El Centenario Pizza

- 57 E 18th St, Brooklyn, NY 11226

Brooklyn locals know that when a serious pizza craving hits, only a few spots truly deliver the quintessential New York experience. Among the bustling pizzerias of the borough, El Centenario Pizza at 57 E 18th St has established itself as a must-try destination, blending traditional Italian flavors with a modern, welcoming atmosphere. This is not just a place for a quick slice; it's a full-service Italian kitchen committed to crafting high-quality, delicious comfort food, from classic pies to hearty pasta dishes and specialty heroes.

El Centenario Pizza, a beacon of authentic Italian cooking in Brooklyn, is rooted in a deep love for the craft of pizza making. Founded by a passionate team with years of combined experience, their mission is to honor time-tested recipes while keeping an eye on fresh, modern culinary techniques. The focus is on using premium ingredients, including homemade dough, fresh mozzarella, and quality meats and produce. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through the Flatbush area, this local gem offers a casual, cozy spot perfect for lunch, dinner, or satisfying that late-night hunger.

The restaurant offers a wide and varied menu that goes far beyond the basic cheese and pepperoni. Their specialty thin-crust pizzas are a major highlight, featuring creative combinations and beloved classics. For those seeking something heartier, the menu is packed with traditional Italian-American fare, including a selection of pasta, hot heroes, Stromboli, calzones, and even a full lineup of burgers and wings. This extensive selection ensures there's something to please everyone at the table, from traditionalists to those looking for a unique pizza experience.

A dedication to service and accessibility underscores the entire operation. El Centenario Pizza understands the rhythm of life in New York, which is why they offer a full spectrum of convenient service options, including swift delivery and curbside pickup. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere also make it a great place to sit down, relax, and enjoy a meal with family and friends. When you're searching for your next go-to spot for authentic, satisfying Italian food in Brooklyn, El Centenario Pizza consistently rises to the occasion.

***

Nestled right in the heart of Brooklyn, El Centenario Pizza is conveniently located at 57 E 18th St, Brooklyn, NY 11226, USA. Its prime location makes it easily accessible for residents and workers in the surrounding neighborhoods, including Flatbush and Midwood. The restaurant’s visibility and ease of access contribute to its popularity as a local favorite for a quick and reliable meal.

For the convenience of all New Yorkers, the establishment prioritizes accessibility features. They offer a wheelchair-accessible entrance and wheelchair-accessible seating, ensuring that every member of the community can comfortably enjoy their dining experience. The neighborhood setting means it’s a staple for everyday meals, whether you're grabbing a slice during a lunch break, picking up dinner on the way home, or sitting down for a family meal.

***

El Centenario Pizza is structured to provide maximum convenience for the busy New York clientele. Their range of service options ensures you can enjoy their food wherever you are.

• Dine-in: Enjoy a casual and cozy meal at the restaurant with available seating.
• Takeout: Perfect for a quick grab-and-go meal.
• Delivery: Get your pizza, pasta, and heroes delivered right to your door.
• Curbside Pickup: An ultra-convenient option for customers on the move—order ahead and pick up right outside.
• Catering: Full catering services available, including trays of salad, pasta, and chicken/meat entrees, ideal for parties and gatherings.
• Counter Service: Quick service available for single slices or fast orders.
• Credit and Debit Card Payments: Accepting major forms of payment for a seamless transaction.

***

The menu at El Centenario Pizza is a vibrant mix of authentic Italian staples and inventive pizza concepts, all prepared with fresh, quality ingredients. Here are some standout features and popular menu items that make this spot a neighborhood favorite:

• Specialty Thin Crust Pizzas: The core of their menu, featuring unique pies like the Lasagna Pizza (with ground beef, ricotta, mozzarella, and tomato sauce), the spicy Taco Pizza (seasoned ground beef, jalapeños, cheddar cheese, and onions), and the always-popular Homemade Buffalo Chicken Pizza.
• The Famous Grandma Pie: A must-try square pie made with olive oil, fresh basil, tomato chunks, and mozzarella cheese. They also offer creative twists like the Grandma Vodka Pizza and the Grandma MVP Pizza (Marinara, Vodka, Pesto).
• Classic Pizza Variety: Offering the essentials, including the standard Large Cheese Pie, Sicilian Pie, Brooklyn Style Sicilian Pizza, and a 10" Gluten Free Pizza option to accommodate various dietary needs.
• Hearty Italian Heroes: A selection of satisfying hot heroes like Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm, and the specialty El Centenario Special Hero (Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, and tomatoes).
• Comfort Food and Appetizers: The menu is rich with comfort food and quick bites, including crispy Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks, Buffalo Wings (available in Buffalo, BBQ, and Garlic flavors), and Chicken Fingers.
• Full Pasta Menu: Beyond pizza, they offer classic Italian entrees such as Baked Ziti Parmigiana, Meat Lasagna, Chicken Parmigian with Pasta, and different pasta options like Spaghetti or Ziti Ala Vodka and Shrimp Alfredo.
• Convenient Meal Deals: The “Online” specials provide great value for families or group meals, such as the combo featuring Two Large Pies, Two Buffalo Wings & a 2 Liter Soda.
• Casual and Cozy Atmosphere: The dining environment is designed to be relaxed, casual, and friendly, perfect for all ages and family dining. The service is often highlighted as fast and commendable by customers.
• Desserts: Don't skip the sweet endings with classic Italian desserts like Cannoli and Tiramisu, alongside favorites like Cheesecake and Chocolate Cake.

***

For orders, inquiries, or to find out more about their menu, here is the essential contact information for El Centenario Pizza:

Address: 57 E 18th St, Brooklyn, NY 11226, USA

Phone: (347) 295-2443

***

When you’re navigating the culinary landscape of New York, finding a local spot that consistently delivers on quality, variety, and service can be a game-changer. El Centenario Pizza offers a compelling combination of all three, making it a reliable and delightful choice for any meal occasion.

The sheer depth of their menu means that El Centenario is much more than just a pizza place. While their authentic thin crust and deep-dish options, like the ever-popular Grandma Pie and the unique Lasagna Pizza, are reason enough to visit, the restaurant excels across all categories. They offer a complete dining experience, from satisfying appetizers like their crispy Fried Calamari and famous Garlic Knots to full-sized Italian entrées and heroes. The commitment to providing comforting, familiar food makes it an instant go-to for a “quick bite” that feels substantial and homemade.

For busy New Yorkers, the emphasis on convenience is paramount. The availability of delivery, takeout, and curbside pickup means you can enjoy their delicious food without interrupting your day. Whether you're planning a corporate lunch, a weekend party, or a simple weeknight dinner, the efficient service, which customers consistently praise as "fast," ensures a smooth experience. Their catering menu, featuring large trays of Baked Ziti and Chicken Parmigian, is a straightforward solution for feeding a crowd with high-quality Italian food.

Ultimately, choosing El Centenario Pizza is about supporting a local Brooklyn institution that prides itself on food quality and customer satisfaction. The friendly, family-oriented atmosphere and the diverse menu—which includes options for solo diners, families, and those with specific needs like gluten-free pizza—cement its status as a true neighborhood cornerstone. For an authentic, reliable, and delicious Italian-American meal in Brooklyn, El Centenario Pizza is highly recommended. Stop by 57 E 18th St and discover your new favorite slice today.

El Centenario Pizza

57 E 18th St, Brooklyn, NY 11226, USA