Catch 24 Cafe

- 220-25 Jamaica Ave, Jamaica, NY 11428

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers in search of satisfying, hearty meals, particularly those with a craving for well-prepared seafood and classic comfort dishes, the local dining scene in Queens offers a few hidden gems. One such establishment that has captured the attention of residents is Catch 24 Cafe, located in the bustling neighborhood of Jamaica. This spot has emerged as a go-to location for those seeking generous portions and flavorful meals that remind them of home-cooked favorites, with a focus on expertly fried and grilled seafood, as well as classic American sides. Catch 24 Cafe distinguishes itself by offering a menu that emphasizes quality and seasoning, making it a popular choice for a quick, satisfying lunch or a full family dinner. While primarily known for its takeout and delivery convenience, the cafe strives to be a dependable fixture in the community, providing food that is both filling and seasoned to local tastes. Whether you're in the mood for a simple fish sandwich, a full salmon dinner, or their highly-praised mac and cheese, Catch 24 Cafe invites locals to experience their selection of freshly prepared dishes.

The restaurant's focus is on delivering a diverse menu centered around fish and chicken, featuring crowd-pleasers like whiting, jumbo shrimp, and chicken wings, all available with a variety of classic side dishes. Based on feedback from the community, customers often appreciate the substantial serving sizes, noting the good value for the price in the current economy. The vibe of the establishment leans toward a casual atmosphere, perfectly suited for the quick-service model of takeout and delivery that has become a staple for many busy Queens residents. However, like any local spot, experiences can vary. While many praise the fresh, perfectly seasoned food and the care taken with special instructions, some historical customer reviews have pointed to occasional inconsistencies in the preparation of sides or issues with order accuracy and waiting times, particularly for delivery partners. For a true taste of local comfort cuisine in Queens, Catch 24 Cafe remains a notable option worth exploring.

Location and Accessibility

Catch 24 Cafe is conveniently situated in a high-traffic area of Queens, making it accessible to a large portion of the New York City community. The specific address is 220-25 Jamaica Ave, Jamaica, NY 11428, USA. This location places the cafe right in the heart of Jamaica, an area known for its vibrant local commerce and excellent connectivity via public transit. The Jamaica Avenue corridor is a key thoroughfare, which is an advantage for both walk-in customers and delivery services covering the surrounding neighborhoods.

For New Yorkers relying on public transportation, the Jamaica area is a transportation hub. The cafe's location on Jamaica Avenue is well-served by local MTA bus routes, offering easy access from various parts of Queens and beyond. While specific subway proximity would require precise mapping, the general area benefits from being close to major transit lines that serve the area. For those driving, the location is on a main street, but as with many popular spots in Queens, street parking is typically available but may require some patience, especially during peak dining hours. It is noted that free street parking is generally available in the area, offering a manageable option for quick pickups. The accessibility of the location is a significant factor in the restaurant’s popularity, making it a simple choice for residents looking to grab a quick and satisfying meal on the go. Furthermore, the establishment is noted for accommodating various services, which ensures that even if you're not in the immediate vicinity, you can still enjoy their menu.

Services Offered

Catch 24 Cafe provides several key services designed to cater to the fast-paced lifestyle of New York residents. The focus is heavily on convenience and accessibility, ensuring customers can enjoy their meals whether they choose to visit the location or have their food brought to them.

• Takeout / Takeaway: Customers can place their orders and pick up their freshly prepared food directly from the cafe. This is a popular option for local residents and those who are passing through the Jamaica area.
• Delivery: The restaurant utilizes various third-party delivery services, making their extensive menu available for delivery throughout a wide service radius in Queens. This service is essential for the modern dining experience in NYC.
• Dine-in: While the atmosphere is generally described as casual and focused on quick service, the option to dine in is available for patrons who prefer to eat on-site.
• Catering: The cafe offers catering options, which can be ideal for local events, family gatherings, or office lunches, allowing larger groups to enjoy their popular seafood and comfort food dishes.
• Diverse Offerings: The menu accommodates different dining needs, including options for small plates, quick bites, and full comfort food meals.
• Dietary Request Accommodation: The staff is noted to take special instructions seriously, with reports of accommodating requests such as cooking shellfish away from other foods for allergy concerns.

Features / Highlights

The reputation of Catch 24 Cafe is built on several standout features and menu highlights that draw a loyal customer base, even in a competitive dining environment like Queens. These highlights reflect the dedication to flavorful, substantial, and value-driven food.

• Seafood and Comfort Food Focus: The menu is a delightful blend of fresh-tasting seafood and classic comfort side dishes. Popular entrees include the Salmon with Two Sides, Whiting with Two Sides, and Jumbo Shrimp Dinners.
• Highly-Praised Sides: The side dishes often receive high marks from customers. Their Mac & Cheese is a fan-favorite, described as creamy and rich. Other popular sides include Candied Yams and Mashed Potatoes, though customers generally appreciate the range of side choices to complete their meals.
• Crispy and Flavorful Fried Fish: The fried fish, particularly the Whiting fillet, is consistently commended for being fried until crispy, flavorful, and not oily, distinguishing it from lower-quality preparations.
• Generous Portion Sizes: A recurrent theme in customer feedback is the value offered through large and generous portions, which many feel is an excellent benefit in the current economy.
• Boil Bags: For patrons seeking a different kind of seafood experience, the menu occasionally features options like Crab and Shrimp Boil Bags, providing a unique and flavorful communal dining choice.
• Casual and Kid-Friendly Atmosphere: The establishment offers a casual, comfortable setting suitable for a quick meal, and it is noted as having a kid-friendly atmosphere with visual elements that appeal to families.
• Diverse Menu Preparation: Main proteins like Salmon and Whiting can often be customized, with options for preparation methods like fried, grilled, baked, or even jerked, adding flexibility for health-conscious or flavor-seeking customers.

Contact Information

For New York locals looking to contact Catch 24 Cafe, place an order, or inquire about their services, the following information is available:

Address:

Phone:

Please note that while the business has a consistent location, it is always a good practice to call ahead to confirm their current hours of operation before planning a visit, especially as business schedules can sometimes fluctuate.

What is worth choosing

For New Yorkers navigating the vast dining landscape of Queens, Catch 24 Cafe is worth choosing for several compelling reasons, primarily centered around its commitment to flavorful, value-driven comfort food. If you are a fan of classic Southern or soul food-inspired dishes alongside well-prepared seafood, this Jamaica spot is likely to satisfy.

The most highly recommended items are consistently the seafood and a select few sides. The Salmon with Two Sides is a must-try, available grilled, baked, or jerked, and has often been cited as the most popular item on the menu. Customers frequently praise it for being cooked to perfection—crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. Following closely behind is the Whiting with Two Sides, celebrated for its non-oily, flavorful, and perfectly crispy fried preparation. Pairing either of these with the decadent Mac & Cheese is a local favorite combo that offers genuine comfort food bliss. The Mac & Cheese is specifically highlighted in numerous positive reviews for its creamy texture and rich, cheesy flavor.

Beyond the excellent food, the cafe’s value proposition is a major draw. In a city where dining costs can escalate quickly, Catch 24 Cafe provides generous portion sizes at a reasonable price point, which many customers recognize as a significant advantage. The flexibility of their menu, allowing customers to choose their protein and two sides, ensures a customizable and fulfilling meal every time. Furthermore, the commitment to offering multiple service options—from dine-in to easy takeout and delivery—makes it an exceptionally convenient choice for the busy New Yorker. While there are some historical comments about occasional service speed or consistency issues that reflect the reality of operating a high-volume local spot, the overwhelming majority of positive feedback focuses on the delicious taste, perfect seasoning, and overall satisfaction derived from their hearty, well-made meals. If you are in Queens and craving fresh, well-seasoned comfort seafood, Catch 24 Cafe on Jamaica Avenue provides a dependable and satisfying option that locals consistently return to.

Catch 24 Cafe

220-25 Jamaica Ave, Jamaica, NY 11428, USA