Cookies and Creamery

- 1437 Carroll St, Brooklyn, NY 11213

For New Yorkers on the hunt for a truly unique and high-quality dessert experience, Cookies and Creamery stands out as a hidden gem in the heart of Brooklyn. Located on Carroll Street, this establishment transcends the typical bakery or ice cream parlor, offering an array of refined, artisanal, and, notably, exquisite kosher desserts. It's a culinary destination for those who appreciate deep flavor, elegant presentation, and treats that cater to various dietary preferences without compromising on taste.

The core of Cookies and Creamery’s appeal lies in its dedication to creating heavenly, and often unique, treats. It’s known throughout the local community for its masterful blend of classic dessert forms with imaginative, global-inspired flavors. From non-dairy ice cream that customers rave about for its depth of flavor to beautifully crafted cakes perfect for any celebration, the entire menu is a testament to the dedication of the pastry chef, Sarah, and her commitment to quality and artistry. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick indulgence or planning the desserts for a major event, this Brooklyn spot provides a sophisticated take on sweets.

Cookies and Creamery is conveniently nestled in Brooklyn, making it easily accessible for residents across the New York area. You can find this sweet haven at:

1437 Carroll St, Brooklyn, NY 11213, USA

The Carroll Street location places it within a vibrant, community-focused neighborhood, allowing for an easy stop-in for a quick treat. While current service options focus on In-store pickup and Takeout, making it ideal for a quick visit to satisfy a sudden craving or pick up a pre-ordered dessert, the location’s placement in Brooklyn ensures it’s a manageable trip for anyone in the five boroughs looking for top-tier kosher and non-dairy options. The shop accepts Credit cards and Debit cards for quick and easy payment.

Cookies and Creamery functions as a versatile establishment that covers multiple sweet-tooth needs, serving as a:

• Bakery, offering a variety of baked goods, cakes, and pastries.
• Cake shop and Cupcake shop, specializing in full cakes and custom orders for special events.
• Ice cream shop, renowned for its deeply flavored, often non-dairy ice cream selections.
• Kosher grocery store (in its retail offerings of kosher-certified goods).
• Kosher restaurant (in its capacity to serve ready-to-eat, certified kosher food).
• Catering for special events, with a noted history of providing exquisite desserts for engagement parties and other significant celebrations.

The experience at Cookies and Creamery is defined by several key features that set it apart from other dessert shops in New York:

• Exquisite Kosher Desserts: The shop is highly praised for offering unique and refined kosher desserts, a significant feature that caters to the local Jewish community and anyone seeking high-quality, certified treats.
• High-Quality Non-Dairy Ice Cream: Customers frequently rave about the deep flavors of the non-dairy ice cream, often noting that it surpasses traditional dairy ice creams in richness and complexity.
• Artisanal and Unique Flavor Profiles: The menu showcases sophisticated flavor combinations that are difficult to find elsewhere in the city, such as Miso Brownie ice cream, Black Halva ice cream, Passionfruit Meringue Tart petit gateaux, and Spiced Rum Brown Butter Carrot cake.
• Beautiful Presentation: The desserts are consistently described as beautiful and works of art, indicating an exceptional focus on aesthetics and plating that makes them perfect for gifts or events.
• Specialty Cake Flavors: The cake menu features inventive flavors like Pistachio Rose, Earl Grey Cardamom Cake, and Lime Tres Leches, offering a modern twist on celebration cakes.
• Seasonal and Themed Offerings: The variety of Hamantaschen flavors, such as Espresso Halva Chocolate Ganache and Bourbon Caramel Apple Pie, demonstrates a commitment to seasonal and holiday-specific items.
• Dedicated Pastry Chef (Sarah): Reviews often highlight the dedication and personalized service from the chef, Sarah, who is known for being easy to work with and for creating heavenly treats that are both dairy-free and, in some cases, gluten-free.

When visiting Cookies and Creamery, the sheer variety of unique options can make a decision difficult, but several categories stand out as "must-try" items that embody the store’s unique identity.

For ice cream aficionados, stepping beyond the Classic Vanilla or Classic Chocolate is highly recommended. The adventurous New York palate will appreciate the complex, savory-sweet notes in the Miso Brownie or Charred Sweet Corn ice creams. These are the flavors that local customers claim have a "deep flavor that can't be found anywhere else Kosher." The non-dairy ice cream itself is a marvel, consistently receiving top marks for its creamy texture and rich taste that defies its dairy-free status.

The Petit Gateaux section is another highlight, perfect for personal indulgence or a small, elegant gift. The names alone promise a luxurious experience: Matcha Raspberry, Tropical Indulgence, and Chai Latte all speak to a refined sensibility and a careful balance of flavors. The Passionfruit Meringue Tart is an excellent choice for a bright, tangy, and textural experience.

In the cake category, the Passionfruit Cheesecake is a frequently lauded choice, while unique flavors like Blueberry Cardamom Cake and the sophisticated Tonka Almond cake are worth trying for an unforgettable dessert. For a more traditional but elevated bakery treat, the Best. Brownies. Ever and the decadent Dulce De Leche Stuffed Dark Chocolate Cookies live up to the shop's high standards. The combination of unique ingredients, beautiful presentation, and expert preparation ensures that anything you choose from Cookies and Creamery will feel like a truly special treat, whether it's an everyday cookie or a spectacular celebratory cake.

The consistent feedback from New York customers is not just about the quality of the ingredients, but the feeling that each item is a labor of love. As one happy customer noted after having their event catered, the work is "beautiful and delicious," and the chef is "extremely dedicated." This level of personal care is what keeps local New Yorkers coming back to this Brooklyn spot for all their sweet needs.

If you are in the New York area and wish to place an order, inquire about catering, or check on the availability of a specific item, you can reach Cookies and Creamery using the following details:

Address: 1437 Carroll St, Brooklyn, NY 11213, USA

Phone: (914) 261-0063

Mobile Phone: +1 914-261-0063

Remember to consider ordering in advance for custom or large orders, as the popularity of this highly-rated Brooklyn establishment can mean that specialty items sell out quickly.

Cookies and Creamery

1437 Carroll St, Brooklyn, NY 11213, USA