Dine Droop
Dine DroopDining Insightsrestaurants near me
ConnecticutNew JerseyNew York

Dine Drooprestaurants near meNew YorkNassau CountyMerrickrestaurants in Jerusalem AvenueGuy Anthony's
Guy Anthony's ico

Guy Anthony's
- 2208 Jerusalem Ave, Merrick, NY 11566

Italian restaurant ★4.0 (41)·$30–50

2208 Jerusalem Ave, Merrick, NY 11566, USA

4.0
Thank you to Guy Anthony's for providing a wonderful party experience for my daughter's family filled engagement party. They were so accommodating in allowing me to drop off items the night before which was so helpful. When I arrived the next day, some of my items were already set up for me! L A and staff were attentive and helpful. The food was delicious and our guests left full and happy. They displayed our cake beautifully on a separate table without me having to ask to do anything. The flow of the party was perfect. We plan to do another party there in the future! - Meri Schneider
Guy Anthony's Overview Intro Menu Detail Photos Location Reviews
$30–50 per person Reported by 41 people$20–30$30–50$50–100

Guy Anthony's Introduce

For residents of **New York** and Long Island searching for an authentic, warm, and memorable Italian dining experience, **Guy Anthony's** stands out as a true local gem in **Merrick, NY**. This is more than just a place to eat; it’s a destination where the flavors of Italy meet the comfort of a neighborhood eatery. Whether you're planning a romantic dinner, a celebratory event, or just craving a plate of perfectly prepared pasta, Guy Anthony's offers a welcoming setting and a diverse menu to satisfy every craving. Known for its dedication to excellent food and attentive service, it's become a beloved spot in the community.

The culinary philosophy here centers on using quality ingredients to craft both time-honored Italian classics and exciting, contemporary dishes. The extensive menu ranges from tempting appetizers and fresh salads to hearty entrees, ensuring there is a delicious option for everyone in your party. Locals appreciate the effort Guy Anthony's makes to provide a comprehensive dining experience, blending a lively atmosphere with truly exceptional cuisine.


Location and Accessibility

Guy Anthony's Italian Restaurant is conveniently located in Merrick, Long Island, making it an accessible spot for many New Yorkers looking to enjoy fine dining without the hassle of the city. The physical address is **2208 Jerusalem Ave, Merrick, NY 11566**.

The location is designed with guest convenience in mind. When planning your visit, you'll be happy to know that **parking is easy** with both a **free parking lot** and **free street parking** available, eliminating one of the common stresses of dining out in the New York area. Furthermore, the establishment demonstrates a commitment to welcoming all patrons, offering **wheelchair accessible parking lot** and **wheelchair accessible seating**, ensuring a comfortable experience for guests with mobility needs.


Services Offered

Guy Anthony's provides a variety of services to accommodate different needs and dining preferences for the New York community, from a casual weeknight meal to large-scale event catering. Their focus is on flexibility and high-quality delivery across all offerings.

  • **Dine-in:** Enjoy the full restaurant experience in a casual, cozy, and romantic atmosphere, perfect for groups, couples, or even solo dining.
  • **Takeout:** Perfect for busy New Yorkers, this service allows you to enjoy the full menu from the comfort of your home or office.
  • **Private Events & Catering:** As evidenced by enthusiastic customer reviews, Guy Anthony's excels at hosting and catering events, offering detailed services for engagement parties, birthdays, and other family gatherings. Their diverse hors d'oeuvres, barbeque, and upscale sit-down menus show a capacity for handling a wide range of event styles and sizes.
  • **Extensive Menu Options:** The offerings are impressively broad, including Halal food options and small plates, catering to diverse dietary needs and preferences. Specialized menus like the "Lite Cuisine" offer great choices for those looking for options under 450 calories.
  • **All-Day Dining:** The restaurant provides dining options that cover **Breakfast** and **Brunch**, in addition to their popular **Lunch** and **Dinner** services.

Features / Highlights

The experience at Guy Anthony's is elevated by several standout features that distinguish it from other Italian dining spots in the region. They focus on creating an environment that is both engaging and comfortable, with a strong emphasis on service and quality.

  • **Exceptional Ambiance:** The atmosphere is described as **Casual, Cozy, and Romantic**, making it suitable for any occasion, whether it’s a fun group dinner or an intimate date night.
  • **Live Music:** A significant draw is the presence of **live music**, which adds a lively and entertaining backdrop to your dining experience.
  • **Fast and Attentive Service:** Customers frequently highlight the **fast service** and the attentive, helpful nature of the staff, ensuring a smooth and enjoyable meal.
  • **Great Cocktails and Bar Onsite:** The restaurant is known for its **great cocktails**, with a **bar onsite** providing a perfect spot to relax before or after your meal.
  • **Serves Local Specialty:** While primarily Italian, the menu also includes items that appeal to local tastes, such as the American Cuisine section featuring an $8 Oz. Jumbo Hamburger and Philly Cheese Steak, showcasing a commitment to a broad appeal.
  • **Authentic Brick Oven Appetizers:** A specialty of the house includes the **Brick Oven Style Appetizers** with offerings like Pizza Marguerita, Quattro Formaggi, and Pizza Pollo, baked to perfection.

Contact Information

For reservations, takeout orders, or inquiries about catering and events, New York area residents can easily reach Guy Anthony's using the following contact details:

Address: **2208 Jerusalem Ave, Merrick, NY 11566**

Phone: **(516) 221-5555** (or mobile: **+1 516-221-5555**)

Since the restaurant is popular and prides itself on its ability to host groups and events, it's worth noting that **reservations are required**, particularly if you are planning to dine during peak hours or with a larger party. Planning ahead will ensure the best possible experience.


What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Guy Anthony's means selecting a reliable and high-quality Italian dining experience close to home for New York residents. What truly makes this establishment stand out is the masterful blend of tradition, variety, and personalized service. The menu's depth is a compelling reason to visit, offering everything from fresh pasta dishes with your choice of eight classic sauces (including Pesto, Vodka Sauce, and Marinara) to sophisticated entrees. Imagine savoring the **Seafood Fra Diavolo Over Linguine** or the classic **Fresh Baked Lasagna**, all prepared with a dedication to authentic Italian flavors.

Beyond the a la carte menu, the restaurant's renowned catering and party services are a significant draw. The ability to provide full-service engagement parties, complete with beautiful setup and delicious food, as highlighted in glowing customer feedback, positions Guy Anthony's as a top choice for event planning on Long Island. They handle all the details, from the antipasto station to the dessert display, allowing hosts to relax and enjoy their guests.

Finally, the overall atmosphere and attention to detail—from the excellent cocktails and live music to the convenience of free parking and accessible seating—create a full-circle experience that is both **friendly and professional**. Whether you are dining solo, celebrating with a group, or planning your next major event, Guy Anthony's in Merrick provides a consistently high standard of food and hospitality that New York customers can depend on.

Guy Anthony's Menu

  • Appetizers

  • Shrimp Cocktail $10.95
  • Marinated Grilled Vegetables $8.95

    with roasted peppers

  • Stuffed Portobello Mushroom $8.95
  • Hot Antipasto $12.95
  • Fried Zucchini Sticks $5.50

    with marinara sauce

  • Fried Mozzarella Sticks $6.50

    with marinara sauce

  • Fried Calamari $8.95
  • Baked Whole Clams Oreganata $7.95

    1/2 dozen

  • Brick Oven Style Appetizers

  • Four Cheese Calzone $8.95
  • Pizza Pollo $11.95
  • Quattro Formaggi $10.95
  • Pizza Pescatore $14.95
  • Pizza Primavera $10.95
  • Pizza Marguerita $10.95
  • Greek Pizza $10.95
  • Fresh Pasta and Sauces

    Your Choice of Sauces: Pesto, Marinara, Bolognese, Oil & Garlic, Fra Diavolo, Alfredo, Vodka Sauce, Filetto Di Pommodo

  • Linguine $14.95
  • Ravioli $16.95
  • Cheese Tortellini $16.95
  • Cavatelli $15.50
  • Penne $14.95
  • Egg Fettuccine $14.95
  • Angel Hair $14.50
  • Gnocchi $15.50
  • Fresh Salads

  • Cold Antipasto Salad $12.50
  • Country Salad $8.95
  • Bruschetta Boccoccino Salad $8.50
  • Tossed Salad $5.50
  • Sliced Tomato $8.95

    with mozzarella and proscuitto

  • Greek Salad $8.95
  • Three Leaf Caesar Salad $7.50
  • Grilled Chicken $18.95

    with caesar salad

  • Pesto Marinated Grilled Chicken and Vegetables $18.95
  • Entree Suggestions

  • Marinated Skirt Steak $22.95

    with steak fries

  • Salmon Bruscetta Over Angel Hair Pasta $20.95

    with broccoli

  • Penne Rustica $17.95
  • Seafood Fra Diavolo Over Linguine $23.95
  • Cannelloni $18.95
  • Seafood Ravioli $21.95

    with grilled shrimp

  • Fresh Baked Lasagna $17.95

    with chicken ragout

  • Pasta Primavera $16.95
  • Linguine $18.95

    with red or white clam sauce

  • Fried Or Sauteed Calamari $18.95

    with linguine

  • Eggplant Rollatine $17.95

    with spinach and three cheeses

  • Eggplant Parmigiana $17.95

    with linguine

  • Shrimp, Veal, and Chicken Entrees

    Served with Linguine Or Penne (Substitute Vegetables At $2.00 Extra

  • Bruschetta: Breaded

    with chopped marinated tomatoes

  • Piquante

    sauteed in lemon butter, red onion, capers, red crushed pepper

  • Sorrentino

    sauteed in eggplant marsala sauce with mozzarella & proscuitto

  • Francaise

    sauteed in an egg batter with lemon butter and wine

  • Picatta

    sauteed in lemon butter and wine sauce

  • Parmigiana

    with tomato sauce and mozzarella

  • Marsala

    brown sauce with marsala wine and mushrooms

  • American Cuisine

  • Philly Cheese Steak $12.95

    with fries

  • 8 Oz. Jumbo Hamburger $9.95

    with fries

  • 8 Oz. Jumbo Cheeseburger $10.95

    with fries

  • Hot & Spicy Wings $10.95

    with bleu cheese and celery

  • Lite Cuisine

    Under 450 Calories

  • Grilled Chicken Sausage Florentine $17.95
  • Baked Eggplant Parmigiana $17.95
  • Pasta Primavera Over Linguine $16.95
  • Grilled Chicken Bruschetta Over Tossed Greens $18.95
  • Grilled Raspberry Chicken Over Tossed Greens $18.95
  • Grilled Veal $19.95

    with broccoli

  • Grilled Chicken Vegetable Wrap $14.95

    with mescaline greens

  • Side Orders

  • Sauteed Spinach $6.95
  • Sauteed Broccoli $5.95
  • Sausage Or Meatballs $5.95
  • French Fries $3.50
  • Assorted Vegetables $4.95
  • Garlic Bread $2.95
  • Garlic Bread $3.95

    with mozzarella

  • Hors D'oeuvres Menus - Complete Hors D'oeuvres Menu

  • Crudite Station

    with international cheeses & fresh fruits

  • Fresh Vegetable Antipasto Station

    garlic rounds with assortment of delectables such as roasted garlic-artichoke spread, marinated grilled vegetables, brie with sundried tomatoes, fresh mozzarella with proscuitto, bruschetta pomodoro with basil and fresh baked focaccia

  • Pasta Station

    homemade veal-stuffed canneloni and tortellini in vodka sauce

  • Sea Scallops Wrapped In Bacon
  • Sweet & Sour Meatballs
  • Stuffed Mushroom Caps Oreganata
  • Miniature Beef Wellingtons
  • Sesame Chicken Tenders

    with honey mustard & pineapple

  • Sausage & Spinach Wheels

    with fresh romano cheese

  • Carved Smoked Turkey & Roundeye of Beef
  • Pate and Chilled Salmon

    with whole grain mustard & grain breads

  • Sushi & Sashimi
  • Assorted Cakes & Butter Cookies

    midnight mousse cake, chocolate brownie cheesecake, hazelnut white mousse cake

  • Coffee, Tea and Decaf
  • Hors D'oeuvres Menus - Selected Hors D'oeuvres Menu

  • Assorted International Cheeses & Fresh Fruit
  • Antipasto Station

    fresh mozzarella, bruschetta, soprasatta, provolone, grilled vegetables, marinated mushrooms, crostini, assorted peppers, sundried tomatoes, proscuitto, assorted fresh baked focaccia

  • Pasta Station

    with penne & bowtie with your choice of vodka sauce or bolognese sauce

  • Miniature Swedish Meatballs
  • Sesame Chicken Tenders
  • Crudite Platter

    with creamy herb dip

  • Teriyaki Beef Kabobs
  • Fresh Baked Spinach Breads & Sausage Wheels
  • Miniature Quiche
  • Stuffed Mushroom Caps

    with crabmeat

  • Miniature Crab Cakes

    with tartar sauce

  • Assorted Dessert Station

    miniature cannoli, miniature eclairs, assorted butter cookies, miniature mousse cups, miniature cheesecake tartlets with fresh fruit

  • 100% Colombian Coffee and Assorted Teas
  • Hors D'oeuvres Menus - Limited Cold Hors D'oeuvres Menu

  • Assorted International Cheeses & Fresh Fruit

    served with carr's water bisquits

  • Fresh Crispy Crudite Platters
  • Italian Canape Platters

    featuring crostini with bruschetta, artichoke, roasted pepper spread, and marinated grilled vegetables

  • Assorted Pate Platter

    with mushroom cognac, veal and sausage, and three-vegetable pate

  • Assorted Smoked Fish Sampler

    to include smoked salmon and smoked trout with black bread and dijon horseradish sauce

  • Sliced Shrimp Over Cucumber with Fresh Dill

    with a dollop of our tangy cocktail sauce

  • Barbeque Fun - the Basic Bbq Menu

    $16.95 Per Guest Soda, Ice Tea and Lemonade Available At $3.50 Per Guest

  • Hotdogs, Hamburgers & Cheeseburgers
  • Sausage & Peppers
  • Bbq Chicken In Our Zesty Sauce /Or Grilled Chicken Breast

    with bruschetta over greens corn on the cob

  • California Potato Salad

    with fresh dill /or fusilli pasta salad with broccoli & olives

  • Tomato Cucumber Salad

    with italian herbs

  • Watermelon
  • Barbeque Fun - the Full Bbq Menu

    $22.95 Per Guest (25 - 49 Guests) $20.95 Per Guest (50 Or More Guests) Soda, Ice Tea and Lemonade Available At $3.50 Per Guest

  • Hotdogs, Hamburgers & Cheeseburgers
  • Marinated Chicken Breast

    with bruscetta over mescaline greens

  • Bbq Chicken & Ribs
  • Marinated Teriyaki Lamb
  • Marinated Steak
  • Corn On the Cob
  • Marinated Grilled Vegetables

    with portobello mushrooms

  • Fusilli Pasta Salad

    with sundried tomato & olive

  • New Potato Salad

    with fresh dill

  • Garden Tomato Cucumber Salad
  • Holiday Time - Holiday Entrees

  • Sliced Roast Turkey

    with stuffing & gravy

  • Whole Roast Turkey

    with sausage stuffing & gravy

  • Roast Stuffed Chicken

    with sausage and creamy tarragon and sun dried tomatoes

  • Roast White Pork Loin Bordelaise

    with mushroom & tomato demi-glaze

  • Seafood Crepes

    with scallops, crab and shrimp

  • Seafood Ravioli In a Vodka Sauce
  • Cultivated Mussels

    over orzo cooked in a light marinara sauce

  • Individual Beef Wellington In Puff Pastry
  • Beef Roulade

    with vegetables and beef stuffing in a port wine sauce

  • Traditional Pot Roast

    with vegetables & potatoes

  • Sauerbraten

    marinated beef) in a savory gravy with ginger snaps

  • Barbeque Fun - the Upscale Bbq Menu

    $27.00 Per Guest (25 - 49 Guests) $25.00 Per Guest (50 Or More Guests) Includes Soda, Ice Tea & Lemonade

  • Hotdogs, Hamburgers & Cheeseburgers
  • Pesto Marinated Chicken Breast Bruscetta Over Mescaline Greens
  • Bbq Marinated Chicken In Our Zesty Sauce
  • Marinated Teriyaki Steak
  • Steamed Mussels & Clams
  • Fresh Shucked Clams

    with cocktail sauce

  • Corn On the Cob
  • California Potato Salad
  • Fusilli Pasta Salad

    with sundried tomato & olive

  • Garden Tomato Cucumber Salad
  • Holiday Time - Holiday Sides

  • Apple Sausage Stuffing
  • Traditional Sausage Stuffing
  • Traditional Mashed Potatoes
  • Smashed New Potatoes

    with glazed onions

  • Mashed Parlied Yellow Turnips
  • Gratin Sweet Potatoes

    with honey & orange

  • Whole Candied Sweet Potatoes
  • Long Grain and Wild Rice
  • Fresh Cranberry and Orange Relish
  • Fresh Cranberry Sauce
  • Steamed Broccoli

    with baby carrots

  • Crispy Potato Pancakes
  • Stewed Red Cabbage

    with cranberry & apple

  • Steamed Artichokes

    with romano & bread crumbs

  • Barbeque Fun - the Upscale Bbq Menu - Dessert

    $27.00 Per Guest (25 - 49 Guests) $25.00 Per Guest (50 Or More Guests) Includes Soda, Ice Tea & Lemonade

  • Homemade Apple Cobbler
  • Italian Ices
  • Watermelon
  • Upscale Menus - Selected Sitdown Dinner

  • Butlered Hors D'oeuvres

    shrimp cocktail, baby lamb chops, baby spinach pinwheels, bruscetta over crostini, mushroom tart in phyllo cup

  • Appetizers

    figs wrapped with proscuitto or beef carpaccio with asparagus garni

  • Pasta

    squid ink pasta with lump crabmeat or lobster ravioli beurre blanc

  • Salad

    mescaline greens with gorgonzola, mandarin oranges and raisins

  • Entree Selections

    medallions of beef with portobello mushrooms, veal picatta, steamed seabass in a ginger leek broth with cockels

  • Dessert

    assorted italian pastries, assorted gourmet cakes, fresh fruit platters, brewed 100% columbian coffee, herbal teas and espresso

  • Upscale Menus - Selected Sitdown Dinner - Menu 1

    $45.00 Per Guest Minimum of 50 Guests

  • Cocktail Hour

    assorted seasonal fruits and crudite with cracked pepper dip and baby spinach dip and international cheeses such as smoked gouda, havarti, sage bleu and new york cheddar, smoked chicken quesadilla with cilantro cream salsa, miniature basil and romaro infused meatballs in a light bechemel with a touch of veal demi, beef negamaki with asparagus and hoisen sauce, crab cocktail canope over carved cucumber with fresh dill

  • Talian Hors D'oeuvres Station

    penne ala vodka homemade canneloni, antipasto display with marinated grilled vegetables, crostini with fresh mozzarella and sundried tomatoes, thin sliced prosciutto, imported provolone and soprasatta with assorted tuscan olives and marinated mushrooms and artichoke hearts with assorted focaccia breads

  • Buffet

    steamed chilean sea bass with leeks, tomato and hearts of celery, wild mushroom crepes with shitake, portabello and porcini mushrooms, marinated filet mignon carved at the buffet, endive, radicchio and redleaf salad with crumbled gorgonzola and balsamic vinaigrette, assorted julienne vegetables in basil butter, fresh assorted baggets and sweet butter

  • Dessert

    assorted italian pastries, gourmet cakes and fresh fruits, brewed 100% columbian coffee, decaf and assorted teas

  • Upscale Menus - Selected Sitdown Dinner - Menu 2

    $45.00 Per Guest Minimum of 50 Guests

  • Cocktail Hour

    california rolls (crab, shrimp, avocado and cucumber), an endive boat with spicy tuna tarter, miniature eggplant canope with goat cheese in phyllo cup, pannini squairs with a roasted garlic and spinach stuffing, miniature beef wellingtons with a mushroom duxel, miniature maryland lump crab cake with a pesto aioli

  • Mexican Hors D'oeuvres Station

    with fresh salsa, tortilla chips, guacamole, sour cream, three bean chili nachos, spicy chicken taquitos, beef empanadas with assorted cheese quesadilla and crudite

  • Buffet

    salmon bruschetta w/ fresh basil and marinated garden tomatoes with a touch of herb breadcrumbs, wild mushroom ravioli in a sherry mushroom sauce, seared glased duck breasts with orange, ginger and gran marnier, long grain and wild rice, medley of roasted carrots, squash and fennel with fresh thyme, mescaline country salad with walnuts, honey mustard, craisins, hierloom cherry tomatoes and gorgonzola, assorted focaccia breads

  • Dessert

    assorted pastries, assorted gourmet cakes and assorted fresh fruits and berries, brewed 100% columbian coffee, decaf and assorted teas

  • Upscale Menus - Selected Sitdown Dinner - Menu 3

    $40.00 Per Guest Minimum of 50 Guests

  • Cocktail Hour

    sliced ahi tuna with thai sauce over sliced cucumber, shrimp wrapped in bacon in our smokin bbq sauce, portobello mushroom tartlets with a touch of romano cheese, risotto croquetts with saffron and fontina cheese, international cheeses with bakes brie en croute with apricot, smoked gouda, new york cheddar, jarlsburg swiss with pepperoni and water biscuits, pasta station to include: bowtie bolognese or penne carbona with assorted focaccia breads

  • Buffet

    sliced marinated black angus skirt steak, chicken breast florentine with toasted pine nust, prosciutto and spinach, caramelized onion, red bliss smashed potatoes, fresh swiss chard with extra virgin olive oil and roasted garlic, classic ceasar salad, assorted semolina rolls and poppy rolls

  • Dessert

    hocolate mousse cake and assorted butter cookies, fresh brewed 100% columbian coffee, decaf and assorted teas

  • Upscale Menus - Selected Sitdown Dinner - Menu 4

    $40.00 Per Guest Minimum of 50 Guests

  • Cocktail Hour

    asparagus in herbed puff pastry parmesan with prosciutto and roasted pepper fresh baked sausage and spinach wheels with roasted garlic and xvoo teriyaki glazed beef kabobs, crudite baskets with creamy pepper and garlic dipbaked brie with mango chutney, miniature potato, zucchini pancakes with sour cream and fresh chives

  • Buffet

    baked stuffed tilapia with crabmeat and roasted vegetable stuffing, herb encrusted pork loin with apple jack tarragon sauce, chicken risotto with a melange of mushrooms and baby peas, asiago salad with hearts of romaine and grape tomatoes with our buttermilk dressing, assorted julienne vegetables in basil butter, fresh assorted breads and sweet butter

  • Dessert

    elected fresh fruits and berries, miniature cannolis, eclairs and napoleans, fresh brewed 100% columbian coffee, decaf and assorted teas

  • Upscale Menus - Selected Sitdown Dinner - Menu 5

    $40.00 Per Guest Minimum of 50 Guests

  • Cocktail Hour

    baked miniature coctail franks with honey mustard dipping sauce, classic melon wrapped in proscuitto, miniature vegetable napoleans with fresh mozzarella, beef satay with pineapple and red bell pepper, endive boats with crabmeat and cocktail sauce

  • Buffet

    mediteranean ravioli with spinach, black sicilian olives, feta cheese in a pommodoro sauce, grilled sesame chicken with snow peas and broccoli and asian orange ginger sauce, red bliss potatoes with sundried tomatoes and roasted garlic, sauted filet of sole picatta (lemon, butter, white wine), chopped garden salad with cucumber, tomato, bermuda onion, hearts of palm and baby carrots in a lemon poppey vinagrette, assorted french bread and semolina baggets with sweet butter

  • Dessert

    fresh brewed 100% columbian coffee, decaf and assorted teas, roasted pears trifle with assorted berries and grapes assorted miniature cheesecake

  • Upscale Menus - Selected Sitdown Dinner - Menu 6

    $35.00 Per Guest Minimum of 50 Guests

  • Cocktail Hour

    risotto croquettes with saffron and fontina cheese, steamed chinese dumplings with hoisen sauce, crabmeat roll with wasabi dipping sauce, bruschetta over crostini with fresh mozzarella, pannini squares with mushroom leak duxel and spinach

  • Buffet

    saute chicken brest with balsamic fig reduction, eggplant rollatine with three cheeses and a tomato basil sauce, rigatoni with creamy bolognese sauce, grilled vegetables with saute sage leaves and xvoo, tri color salad with shaved romano cheese

  • Dessert

    chocolate torte with rasberry sauce and selected fresh fruits, fresh brewed 100% columbian coffee, decaf and a selection of teas

  • Sandwich Menu - New Cocktail Sandwich Menu

    Choose From the Following Options

  • Miniature Cocktail Sandwich Platter $49.95

    served on our homemade poppy & sesame rolls displayed on a decorative platter platters can be picked up & served

  • Sandwich Wrap Platters $49.95

    served with a tasty thin dough wrap displayed on a decorative platter choice of 4 of the following: ham & swiss, roast beef with horseradish mayonnaise, shrimp & crabmeat salad, provolone & salami, pepperoni & cheddar, fresh roast turkey with honey mustard

  • Sandwich Menu - Party Hero Happiness

  • Marinated Grilled Vegetables $15.00

    with fresh mozzarella

  • Grilled Chicken $18.00

    with shredded romaine, red leaf & radicchio topped with our tasty bruschetta

  • Marinated Teriyaki Steak Hero $20.00

    with muenster cheese, grilled onions, and roasted peppers with a puree of bell pepper vinaigrette

  • Tray & More - Salads

    $2.00 Per Person for 20 Or More Guests, $3.00 Per Person for 19 Or Less Guests

  • Three Leaf Salad

    endive, romaine, red leaf with balsamic vinaigrette

  • Caesar Salad
  • Spinach Salad
  • Tomato-Cucumber Salad

    with virgin olive oil

  • Risotto Salad

    with carrots, walnuts and raisins

  • New Potato Salad

    with fresh dill and sour cream

  • Creamy Cole Slaw

    with dill seed

  • Tray & More - Additional Cold Salads

    $3.00 Per Person for 20 Or More Guests $4.00 Per Person for 19 Or Less Guests, a Combination of Bruschetta, Fresh Mozzarella, Peppers, Sundried Tomato, Grilled Eggplant, Roast Peppers, Artichoke Hearts, Provolone, Olives, Salami, and Cappicola

  • Fresh Fruit Salad

    with peach schnapps

  • Pasta Seafood Salad

    $.50 extra

  • Marinated Eggplant

    with roasted peppers

  • Pepper-Sundried Tomato Salad

    with four different peppers

  • Antipasto Salad

    $1.00 extra

  • Tray & More - Vegetables

    $2.00 Per Person - 20 Or More, $3.00 Per Person - 19 Or Less

  • Stir Fried

    with mixed veggies

  • Saute Escarole

    with oil & garlic

  • Assorted Julienned with Basil
  • Steamed Broccoli
  • Componata, Celery, Eggplant, Olive
  • String Beans Italiana
  • Chilled String Beans
  • Tray & More - Starches

    $2.00 Per Person - 20 Or More, $3.00 Per Person - 19 Or Less

  • Long Grain and Wild Rice
  • Spanish Style Rice
  • Boiled New Potatoes with Dill
  • Baked Stuffed Potatoes
  • Roasted Rosemary Potatoes
  • Potatoes O'brien
  • Potatoes Lyonnaise
  • Tray & More - Pastas

    Pasta Entrees Are Also Available with Other Pasta Substitutions Such As Gnocchi, Penne, Rigatoni, Cavatelli, Bowtie, Fusilli, Angel Hair, Linguini, and Fettuccine.

  • Fresh Baked Lasagna $90.00
  • Seafood Lasagna $95.00
  • Vegetarian Lasagna $80.00
  • Tortellini Bolognese $85.00
  • Baked Tortellini $85.00

    with three cheeses

  • Seafood Ravioli $100.00

    crab, shrimp stuffing w/ vodka sauce

  • Penne Pollo $90.00

    grilled chicken, brandy & asparagus

  • Baked Penne Rigate $75.00

    with bolognese

  • Rigatoni Rustica $80.00

    sundried tomato, broccoli & sausage

  • Rigatoni Ala Vodka Sauce $75.00
  • Penne Al Oilio $80.00

    with broccoli rabe (in season)

  • Fettuccini Carbonara $75.00

    peas, prosciutto, alfredo sauce

  • Oriental Seafood Stirfry $110.00

    with scallops & shrimp

  • Oriental Style Fettuccine $80.00

    w/chicken, snow peas & ginger

  • Wild Mushroom Ravioli $90.00

    sherry cream sauce

  • Baked Ravioli $80.00
  • Stuffed Shells $80.00
  • Baked Manicotti $80.00
  • Cannelloni $95.00

    stuffed with chicken, veal & spinach

  • Seafood Canneloni $110.00

    stuffed with shrimp, scallops, crab

  • Linguini $110.00

    with shrimp & scallop sauce

  • Linguini $95.00

    with red or white clam sauce

  • Pasta Primavera $80.00

    with oil & garlic

  • Tray & More - Chicken

  • Chicken Cacciatore $90.00

    with chicken parts, peas & mushrooms

  • Chicken Scarpariella $90.00

    chicken parts, oil, garlic & pepperoncini

  • Chicken Francaise $95.00
  • Chicken Lassere $95.00

    breast with lemon, brown sauce, artichokes & mushroom

  • Chicken Marsala $95.00
  • Chicken Rollatine $95.00

    breast with three cheeses, prosciutto & spinach w. madeira mushroom sauce

  • Creamy Tarragon Chicken $95.00

    with sundried tomatoes

  • Grilled Sesame Chicken $90.00

    with snow peas & broccoli

  • Chicken Parmesan $90.00
  • Stuffed Breast of Chicken $90.00

    with herbed vegetable stuffing

  • Tray & More - Veal

  • Veal Francaise $120.00
  • Veal Bolognese $120.00
  • Veal Marsala $120.00
  • Veal Rollatine $140.00

    stuffed with three cheeses, prosciutto & spinach topped with a madeira mushroom sauce

  • Veal Schnitzel $120.00

    topped with a sherry cream sauce with mushrooms & pimentos

  • Veal Parmesan $120.00
  • Tray & More - Seafood

  • Poached Sea Bass $140.00

    with ginger, celery and leek broth

  • Seafood Newburgh $140.00

    with scallop, shrimp, crab & white fish

  • Stuffed Sole Florentine Beurre Blanc $135.00
  • Baked Scrod Oreganata $120.00
  • Swordfish Or Tuna Steak Milanese

    topped with seasoned bread crumbs & chopped marinated tomato

  • Shrimp Parmesan, Shrimp Italiano, Shrimp Scampi $2.00
  • Seafood Provencale $150.00

    sole, shrimp, scallops & mussels poached in tomato wine broth with spinach & mushrooms

  • Poached Sole In Shrimp Sauce $135.00

    with snow peas & ginger

  • Tray & More - Beef, Carved Meats & Additional Entree Selections

  • Sausage and Peppers $85.00
  • Beef Roulades $100.00

    stuffed with celery & mushrooms in a port wine sauce

  • Beef Bourguignonne Or Stroganoff $100.00
  • Marinated Sliced Teriyaki Steak $110.00
  • Pot Roast $90.00

    with puree of vegetable gravy

  • New Zealand Rack of Lamb

    with rosemary

  • Marinated Leg of Lamb $110.00

    with mint sauce

  • Sliced Filet Mignon Marsala
  • Roast Prime Rib
  • Roast Beef $95.00
  • Eyeround of Beef $100.00

    (whole or sliced) in a rich demi-glaze

  • Roast Pork Loin Bordelaise $100.00

    veal stock, mushrooms, tomato

  • Smoked Lundys Ham $95.00

    with honey mustard glaze

  • Roast Turkey $5.25

    with apricot glaze

  • Creamy Risotto $90.00

    with chicken, peas & portobellos

  • Eggplant Rollatine $80.00

    with four cheeses

  • Traditional Eggplant Parmesan $80.00
  • Tray & More - Desserts

  • Chocolate Cappuccino Cake
  • Chocolate Brownie Cheesecake
  • California Carrot Cake
  • Hazelnut Cream Cake
  • Chocolate Raspberry Cake
  • Fruit Tarts
  • Eclair
  • Miniature Pastries
  • Fruit Bread
  • White Midnight Mousse
  • Deep Chocolate Torte
  • Peanut Butter Mousse Cake
  • Midnight Mousse Layer Cake
  • Apple, Banana Walnut Cake
  • Cannoli
  • Cheesecake
  • Cookies

Guy Anthony's Details

  • Service options

  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Delivery
  • Highlights

  • Fast service
  • Great cocktails
  • Live music
  • Serves local specialty
  • Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
  • Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Offerings

  • Halal food
  • Small plates
  • Dining options

  • Breakfast
  • Brunch
  • Amenities

  • Bar onsite
  • Restroom
  • Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Cozy
  • Romantic
  • Crowd

  • Groups
  • Planning

  • Reservations required
  • Payments

  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards
  • Parking

  • Free parking lot
  • Free street parking
  • Parking

Guy Anthony's Photos

Guy Anthony's Picture 1Guy Anthony's Picture 2Guy Anthony's Picture 3Guy Anthony's Picture 4Guy Anthony's Picture 5Guy Anthony's Picture 6Guy Anthony's Picture 7Guy Anthony's Picture 8Guy Anthony's Picture 9Guy Anthony's Picture 10

Guy Anthony's Location

Guy Anthony's

2208 Jerusalem Ave, Merrick, NY 11566, USA

Guy Anthony's Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 218 user reviews.

food and servicepricesmusicpartydiningentertainmentthursdaybaby showerveal sorrentinobridal shower

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More restaurants near me

  • Kenko Asian CuisineKenko Asian Cuisine4.0 (156 reviews)

    2 Merrick Ave, Merrick, NY 11566, USA

  • Chipotle Mexican GrillChipotle Mexican Grill3.0 (275 reviews)

    2312 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • Cheeks & Bean Gelato Co.Cheeks & Bean Gelato Co.4.0 (62 reviews)

    2326 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • Wayback BurgersWayback Burgers4.0 (665 reviews)

    2306 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • Whiskey Reds Irish PubWhiskey Reds Irish Pub4.0 (96 reviews)

    2552 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • Hunan DynastyHunan Dynasty4.0 (493 reviews)

    2292 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • Azerbaijan GrillAzerbaijan Grill4.0 (661 reviews)

    2366 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • SoBolSoBol4.0 (124 reviews)

    2332 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • QDOBA Mexican EatsQDOBA Mexican Eats4.0 (1280 reviews)

    2160 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • Mama Theresa's East MeadowMama Theresa's East Meadow4.0 (724 reviews)

    2411 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • Surf City SqueezeSurf City Squeeze3.0 (8 reviews)

    2375 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • Moe's Southwest GrillMoe's Southwest Grill4.0 (568 reviews)

    2565 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Top restaurants Searches

    Trending Dining Insights Posts