John & Tony's Pizza: The Westchester Icon Serving Classic New York Italian

John & Tony's Pizza Introduce

## Introduction / Overview

For generations of New Yorkers, particularly those in the Westchester County area, the name

John & Tony's Pizza

is synonymous with authentic, old-school Italian-American dining. While the official name on record may be

John & Tony's Pizza

, many locals know and revere this Mount Vernon institution by its historical moniker,

Johnny's Pizzeria

, a legendary spot that has been serving up some of the Tri-State region’s most acclaimed thin-crust pizza since its founding in 1942. It is not just a pizza joint; it is a time-honored landmark, steeped in family history, culinary tradition, and a dedication to quality that has made it a true destination.

This establishment stands proudly as both a classic

Pizza restaurant

and a full-service

Italian restaurant

. For decades, families have flocked here not only for a quick bite but for the comfort of a casual, neighborhood atmosphere that feels authentically New York. The restaurant has been called "the original" and "the best" by patrons who have loyally returned for over 70 years, often bringing their own children and grandchildren to experience a taste of history. Its appeal is universally strong among

Locals

, ensuring a consistent, community-driven dining experience that is perfect for

Lunch

Dinner

, whether you are dining alone or with family, making it unequivocally

Good for kids

This is a place where culinary tradition is paramount. The philosophy centers around providing

Comfort food

and classic Italian dishes made with care, resulting in a reputation that often sees customers bypassing numerous other eateries just to get a taste of their specialty pizza and other favorites. Its renown extends throughout the state, a testament to its enduring commitment to quality and the distinctive style of its food.

## Location and Accessibility

John & Tony's Pizza

is centrally located in the heart of Mount Vernon, a crucial city in Westchester County, New York. The current address is

11 W Grand St, Mt Vernon, NY 10552, USA

. This location places it conveniently for New York residents looking for an authentic meal outside the immediate bustle of New York City, serving as a pillar of the local Mount Vernon culinary scene.

For those traveling by car within the New York region, accessibility to Mount Vernon is typically straightforward, though prospective patrons should note that local parking, especially around a popular establishment, can sometimes be a challenge, as noted in customer feedback. However, the reward for the journey is the experience of one of Westchester's oldest and most lauded pizzerias. Furthermore, the history of this place ties it to the local geography, with one long-time patron recalling its earlier days in Bronxville before its final move. The restaurant has a deep, multi-location history within the Mount Vernon area, having moved from its original Third Street and Fourth Avenue corner spot, to Gramatan Avenue, and then its location on West Lincoln Avenue (which some historical records associate with the name

Johnny's

Johnny's Pizzeria

) before its association with the

11 W Grand St

address. Regardless of its exact historical addresses, its identity remains firmly planted as a Mount Vernon landmark.

## Services Offered

John & Tony's Pizza

offers multiple convenient ways for New York patrons to enjoy their acclaimed Italian fare, catering to various needs and schedules:

**Dine-in:**
The restaurant provides a casual, immersive setting perfect for enjoying a hot pizza fresh out of the kitchen. It is an ideal spot for a
Lunch
or
Dinner
outing.
**Takeout:**
Local customers can easily place an order to pick up their food and take it home, perfect for those seeking a quick, quality meal for the family.
**Delivery:**
The convenience of having their celebrated Italian food and pizza delivered directly to homes and businesses in the Mount Vernon and surrounding New York area is offered.
**Full Menu:**
Beyond the primary offerings, the full menu at the historical
Johnny's Pizzeria
includes a wide variety of Italian
Entrees
,
Pasta
dishes, and
Appetizers
, ensuring there is something for everyone.

## Features / Highlights

The true allure of

John & Tony's Pizza

lies in its unique characteristics and historical commitment to a distinctive style of pizza, making it a beloved choice among discerning New York pizza aficionados:

**The Ultra-Thin Crust Pizza:**
The most famous feature is arguably the signature, ultra-thin crust pizza. Reviewers consistently praise its
zero flop, good crisp,
and
thin and tasty
character. This dedication to the specific thin-crust style distinguishes it within the competitive New York pizza market.
**Old-School Family Legacy Since 1942:**
With a history dating back to 1942, this is one of Westchester’s oldest pizzerias. The Piscopo family’s legacy, including the late Joe Piscopo Sr. and his wife Maria Piscopo (who was the matriarch for 40 years), is woven into the atmosphere, creating a genuine, lived-in charm. It's a true
old-school
establishment.
**Pies Only Policy (Historically):**
The establishment is historically known for its commitment to quality by serving pizza
by the pie only
, not slices. While the current listing mentions slice options elsewhere, this traditional, non-slice approach solidified its status as a premium pizza destination.
**A Shrine to New York Culture:**
The ambiance is distinctly New York, sometimes described as a
shrine to the NY Yankees
, with memorabilia giving the place a classic, homey, throwback feel that resonates strongly with local patrons.
**The Hot Hero Selection:**
The menu features a robust list of comforting, classic
Hot Heros
including staples like
Meatball Parm
,
Sausage & Pepper
, and
Chicken Parm
, providing hearty
Comfort food
beyond the pizza.

## Contact Information

**Address:**

11 W Grand St, Mt Vernon, NY 10552, USA

**Phone:**

(914) 664-4100

**Alternative Phone/Mobile:**

+1 914-664-4100

## What is Worth Choosing

For any New York resident, especially a Westchester local,

John & Tony's Pizza

is an essential stop not just for food, but for the authentic atmosphere of a classic, multi-generational American-Italian establishment. The single most compelling reason to choose this spot is its celebrated **ultra-thin crust pizza**. The commitment to a crispy, non-soggy, flavorful pie, often featuring the sauce layered on top of the cheese, is what sets it apart and has earned it a reputation as one of the best in the Tri-State region. The pizza here is consistently described as delicious, crispy, and flavorful, a true classic.

Beyond the pizza, the experience itself is a worthwhile draw. You are stepping into a piece of Mount Vernon history that has been a community staple

since 1942

. Choosing

John & Tony's Pizza

means choosing a casual dining spot where the spirit of the original owners and the dedication to simple, high-quality, Italian-American

Comfort food

lives on. Customers praise the overall food quality, noting that the service is also great, though potential patrons should be aware that some long-standing local businesses like this may only accept cash payments. It is a perfect choice for those seeking a quick, reliable lunch or a traditional, satisfying dinner with friends or family in a place cherished by generations of local New Yorkers.

John & Tony's Pizza Food & drink

Pizza
Sm Pizza $17.00
Ex Lgpizza $18.00
Ci Ian Pizza $18.00
Hite Pizza
Ege Pizza
Traitems $3.00

Hot Heros
Meatball Parm $8.00
Sausage & Pepper $8.00
Sausage
Sausage Parm
Eggplant $7.00
Eggpl Ntparm $8.00
Chicken $7.00
Chicken Parm $8.00
Pepper Eg S
Potato Eggs

Beverages
Can Soda
Bottle Wat
Snapple Drinks

John & Tony's Pizza Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Locals

Children
Good for kids

John & Tony's Pizza Photos

John & Tony's Pizza Location

John & Tony's Pizza

New York Westchester County Mount Vernon Fleetwood West Grand Street

11 W Grand St, Mt Vernon, NY 10552, USA

John & Tony's Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 65 user reviews.

italianschooleggplantgarlic breadsausagepiefashionareanew york pizzapepperoni

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

They scammed me for the price it says $20 for the veggie large and $18 for the cheese larger but since they know, I’m from out of town they charge me $28. They said they didn’t change that price of that board. I don’t believe that the pizza is good but the way how they treated I didn’t like it.
August 23 · Ali M
Best in Westchester. Been going there for over 40 years since they were in Bronxville. Always good to also talk about politics and Italy w/the father.
June 14 · D C
Old school - style Italian food - John & Tony are famous for their special dinners 🍽 and 🍕 Pizza. ..
August 17 · John Galluzzi
Really incredible pizza! Well made and genuine Italian slices 10/10
May 31 · Jacobo Dominguez
They know how to make ny pizza. They make the crust slightly crispy if you ask for it.
August 17 · Blesson George