Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria

- 92 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925

For New York locals in the Orange County region, particularly those around the scenic Greenwood Lake area, **Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria** stands out as a reliable and comprehensive destination for authentic Italian cuisine and, of course, a fantastic slice of pizza. This establishment goes well beyond a simple pizza shop, operating as a full-service Italian restaurant that caters to nearly every dining need, from a quick solo lunch to a large family dinner, and even extensive catering for events.

Located conveniently on Windermere Avenue, Four Brothers prides itself on offering a massive menu that truly has something for everyone. Whether you’re craving a classic **Cheese Pizza**, a hearty **Meat Lasagna**, or a unique specialty like the **Penne Alla Vodka Pizza** or **Philly Cheese Steak Pizza**, this spot covers all the bases. Their dedication to variety ensures that traditional Italian fare, pizzeria staples, and inventive fusion creations are all available under one roof.

The commitment to accommodating all appetites is evident in their extensive size options for pizzas, ranging from Personal (8 Slices) up to XX-Large (8 Slices) and even a massive 28” Pizza. Moreover, they’ve clearly dedicated effort to offering specialty dinner items, including various preparations of Chicken and Veal, alongside an impressive seafood selection and even **Mexican Dinners**, adding a delightful and unexpected layer of culinary diversity.

Local customers appreciate the quality, noting the pizza is delicious and the staff is typically friendly, which contributes to an overall pleasant dining experience. While they occasionally face challenges during peak busy times, the general consensus points toward a rewarding treat that's well worth the visit or the delivery wait. For those looking for a comfortable, casual place to enjoy great food near Greenwood Lake, Four Brothers remains a top-tier choice.

Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria is situated in the heart of the community at a highly visible and accessible address, making it a natural hub for locals and visitors exploring the Greenwood Lake area of New York.

The exact location is: **92 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925, USA**.

This Windermere Avenue address places the restaurant along a main artery, offering excellent convenience. For drivers, a significant highlight is the availability of both a **Free parking lot** and **Free street parking**, which removes the typical headache of finding a spot in a busy town center—a major plus for any New Yorker planning a visit. The establishment also demonstrates a strong commitment to accessibility, ensuring that all patrons can visit comfortably:

• **Wheelchair accessible parking lot** is provided for ease of entry and exit.
• **Wheelchair accessible restroom** is available within the premises.
• **Wheelchair accessible seating** options ensure comfortable dining for all guests.

The location is set up for both quick pick-ups and a relaxed sit-down meal, positioning it perfectly to serve the diverse needs of the Orange County community.

The service model at Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria is built on comprehensive flexibility, ensuring customers can enjoy their Italian and pizza favorites exactly how and where they prefer. The core services are designed to maximize convenience and cover a wide range of needs, from individual meals to large-scale events.

• **Dine-in:** Guests are welcome to enjoy a meal on-site in a casual, cozy, and quiet atmosphere. **Table service** is provided, and the restaurant **Accepts reservations** for those planning group outings or wanting to ensure a spot during peak hours.
• **Takeout/Curbside Pickup:** For those on the go, the restaurant offers fast and efficient takeout service. Customers are even encouraged by one reviewer to **call their pizza ahead of time** since they make it to order, ensuring minimal wait.
• **Delivery:** The restaurant operates as a dedicated **Delivery Restaurant**, offering the ultimate convenience of receiving fresh pizza and Italian dishes right to your door (with a **No-contact delivery** option also available).
• **Catering:** An extensive menu of **Hot Trays Catering**, **Salads Catering**, **Wings Catering**, and large **Subs Catering** is offered, making it a perfect partner for local parties, business lunches, or family gatherings.
• **Beverages:** The menu includes a selection of **Coffee** and **Wine** to complement dining options, appealing to those looking for a full dining experience.
• **Family & Group Dining:** They are **Good for kids**, offering a dedicated **Kids’ menu** and **High chairs**, and their large dining area makes them suitable for **Groups**.

Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria distinguishes itself in the competitive New York food scene through several notable features that enhance the customer experience and menu diversity:

• **Expansive Menu Variety:** Unlike a typical pizzeria, they offer a vast array of options spanning **Pizza restaurant** staples, classic **Italian restaurant** entrees (like Chicken Marsala and Veal Sorrentino), and unique items like **Mexican Dinners** (Burritos, Fajitas, Quesadillas).
• **Specialty Pizza Innovations:** The menu features highly creative and sought-after pizzas, such as **Philly Cheese Steak Pizza**, **Chicken Marsala Pizza**, **Buffalo Chicken Pizza**, and even the customer-favorite **Half Topping Pizza** combinations.
• **Comfortable Outdoor Seating:** They offer **Outdoor seating**, which, as one customer mentioned, is particularly "nice" during the summer months, providing a relaxed, al fresco dining experience near the lake.
• **Family-Friendly Amenities:** The inclusion of a **Kids' menu** and **High chairs** ensures a welcoming environment for families, solidifying its role as a true community restaurant.
• **Multiple Payment Convenience:** Accepting **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments** offers modern convenience for quick transactions.
• **Accessibility and Parking:** The provision of both a **Free parking lot** and comprehensive **Wheelchair accessible** features (parking, seating, restroom) removes barriers for a wide range of customers.
• **Vegetarian Options:** The menu includes a selection of **Vegetarian options**, such as the **Grilled Veggie Lovers Pizza** and various side dishes, catering to diverse dietary preferences.

To place an order, make a reservation, or inquire about catering services at Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria, please use the contact details provided below:

Address: **92 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925, USA**
Phone: **(845) 595-1966**
Mobile Phone: **+1 845-595-1966**

For the fastest service, especially for large orders or specialty pizzas that are made to order, calling ahead is highly recommended by frequent patrons.

For residents and visitors in the New York region, Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria is an excellent choice primarily for its **unrivaled menu depth** and commitment to **customer-focused dining**. It’s not just a pizza joint; it’s a full-scale Italian eatery that provides extraordinary variety and convenience.

What makes it truly worth choosing is the ability to satisfy nearly any craving in a single order. You can start with a **Fried Calamari** appetizer, enjoy a main course from the extensive **Chicken** or **Veal** section, or dive into one of their unique, highly customizable pizzas—like the **Half Philly Cheesesteak / Half BBQ Chicken with Jalapeños** praised by one customer. This versatility, combined with generous portions and a focus on both classic and inventive recipes, ensures a satisfying and exciting meal every time.

The dedicated service options are another key draw. Whether you need an affordable **Family Dinner Special** delivered on a busy weeknight, a cozy spot for a **Casual** dine-in experience with **Wine**, or a complex **Catering** order for a large event, Four Brothers provides the infrastructure to handle it all. The combination of easy accessibility, free parking, and diverse offerings solidifies its position as a superior local dining option in Greenwood Lake, making it a reliable choice for a high-quality, convenient, and comprehensive Italian-American meal.

Four Brothers Restaurant & Pizzeria

92 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925, USA