Buttercooky Bakery & Café

- 217 Jericho Tpke, Floral Park, NY 11001

Introduction / Overview: Buttercooky Bakery & Café, A Long Island Tradition

For over six decades, the Buttercooky Bakery & Café in Floral Park has been a beloved institution, serving Long Island residents with exceptional baked goods and sweet memories. As a third-generation, family-owned business, Buttercooky has built a sterling reputation on the foundational principle that "Baked with butter makes it better." This commitment to premium ingredients and time-honored baking traditions is evident in every cookie, pastry, and custom cake they create. The flagship Floral Park location is more than just a bakery; it is a full-service café and a cherished community fixture where locals gather for breakfast, a quick coffee, or to plan life's sweetest celebrations.

The bakery’s extensive menu caters to every craving, from classic New York-style favorites to modern, innovative creations. While renowned for spectacular custom cakes for weddings and special events, their daily offerings are just as impressive. Customers rave about the rich, fresh desserts, with the Tres Leches Cake often highlighted as a standout favorite for its perfect balance of moisture and sweetness. Buttercooky is dedicated to not just meeting, but exceeding, the expectations of the New York community, even offering options to accommodate special dietary needs, including gluten-free selections and a commitment to providing kosher goods.

Whether you need a full tiered wedding cake, a decadent slice of chocolate mousse, a fresh-baked bagel for breakfast, or one of their now-famous Dubai Chocolate Treats, Buttercooky Bakery & Café provides a vibrant and inviting atmosphere. They are a one-stop destination for all things sweet and celebratory, consistently delivering beautiful creations that taste as good as they look.

Location and Accessibility

The original and flagship location of Buttercooky Bakery & Café is conveniently situated in the heart of Floral Park, making it easily accessible for residents across Long Island and the greater New York area.

The address is:

217 Jericho Tpke, Floral Park, NY 11001, USA

Accessibility is a priority for the café, which is located on a major thoroughfare. The establishment offers a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring all members of the community can comfortably visit. For drivers, both free and paid street parking options are available nearby. The central location on Jericho Turnpike makes it an effortless stop for those traveling through or residing in the Nassau County area, ready for a quick visit or a leisurely dine-in experience.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café also keeps consistent, accommodating hours, as they are open daily from 7:00 AM to 8:00 PM, giving you plenty of time to pick up a morning pastry, grab an afternoon coffee, or secure a dessert for an evening event.

Services Offered

Buttercooky Bakery & Café serves the Floral Park community and beyond with an extensive range of goods and convenient services, establishing them as a versatile destination for all things baked and caffeinated.

• Full-Service Bakery & Café: Offering everything from daily breakfast pastries and bread to a large selection of decadent desserts and high-quality coffee and espresso drinks.
• Custom & Wedding Cakes: Specializing in creating classic, unique custom cakes, and tiered wedding cakes, with a consultation process to design the perfect centerpiece for any event. They offer flexible options for combining multiple cake and filling flavors across different tiers.
• Dietary Accommodations: The professional team is equipped to handle requests for special dietary needs, including food allergies, intolerances, and offering popular options like gluten-free cheesecakes and custom-made desserts.
• In-House Dining & Quick Service: Customers can enjoy their treats in the café with Dine-in options, or they can opt for a Quick visit, Takeout, or In-store pickup.
• Delivery Services: For maximum convenience, the bakery offers delivery through various platforms, allowing you to enjoy their fresh-baked goods at home or the office.
• Specialty Dessert Orders: Provides custom orders for dessert tables and a variety of unique creations like a vast selection of French Pastries, Tarts, Eclairs, and seasonal treats for holidays like Easter and Father’s Day.
• Beverages: A full selection of drinks including Hot Coffee, Cold Brew, Hot Chocolate, Lattes, and a variety of espresso and tea options.

Features / Highlights

Buttercooky Bakery & Café sets itself apart in the competitive New York bakery scene with several key features that drive its decades-long success.

• Third-Generation Family Ownership: Having been a family-owned and operated business for over 60 years, the bakery maintains a consistent commitment to quality, community, and tradition.
• Innovative Dessert Trends: The bakery is quick to adopt and perfect exciting new creations, demonstrated by the popularity of their DUBAI CHOCOLATE TREATS line, featuring unique items like The Dubai Chocolate Croissant and Cannoli.
• Extensive Menu Variety: With offerings that span from simple Plain Bagels and Muffins to elaborate Mousse Cakes (including Tres Leche, Silk & Satin, and Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse) and multiple varieties of Cheesecakes and Pies, there is truly something for every palate.
• Celebration Ready: They offer both ready-to-go Showcase Cakes like Strawberry Shortcake and Black Forest Cake, as well as helpful add-ons like a wide range of numbered and specialized Candles for any birthday or celebration.
• Gluten-Free Expertise: Beyond simple accommodations, they are known for crafting complex and delicious desserts that are entirely gluten-free for guests with Celiac disease, such as the 7" NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free) and the Individual Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free).

Contact Information

To plan your custom order, check on daily selections, or simply inquire about hours, you can reach the Buttercooky Bakery & Café Floral Park location using the following information:

Address: 217 Jericho Tpke, Floral Park, NY 11001, USA

Phone: (516) 354-3831

Mobile Phone: +1 516-354-3831

What Is Worth Choosing

Choosing Buttercooky Bakery & Café for your next sweet indulgence or major event means selecting a business with a long-standing tradition of excellence, though it is wise for customers to note that, as a high-volume and popular destination, service experiences can vary. Overall, the consistent quality of the baked goods is the bakery's strongest draw.

Why Buttercooky Stands Out:

The bakery’s reputation for spectacular, fresh cakes, especially for weddings and anniversaries, is a major reason for its loyal following. Customers frequently praise the beauty and taste of their tiered cakes, noting that Buttercooky often replicates provided design pictures perfectly. The option for an at-home tasting kit for custom orders makes the planning process enjoyable and convenient for busy New Yorkers.

For everyday indulgence, the sheer variety is unbeatable. Where else can you find a traditional Italian Cheesecake alongside a trending Biscoff Croissant or a decadent Tres Leches Cake? Their menu depth ensures that everyone, from the simple vanilla lover to the adventurous dessert connoisseur, finds a favorite. The bakery also excels at catering to special occasions, providing a large selection of individual French Pastries and slices, ideal for creating a varied and impressive dessert spread.

Moreover, as a recognized Long Island staple, when you choose Buttercooky Bakery & Café, you are supporting a family-owned business that has been central to creating local memories for decades. This legacy is one of the most compelling reasons why this Floral Park spot remains a premier destination for anyone seeking high-quality, memorable, and delicious baked goods in the New York area. Despite occasional reported service issues during peak times, the majority of the community agrees: for taste, quality, and celebration-worthy desserts, Buttercooky is a proven Long Island favorite.

Buttercooky Bakery & Café

217 Jericho Tpke, Floral Park, NY 11001, USA