Jessie's Nutty Cups

- 53rd Street Sunset Park Brooklyn, Brooklyn, NY 11232

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers who appreciate the artisanal over the mass-produced, Jessie’s Nutty Cups offers a delightfully sophisticated alternative to the traditional candy cup. Operating out of Brooklyn, New York, this unique establishment is better described as a specialized gourmet confectionery or chocolate studio, though it falls under the broad banner of a specialized 'bakery' due to its handcrafted approach to sweets. The core mission of Jessie's Nutty Cups is simple yet profound: to create superior-quality peanut butter cups that elevate the classic chocolate and nut butter combination far beyond what is commonly available.

The story begins with a realization of the demand for a quality peanut butter cup that transcends the simple, often overly sweet and dry versions found on store shelves. From this inspiration, Jessie’s Nutty Cups was born, promising to maintain superior quality and a handcrafted process. This dedication starts with roasting raw peanuts to create an all-natural, delectably gooey, and lightly sweetened peanut butter filling. This filling is then perfectly complemented by sustainably produced Belgian Chocolate, which is expertly tempered to provide that pleasing, professional chocolaty 'snap.' The result is a perfect, two-bite treat that’s designed to interrupt your mundane Monday with a moment of pure, nutty bliss.

Location and Accessibility

Jessie's Nutty Cups is proudly produced locally right here in the heart of Brooklyn, specifically within the dynamic Sunset Park neighborhood. This centralized New York City location is where the magic happens, ensuring every handcrafted cup is as fresh as possible before it reaches the customer. While the company's products are widely distributed across the country through online sales and specialty retailers, its roots and production remain firmly planted in Kings County, NY, a true testament to its local New York origin.

The production address indicates a location within the area, often associated with commercial or wholesale operations:

Address: 170 53rd Street Suite 216, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA

The ability to purchase these gourmet treats locally is a key benefit for New York area residents. While not a traditional walk-in bakery storefront, local customers in New York can often find the products at various high-end, specialty, and gourmet retailers across the region. These retailers include well-known local institutions such as Whole Foods (Williamsburg), Murray's Cheese, and Bedford Cheese Shop, making the "perfectly Nutty" cup readily accessible without relying solely on shipping.

Services Offered

The primary focus of Jessie’s Nutty Cups is the creation and distribution of its signature gourmet confectionery. Its services are structured to ensure broad accessibility to its specialty products, both locally and nationally.

• Handcrafted Production: Every peanut butter and almond butter cup is made to order and put together by hand in their Brooklyn facility, guaranteeing the utmost freshness and quality.
• Retail Sales: Products are stocked at numerous specialty and gourmet retailers across New York City and the nation, providing convenient local access.
• Online Ordering: Customers can purchase products directly through the official website and various premium online marketplaces like Goldbelly and Uncommon Goods for direct-to-door delivery.
• Subscription Service: A 'Nutty Subscription' is offered, allowing enthusiasts to receive a monthly box of assorted cups, including seasonal and limited-time 'Nutty Cup of the Month' flavors.
• Wholesale: The company supplies its gourmet cups to over 100 specialty and gourmet retailers, demonstrating a strong business-to-business model.
• Custom Assortments: Offering gift boxes and custom product assortments, making them an ideal choice for corporate gifts, events, or personal indulgence.

Features / Highlights

Jessie’s Nutty Cups has built a strong reputation in the competitive New York food scene based on several distinctive features that separate them from mass-market competitors.

• Gourmet, Handcrafted Quality: The cups are entirely handmade in New York City, promising superior quality and attention to detail over mass-produced alternatives.
• Proprietary Peanut Butter Filling: They start by roasting raw Virginia peanuts to create their own delectably gooey, lightly sweetened, and all-natural filling, made with ingredients people recognize.
• Sustainably Produced Belgian Chocolate: The use of sustainably produced Belgian Chocolate is a major highlight, which is carefully tempered to achieve a superior, satisfying 'snap'.
• Creative Flavor Profiles: The brand is famous for its creative and unique twists on the classic peanut butter cup, going far beyond simple milk or dark chocolate options.
• Signature Stock Flavors: Bestsellers include the Dark Sea Salt, which offers a perfect sweet and salty balance, and the inventive PB&J, featuring a triple berry jam based on the original recipe.
• Diverse Assortment: Stock flavors consistently include Original Nutty Cups, Nutty Cookies 'n' Cream, Nutty Pretzel Cups, and Nutty Choco-Hazelnutty Cups, with seasonal offerings like Nutty Coffee or Apple Spice Cups.
• Focus on Community: As a locally produced business in Brooklyn, the company is committed to maintaining its handmade process to provide jobs and support the local community.
• Premium Gifting Option: The beautifully packaged cups, available in gift boxes of 8 or 15, are widely regarded as a fantastic gift for any chocolate and peanut butter lover.

Contact Information

For local customers in New York looking to connect with Jessie’s Nutty Cups for inquiries, wholesale information, or online orders, please use the following contact details:

Address: 170 53rd Street Suite 216, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA

Phone: (347) 676-0927

What is worth choosing

Choosing Jessie's Nutty Cups is a deliberate decision to prioritize quality, local craftsmanship, and imaginative flavor over the standard confectionery offering. For a New Yorker, particularly one who values high-quality, gourmet treats, this Brooklyn-born brand is worth seeking out for several compelling reasons that redefine the peanut butter cup experience.

First and foremost, the core product is exceptional. Unlike mass-produced cups which can be overly sweet with a dry, pasty center, Jessie’s provides a truly handcrafted alternative. The delectably gooey, lightly sweetened peanut butter filling, made from freshly roasted peanuts, is the star. When paired with the expertly tempered, high-quality Belgian chocolate—whether smooth milk, rich dark, or creamy white—it creates a two-bite treat that reviewers have called the "World's best PB cups." This attention to quality ensures a product that tastes more like a gourmet chocolate confection and less like a candy treat.

Secondly, the inventive flavor portfolio is a game-changer. Why settle for plain when you can indulge in a Dark Sea Salt cup that perfectly marries sweet and savory, or a PB&J cup that layers triple berry jam for a nostalgic, complex twist? The stock flavors like Cookies 'n' Cream and Pretzel offer different textures—crunchy, chewy, or creamy—that engage the palate in a way that is utterly unique to this brand. The constantly rotating seasonal 'Cup of the Month' flavors also offer a reason for repeat visits, both online and at local retailers.

Finally, by choosing Jessie’s Nutty Cups, you are supporting a dedicated, women-owned business that is an active part of the NYC small business community. Every purchase helps maintain a handmade production process that supports local employment and promotes superior-quality ingredients. For a beautiful, delicious, and artisanally crafted chocolate experience that stands head and shoulders above the rest, Jessie's Nutty Cups is the definitive choice for any discerning New Yorker with a sweet tooth.

Jessie's Nutty Cups

53rd Street Sunset Park Brooklyn, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA