizer plates hadn’t even been cleared and our entrees hadn’t arrived.When the food finally came, the lasagna was solid—definitely homemade and a massive portion, enough to feed a small family. However, the Margherita pizza was incredibly undercooked. The mozzarella was still hard, and the pizza lacked any of the classic flavor or texture you’d expect. We didn’t eat it.When the waitress returned and asked if we wanted a box, we declined for the pizza and explained that it wasn’t good. She kindly offered to replace it, but by that point, we’d been sitting there so long and were so turned off by the experience that we declined.Here’s where it went from bad to worse: the owner came out visibly defensive and aggressive after hearing we didn’t like the pizza. Instead of offering a sincere apology or trying to make it right, she condescendingly asked, “Do you even know what a Margherita pizza is?” and insisted no one had ever complained about her pizza before. It was shocking, unprofessional, and frankly, insulting.Let me be clear: I would not have left a review if the staff had simply apologized and handled it with grace. But the owner’s reaction cemented my decision. If someone is dissatisfied, you acknowledge it and try to resolve it, not argue with them or question their palate.Needless to say, we won’t be back—and we’ll be telling others to steer clear as well.
July 25 · Anthony Pennella
We've had two types of experiences at Boniello's.1) We've eaten there multiple times. The food and selection is outstanding. The staff are very attentive and friendly. As a whole, it's an excellent dining experience and has become our "goto" location when we go out to eat. Highly recommend.2) We had them cater our daughter's graduation party and again, they were a great choice. The food was awesome. The staff member they sent to setup everything was extremely friendly and it was ridiculously hot out! We were more than happy with their catering service. Again.... Highly recommend.
July 31 · Dan Salamon