Grilled Cheese Society Introduce
For those moments when only the ultimate comfort food will suffice, Grilled Cheese Society in Yonkers, NY, offers a tempting selection focused on elevating the classic grilled cheese sandwich. Operating as a restaurant, grill, and specialized sandwich shop, the establishment aims to deliver a delicious and modern take on the quintessential ooey-gooey, toasty, cheesy delight. While the core concept is straightforward—cheese the day, as their motto suggests—the menu expands to include creative pairings and hearty sides that cater to a wide audience across New York.
The society specializes in crafting extra-indulgent grilled cheese creations that serve as an ideal quick bite for lunch or a satisfying casual dinner. The menu is structured around a series of signature sandwiches, each a unique combination of cheeses, meats, and special sauces. These offerings are complemented by essential comfort food sides and a classic pairing: creamy tomato soup. The atmosphere is designed to be casual, making it a fitting stop for solo diners, families with children, or anyone seeking a straightforward, gratifying meal without the fuss of formal dining.
It is important for potential patrons to note that the service model, which includes extensive delivery options, suggests a structure focused on convenience and reach throughout the New York area. This model, often utilizing a ghost kitchen or virtual setup, emphasizes fast order fulfillment and the availability of their food via popular delivery platforms. While the goal is to provide a flavorful and enjoyable meal, potential customers should be aware that the overall quality can be inconsistent, as reflected in varied customer feedback, which ranges from reports of tasty, satisfying meals to concerns regarding food preparation consistency, such as the quality of fries and bacon.
The Grilled Cheese Society in Yonkers is conveniently located to serve the Westchester community and surrounding boroughs. The main address for operations is:
- Address: 28 Bashford St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Situated in Yonkers, the location is accessible for both local residents and those passing through the area. As the business model is heavily focused on delivery and takeout, accessibility is defined by the ease of ordering and receiving food. However, for those looking for a traditional dine-in experience, that option is available. The focus on a casual setting and its appeal to children make it an easy choice for family outings or a low-key meal. The centralized location in Yonkers supports their ability to offer multiple reliable service options across the region.
The Grilled Cheese Society offers a robust range of services tailored for maximum customer convenience, reflecting the demands of the fast-paced New York lifestyle.
- Dine-in: Provides a casual and simple atmosphere for customers who prefer to enjoy their meal on-site.
- Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Extensive delivery options, including a no-contact service for safety and convenience, ensuring their comfort food can be enjoyed at home.
- Takeout: Efficient service for picking up orders, ideal for quick meals on the go.
- Catering: While not explicitly listed on all public menus, the nature of the sandwich offerings makes them suitable for group orders, lunch meetings, or casual event catering.
- Broad Menu Times: The menu is available for both lunch and dinner, making it a flexible option for mid-day breaks or evening comfort meals.
- Payment Options: Accepts both Credit Cards and Debit Cards for smooth and straightforward transactions.
The menu at Grilled Cheese Society goes beyond the simple slice of melted cheese, offering creative and indulgent takes on the classic sandwich.
- Creative Grilled Cheese Menu: Features unique specialty sandwiches like 'The Regular' (two fried eggs, bacon, American cheese, tomato & Society Sauce) and 'The Special' (Chorizo, queso fresco, pepper jack cheese, roasted jalapeños, and red peppers mix).
- The Blue Plate Special Combo: A highly popular and complete meal deal which typically includes 'The Usual' (classic American cheese grilled cheese), a cup of Creamy Tomato Soup, a Homestyle Chocolate Chip Cookie, and a choice of drink.
- Choice of Bread: Customers can customize their grilled cheese with a choice of Wheat or White bread. Gluten-Free options may also be available, depending on the current menu.
- Classic Side Offerings: Provides essential comfort food accompaniments like Classic Fries, Spicy Fries (with fiery ghost pepper seasoning), Mac & Cheese, and Toasty Mac Bites.
- Good for Kids: The simple, appealing nature of the food, especially the classic 'The Usual' and sides like fries, makes the restaurant a good choice for children.
- Creamy Tomato Soup: Offers a classic, warm, and comforting side, which is the perfect traditional pairing for any grilled cheese sandwich.
For placing orders, checking on delivery status, or for any business inquiries regarding the Yonkers location, please use the following contact details:
- Address: 28 Bashford St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
- Phone: (888) 663-7270 (or +1 888-663-7270)
For those in the New York region looking for a reliable source of simple, yet satisfying comfort food, Grilled Cheese Society is a convenient option. Given the nature of the menu, the best value and experience often comes from selecting the complete package.
The absolute best choice for a first-time visitor is The Blue Plate Special Combo. This combines the straightforward, classic appeal of 'The Usual' grilled cheese with the traditional companion, the Creamy Tomato Soup, plus a dessert and drink. It provides a full, nostalgic meal experience at a set price point. For those with a more adventurous palate, 'The Regular' or 'The Special' are worth trying, as they showcase the more creative, loaded sandwich options available. Finally, for an added kick, the Spicy Fries, dusted with a fiery ghost pepper seasoning, offer a flavorful alternative to the classic side. The deli serves a specific niche, and when patrons choose the most popular, core items, they are most likely to find the satisfying comfort they are seeking from a dedicated grilled cheese establishment.
Grilled Cheese Society Services
Grilled Cheese
Choice of bread: Wheat, White.
- The Usual $9.00
The classic- American cheese on white bread.
- The Regular $11.00
2 fried eggs, bacon, American cheese, tomato and Society sauce on white bread.
Soup
- Creamy Tomato $5.00
Combo
Choice of bread: Wheat, White. Choice of Drink: Bottled Water, Cola, Lemon Lime Soda, Lemonade.
- The Blue Plate Special $17.00
The Usual served with a cup of creamy tomato soup, a chocolate chip cookie and choice of drink.
Sides
- Classic Fries $4.00
- Spicy Fries $5.00
Fries with fiery ghost pepper seasoning.
Dessert
- Homestyle Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.50
Drinks
- Bottled Water $3.00
- Cola $3.00
- Lemon Lime Soda $3.00
Grilled Cheese Society Details
Service options
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
Atmosphere
- Casual
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Grilled Cheese Society Photos



Grilled Cheese Society Location
Grilled Cheese Society
28 Bashford St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Grilled Cheese Society Reviews
This place is a pretty restaurant but the food is just awful. Fries were raw, pizza tasted like old burned pizza, and the bacon was burned too. They need to improve a lot.
April 30 · Angee XiomyCheese sandwich society. 🤷♀️
September 20 · Thomas Smith
More restaurants near me
Lost Borough Ice Cream4.0 (218 reviews)1 Larkin Plz, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Singa's Famous Pizza & Grill Restaurant4.0 (618 reviews)41 Dock St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Dock Street Gourmet Deli4.0 (153 reviews)31 Dock St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Mon Amour Coffee & Wine Yonkers4.0 (58 reviews)40 Nepperhan St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Starbucks3.0 (77 reviews)16 Nepperhan St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
The Wedge Sandwich Shop4.0 (248 reviews)28 Warburton Ave, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Off the Hook of Yonkers4.0 (244 reviews)47 N Broadway, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Andiamo4.0 (9 reviews)61 Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Khangri Japanese sushi4.0 (636 reviews)22 Warburton Ave, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Zuppa4.0 (590 reviews)59 Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
La Bella Havana4.0 (771 reviews)35 Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Guapo Mexican and Cuban Cuisine4.0 (2250 reviews)10 Warburton Ave, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Lovely Day4.0 (478 reviews)
El Rumbero Bar - Restaurant3.0 (324 reviews)
Fansway Teriyaki Kitchen4.0 (302 reviews)
Dunkin'3.0 (309 reviews)
Casa Louie4.0 (149 reviews)
Brock's Deli4.0 (121 reviews)Top restaurants Searches
Trending Dining Insights Posts
Discovering French Restaurants That Offer Seasonal and Locally Sourced Menus
How Steak Houses Are Reinventing Classic Cuts With Modern Techniques
Best Sushi Restaurants for Every Budget and Taste: A Complete Guide
How Coffee Shops Are Encouraging Community Engagement Through Events
How Breakfast Restaurants Are Offering Creative and Healthy Menu Options
How Seafood Restaurants Are Combining Traditional Recipes With Contemporary Style
