Jersey Mike's Subs

- 2345 Jericho Tpke, Garden City Park, NY 11040

When New Yorkers crave a classic, high-quality submarine sandwich, few places deliver the authentic deli experience quite like Jersey Mike's Subs. This location, strategically situated in Garden City Park, serves as a reliable cornerstone for residents across Nassau County looking for a consistently excellent, made-to-order meal. More than just a typical fast-food spot, Jersey Mike's operates as a full-service Sandwich shop and Deli, specializing in subs prepared the right way: with meats and cheeses sliced fresh right in front of you.

The core of the Jersey Mike's appeal lies in its commitment to freshness and its famous "Mike's Way" preparation—onions, lettuce, tomato, red wine vinegar, olive oil blend, and spices. This attention to detail results in food quality that is frequently praised. As one loyal customer noted, the subs are "ALWAYS made with love," and the food quality earns a strong "10" out of 10. For those navigating busy schedules, Jersey Mike's provides the perfect balance of quality ingredients, speed, and customization, making it an excellent choice for Lunch, Dinner, or Solo dining when local delis might be out of reach.

It is worth noting that while the food is consistently lauded, customer experiences with service can vary. However, the overall sentiment remains overwhelmingly positive, with the exceptional taste and freshness of the sandwiches acting as the primary draw. The atmosphere is definitively Casual, inviting families and college students alike to enjoy a quick and satisfying bite.

Location and Accessibility

The Garden City Park location of Jersey Mike's Subs is conveniently situated on one of Long Island's major arteries: 2345 Jericho Tpke, Garden City Park, NY 11040, USA. This placement on Jericho Turnpike ensures high visibility and easy access for both local traffic and commuters traveling across Nassau County.

The establishment is highly accommodating to all patrons, with a comprehensive focus on accessibility. Features include a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a comfortable Wheelchair accessible restroom, and designated Wheelchair accessible seating.

For drivers, parking is simplified with readily available Free parking lot access and options for Free street parking. The store’s location within a commercial hub and its commitment to being Family-friendly makes it a practical and easy stop for any planned or impromptu meal. Additionally, those with pets can take advantage of the fact that Dogs allowed outside.

Services Offered

Jersey Mike's Subs in Garden City Park offers a wide range of services designed to provide maximum flexibility and convenience for the modern New York lifestyle:

• Dine-in and Takeout: Patrons are welcome to enjoy their subs in the Casual seating area, equipped with Wi-Fi and Restroom facilities, or grab their order quickly for Takeout.
• Delivery Options: A full suite of off-premise service is available, including standard Delivery, convenient Curbside pickup, and No-contact delivery for added peace of mind.
• Catering Services: Recognized as a professional Caterer, the shop can provide large, satisfying sub platters and boxes for office meetings, parties, or large family gatherings, making it an excellent alternative to traditional catering options.
• In-Store Ordering and App Ordering: Customers can place orders in person at the counter to watch their meats and cheeses sliced, or utilize the mobile app for quick, pre-paid ordering, a method popular among frequent users.
• Kid-Friendly Amenities: The restaurant is Good for kids and provides High chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu, ensuring a welcoming environment for families.

Features / Highlights

The core identity of Jersey Mike's is built upon several key features that appeal to the discerning palate of the Long Island consumer:

• Fresh-Sliced Quality: The signature feature is the slicing of premium meats and cheeses for every sub, ensuring maximum flavor and freshness—a critical difference from many competitors.
• The "Mike's Way" Preparation: Subs are traditionally topped with the famous combination of red wine vinegar, olive oil blend, spices, onions, lettuce, and tomatoes, which elevates the sandwich beyond basic deli fare and locks in a unique flavor.
• Diverse Dietary Offerings: The menu is notably inclusive, offering Halal food options, which is a significant feature for the local community, alongside readily available Vegetarian options and Vegan options.
• Comfort Food Focus: While simple, the subs are classified as Comfort food—a satisfying, reliable, and hearty meal that appeals to a wide variety of tastes and ages.
• Versatile Menu Structure: Whether you're craving a cold sub, a hot sub (like the famous cheesesteaks), or a healthy option, the menu supports a Quick bite for any time of day, fulfilling both lunch and dinner demands.

Contact Information

To place an order for pickup, coordinate a delivery, or inquire about catering services, please use the following contact details:

Address: 2345 Jericho Tpke, Garden City Park, NY 11040, USA

Phone: (516) 619-1400

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting Jersey Mike's Subs in Garden City Park, the best choices center around the subs that exemplify their commitment to freshness and their unique preparation style. For a new patron, the following choices are highly recommended to capture the full Jersey Mike's experience:

The Number 13, The Original Italian, is the gold standard and the definitive choice. This sub is packed with provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, and salami, and should always be ordered "Mike's Way." The fresh slicing of the cold cuts and the tang of the vinegar and oil dressing truly showcase why the food quality is so highly rated by local customers.

If you prefer a hot sub, which is a substantial and satisfying meal, any of their Cheesesteak options come highly recommended as they are prepared on the grill with freshly sliced ingredients. These hot subs are the perfect comfort food for a chilly New York day or a hearty dinner.

For patrons looking for non-meat or alternative dietary options, choosing any sub with Halal meat or exploring the full range of Vegan and Vegetarian options ensures they still benefit from the famous freshly sliced cheeses and crisp vegetables that are central to the Jersey Mike's experience. While one customer noted the inability to toast the bread as a "qualm," the consistent quality of the freshly prepared ingredients ensures the subs' natural flavors stand on their own. Whether you're grabbing a sub via curbside pickup or utilizing the fast delivery service, Jersey Mike's remains a top-tier choice for authentic deli quality on Long Island.

Jersey Mike's Subs

2345 Jericho Tpke, Garden City Park, NY 11040, USA