Butterly Bakeshop

- 263 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Introduction / Overview

For Brooklyn locals and dessert lovers across New York, a visit to Butterly Bakeshop, located right near the vibrant Prospect Park West area, promises a delightful and memorable sweet experience. This charming destination has established itself as a premier spot for high-quality, beautifully crafted baked goods, specializing in everything from signature whole cakes to individual treats like cookies and gourmet cupcakes. Customers consistently praise the bakeshop for its visually appealing atmosphere, warm and inviting décor, and an unwavering commitment to both stunning presentation and rich, satisfying flavors.

Butterly Bakeshop is more than just a typical bakery; it’s a full-service cake, cookie, and cupcake shop that caters to everyday cravings and life's most special occasions, including acting as a dedicated wedding bakery. What truly sets this establishment apart in the competitive NYC bakery scene is its dedication to customization and its commitment to inclusivity, proudly identifying as a women-owned business and fostering an LGBTQ+ friendly environment. Whether you're seeking a quick, indulgent treat, a spectacular custom cake for a celebration, or a variety of specialty desserts, Butterly Bakeshop offers a diverse selection that ensures every customer finds something to love. This local gem consistently aims to provide a personalized experience, making it a beloved neighborhood favorite in Brooklyn.

Location and Accessibility

Butterly Bakeshop boasts a prime and accessible location at 263 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA. Situated in a popular and vibrant section of Brooklyn, it’s a convenient stop for residents in the Windsor Terrace and Park Slope neighborhoods, as well as a great destination for anyone enjoying a day near Prospect Park. The physical location is easy to find and designed to be welcoming to all members of the community.

Accessibility is a key priority for the bakeshop, which features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that all patrons can comfortably enjoy their offerings. For those arriving by car, paid street parking is available in the vicinity. Being in a neighborhood like Prospect Park West, the bakeshop is also readily accessible via public transit options, making it an easy trip from other parts of Brooklyn and beyond. The convenience of its location contributes significantly to its reputation as a go-to spot for both quick visits and pre-arranged order pickups.

Services Offered

Butterly Bakeshop provides a comprehensive range of services tailored to meet various customer needs, from a casual coffee break to large-scale event catering. Their service model focuses on convenience and quality, adapting to the busy New York lifestyle.

• In-store Shopping: Customers can enjoy the warm, inviting ambiance, browse the daily selections of fresh-baked goods, and make purchases directly inside the shop.
• Takeout: All menu items are available for quick and convenient takeout, perfect for those on the go.
• Delivery: The bakeshop offers local delivery services through various third-party platforms, bringing their delicious creations right to your doorstep across a wide service area in New York.
• In-store Pickup: Pre-ordered custom cakes, cupcakes, and other items can be picked up at the store, ensuring orders are ready and waiting without a long wait time.
• Onsite Services: The team is available for consulting on special requests, particularly for elaborate custom and wedding cakes, providing personalized attention for significant life events.
• Custom Cakes: A core specialty, offering tailor-made designs and flavors for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, and all major celebrations. Customers can discuss ideas with the knowledgeable staff to create a truly personalized dessert.
• Same-day Delivery: While general information can sometimes be conflicting on direct delivery, delivery services are widely available through online ordering platforms, often offering same-day options on specific, featured items.

Features / Highlights

The appeal of Butterly Bakeshop stems from a blend of product quality, business ethics, and excellent customer-focused policies. Several key features make this Brooklyn bakery a local standout:

• Women-Owned Business: The bakeshop proudly identifies as women-owned, contributing to and promoting female entrepreneurship within the New York business landscape.
• Signature Baked Goods: The menu is robust and includes highly praised items like the legendary Brooklyn Blackout Cake (a decadent Devil's Food Cake with chocolate pudding and chocolate drip), the Chocolate Chunk Cookies (a customer favorite), Turtle Cake, and their rich Red Velvet Cake.
• Dietary and Specialty Options: The bakery caters to various dietary preferences, offering a wide selection of vegan and gluten-free items, such as Vegan GF Chocolate Chip Cookies, GF Dulce De Leche Cupcakes, and the ability to order custom vegan cakes with notice.
• High Ratings and Customer Praise: The bakeshop consistently receives high ratings (often 4.6 to 4.9 stars across platforms) for its incredible flavors, visual artistry in custom cakes, and overall quality of baked goods.
• Inclusivity and Atmosphere: Identified as an LGBTQ+ friendly establishment, the bakeshop maintains a welcoming and cozy environment, complete with Wi-Fi for a comfortable, quick visit.
• Diverse Offerings: Beyond cakes and cupcakes, the menu includes a variety of individual desserts like Banana Pudding, Fudgy Brownies, Brownie Cheesecake, Apple Pie Cheesecake, and a classic French Macarons collection.
• Beverage Selection: Fresh coffee is available to pair perfectly with any sweet treat, making it an ideal spot for an afternoon pick-me-up.

Contact Information

For general inquiries, placing orders, or discussing a custom cake, customers can reach Butterly Bakeshop through the following contact channels:

Address: 263 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

Phone: (929) 276-3617

What is Worth Choosing

When looking at the extensive menu and glowing reviews, a few items from Butterly Bakeshop stand out as must-try options. The sheer variety and consistent quality across categories are what truly make this bakeshop worth choosing for any New York local.

The Brooklyn Blackout Cake is frequently mentioned by customers and is a clear signature item. Descriptions highlight its rich flavors and decadent nature, making it a perfect choice for true chocolate enthusiasts. For those ordering just a slice, the Blackout Cake slice is a consistently highly-rated item.

For individual indulgence, the Chocolate Chunk Cookie is a customer favorite, highly recommended by those who visit. Another popular choice, particularly in the bars and individual dessert section, is the Banana Pudding, which customers describe as a quintessential summer dessert and one of the best items on the menu. The Carrot Loaf Mini is also a standout, noted for being moist and topped with luscious cream cheese frosting.

If you are planning a special occasion, choosing Butterly Bakeshop for a Custom Cake is highly recommended. Reviews repeatedly emphasize the "great artistry, delicious flavors, and stunning designs" of their bespoke creations, such as the praised strawberry milkshake cake flavor. The staff is known for their attentive service in ensuring custom orders are tailored to exact customer needs. Even for customers with specific dietary needs, the presence of appealing vegan and gluten-free alternatives, such as the GF Oatmeal Cranberry Cookie and various dedicated cupcakes, ensures that no one has to miss out on a celebratory sweet.

While a few reviews note that consistency can occasionally be a challenge, the overwhelming majority of local feedback focuses on the bakeshop's incredible quality, friendly service, and the sheer delight of their best-selling items. Choosing Butterly Bakeshop means supporting a women-owned local business that prides itself on creating visually beautiful, high-quality, and richly flavored desserts, perfect for celebrating life's sweet moments right here in Brooklyn.

Butterly Bakeshop

263 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA