Stewart's Lafayette Deli

- 658 Lafayette Ave, Hawthorne, NJ 07506

Introduction / Overview

For residents across Northern New Jersey, finding a true, dependable local deli—one that consistently delivers on freshness, quality, and community spirit—can feel like striking gold. In Hawthorne, that gold standard is widely considered to be Stewart's Lafayette Deli. This isn’t just another sandwich shop; it's a gourmet deli that has firmly established itself as a cornerstone of the community, offering everything from classic New Jersey breakfast items to specialty sandwiches and comprehensive catering services. Stewart's Lafayette Deli stands out not only for its commitment to high-quality ingredients but also for its welcoming atmosphere, which has earned it a reputation as a friendly and inclusive local spot.

Since 1986, this establishment has been committed to serving exceptional food, a tenure that speaks volumes about its quality and local popularity. The deli proudly identifies as a women-owned business, adding another layer of distinction to its strong community presence. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick, essential morning coffee and bagel, picking up a substantial lunch for the workday, or planning a full catering spread for a family gathering or corporate event, Stewart’s Lafayette Deli is geared to meet the demand. They are known for using premium ingredients, including the notable use of Boar’s Head meats and cheeses for their platters and sandwiches. The menu showcases an impressive range of classic deli fare, hot sandwiches, specialty items, and freshly made salads, embodying the best of New Jersey's comfort food culture.

The true measure of any great New Jersey deli is often found in its signature items, and Stewart’s does not disappoint. Customer reviews frequently praise their exceptional takes on regional favorites. For example, their Sloppy Joe sandwich, a New Jersey classic typically featuring layers of deli meat, Swiss cheese, Russian dressing, and coleslaw on three slices of rye bread, has earned rave reviews for its quality and flavor. Similarly, their seasonal specials, such as a renowned Thanksgiving turkey sandwich—packed with fresh turkey, stuffing, gravy, and cranberry on a roll—highlight their dedication to home-cooked taste and fresh, locally sourced ingredients when possible, like the farm-fresh turkey mentioned by enthusiastic patrons.

Stewart’s Lafayette Deli operates primarily as a provider of quick, satisfying meals. It serves as a classic breakfast restaurant for early risers, a bustling lunch restaurant for the mid-day rush, and a full-service sandwich shop throughout its operating hours. The focus is on convenience without compromising on quality, making it the perfect choice for a quick visit while still offering the warmth and personalization of a local favorite.

Location and Accessibility

Stewart's Lafayette Deli is conveniently situated right in the heart of Hawthorne, New Jersey, making it highly accessible for both local residents and those traveling through the Passaic County area. Its location at 658 Lafayette Ave, Hawthorne, NJ 07506, places it on a main thoroughfare, making it simple to find for anyone needing a quick stop for a delicious meal.

For patrons driving to the deli, parking is available and practical, which is a significant convenience in many North Jersey towns. The business notes that free street parking is available, alleviating the stress of finding a spot during busy meal times. This accessibility encourages customers to make a quick stop, whether for an immediate meal or for a fast pickup of a catering order.

In terms of service accessibility, Stewart’s Lafayette Deli has adapted to modern customer needs. While the deli offers the traditional in-store shopping experience—where you can browse, order, and watch your food being prepared—they also provide several convenient options for those on the go. These service options ensure that their fantastic food is readily available, catering to the fast-paced lifestyle of New Jersey locals. The blend of in-person, in-store shopping and digital, remote ordering highlights their commitment to customer service and convenience.

Services Offered

• Full Deli Counter Service: Offering premium meats and cheeses, including Boar’s Head products, sliced to order.
• Sandwich Shop: A vast menu of hot and cold sandwiches, heroes, and wraps, including specialty sandwiches like the classic New Jersey Sloppy Joe, the Italian Hero, the Reuben, and unique creations like The "Bear" and the Roast Beef Special.
• Breakfast Restaurant: Providing all the morning essentials, from fresh-baked bagels and rolls to egg sandwiches, with popular options like Taylor Ham (pork roll) and cheese, a New Jersey staple.
• Lunch Restaurant: Serving a full array of lunch options including hot entrees, gourmet sandwiches, fresh salads (like Tossed Salad, Chef Salad, and various homemade deli salads such as potato, macaroni, and coleslaw), and soups.
• Comprehensive Catering Food and Drink Supplier: A full catering menu is available for events of any size, offering everything from appetizers (Antipasto, Chicken Tenders, Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato Platter) to main hot trays (Baked Ziti Parmigiana, Penne Vodka, BBQ Pulled Pork) and dessert trays (Brownies, Rice Pudding).
• Specialized Sandwich Platters: Catering options include Triangle Cocktail Sandwiches, assorted Wraps, Deli Style Sloppy Joes (Double Decker Sandwiches), Assorted Sandwiches, and Party Heroes (available by the foot).
• Prepared Cold Buffet and Hot/Cold Buffet Options: Full buffet services priced per person, featuring a selection of cold cuts, cheeses, salads, and bread, with the option to add hot entrees.
• Takeout and Delivery: Convenient options are available for customers to pick up orders in-store or have them delivered through third-party services like Uber Eats, ensuring food is accessible even during a busy day.
• In-Store Pickup and In-Store Shopping: Traditional and quick service models are available for local patrons.

Features / Highlights

• Women-Owned Business: A distinct local feature that contributes positively to the community's entrepreneurial landscape.
• Commitment to Freshness: Praised by customers for the fresh ingredients and homemade quality of their food, with meats that "literally melt in your mouth," as noted in a review of their roast beef Sloppy Joe.
• Premium Meats and Cheeses: Utilizes high-quality Boar’s Head products for their sandwiches and cold cut platters, a sign of quality for deli aficionados.
• New Jersey Comfort Food Specialties: Excels at local favorites, including the aforementioned Sloppy Joe and their all-important Taylor Ham (pork roll) breakfast options.
• Seasonal and Daily Specials: Offers unique, popular items like the Thanksgiving Turkey Sandwich special, which features fresh turkey, sometimes sourced from local farms, demonstrating a connection to local suppliers.
• Inclusive and Welcoming Environment: Clearly defined as a community space that is LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace, fostering a positive and respectful atmosphere for all patrons.
• Convenient Planning and Payment: Optimized for a quick visit and accepts all major Credit cards and Debit cards.
• Modern Amenities: Offers Wi-Fi access for customers, a helpful feature for quick stops or those planning their day.

Contact Information

Stewart's Lafayette Deli

Address: 658 Lafayette Ave, Hawthorne, NJ 07506, USA

Phone: (973) 427-9009

What is Worth Choosing

For any New Jersey local, choosing Stewart's Lafayette Deli is choosing a blend of tradition, quality, and community support. What truly sets this establishment apart is the palpable sense of care and quality evident in their offerings. This is a deli where the dedication to scratch-made and premium-sourced ingredients is a central focus, elevating their daily fare from simple sandwiches to memorable meals.

It is worth choosing Stewart's for the sheer quality of their signature items. The Sloppy Joe is frequently cited as one of the best in the area, a must-try for anyone who appreciates this iconic Tri-State deli creation. Furthermore, their Turkey Club Sandwich is consistently ranked as a top-liked item. But it’s their seasonal creativity, like the beloved Thanksgiving special, that really captures the heart of home cooking and fresh, farm-to-table flavors, making it a place to return to again and again for both the familiar and the delightfully surprising.

Beyond the excellent food, the dedication to a diverse, welcoming, and friendly environment, coupled with the pride of being a women-owned business, makes Stewart's a conscientious choice. By visiting, you are supporting a local business that not only prioritizes the quality of its products—like utilizing premium Boar’s Head products—but also champions a positive community atmosphere.

Finally, for businesses or families in the Hawthorne and surrounding North Jersey areas, Stewart’s catering service simplifies event planning without sacrificing taste. With extensive options ranging from impressive sandwich platters and party heroes to hot trays featuring comforting Italian specialties and rich desserts, they can manage any event, big or small. Choosing Stewart’s Lafayette Deli means choosing quality, convenience, and a truly authentic taste of New Jersey deli culture, a local staple that deserves your visit.

Stewart's Lafayette Deli

658 Lafayette Ave, Hawthorne, NJ 07506, USA