CARS Eatery: Home of New Jersey's Famous Fat Sandwiches and Comfort Food in Livingston

CARS Eatery Introduce

Welcome to CARS Eatery, a local New Jersey dining spot that has quickly become a standout destination for serious comfort food, especially in the Livingston area. Positioned uniquely as a sandwich shop, American restaurant, and diner all rolled into one, CARS Eatery is famous throughout the region for its inventive and generously portioned menu. While the name “sandwich shop” might suggest a simple deli, CARS elevates the concept with hearty, overstuffed creations, ensuring that every visit satisfies the deepest comfort food cravings.

The cornerstone of the CARS Eatery experience is, without a doubt, the legendary line of “FAT SANDWICHES.” These aren't your average hoagies; they are ambitious, all-in-one meals packed onto a hero roll, combining ingredients like cheesesteak, chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, Mac 'n Cheese Bites, and fries, all drizzled with various signature sauces. Iconic choices like the FAT ROLLS (cheesesteak, chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, fries, and honey mustard) and the FAT FERRARI (chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, fries, and marinara sauce) are local favorites that promise a truly unique and filling meal. This commitment to bold flavors and generous sizing extends across their menu, which also includes classic American offerings like juicy burgers, authentic Philly Cheesesteaks, crispy chicken wings, and indulgent milkshakes.

Beyond the signature sandwiches, the menu features a deep lineup of classic comfort dishes. For burger enthusiasts, the CARS Burger and the indulgent Mac 'n Cheese Burger are must-try items. Cheesesteak purists can enjoy the flavorful Footlong Classic Philly. The dedication to satisfying every craving is clear in their extensive list of sides, which includes their popular Mac 'n Cheese Bites, as well as various seasoned fries, tater tots, and onion rings. And for a sweet finish, their milkshakes, like the Cookies 'n Cream or Banana Nutella, offer the perfect creamy indulgence. This diverse menu positions CARS Eatery not just as a quick stop, but as a full-service experience for lunch, dinner, and late-night dining.

For New Jersey residents looking for an accessible and welcoming place to eat, CARS Eatery is conveniently located in Essex County. The specific address is a central point for those in Livingston and surrounding areas, making it an ideal spot for a planned family meal or a spontaneous quick bite.

The specific location and contact details are:

Address: 142 S Livingston Ave, Livingston, NJ 07039

Phone: (973) 422-2277

Accessibility is a key priority for CARS Eatery, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. The establishment features a wheelchair accessible entrance, restroom, and seating, along with a dedicated wheelchair accessible parking lot. Ample free, on-site parking is available, which is a major convenience for local visitors. The atmosphere is casual and designed to be welcoming to a diverse crowd, including families, large groups, and individuals. They are also noted for being LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space.

CARS Eatery provides multiple ways for customers to enjoy their food, accommodating various dining preferences and schedules in the fast-paced New Jersey lifestyle.

Dine-in: Offering seating, counter service, and table service in a casual, family-friendly atmosphere.
Takeout: Quick and easy pickup service for those on the go.
Delivery: Convenient delivery options to enjoy the full menu from the comfort of home.
Catering: Specialized catering services, featuring options like Fat Sandwiches Boxes, various Wing platters, and sides, perfect for office parties, family events, or large group gatherings.
Dining Options: Available for Lunch and Dinner, also serving Late-night food.

CARS Eatery is committed to a high-quality, enjoyable, and inclusive dining experience, highlighted by several key features:

Iconic Menu: Home of the famous and unique “FAT SANDWICHES,” a New Jersey comfort food staple.
Diverse Offerings: Menu includes burgers, cheesesteaks, wings, sides, milkshakes, and vegetarian options like The Mac Patty and the FAT CHEVY.
Atmosphere: A casual, welcoming setting that is popular for solo dining, groups, and is specifically Family-friendly.
Inclusivity: Designated as LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace, with a gender-neutral restroom amenity.
Convenience: Offers late-night food, quick bites, and happy hour food specials, perfect for any time of day.
Payment Flexibility: Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.
Family Amenities: Good for kids and includes changing table(s) for parental convenience.
Pet-Friendly: Allows dogs in the designated outside area.

CARS Eatery stands out in the competitive New Jersey food scene for several compelling reasons. It delivers a superior comfort food experience that goes well beyond the standard fare. The main draw remains the incredible value and inventive nature of the food, exemplified by the signature overstuffed sandwiches and the highly-rated sides, like the perfectly seasoned fries and crispy Mac 'n Cheese Bites.

Customers frequently praise the combination of great taste, generous portions, and fair pricing, as reflected in a local customer review noting the large, juicy, and well-seasoned burger, the crispy and well-seasoned fries, and the flavorful milkshake, all for a reasonable total price. Furthermore, the commitment to excellent customer service, such as the manager greeting guests and taking the care to secure leftovers for travel, creates a genuinely positive and memorable experience.

For those in Livingston, NJ, or just passing through, CARS Eatery is a premier local choice for satisfying American comfort food. Whether you are craving the ultimate, ingredient-packed Fat Sandwich, a classic cheesesteak, or simply a great burger and a thick milkshake, CARS delivers quality, convenience, and a truly welcoming atmosphere that locals appreciate. It is the ideal place for a hearty meal at any hour, from a casual lunch to a late-night fix.

CARS Eatery Food & drink

POPULAR ITEMS
Mac 'n Cheese Bites $6.99
Golden & crispy on the outside, irresistibly creamy on the inside—our famous Mac n' Cheese Bites are loaded with a rich blend of three cheeses!
Cookies 'n Cream $6.99
A creamy blend of vanilla ice cream and crunchy cookie crumbles for the perfect sweet treat!
CARS Burger $7.99
A juicy, perfectly seasoned burger patty topped with crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, and our tangy secret sauce—stacked for the perfect bite!
FAT ROLLS $12.49
Juicy cheesesteak, crispy chicken tenders, melty mozzarella sticks, and golden fries, all drizzled with honey mustard on a hero roll!
FAT FERRARI $11.49
Crispy chicken tenders, melty mozzarella sticks, and golden fries, all layered on a hero roll with zesty marinara sauce!
Footlong Classic Philly $16.99
Sliced steak, sautéed onions, and melty American cheese on a hero roll—our classic cheesesteak, packed with flavor!

FAT SANDWICHES
FAT MUSTANG $12.49
Cheesesteak, crispy chicken tenders, Mac 'n Cheese Bites, spicy jalapeño slices, and tangy buffalo-ranch dressing, all served on a hero roll!
FAT BENTLEY $11.99
Chicken tenders, crispy bacon, Mac 'n Cheese Bites, golden fries, and creamy buttermilk ranch, all served on a hero roll!
FAT ROLLS $12.49
Juicy cheesesteak, crispy chicken tenders, melty mozzarella sticks, and golden fries, all drizzled with honey mustard on a hero roll!
FAT FERRARI $11.49
Crispy chicken tenders, melty mozzarella sticks, and golden fries, all layered on a hero roll with zesty marinara sauce!
FAT LAMBO $11.99
Chicken fingers, Mac 'n Cheese Bites, crispy onion rings, golden fries, and spicy sriracha mayo, all served on a hero roll!
FAT FIAT $11.99
Mac 'n Cheese Bites, crispy onion rings, chicken fingers, golden waffle fries, and zesty chipotle mayo, all served on a hero roll!
FAT CHEVY $11.99
Crispy falafel, tangy pickles, fresh tomatoes, crunchy lettuce, and smooth hummus, all served on a hero roll!
FAT AUDI $12.49
Cheesesteak, crispy chicken tenders, bacon, melty mozzarella sticks, and a kick of buffalo ranch dressing, all served on a hero roll!
FAT LEXUS $11.49
Chicken tenders, melty mozzarella sticks, crispy onion rings, golden fries, and sweet golden honey BBQ sauce, all served on a hero roll!
FAT MASERATI $11.99
Chicken tenders, crispy bacon, melty mozzarella sticks, golden fries, and a drizzle of ketchup and mayo, all served on a hero roll!
FAT FORD $11.99
Chicken tenders, sliced cheesesteak, melty mozzarella sticks, marinara sauce, and our creamy cheese sauce, all served on a hero roll!
FAT BEEMER $12.49
Chicken tenders, crispy bacon, onion rings, melty mozzarella sticks, golden fries, and zesty chipotle mayo, all served on a hero roll!
FAT TESLA $11.49
Mac 'n Cheese Bites, golden fries, melty mozzarella sticks, crispy onion rings, and creamy ranch dressing, all served on a hero roll!
FAT PORSCHE $11.49
Chicken tenders, golden fries, crispy onion rings, melty mozzarella sticks, and sweet honey mustard, all served on a hero roll!

BURGERS
CARS Burger $7.99
A juicy, perfectly seasoned burger patty topped with crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, and our tangy secret sauce—stacked for the perfect bite!
All American $8.49
Our juicy burger patty, topped with melty American cheese, tangy pickles, onions, and classic ketchup, all served on a burger bun!
Mac 'n Cheese Burger $11.99
A juicy patty, crispy bacon, homemade mac & cheese patty, and our secret burger sauce, all served on a bun!
The Classic Double $11.49
Double patty cheeseburger, topped with pickles, diced onions, fresh lettuce, and our secret burger sauce, all served on a burger bun!

PHILLY CHEESESTEAKS
8" Classic Philly $11.99
Sliced steak, sautéed onions, and melty American cheese on a hero roll—our classic cheesesteak, packed with flavor!
Footlong Classic Philly $16.99
Sliced steak, sautéed onions, and melty American cheese on a hero roll—our classic cheesesteak, packed with flavor!

CHICKEN SANDWICHES
Classic Chicken Sandwich $7.49
Crispy chicken patty, fresh lettuce, ripe tomato, and creamy mayo, all served on a Martin's potato bun!
Chicken Cheddar Bacon $8.99
Crispy chicken patty, topped with cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, and sweet honey mustard sauce, all served on a Martin's potato bun!
Chicken Mac Sandwich $10.99
A crispy chicken patty, Mac 'n Cheese patty, fresh tomato, and tangy buffalo ranch dressing, all served on a Martin's potato bun!
The Mac Patty (vegetarian) $7.99
Mac & Cheese patty, creamy burger sauce, fresh lettuce, and tomato, all served on a Martin's potato bun!
Sriracha Chicken Sandwich $7.99
Crispy chicken patty, melted cheddar cheese, pickles, and spicy sriracha mayo, all served on a Martin's potato bun!

WINGS
Boneless Wings $0.00
Homemade crispy boneless chicken wings, perfectly seasoned for a flavorful bite!
Bone-In Wings $0.00
Crispy Bone-In wings, with a choice of a variety of flavorful sauces!

SIDES
Mac 'n Cheese Bites $0.00
Golden & crispy on the outside, irresistibly creamy on the inside—our famous Mac ’n Cheese Bites are loaded with a rich blend of three cheeses!
Bacon Mac 'n Cheese Bites $0.00
Crispy on the outside, creamy on the inside—our famous Mac n’ Cheese Bites are loaded with a rich blend of three cheeses and crispy bacon for the ultimate comfort food indulgence!
Fries $0.00
Classic golden fries, perfectly salted for a simple, satisfying crunch!
TaterTots $0.00
Golden, crispy tater tots with a fluffy inside and perfect crunch!
Sweet Potato Fries $0.00
Crispy, golden sweet potato fries with a hint of natural sweetness!
Curly Fries $0.00
Crispy, seasoned curly fries with the perfect twist in every bite!
Chicken Tenders $8.99
Crispy chicken tenders, served with a variety of our favorite dipping sauces for the perfect bite every time!
Chicken & Fries Combo $8.99
Crispy chicken tenders served alongside golden fries for a perfect, satisfying meal!
Cheese Fries $9.49
Golden, crispy fries smothered in our rich, homemade cheese sauce for the ultimate cheesy indulgence!
Cheese Tots $9.49
Golden, crispy tater tots smothered in our rich, homemade cheese sauce for the ultimate cheesy indulgence!
Sweet Potato Cheese Fries $10.99
Crispy sweet potato fries smothered in our rich, homemade cheese sauce for the ultimate cheesy indulgence!
Onion Rings $0.00
Crispy, golden onion rings with a perfect crunch and savory flavor in every bite!
Mozzarella Sticks $0.00
Crispy on the outside, melty on the inside—our mozzarella sticks are served hot and packed with cheesy goodness!
Bacon Cheese Fries $10.99
Golden, crispy fries smothered in our rich, homemade cheese sauce, topped with bacon!
Bacon Cheese Tots $10.99
Golden, crispy tater tots with a fluffy inside smothered in our homemade cheese sauce topped with bacon!
Sweet Potato Bacon Cheese Fries $12.99
Crispy sweet potato fries smothered in our rich, homemade cheese sauce, topped with bacon!
Churros $4.99
Golden, crispy churros dusted with cinnamon sugar for a sweet and satisfying treat!
Funnel Cake Balls $4.99
Warm, crispy funnel cake balls topped with a generous dusting of powdered sugar for the perfect sweet indulgence!

SIDE SAUCES
Side Thousand Island $0.79
Side Ranch $0.79
Side Blue Cheese $1.39
Side Buffalo Ranch $0.79
Side Cheese Sauce $1.39
Side BBQ $0.79
Side Chipotle Mayo $0.79
Side Demented $0.79
Side Honey BBQ $0.79
Side Honey Mustard $0.79
Side Hot $0.79
Side Hummus $1.39
Side Inferno $0.79
Side Ketchup $0.49
Side Marinara Sauce $0.79
Side Mayo $0.79
Side Mild $0.79
Side Slammin' Sriracha $0.79
Side Sriracha Mayo $0.79
Side Sweet Chili $0.79

MILKSHAKES
Cookies 'n Cream $6.99
A creamy blend of vanilla ice cream and crunchy cookie crumbles for the perfect sweet treat!
Chocolate $6.99
A creamy, classic chocolate milkshake!
Vanilla $6.99
A creamy, classic vanilla milkshake made with rich vanilla ice cream for the perfect sweet treat!
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough $6.99
A creamy blend of vanilla ice cream and chocolate chip cookie dough for the ultimate milkshake experience!
Banana Nutella $6.99
A smooth blend of banana and creamy Nutella, creating the perfect milkshake indulgence!
Black 'n White $6.99
A perfect blend of creamy vanilla and chocolate ice cream!
Strawberry $6.99
A creamy, classic strawberry milkshake a perfect sweet treat!
Peanut Butter Cup $6.99
A classic peanut butter cup milkshake, perfectly creamy for an irresistible treat!
Mint Cookies 'n Cream $6.99
A refreshing blend of mint ice cream and crunchy cookie crumbles, creating the perfect cookies 'n cream twist!
Salted Caramel $6.99
A classic salted caramel milkshake, perfectly creamy for an irresistible treat!
Banana Split $6.99
A classic banana split creamy milkshake!
Mint Chocolate Chip $6.99
A refreshing mint milkshake, blended with rich chocolate chip chunks for the perfect creamy treat!
Berries 'n Cream $6.99
A classic creamy Berries 'n Cream milkshake!

FOUNTAIN DRINKS
Pepsi $0.00
Diet Pepsi $0.00
Starry $0.00
Dr. Pepper $0.00
Brisk Iced Tea $0.00
Mountain Dew $0.00
Mug Root Beer $0.00

BOTTLED DRINKS
Pepsi 12oz $2.49
Pepsi 20oz $3.49
Diet Pepsi 12oz $2.49
Diet Pepsi 20oz $3.49
Dr. Pepper 12oz $2.49
Dr. Pepper 20oz $3.49
Mountain Dew 12oz $2.49
Mountain Dew Spark 12oz $2.49
Mountain Dew 20oz $3.49
Bottled Water $2.49
Mug Root Beer 12oz $2.49
Mug Root Beer 20z $3.49
Starry 12oz $2.49
Starry 20oz $3.49
Brisk Iced Tea 12oz Lemon Flavor $2.49
Brisk Iced Tea 20oz Lemon Flavor $3.49
Pepsi 2L $4.99
Diet Pepsi 2L $4.99
Brisk 2L $4.99

CARS Eatery Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in
Onsite services

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Assistive hearing loop

Offerings
Comfort food
Happy hour food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safespace

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
Has changing table(s)

Parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

CARS Eatery Photos

CARS Eatery Location

CARS Eatery

New Jersey Essex County Livingston South Livingston Avenue

142 S Livingston Ave, Livingston, NJ 07039, USA

CARS Eatery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.9 from 79 user reviews.

milkshakemac and cheese bitesfatcheeseburgerpattyseasonedoilfillinglunch

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Greeted by manager upon arrival. Food was brought to the table. Manager also asked if everything was okay and also prepped my son’s left over food so we can take it back home spill free. Ordered the chicken tenders with fries for my son and the Fat Maserati. Food & service was 10/10.
October 23 · Nilda Alarcon
I decided to check out this place because it recently opened.I ordered The Classic Double with a side of fries as well as a small banana split milkshake.The burger was not only large, but also tasted great. The patties and pickles were juicy, and the lettuce was crisp.The fries at initial glance seemed like a small portion, but were a reasonable size. Not only were they crispy, but they were also well seasoned with a taste unlike other places.The milkshake was plenty flavorful with clear hints of banana.The pricing was good, roughly being $22 for my entire order.Although I do not have anything to note particularly about the atmosphere and the employees, I have nothing bad to say about them either.I will definitely come back in the future for more, as well as to see what else they have in store.
August 13 · Matthew Chung
We had 3 burgers and a sandwich. The Mac n Cheese burger was really good. Small feedback to the owners, maybe you could let the oil drip off a little more before placing it on the beef patty. The footlong sandwich was too big. Think subway sandwich x 2 for size. Taste was spot on, especially with the fries all stuffed in the sandwich. (Ordered the fat Maserati). Would definitely return again.
August 30 · Janice Tan
Came on my lunch break since it’s right next to my job ! Soon as I walked in with my co workers we were greeted right away ! And our order was ready for pick up as we have ordered on the website. The food was 1000000/10 cannot wait to eat here again ! Friendly staff and tasty food you cannot go wrong ! For my Cars signature burger and fries together it came up to a total of 11.98 not bad ! Fries sooo tasty and burger fresh :)
August 13 · Tanasha Gardner
I'm a teacher at The Goddard School in Livingston and the new cars location just opened. Who is delicious the classic cheeseburger is a clean delicious Burger! The service is impeccable and it's the new go to spot for all the teachers at my school! Come in and try it
September 15 · Bridgett Womack