Fairway 74th Street Cafe

- 2131 Broadway, New York, NY 10023

For New Yorkers who love the convenience of grocery shopping and the comfort of a good meal, the Fairway 74th Street Cafe offers the best of both worlds. Located inside the famous Fairway Market on Broadway, this cafe is a bright, casual, and practical dining spot that serves as a welcome respite from the city's hustle. It's not just a place for a quick bite; it's a full-service restaurant that has garnered a loyal following for its quality food, generous portions, and professional service. Whether you're looking for a relaxing breakfast to start your day or a satisfying lunch to power through it, this cafe is a hidden gem on the Upper West Side.

The cafe’s menu is a delightful surprise, offering a wide range of options that go beyond typical cafe fare. A major highlight is their all-day breakfast, which means you can enjoy classics like French Toast or a hearty omelet any time. The Challah French Toast, in particular, is a customer favorite, praised for its ample serving size and delicious taste. Other notable breakfast items include the "Upper West Sider" with smoked salmon and eggs, and the "Heirloom Shakshuka." The menu is extensive and caters to various cravings, from traditional favorites to unique, chef-crafted dishes.

Beyond breakfast, the cafe offers a full lunch and dinner menu. You can find a wide selection of sandwiches, including a Classic Pastrami Reuben made with Fairway's own sourdough rye. The burger section features options like the "Café Classic" and the "GEMINI" burger, while the entrees offer everything from Chicken Milanese to Korean Short Rib. The fact that the ingredients are sourced directly from the market downstairs is a major advantage, ensuring that everything from the produce to the meat is fresh and of high quality. For those with specific dietary needs, there are also healthy options, and even gluten-free pancakes.

The atmosphere of the cafe is another key draw. It’s designed to be comfortable and welcoming, perfect for small groups or solo diners. Customers have noted the great view of the Beacon Theater from the windows, which adds a unique New York touch to the dining experience. The combination of a relaxed setting, delicious food, and a view makes it a favorite spot for a relaxing Saturday morning or a weekday lunch break.

Fairway 74th Street Cafe is located at 2131 Broadway, New York, NY 10023, USA. Its location inside the Fairway Market on Broadway at West 74th Street is highly convenient for anyone in the Upper West Side. The neighborhood is vibrant and bustling, with a mix of residential buildings, theaters, and other popular shops. This makes the cafe a perfect stop for a meal before catching a show at the Beacon Theatre or after a shopping trip.

Getting to the cafe is exceptionally easy thanks to its proximity to public transportation. It is just a few steps from the 1, 2, and 3 subway lines at the 72nd Street station, and a short walk from the B and C trains. This makes it a quick and accessible destination from almost anywhere in Manhattan. While the cafe is located within the supermarket, it offers a separate, dedicated dining space. The bright and open atmosphere makes it a great spot for both quick bites and more leisurely meals.

Fairway 74th Street Cafe provides a variety of services to enhance the customer experience, including:

• Dine-in: The cafe offers full table service, allowing you to sit down, relax, and enjoy your meal in a comfortable and clean environment. The staff is known for being professional and attentive, ensuring a great experience from start to finish.

• Delivery: The cafe offers delivery through various platforms, so you can enjoy their delicious food from the comfort of your home or office. This service brings the freshness of Fairway Market directly to your door.

• Takeout: For those who are on the go but still want a high-quality meal, takeout is a convenient option. You can place an order and pick it up to enjoy elsewhere.

• Catering: Fairway Market, and by extension the cafe, offers catering services for a variety of occasions, making it a great option for events and gatherings. The menu includes a wide range of platters and dishes suitable for any size party.

Fairway 74th Street Cafe stands out for several key features and highlights that make it a local favorite:

• Exceptional Food Quality: As it’s located inside Fairway Market, the cafe has access to the freshest ingredients available. This commitment to quality is evident in every dish, from the fresh pulled mozzarella on their brick oven pizza to their famous smoked salmon.

• All-Day Breakfast: The ability to order breakfast favorites like challah French toast and omelets at any time of day is a major draw for customers who love a good morning meal, no matter the hour.

• Generous Portions: Customers frequently mention the "ample serving" of dishes, ensuring that you get a satisfying and filling meal for a reasonable price. This value is a strong reason for repeat visits.

• Relaxed and Cozy Atmosphere: The cafe is a bright, casual, and quiet place that offers a welcome escape from the city streets. It's a comfortable spot to meet with a small group or to dine alone.

• Great View: The cafe's vantage point offers a unique view of Broadway and the Beacon Theatre, providing a pleasant backdrop for your meal.

• Professional and Attentive Staff: Reviewers consistently praise the staff for their courteous and professional service, which contributes significantly to the overall positive dining experience.

For more information or to make an inquiry, you can contact Fairway 74th Street Cafe at:

• Address: 2131 Broadway, New York, NY 10023, USA

• Phone: (212) 712-1570

Choosing Fairway 74th Street Cafe is an excellent decision for anyone in New York looking for a high-quality, convenient, and satisfying meal. What makes it truly worth choosing is the combination of its practical location and its surprisingly gourmet menu. This is not your typical supermarket cafe; it’s a full-fledged dining destination with chefs who craft delicious meals from scratch using the freshest ingredients available in the market downstairs.

The cafe's ability to cater to different dining needs throughout the day, from all-day breakfast to full dinner entrees, adds to its appeal. Whether you're in the mood for a classic deli sandwich, a hearty plate of pancakes, or a flavorful stir-fry, the menu has something to satisfy every craving. The generous portion sizes and reasonable prices provide great value, making it a smart choice for a filling meal. Finally, the pleasant atmosphere and professional staff create a relaxing and enjoyable experience that feels worlds away from the busy supermarket below.

For a meal that is consistently amazing in terms of food, service, and atmosphere, Fairway 74th Street Cafe is a top-tier choice. It’s a place where you can relax, enjoy a great view, and eat well, proving that convenience and quality can go hand-in-hand in the city that never sleeps.

Fairway 74th Street Cafe

2131 Broadway, New York, NY 10023, USA