Fisherman's Cove

- 1420 Rockaway Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11236

Fisherman's Cove is an established culinary fixture in the Canarsie neighborhood of Brooklyn, distinguishing itself as a dual-concept dining spot that specializes in both **Caribbean cuisine** and **Seafood**. Situated on Rockaway Parkway, this restaurant aims to provide authentic flavors and a lively, accessible dining environment for the community. The core menu is built around popular, hearty Caribbean staples, offering comforting and flavorful options suitable for any time of the day, from a quick bite to a full, satisfying dinner.

The restaurant caters to a wide and diverse audience, popular with **Locals, College students, Families, and Tourists** alike. Its atmosphere is categorized as both **Casual** and **Trendy**, suggesting a relaxed yet vibrant setting that is conducive to spontaneous visits. Service is versatile, accommodating modern consumer demands with options for **Delivery, Takeout, and Dine-in**. Furthermore, its hours extend to provide **Late-night food**, making it a valuable resource for those seeking quality meals outside of standard dining hours.

The extensive food and drink menu features essential Caribbean proteins and sides. Main courses include favorites like **Jerk Chicken, Stew Chicken, Curry Chicken, Oxtail, Goat, and Fish**, with prices reflecting typical Brooklyn dining values. Sides such as **Rice & Peas, Mac & Cheese, Cabbage, and Plantains** ensure a complete and traditional Caribbean meal. This broad offering, coupled with service options like accepting reservations despite often having a wait, positions Fisherman's Cove as a significant destination within the 11236 area code.

Fisherman's Cove is located at **1420 Rockaway Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11236, USA**. This address places the establishment in the heart of Canarsie, a highly accessible and key area within southeastern Brooklyn. Rockaway Parkway is a major, high-traffic corridor, ensuring the restaurant benefits from excellent visibility and convenient local access.

For patrons utilizing New York’s public transit system, the location on a major parkway means it is well-served by several MTA bus lines. While the exact proximity to subway stations may require local knowledge, Canarsie is generally accessible via the L train line, making the restaurant reachable from a significant portion of Brooklyn and Manhattan with a final bus transfer or car ride. The restaurant’s strategic placement within the 11236 zip code reinforces its role as a dedicated neighborhood institution, easy for locals to reach whether they are coming from home, work, or school. Given the restaurant’s popularity for lunch, dinner, and even late-night service, its street-level accessibility on a primary avenue is a major benefit for quick pickups and spontaneous dine-in visits. Furthermore, the area is generally accommodating for various modes of transit, including ride-shares and personal vehicles, though parking availability, as is typical in a dense New York neighborhood, may vary.

Fisherman's Cove provides a comprehensive set of services designed to meet modern urban dining demands across all customer segments.

• Multi-Channel Service: Offers **Dine-in**, **Takeout**, and **Delivery** options, ensuring patrons can enjoy their meals wherever they prefer.

• Full Lunch and Dinner Service: Operates consistently throughout the day, covering key dining periods, making it reliable for daily meals.

• Late-Night Food Provision: A significant service highlight, catering to customers who need food options outside of regular hours.

• Reservations Accepted: Despite its casual nature, the restaurant **Accepts reservations**, a service that is particularly useful for groups, though there is often **Usually a wait**, indicating high demand.

• Focus on Comfort and Quick Bites: The menu offers items categorized as **Comfort food**, **Quick bite**, and **Small plates**, providing options for every appetite level and time constraint.

• Variety of Payment Methods: Accepts **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments**, ensuring a smooth and modern transaction experience.

• Specialty Beverage Service: Offers a selection of popular Caribbean and local soft drinks such as **D & G Gingerbeer, Tropical Rhythms, and Vita Malt**, enhancing the authentic meal experience.

Fisherman’s Cove is noted for several key features that draw a varied crowd, although potential customers must be aware of reported inconsistencies in food quality.

• Dual-Cuisine Specialization: The focus on both authentic **Caribbean** cuisine (Jerk Chicken, Oxtail) and **Seafood** provides a broader menu appeal than most single-focus restaurants.

• Diverse and Affordable Menu: The offering includes numerous popular mains such as **Oxtail ($15.00 - $16.00), Fish ($15.25), and Jerk Chicken ($11.75)**, supported by a range of traditional sides, making it an accessible choice for diverse budgets.

• Appealing Atmosphere: Described as both **Casual** and **Trendy**, the restaurant offers a relaxed and lively environment suitable for various social outings.

• High Local Popularity: The restaurant is demonstrably popular, indicated by being noted as a destination for **Locals, College students, and Tourists**, and by the service option note that there is **Usually a wait**.

• Factual Customer Experience Note (Critical Quality Warning): Despite its popularity, customers should be aware of significant, documented quality concerns. Multiple reviews mention issues with protein preparation, specifically citing **hairy, hard, undercooked, and not properly cleaned/skinned oxtail**, and instances of **dry/hard plantains**. One customer noted spending $25 on a meal that was deemed "disgusted with what had seen" and advised future patrons to "Skip this location unless you want undercooked hairy meat." This highlights a serious, reported inconsistency in kitchen standards that prospective diners should factor into their decision.

• Late-Night Availability: The offering of **Late-night food** is a crucial highlight in an area where dining options may be limited after standard evening hours, providing a much-needed service.

For direct inquiries, placing an order for takeout, or making a reservation at Fisherman's Cove in Brooklyn, use the following contact details:

Address: 1420 Rockaway Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11236, USA

Phone: (718) 975-8625

For a local user in the New York region, Fisherman’s Cove is a venue that presents a clear trade-off between **convenience and potential culinary risk**. It is worth choosing for its highly accessible location in Canarsie, its **versatile service options (Dine-in, Takeout, Delivery)**, and its extensive offering of authentic Caribbean comfort food favorites like the highly demanded **Oxtail** and classic **Jerk Chicken**. If you are looking for a lively, casual, and trendy spot that is open late and offers a wide array of options for both seafood lovers and fans of West Indian cuisine, this restaurant fulfills that logistical requirement perfectly.

However, it is crucial that the choice be informed by the verifiable customer reports. While the menu is appealing and the prices are typical for the area, the multiple, explicit customer complaints detailing severe quality control issues—specifically citing **undercooked, hard, and poorly cleaned meat**—cannot be ignored. Therefore, a discerning New York diner may choose this location for its accessibility and broad menu but should exercise caution, particularly when ordering high-value items like the Oxtail. The restaurant is an essential part of the local dining landscape, especially for its late-night availability, but prospective patrons should weigh the benefit of its convenience and authentic menu against the documented risk of inconsistent food preparation quality. If the kitchen standards improve and the reported issues with meat preparation are definitively addressed, Fisherman’s Cove has the potential to be a truly outstanding neighborhood favorite.

Fisherman's Cove

1420 Rockaway Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11236, USA