Your Brooklyn Dining Guide: Exploring the NYU Lutheran Coffee Shop

NYU Lutheran Coffee Shop Introduce

The New York City dining scene is renowned for its diversity, and within that landscape, the classic American coffee shop or diner holds a special, comforting place. For locals in the Sunset Park area of Brooklyn, and specifically those visiting or working at the NYU Langone Hospital—Brooklyn campus, the

NYU Lutheran Coffee Shop

offers a welcoming, sit-down dining experience that provides a reliable break from the day. Located conveniently within the hospital facility, this spot is more than just a quick grab-and-go counter; it's a full-service, classic diner-style eatery serving up a wide variety of meals from morning until well into the day.

This coffee shop is a true local resource, catering to a diverse clientele including medical staff, patient visitors, and residents from the surrounding Brooklyn neighborhood seeking a hearty, familiar meal. The atmosphere of a coffee shop diner—often combining fast, friendly service with a broad menu of comforting classics—makes it an ideal choice when you need substantial, reliable food without a fuss. It serves as a culinary anchor within the large hospital complex, complementing the buffet-style offerings of the main cafeteria with a dedicated space for sit-down meals.

The menu at the

NYU Lutheran Coffee Shop

is notably extensive, mirroring the vast offerings you would expect from a New York diner. It covers all the essential categories for breakfast, lunch, and beyond, with a focus on value and variety. For early risers and those looking for a power start to their day, the breakfast selection is particularly comprehensive. You'll find staples like

Two Eggs Any Style

, a range of

Omelettes

including Western, Cheese, Spanish, and Veggie options, and griddle favorites such as

Pancakes

and

French Toast

. For those who prefer a grab-and-go morning meal, there are assorted

Bagels and Muffins

available.

As the day progresses, the focus shifts to robust lunch and house specialties. The menu moves into classic deli-style heroes and wraps, like the

Grilled Chicken Hero

or the

Roast Beef Hero

, alongside a selection of popular wraps. One customer noted the quality of the

panini

, suggesting that the grilled sandwiches are a solid choice for lunch. The menu also features comfort foods and hearty plates, a hallmark of the classic New York diner experience. Items such as the

Fried Fish Deluxe

with all the fixings,

Shrimp Parmigiana

, and specialty sandwiches like the

Big Texan

(hot roast beef with mozzarella cheese) provide substantial, filling options.

Furthermore, for those seeking a quick and satisfying combo, the menu includes several lunch combos served with

french fries

and a soda. This is where you can find those diner classics that hit the spot, such as the

Cheese Burger Combo

or the

Philly Cheese Steak Combo

. The inclusion of items like the

Gyro Combo

Falafel Combo

, and various

Tacos

also speaks to the diverse culinary expectations of a Brooklyn local spot, blending traditional diner fare with international street food favorites. This breadth of choice ensures that whether you’re craving a classic patty melt or something a little more adventurous, there's likely an option to satisfy.

One of the most valuable aspects of this particular location is its placement within the NYU Langone Hospital—Brooklyn campus. It serves a crucial function by providing easily accessible, high-quality, and varied meal options for the hospital community. In a setting where time can be limited and the need for a comfortable, sit-down meal is high, having a dedicated coffee shop on the second level of the main lobby is a significant amenity. It offers a quieter, more relaxed environment compared to a large main cafeteria, allowing for a moment of respite.

Customer feedback highlights both the positives and areas for improvement. A common sentiment is the satisfaction with the savory dishes. For instance, a customer specifically enjoyed the

cheeseburger

and

sweet potato fries

, affirming the quality of their main dishes and the diner's ability to execute classic comfort food well. However, another customer's feedback regarding the

bagels

and cream cheese suggests a mixed experience with the lighter fare, particularly noting a high price point for a seemingly small amount of cream cheese. This is a common and important consideration for New Yorkers, for whom a quality bagel is a fundamental expectation. The note on counter seating discomfort for larger or taller patrons also provides valuable insight, suggesting that table seating might be the more comfortable option for some.

Location and Accessibility

The

NYU Lutheran Coffee Shop

is situated on the second level in the main lobby of the NYU Langone Hospital—Brooklyn campus. This location is in the Sunset Park neighborhood of Brooklyn, making it a convenient destination for anyone in the hospital or the immediate surrounding community.

Address:

5501 1st Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA.

Services Offered

Full-service, sit-down dining experience, separate from the hospital's main buffet-style café.
Extensive breakfast menu featuring eggs, omelettes, pancakes, and French toast.
Wide array of grab-and-go morning options including bagels, muffins, and pastries.
Comprehensive lunch menu with hero sandwiches, wraps, house specialties, and combo meals.
Diner-style comfort food, including cheeseburgers, grilled sandwiches (panini), and fries.
A variety of international-inspired dishes such as Gyro, Falafel, and Tacos.

Features / Highlights

On-site dining located on the second level of the main lobby at NYU Langone Hospital—Brooklyn.
Classic New York-style coffee shop diner with a very diverse menu.
Strong selection of affordable, hearty breakfast options, including popular omelettes and griddle favorites.
Known for quality savory items like cheeseburgers, sweet potato fries, and panini, as per customer reviews.
Convenient and reliable meal option for hospital staff, visitors, and nearby Brooklyn residents.

Contact Information

Address:

5501 1st Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA

Phone:

(718) 630-7145

Mobile Phone:

+1 718-630-7145

What is worth choosing

For New Yorkers in the Sunset Park area, especially those with ties to the NYU Langone Hospital—Brooklyn campus, the

NYU Lutheran Coffee Shop

is worth choosing for its incredible variety and comforting, substantial food. The value proposition here lies in the broad, classic diner menu, which ensures there is always something to satisfy a serious craving, from a quick egg sandwich to a full-fledged comfort meal.

If you are visiting for lunch, the combo meals, which pair a main item like a

Cheeseburger

Philly Cheese Steak

with fries and a drink, represent a great value for a filling meal. As noted by a local customer, the

cheeseburger and sweet potato fries

are an excellent choice and a definite must-try from the savory menu. Additionally, the selection of wraps and house specialties, like the

Big Texan

or a grilled panini, provide quick, well-prepared options that rise above typical hospital food.

The real strength of this location is its functionality as a neighborhood spot in a high-traffic location. It’s a dedicated sit-down space that offers a momentary escape, making it an invaluable resource. While the feedback on some of the bakery items, like the bagels, suggests that patrons may want to focus on the main dishes, the overall consensus points to a reliable source of traditional diner fare. It is the perfect place when you need a hearty, flavorful meal served with efficiency and a sense of familiarity, right in the heart of Sunset Park, Brooklyn. Don't overlook this local gem for your next breakfast or lunch outing.

NYU Lutheran Coffee Shop Photos

NYU Lutheran Coffee Shop Location

NYU Lutheran Coffee Shop

New York Kings County Sunset Park 1st Avenue

5501 1st Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA

NYU Lutheran Coffee Shop Reviews

The bagels have male pattern baldness with how little cream cheese they give you... For 5$!!!
May 22 · Eva Lau
Nice coffee shop diner. Was hungry for cheeseburger and sweet potatoes fries. It was good. They make good panini too. Good service. My only complaint is the seating for single around the counter is not comfortable. Not enough leg space. I am a bit large and tall so my legs need room.
November 06 · Pam C
I come here ever so often when visiting a patient. I must say that the food here is really good and reasonable in price. Waitstaff is friendly and service is quick. The only issue is that it is cash only.
September 28 · Lisa S
The Greek wrap with well done fries! I look forward to this everytime I visit there! It's perfectly made, I wouldn't change a thing, the service, the hospitality, it's just right, everyone there deserves 5 Stars!!
January 12 · Charon Vasquez
Food is great, but waiters take their own tip without your knowledge. I have had to speak to their manager about it. I have no problem tipping, but I shouldn't be tricked into giving an $8 tip. What they do is give themselves a 20% gratitude and circle it and writing "thank you" next to it so it seems like that's the total of the bill. DONT GO HERE!!
February 06 · Ana Rabanal