Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook

- 5 Huntington Ave, Lynbrook, NY 11563

Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook: A Lynbrook Staple Evolving to Serve the New York Community

In the competitive culinary landscape of Long Island, where great Italian-American food is an expectation, Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook has earned its reputation as a community staple since the early 1980s. Located in the heart of Nassau County, this pizza restaurant is celebrated not only for its commitment to classic, quality recipes but also for maintaining exceptional value that makes it a favorite for families, commuters, and solo diners across the New York region. While the business is currently undergoing a fresh chapter under new, passionate ownership—evolving into what is also known as AP Pizza & Cafe, complete with remodeling and expanded seating—the core promise remains: serving the same delicious, original recipes and keeping prices remarkably affordable, a dedication highlighted by loyal customers.

More than just a place for a quick slice, Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook offers an extensive menu of comforting Italian classics, designed to cater to every meal and occasion, from a quick solo lunch to full-scale catering for large parties. Known for specializing in classic comfort food and providing quick bites, the restaurant has seamlessly blended the traditional pizzeria experience with modern convenience. Their multifaceted offerings, including a standout line of frozen dinners and unbeatable daily specials, truly set them apart as a valuable resource for busy New York households seeking quality food at a price that won't strain the budget. The emphasis is always on quality, passion for the food, and deep community roots, ensuring that this Lynbrook landmark continues its legacy for decades to come.

Location and Accessibility in Lynbrook, NY

Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook is conveniently situated at 5 Huntington Ave, Lynbrook, NY 11563, USA. Lynbrook is a key village in Nassau County, known for its busy commercial areas and easy access via major Long Island thoroughfares like Sunrise Highway. This location is tucked away just off the main road, making it a simple stop for those traveling or passing through the South Shore region.

For the New York customer, accessibility is paramount, and Joey's excels in offering practical options. A major highlight noted by the business itself is the availability of Free Street Parking. In a village like Lynbrook, where parking spaces are often strictly regulated by permits and time limits in municipal fields, guaranteed free parking immediately elevates the convenience factor for customers coming in for a quick pickup or a casual dine-in meal. This is a significant logistical advantage for both local families and commuters. The central location in the village also allows for fast and reliable Free Delivery to all of Nassau County, ensuring that residents throughout the county can enjoy their renowned dishes without leaving home. The establishment is clearly popular for both lunch and dinner visits, and its accessible location and parking solutions make it a practical choice any day of the week.

Services Offered

Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook provides a full spectrum of service options that are designed to meet the diverse needs of the busy New York clientele, from rapid pickups to large-scale events.

• Comprehensive Delivery and Takeout: The restaurant offers Delivery, Takeout, No-contact delivery, and even Curbside pickup, maximizing convenience for all customers. Delivery is free across all of Nassau County.
• Dine-in Service: Patrons can enjoy their meals in a Casual atmosphere, perfect for solo dining, a quick lunch, or dinner with the family, with the added benefit of a newly remodeled dining area.
• Extensive Catering Services: They offer Catering for parties and events, featuring everything from pizza packages (e.g., 5 Regular Pies for $35.00) to large, hot party trays of entrees like Chicken Parm and Baked Ziti. Specialized services include Hot Buffet catering (minimum 25 people) with complementary trays and utensils provided.
• Unique Heat-N-Serve Options: Customers can order Hot Trays to Go or Cold Party Trays that are ready for pickup (Pick-Up Special $25 Each, Hot Delivered $35 Each), providing flexible solutions for hosts.
• Kid-Friendly Environment: The business is noted as Good for kids, offering a Kids' menu alongside their comfort food offerings, making it a great destination for families.
• Payment Flexibility: All modern payment methods are accepted, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features and Highlights of the Menu and Value

The menu at Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook is built around traditional Italian comfort food and is packed with compelling features, most notably its value and variety.

• Unbeatable Pizza Value: The shop is famous for its special pricing. Highlights include the Tuesdays Special Large Pie for only $7.00 (Pick-up only) and the Pick Up Special Large Pie for $8.29. These prices are consistently noted by customers as the most reasonable on Long Island, offering a return to "turn back in time" pricing. The pizza itself features a wide selection of Toppings, from classic Pepperoni and Sausage to specialties like Sauteed Spinach and Buffalo Chicken.
• The Frozen Dinner Program: A unique offering is the selection of 21 different homemade frozen dinners, priced affordably at $5.00 each. These are explicitly marketed as "great for the elderly, busy families or commuter launches" and include favorites like Chicken Parmesan with Penne, Meat Lasagna, and Baked Ziti. An exceptional deal is the "Buy 5 Dinners Get One Large Pie For $5.25."
• Homemade Specialties: The business prides itself on making food from scratch, including Joey's Homemade Foccacia Bread, which is used for all their Hot Heros (e.g., Chicken Parm Hero, Meatball Parm Hero, all priced at $11.00). They also offer Tomato Sauce-Fully Cooked and Fully Cooked Meatballs as pre-made products for customers.
• Full Italian Entree Selection: Beyond pizza, the menu offers a strong line of hot entrees, all priced at $13.25 and served with a choice of pasta or vegetable. Options include Chicken Parmesan, Eggplant Parmesan, and even Shrimp Parmesan, providing a full-service Italian dining experience.
• Extensive Catering Variety: Catering goes beyond just standard trays, offering pre-breaded/fried items like Chicken Cutlets and Eggplant, and specialty side dishes like Stuffed Mushrooms and Baked Clams.

Contact Information

Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook (AP Pizza & Cafe) is always ready to take your order or reservation.

Address: 5 Huntington Ave, Lynbrook, NY 11563, USA

Primary Phone: (516) 599-2929

Mobile Phone: +1 516-599-2929

What is Worth Choosing at Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook

For anyone in the New York region, especially those throughout Nassau County, Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook is worth choosing primarily for its unrivaled combination of value, convenience, and authenticity. The commitment to keeping prices low, even after a change in ownership, is the single most compelling reason to choose this local institution. As one customer noted, the deals are the "BEST DEALS IN TOWN, BY FAR," with the ability to feed a family with a large pizza and several homemade meals for an incredibly low price. This affordability makes it a critical resource for budget-conscious families and busy individuals.

Beyond the price, the unique frozen dinner program stands out as a major service innovation tailored perfectly for the local New York lifestyle. This offering caters directly to "busy families" and "commuter launches," solving the nightly dinner dilemma with delicious, pre-made Italian staples that are ready to heat and serve, complete with an endorsement from a self-proclaimed "very, very picky" Italian spouse. This practical convenience, paired with the quality of the mild, flavorful sauces and thin, crispy pizza, confirms the restaurant's commitment to both speed and taste.

Furthermore, choosing Joey’s means supporting a local legacy that has been successfully transitioned to a new generation of dedicated owners, ensuring that the recipes that made the original shop a community staple remain consistent. The extensive menu, featuring everything from classic Grandma and Sicilian pizzas to full hot entrees and specialty heroes made on Homemade Foccacia Bread, ensures that every craving is covered. The availability of free street parking, a wide range of delivery options (including free Nassau County delivery), and full catering services solidify Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook as the premier choice for accessible, high-quality, and budget-friendly Italian comfort food on Long Island. It is an ideal solution for any New Yorker seeking the perfect blend of tradition and modern convenience.

Joey's Pizza of Lynbrook

5 Huntington Ave, Lynbrook, NY 11563, USA