Pete’s Brooklyn Eats

- 140 58th St Building B, Brooklyn, NY 11220

Introduction / Overview

In the heart of Brooklyn, New York, especially within the bustling hub of the Brooklyn Army Terminal, lies a true local gem that has cemented its status as a community cornerstone: Pete’s Brooklyn Eats. With an impressive legacy that spans over 35 years, this establishment is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a testament to the enduring bond between fresh, delectable cuisine and the local community. The journey of Pete's Brooklyn Eats was inspired by the love and passion for cooking infused by the owners' parents, a love that continues to be the secret ingredient in every dish served today. The business is proudly family-owned, and this spirit of care extends far beyond the kitchen, manifesting in an unwavering commitment to quality and a deep dedication to supporting the local neighborhood.

Pete's Brooklyn Eats distinguishes itself by offering an expansive and diverse menu that caters to virtually every taste and craving, making it a perfect spot for the busy New Yorker. Customers consistently praise the food for its great quality, freshness, and fair pricing. Whether you are seeking a quick, satisfying lunch, a hearty breakfast, or full-service catering for a large event, this cafe delivers with a friendly and pleasant service that makes people feel truly welcome. It's a culinary experience built on passion, community support, and the simple, yet profound, philosophy inherited from their mother: "if you won't eat it, then don't serve it."

Location and Accessibility

Pete's Brooklyn Eats is conveniently located within a major commercial and industrial landmark in the city. The primary location is situated in the Sunset Park area, specifically at the Brooklyn Army Terminal, making it a key dining option for the numerous professionals and visitors in the vicinity. The precise address guides customers directly to this well-regarded establishment.

Address: 140 58th St Building B, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA

For New Yorkers familiar with the Brooklyn Army Terminal, the cafe is located in Building B. Accessibility to this location is typically centered around serving the complex's workers, but it remains a known spot for local Brooklyn residents as well. It is important for patrons to note that the location at the Brooklyn Army Terminal Building B is often designated for PICKUP only, with a second location (5620 1st ave Brooklyn NY 11220) handling both delivery and pickup services. This ensures flexibility for local users, whether they are on-site at the terminal or ordering from a different part of the neighborhood.

Services Offered

Pete's Brooklyn Eats offers a comprehensive range of culinary services to meet the diverse needs of the Brooklyn community, including daily dining, quick take-out, and event planning.

• Breakfast Service: Offering tempting options to start the day right.
• Lunch Service: Providing a vast selection of hot and cold dishes for the midday meal.
• Catering Services: Available for events of all types, extending their fresh cuisine beyond the cafe walls.
• Pickup Service: Available directly at the 140 58th St Building B location.
• Delivery Service: Offered through their 1st Avenue location and various third-party platforms, ensuring their food is accessible across the local area.
• Diverse Menu Offerings: Encompassing Italian-American favorites and extensive cafe fare.

Features / Highlights

The appeal of Pete's Brooklyn Eats goes well beyond its extensive menu, centering on core features that have made it a neighborhood favorite for decades.

• Family-Owned Legacy: Founded in 1987, the business boasts a 35+ year history, rooted in family passion and tradition, which translates into authentic, high-quality food.
• Community Commitment: The Macaluso family, who run the establishment, are deeply dedicated to the Sunset Park community, regularly sponsoring events, making charity donations, and providing meals to those in need.
• Quality and Freshness: Customers consistently highlight the excellent quality of the ingredients and the overall freshness of the food served.
• Expansive Menu Variety: The offerings span from best-in-class pizzas and calzones to hearty pasta dishes, fresh salads, hot and cold sandwiches, and a selection of meat and seafood entrees like grilled salmon and spaghetti.
• Signature Pizza Selection: Known for great pizza, including thin-crust New York style slices, Sicilian square slices, and specialty pies such as Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Chicken Vodka Pizza, Meat Supreme, and Philly Cheesesteak Pizza.
• Customer Favorite Entrees: The menu is praised for having "many many choices of lunch plates from spaghetti to salmon," including popular options like chicken parmigiana, meatball parm, and various seafood pasta dishes.
• Deli and Sandwich Bar: Featuring an array of cold salads, cold sandwiches, and hot sandwiches like the Chicken Parm Sandwich, Brooklyn Cheesesteak, and an authentic Italian Sandwich.
• Fair Pricing: Noted for offering delicious food at reasonable prices, making quality dining accessible to everyone in the area.
• Friendly Customer Service: The team is frequently described as friendly, pleasant, and lovable, prioritizing a positive and welcoming experience for every customer.
• Beverage and Dessert Offerings: Providing fresh drinks, a full collection of soft drinks, and desserts to complete the meal.

Contact Information

For local patrons in Brooklyn seeking to contact the establishment for orders, inquiries, or catering services, the following information is available for the primary Brooklyn Army Terminal location:

Address: 140 58th St Building B, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA

Phone: (718) 492-5222

What is worth choosing

For a New Yorker navigating the vast dining landscape, Pete’s Brooklyn Eats presents a uniquely compelling choice, especially for those working in or visiting the Brooklyn Army Terminal. The cafe’s strength lies in its ability to offer an incredibly wide and high-quality menu under one roof, moving seamlessly between different culinary categories while maintaining a consistent standard of excellence.

If you are looking for a reliable, satisfying, and authentically Brooklyn meal, Pete's is worth choosing for several key reasons. Firstly, the menu breadth is outstanding. The customer feedback proudly mentions having "the best burgers," a "great pizza selection," and "many many choices of lunch plates from spaghetti to salmon." This variety means that whether you are in the mood for a classic New York-style slice, a hearty portion of Baked Ziti, a fresh Garden Salad, or a comforting bowl of Minestrone Soup, Pete’s has you covered. The full lunch menu includes everything from pasta with vodka sauce and shrimp to classic meat and eggplant parmigiana dishes, ensuring a satisfying meal for any dietary preference.

Secondly, the commitment to fresh, quality ingredients at a "fair pricing" point is an invaluable draw in New York City. The family’s dedication to quality, sourcing ingredients locally where possible and supporting small businesses, ensures a fresh product on your plate. This combination of affordability and quality is difficult to find and is a primary reason why the cafe has thrived for over three decades.

Finally, the welcoming and community-focused atmosphere makes it stand out. This is not just transactional food service; it's a neighborhood staple where people feel welcome. Choosing Pete's Brooklyn Eats means supporting a family business that actively gives back to the Sunset Park community, delivering an experience that is as heartwarming as their home-style pasta dishes. For a taste of Brooklyn tradition, quality, and generous portions, Pete's Brooklyn Eats remains a top-tier option.

Pete’s Brooklyn Eats

140 58th St Building B, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA