Gaetano Pizza & Cafe

- 100 Independent Way, Brewster, NY 10509

For those in the New York region seeking a comprehensive Italian and **Pizza restaurant** experience, **Gaetano Pizza & Cafe** in **Brewster, NY**, stands out as a versatile and conveniently located option. More than just a pizzeria, this establishment offers a complete menu of Italian favorites, positioning it as a go-to spot for everything from a quick lunch slice to a full family dinner. Located centrally, Gaetano Pizza & Cafe is dedicated to providing classic **Comfort food** with extensive service options tailored to modern demands, including **No-contact delivery** and **Curbside pickup**.

The core of the menu is, of course, the pizza, available in four sizes: **Personal 10"**, **Small 14"**, **Large 16"**, and **Extra Large 18"**. The range of specialty pies is vast and creative, featuring unique options like **Marsala**, **Lasagna**, **Penne Vodka**, **Chicken Parm**, and even **Salad** and **Potato & Bacon** pizzas, ensuring there is a style and topping combination for every taste. Beyond pizza, the cafe serves a full array of Italian **Dinners**, **Pasta Dishes**, and hearty **Wedges** (subs), confirming its identity as a full-service **Italian restaurant**.

While the restaurant aims for quality, it is important for potential patrons to note that occasional customer feedback has pointed out inconsistencies. A few reviews mention issues with the food being overly salty or the appearance of pizza-by-the-slice not meeting expectations during busy times. However, for a local business with a comprehensive menu and full service capabilities, it remains a heavily trafficked establishment popular for its convenience and broad selection, catering well to large **Groups** and even **Tourists** passing through the area.

Gaetano Pizza & Cafe is strategically located at **100 Independent Way, Brewster, NY 10509, USA**, making it easily accessible from major routes in Putnam County. Its position ensures convenience for both local residents and individuals traveling nearby, with excellent infrastructure to support all visitors.

The restaurant provides outstanding accessibility features, ensuring comfort for every guest:

• **Parking:** Ample parking is available, including a **Free parking lot**, **On-site parking**, and complimentary **Free street parking**.
• **Wheelchair Accessibility:** The facility is fully equipped with a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, dedicated **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, a **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating**.
• **Crowd:** The atmosphere is **Casual**, perfect for accommodating a wide array of customers from **Groups** of friends to local families and **Tourists**.

Gaetano Pizza & Cafe offers a multitude of service options, prioritizing customer convenience whether dining in or carrying out their Italian feast:

• **Delivery & Takeout:** Offers standard **Delivery** service, along with efficient **Takeout** and the added convenience of **Curbside pickup** and **No-contact delivery**.
• **Dine-in & Seating:** Provides **Dine-in** service with comfortable **Seating** and full **Table service** for a relaxed meal.
• **Meals Served:** Available for **Lunch** and **Dinner**, with a wide variety of meal types that are perfect for a **Quick bite** or a more substantial dining experience.
• **Catering:** Offers full **Catering** services, making it a reliable partner for local events, parties, and business meetings in the New York region.
• **Family-Friendly Amenities:** The restaurant is **Good for kids**, providing a dedicated **Kids' menu** with favorites like **Spaghetti With Meatball** and **Chicken Fingers & Fries**, along with necessary **High chairs**.
• **Payments:** Accepts diverse payment methods, including **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and modern **NFC mobile payments**.

What distinguishes Gaetano Pizza & Cafe is its extensive menu variety that covers every facet of classic Italian-American cuisine, and its specialized offerings:

• **Creative Specialty Pizzas:** The menu features an exceptional range of specialty pies like the popular **Penne Vodka**, **Lasagna**, and the spicy **Buffalo** chicken pizza, catering to adventurous tastes alongside traditional choices like **Margherita** and **White**.
• **Full Italian Dinners:** Beyond pizza, the "Dinners" section offers complete entrees such as **Chicken Parmigiana**, **Chicken Francese**, **Veal Marsala**, and **Shrimp Scampi**, served as satisfying, classic Italian-American portions.
• **Comprehensive Kids' Menu:** A dedicated menu simplifies ordering for younger patrons, ensuring child-friendly, familiar dishes like **Ravioli** (5) and **Baked Ziti With Ricotta**.
• **Substantial Appetizers and Sides:** The "Appetizers" and "Rolls" menus offer popular snacks and small meals, including **Fried Calamari**, **Chicken Wings (8)**, and various stuffed rolls like the **Chicken Roll** and **Stromboli**.
• **Diverse Lunch Options:** The **Wedges** and **Wraps** menus provide excellent lunch choices, featuring heroes like the **Italian Combo**, **Grilled Chicken With Broccoli Rabe**, and a fiery **Blazing Buffalo** option in both sandwich and wrap form.
• **Dietary Accommodation:** Offers clear **Vegetarian options** across its menu, including the **Veggie** pizza, **Garden Veggie** pizza, and classic pasta dishes without meat.
• **Pizza by the Slice:** An ideal option for a fast, inexpensive **Solo dining** or **Quick bite**, with choices for **Regular**, **Sicilian**, and **Special** slices.

For placing an order, booking catering, or making any inquiries, please contact Gaetano Pizza & Cafe using the details below:

Address: **100 Independent Way, Brewster, NY 10509, USA**

Phone: **(845) 278-9500** (also listed as **+1 845-278-9500**)

When visiting Gaetano Pizza & Cafe in Brewster, NY, the best choice for a local New York diner is to explore the inventive specialty pizzas and the hearty, traditional Italian **Dinners**. While the classic **Cheese** pizza is available in four sizes, the restaurant truly shines with its unique pies, such as the **Penne Vodka** pizza or the decadent **Chicken Parm** pizza, which offer a full-meal experience in a pizza format. These options reflect the creativity and versatility of a great local Italian spot.

For those looking for a full, sit-down Italian meal, choosing an item from the "Dinners" menu, like the **Chicken Francese** or the **Veal Parmigiana**, provides excellent value and authentic **Comfort food**. The availability of every service option imaginable—from **Curbside pickup** to comprehensive **Catering**—makes Gaetano Pizza & Cafe a reliably convenient destination. Whether you’re ordering a **Combo** pizza for a party, a **Baked Ziti** dinner for a family night, or just grabbing a **Meat Lovers** slice for lunch, its wide selection and customer-focused services solidify its position as an essential local Italian and pizza spot in the Brewster area.

Gaetano Pizza & Cafe

100 Independent Way, Brewster, NY 10509, USA