Brooklyn's Finest Pizza

- 1250 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305

For residents of Staten Island who crave the authentic flavor and expansive variety of a classic New York pizzeria, **Brooklyn's Finest Pizza** delivers on its promise. Strategically located on **Hylan Boulevard** in the 10305 area, this restaurant has become a cornerstone for locals seeking high-quality, generously portioned Italian-American fare. More than just a pizza shop, Brooklyn's Finest operates as a full-service dining destination, offering everything from morning meals to late-night dinners, all centered around a philosophy of **comfort food** and neighborhood reliability.

The menu is a testament to the diverse tastes of the New York diner. While it honors the heritage with perfect **Brooklyn Style Pizza** and **Grandma’s Pizza**, it also embraces modern culinary trends through its selection of **Brooklyn’s Specialty Large Pies**. Innovative offerings like the **Hot Honey Roni Pie**, **Buffalo Calamari Pie**, and **Chicken Bacon Ranch** sit comfortably alongside classics, ensuring there is a pizza for every palate and occasion. The commitment to variety extends to the hot kitchen, featuring comprehensive sections for **Entrées** (Veal, Chicken, Shrimp), **Pasta Dishes**, and creatively named **Neighborhood Heros** that pay homage to iconic Brooklyn locations like "The Sheepshead Bay" and "The Williamsburg."

What makes Brooklyn's Finest truly stand out in a competitive market is the consistently positive feedback regarding customer relations and overall food quality. Loyal patrons, some ordering twice a week for years, laud the food as "always fresh and absolutely delicious" and praise the owner and staff for being "friendly, professional, and always welcoming." This combination of an outstanding, varied menu and dedication to superior customer service makes Brooklyn's Finest Pizza a highly recommended choice for anyone in the New York region looking for their new favorite pizza spot.

***

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is situated on a prominent thoroughfare in Staten Island, offering optimal convenience and highly valued accessibility features.

The address is:

1250 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA

The location on **Hylan Boulevard** is easily reachable, and the restaurant takes the stress out of visiting with dedicated amenities for all guests.

Accessibility and Parking Highlights:

• Free Parking Lot: A significant advantage in the New York area, providing stress-free access for dine-in and pickup customers.
• Full Wheelchair Accessibility: The premises are designed to be inclusive, featuring a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating**.
• Pet-Friendly Outdoor Space: Allows **Dogs allowed outside**, making it convenient for patrons enjoying a meal with their pets.

***

The operational model of Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is built around maximum convenience and comprehensive service to meet the demanding schedule of New York life.

• Delivery Excellence: Offers **Delivery** and the option for **No-contact delivery**, recognized for its **Fast service** and reliability.
• Dine-in and Takeout: Patrons can enjoy the **Casual** atmosphere with available **Seating** and **Table service**, or quickly grab their order via **Takeout**.
• Extended Dining Hours: The restaurant serves **Breakfast**, **Lunch**, and **Dinner**, making it a true all-day option for the local community.
• Full-Service Catering: Provides **Catering** for parties and events, offering an easy way to serve authentic Italian food to a large group.
• Reservations Accepted: While offering casual dining, the restaurant **Accepts reservations**, a useful option for larger groups.
• Family-Focused: Categorized as **Good for kids**, and provides **High chairs** and a dedicated **Kids' menu**, ensuring a welcoming environment for families.
• Beverage Options: Offers **Alcohol**, **Beer**, and **Wine** to complement dinner, along with classic New York beverages like **Manhattan Special** and **Old Fashioned Brooklyn Egg Creams**.

***

The diverse menu and special offerings are key reasons why Brooklyn's Finest is a local favorite in the 10305 zip code.

• Specialty and Traditional Pies: Unrivaled selection including **Thick Crust Sicilian Pizza**, **Whole Wheat Pan Pizza**, and the innovative **Cauliflower Crust** for a lighter, gluten-friendly option.
• "Taste of Brooklyn" Favorites: Features authentic NYC-Italian-American classics like the **Cheese Rice Ball**, **Meat Rice Ball**, and **Panelle Special Sandwich**, providing a truly local flavor profile.
• Signature Hero Sandwiches: The **Neighborhood Heros** menu is a highlight, with over 25 distinct, generously sized heroes named after Brooklyn locations, alongside favorites like **Philly Cheesesteak** and **Shrimp Parm Hero**.
• Full Italian Entree Selection: Provides classic full dinners such as **Chicken Francese**, **Veal Parmigiana**, **Shrimp Scampi**, and various **Baked Pasta Dishes** (Lasagna, Stuffed Shells), making it an Italian restaurant as much as a pizzeria.
• Innovative Dessert Menu: Beyond the traditional **Cannoli** and **Zeppoles**, the menu features playful treats like **Fried Oreo** and **Fried Twinkies**, appealing to a fun, casual crowd.
• Health and Dietary Options: Includes dedicated **Vegetarian options** across the menu, a **Salad Pie**, and several salad choices like the **Brooklyn Salad** and **Lite And Crunchy Salad**.

***

For New Yorkers in the Staten Island area, **Brooklyn's Finest Pizza** is an essential choice due to its **unbeatable menu variety** and its established role as a **reliable neighborhood anchor**. It successfully manages to provide both a quick, satisfying pizza meal and a full, quality Italian dining experience.

What truly sets this spot apart is its deep commitment to providing a solution for virtually any appetite at any time of day. You can easily switch from a **Breakfast Wrap** to a **Classic Round Pizza** for lunch, and finish with a full **Veal Francese Entree** for dinner. The sheer number of creative, house-named specials—from the pizzas to the heroes—demonstrates a passion for the food that keeps customers loyal for years. While the occasional mixed experience, such as the reported issue with a cold meal, may occur in any high-volume service, the overwhelming long-term praise for the food's freshness and the staff's professionalism, particularly from the owner, confirms its reputation. For the best combination of specialty pizza, full Italian comfort food, and exceptional accessibility in the 10305 area, Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is a consistently excellent choice.

***

To place a delivery or takeout order, inquire about catering, or make a reservation, please use the contact information below.

Address: 1250 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA

Phone: (718) 815-7070

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza

1250 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, USA