Killmeyer's Introduce
For New Yorkers seeking a dining destination that is steeped in history and offers an authentic, yet relaxed, atmosphere, **Killmeyer's** is a standout institution. Operating as a quintessential **Bar & grill** while simultaneously serving as a premier **German restaurant** and **American restaurant**, it delivers a unique and highly satisfying experience right on Staten Island. This establishment is recognized not just for its food and drink, but as a local landmark—an establishment that has been a cherished part of the New York community since 1888, offering a truly **Historic** feel.
The core identity of Killmeyer's is built around quality and comfort. It proudly serves **Comfort food** that spans continents, specializing in German favorites that are considered a true **local specialty**, alongside beloved American dishes. The ambiance is notably **Casual** and **Cozy**, often described as having an old-fashioned Bavarian charm, perfect for an intimate dinner or a lively gathering. It successfully caters to a diverse **Crowd**, popular with both local **Groups** and **Tourists** exploring New York City. The restaurant is a full-service venue, featuring a fantastic **Bar onsite**, a comprehensive menu covering **Brunch**, **Lunch**, and **Dinner**, and an engaging entertainment program that includes **Live music** and viewing **Sports** events.
Patrons consistently highlight the **Fast service**, the commitment to quality beverages—notably the **Great beer selection** and **Great cocktails**—and the delicious **Great dessert** options. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a returning local, Killmeyer's offers a reliable, warm, and highly enjoyable New York dining experience.
---
Killmeyer's Bar and Grill is conveniently situated at a well-known address on Staten Island, making it an accessible and easy-to-locate spot for residents across the New York metropolitan area. The address is precisely: **4254 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309**. Located along this major thoroughfare, it's a straightforward destination for those traveling by car or local transport.
The restaurant is committed to ensuring a comfortable visit for all guests, offering numerous accessibility features. Finding parking is made simple with both a dedicated **Free parking lot** and the option of **Free street parking**. For guests requiring mobility assistance, the building is fully equipped, featuring a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, designated **Wheelchair accessible parking lot** spaces, a **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, and appropriate **Wheelchair accessible seating**. This commitment to full access underscores its reputation as a welcoming, inclusive **Family restaurant** and community gathering place in New York.
---
Killmeyer's offers a robust suite of services that make it a highly versatile choice for dining, celebration, and casual visits:
- **Flexible Dining Availability:** Guests can choose from standard **Dine-in** service with **Table service**, convenient **Takeout**, and relaxing **Outdoor seating** options, particularly popular during the warmer months when the Beer Garden is open. The menu is available for **Brunch**, **Lunch**, and **Dinner**.
- **Event and Party Catering:** The business excels at **Catering**, providing options for both on-premises events and **Off Premises Catering**. Noteworthy party options include the **House Buffet Party** at $28 per person and the unique **Beer Garden Pig Roast BBQ** starting at $40 per person, offering a full German feast for groups of all sizes. Full trays of German favorites like **Our Famous Sauerbraten ($90.00)** are available for off-site events.
- **Reservations and Planning:** The venue **Accepts reservations**, which is highly recommended for **Groups** to ensure preferred seating and to facilitate party planning.
- **Exceptional Weekly Value:** A range of specials boosts the value proposition, including a Buy One Entree, Get the Second One Free deal on select items, the **Wednesdays** special of **German Style Pork Ribs ($15.00)**, and the highly family-friendly **Thursdays** promotion: **Kids Eat Free!!!** with an adult entree purchase.
- **Happy Hour Excellence:** The popular **Happy Hour** runs **Monday - Friday from 4 PM - 7 PM**, featuring **Half - Priced 1/2 Litre Select Draught Beers**, affordable **House Wine ($4.00)** and **House Cocktails ($4.00)**, and delicious **Bar Food Specials ($5.00)**.
- **Full Bar Offerings:** The **Bar onsite** serves a complete range of **Alcohol**, **Beer**, **Wine**, **Cocktails**, and **Hard liquor**, alongside **Coffee**. They also provide **Late-night food** options.
---
What sets Killmeyer's apart in the competitive New York dining scene are its unique features and its blend of authentic and approachable menu items:
- **Unmatched German Authenticity:** The menu is a highlight reel of genuine German cuisine. Key **Entrees** include the signature **Killmeyer's Sauerbraten ($19.50)**, **Wienerschnitzel ($21.00)**, **Beef Rouladen ($19.50)**, and the extensive **German Wurst Sampler ($16.00)**, all providing true European flavor.
- **Acclaimed Beverage Selection:** The restaurant is lauded for its **Great beer selection** of imported and craft brews, complemented by a **Great wine list** and creative **Great cocktails**, cementing its status as a top-tier **Bar**.
- **Historic and Inviting Atmosphere:** The **Historic** setting and old-fashioned Bavarian ambiance create a truly unique New York experience. The presence of **Live music** further enhances the vibrant, comfortable atmosphere, appealing to those seeking a lively evening.
- **Signature Appetizers and Pub Fare:** Don't miss the famous **Our Famous Potato Pancakes ($6.00)** or the unique **Forest Wives Mushrooms ($9.50)**. For a quick bite, the menu includes satisfying pub classics like a delicious **Pastrami ($7.50)** sandwich, **Fish & Chips ($8.50)**, and **Chicken Wings ($7.50)**.
- **Exceptional Lunch Value:** The lunch-time version of **German Specialties** priced under $10.00, such as the **Sauerbraten ($9.00)** or **Jägerschnitzel ($8.00)**, offer an incredibly accessible way to enjoy authentic cuisine without the dinner price tag.
- **Family-Friendly Focus:** Being a dedicated **Family restaurant**, the provision of a **Kids' menu** and the popular **Kids Eat Free!!!** promotion on Thursdays are key features that appeal to Staten Island families.
---
To reach Killmeyer's for reservations, information on live music schedules, or catering inquiries, please use the following contact details:
Address: 4254 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309
Phone: (718) 984-1202
Mobile Phone: +1 718-984-1202
---
For a local New York patron deciding what to choose at Killmeyer's, the best decision is to embrace the blend of its German heritage and its American pub identity. **The must-order item is the Killmeyer's Sauerbraten ($19.50).** This signature dish is the truest representation of the establishment's long-standing tradition as an authentic **German restaurant** and is a classic that cannot be missed.
To maximize value and experience, timing your visit for the daily specials is highly recommended. The **Happy Hour** running Monday through Friday from 4 PM to 7 PM provides the perfect opportunity to sample the **Great beer selection** with **Half - Priced 1/2 Litre Select Draught Beers** and enjoy some **Bar Food Specials ($5.00)**, making it ideal for a post-work gathering. Families should circle **Thursdays** on their calendars, as the **Kids Eat Free!!!** promotion makes it the most economical and fun night for a family meal. For a quick, affordable lunch, the selection of **German Specialties** available for under $10.00 (like **Jägerschnitzel** or **Chicken Schnitzel**) provides incredible quality and authenticity unmatched by typical fast-casual options.
Finally, for those looking for a celebratory atmosphere, choosing one of the full catering options, like the **Beer Garden Pig Roast BBQ**, ensures a truly unique and memorable event, showcasing the restaurant’s ability to host a major feast with traditional German flair. The combination of **Historic** setting, **Live music**, and excellent, hearty food makes Killmeyer's a standout choice for any occasion on Staten Island.
Killmeyer's Menu
Lunch Special
- 1/2 Sandwich with a Cup of Soup du Jour $7.00
Turkey, Ham, Corned Beef, or Pastrami
German Specialties
- Jägerschnitzel $8.00
with German home fries and vegetables
- Chicken Schnitzel $8.00
with mashed potatoes and vegetables
- Sauerbraten $9.00
with potato dumpling and red cabbage
- Wienerschnitzel $10.00
with spätzle and vegetables
- Kassler Rippchen $8.00
with mashed potatoes and sauerkraut
- Beef Goulash $8.00
with Egg Noodles
Salads & Soups
- Spinach Salad $6.00
- Grilled Chicken $8.00
with House Salad
- Tuna Fish House Salad $7.00
with sliced egg
- Soup du Jour $4.50
- Goulash Soup $5.00
Sandwiches
choice of roll, rye, or pumpernickel
- Liverwurst $6.00
and Onion with sauerkraut and German home fries
- BLT $6.00
with Steak Fries
- Fresh Turkey Breast $6.50
(hot or cold) with German home fries
- Fresh Ham $6.50
(hot or cold) with German home fries
- Black Forest Ham $6.50
with German home fries
- Pastrami $7.50
with steak fries
- Corned Beef $6.50
with steak fries
- Fresh Roast Beef $8.00
(hot or cold) with steak fries
- Reuben $8.50
with sauerkraut and German home fries
- Hamburger Deluxe $9.00
with steak fries and onion rings
- Veggie Burger $8.50
with sweet potato fries
- Wurst on a Roll $7.00
with mashed potatoes (choose from Bratwurst, Knockwurst, Weisswurst or Kielbasa)
Additional Offerings
- Steak Fries $4.00
- Onion Rings $5.00
- Potato Packages $5.50
with sour cream and apple sauce
- Two Hot Dogs with Kraut $7.00
and steak fries
- Fish & Chips $8.50
with tarter sauce
- Chicken Wings $7.50
with bleu cheese and celery
- Imported Cheese Plate with Fruit $15.00
- Escargot $9.00
- Frikadelle $4.50
- Beer Stick $3.00
- Landjäger $3.00
- Laberkäse $6.00
Appetizers
- Our Famous Potato Pancakes $6.00
with apple sauce and sour cream
- Escargot $8.00
snails with toast served in garlic butter
- Forest Wives Mushrooms $9.50
with bacon in cream sauce over sliced pumpernickel
- Imported Cheese & Fruit Plate $15.50
sliced assortment of cheese with seasonal fruit and crackers
- Smoked Fish Plate $16.00
assorted smoked fish including salmon and trout with horseradish sauce and crackers
- Oysters Bismark $16.00
6 Blue Point oysters broiled with spinach, bacon, Gorgonzola cheese, and cream
- Flammkuchen $12.50
traditional German pizza with thin sliced onion, fresh bacon, and creme fraiche
Salads
- House Salad $6.50
tossed greens with tomato wedges, sliced Bermuda onion, and sliced cucumber
- Spinach Salad $9.00
with sliced fresh mushrooms, sliced hard boiled egg, and our warm bacon dressing
- Grilled Chicken Salad $14.50
crisp Romaine lettuce and garden-fresh vegetables topped with sliced grilled chicken breast and your choice of dressing
- Summer Salad $14.50
mixed greens with chopped Granny Smith apple, candied walnuts, thin sliced onion, crumbled Gorgonzola all tossed with our homemade raspberry vinaigrette
Soups
- Spicy Beef Goulash $5.00
- Fresh Soup du Jour $5.00
Entrees
- German Wurst Sampler $16.00
choose three of these butcher-fresh sausages: bratwurst, smoked bratwurst, weisswurst, knackwurst, blutwurst,and kielbasy - all served with red cabbage and sauerkraut
- Wienerschnitzel $21.00
a classic German favorite: veal cutlet pounded thin, breaded, and slightly fried, served with spatzle and fresh vegetables
- Killmeyer's Sauerbraten $19.50
marinated pot roast in sweet and sour gravy, served with red cabbage and potato dumplings
- Chicken Schnitzel $17.00
breaded and fried chicken cutlets served with herb butter, mashed potatoes, and fresh vegetables
- Jagerschnitzel $19.00
Pork cutlets with mushroom Hunter gravy, served with German home fries and fresh vegetables. Smothered with creamy Forest Wives Mushrooms makes it a Rahmschnitzel
- Beef Goulash $18.00
spicy paprika gives this traditional beef stew its kick - served over egg noodles
- Oven Braised Beef Brisket $19.50
sliced and served with au jus gravy, mashed potatoes, and fresh vegetables
- Farmer's Feast $19.50
pork roast with beer gravy, smoked pork chop, and a grilled bratwurst served with a potato dumpling, red cabbage and sauerkraut
- Steak Heidelberg $24.00
NY Strip Steak, grilled to order, smothered in a nest of thin fried onions and served on a sizzling platter with mashed potatoes and fresh vegetables
- Beef Rouladen $19.50
sliced rolls of beef stuffed with smoked bacon, onions, mustard, and gherkins, braised, and served with special gravy, red cabbage, and potato dumplings
- Cranberry Pork Loin $19.00
tender pork loin medallions sauteed with Amaretto and cranberries, served with sweet potato fries and fresh vegetables
- Atlantic Salmon in Weissbier Sauce $19.50
pan-roasted with shallots and finished with butter and weissbier and served with rice and fresh vegetables
Drinks
Half Priced 1/2 Liter Select Draughts
- House Wine $4.00
- House Cocktails $4.00
Food
- 4 Potato Pancakes $3.00
- 3 Pulled Pork Sliders $5.00
- 3 Meatloaf Sliders $5.00
- Bratwurst Hoagie $5.00
House Buffet Party
$28 per person
- Pretzels
- Large Tossed House Salad
- Chicken In Mosel Wine
- Sauerbraten
- German Shepherd's Pie (Auf Lauf)
- German Fried Potatoes
- Red Cabbage
- Fresh Vegetables
- Coffee, Tea
- Apple Strudel
Premium Party Buffet
- Fresh Warmed Pretzels
- Sliced Fresh Fruit and Cheeses
- Potato Pancakes with Apple Sauce and Sour Cream
- Tossed House Salad
Entrees
- Our Famous Sauerbraten
- Sauerkraut Auf Lauf (German Shepard's Pie)
- Roasted Pork Loin with Cranberry Sauce
- Beef Goulash with Späetzel
- Fresh Vegetable du Jour
- Red Cabbage
- German Home Fries
Afterwards
- Coffee and Tea
- Warm Fresh Apple Strudel
Beer Garden Pig Roast BBQ
$40 per person. With three hours of draught beer and house wine - $55 per person
- Warm Pretzels
- Tossed House Salad
- Pass-Around Assorted Appetizers
potato pancake bites, grilled kielbasa, etc
- Roast Pig Carving Station
- On the Grill
hamburgers, Chicken filets, Hot Dogs, veggie burgers (upon request), bratwurst
- On the Side
cole slaw, potato salad
- Sauerkraut
- German Fried Potatoes
- Coffee, Tea, Sodas
Off Premises Catering Prices
The price quotes are for full trays that serve approximately 20 portions, unless noted otherwise. 48 hours notice required for most items. A few days notice required for Hasenpfeffer. Other items available, we will try to accommodate most reasonable requests. Sternos and Chafing Dish set up not included, but available for additional cost. Returnable security deposit may be required. New York Sales Tax not included
- Our Famous Sauerbraten $90.00
- Beef Brisket $90.00
- Beef Goulash with Egg Noodles $70.00
- Sliced Bratwurst $80.00
with Sauerkraut and Mashed Potatoes (auf lauf)
- Chicken in Mosel Wine with Mushrooms $70.00
- Hasenpfeffer (Rabbit) $90.00
- Schweinebraten (Oktoberfest Pork) $70.00
- Salmon Filet in Creamy Herb Lemon Sauce $90.00
- Potato Pancakes (Approx. 30 in Tray) $25.00
- Potato Dumpling $25.00
- Red Cabbage $20.00
- Sauerkraut $20.00
Specials
Buy one entree from this selection and get the second one Free!
- Pork Cutlet Jagerscnitzel $17.00
- Beef Goulash $18.00
- Chicken Schnitzel $16.00
- Wurst Sampler $16.00
bratwurst, knackwurst, weisswurst
- Auflauf - German Shephard's Pie $15.00
- Grilled Chicken Salad $14.00
Wednesdays
- German Style Pork Ribs $15.00
Slow cooked with sauerkrat, apples and brown sugar
Tuursdays
- Kids Eat Free!!!
With each adult entree purchased
Happy Hour
Monday - Friday 4PM - 7 PM; Half - Priced 1/2 Litre Select Draught Beers
- House Wine $4.00
- House Cocktails $4.00
- Bar Food Specials $5.00
Killmeyer's Details
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Takeout
- Dine-in
- Delivery
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great beer selection
- Great cocktails
- Great dessert
- Great wine list
- Live music
- Serves local specialty
- Sports
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Happy hour drinks
- Happy hour food
- Hard liquor
- Late-night food
- Quick bite
- Small plates
- Wine
Dining options
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Historic
- Trending
- Trendy
Crowd
- Groups
- Tourists
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
- Parking
Killmeyer's Photos










Killmeyer's Location
Killmeyer's
4254 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA
Killmeyer's Reviews
potato pancakesgerman beerbartendersislandlive musicpierogiesappetizersdraft beerbandmushrooms
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I had the pastrami sandwich and it was absolutely delicious! Robbie, my son, had a cheeseburger and he loved it. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. The atmosphere was relaxed and comfortable. I appreciate that they are wheelchair accessible and the parking is free, though the lot is on the smaller side. Overall, a wonderful experience for both adults and kids.
August 03 · Phil GillI had a pleasant dinner here with my father and relatives. We ordered multiple items, and I had a chance to taste the Forest Wives Mushrooms, Bistro Salad, Oven Braised Beef Brisket, and Crème Brûlée. I also had a pear cider and coffee. The food was delicious, and the atmosphere was lovely, with jazz music playing and the old-fashioned Bavarian ambiance. The service was also excellent, though they took a bit longer than expected to bring us dessert. The location is convenient, with plenty of parking across the street.
July 13 · Arik BurakovskyCelebrated a bday. Comedy show is very vulgar and not funny. Spent way more money than we planned. Meatball was burnt and dry. Will not be going back.
September 02 · Noelle BrunettiWas there first time today, was in mood for some German beer and food. I was pleasantly surprised with the feel of the place, appears quite authentic with its decor. I got one light german draft beer that was a bit weak, and then got Octoberfest Spaten which was much better, so that's good. For food we got Killmeyers namesake dish which appeared to be beef pot roast with potato dumplings and red cabbage in some glaze. The beef was excellent, falling apart so easy and good quality. Unfortunately the glaze was sweet and just didn't go with the dish, so was the red cabbage, just too sweet. My wife got the goulash which was much more tasty than the sweet glaze so I'd recommend opting for that option. Overall I was pretty happy and would definitely go back for some sausages and more beer to try. Hoping next time it would be more 5 star experience.
October 11 · Henry DThis was the most delicious beer I’ve ever tried! Grapefruit is my top favorite!The staff were very friendly. There was live music on Sunday, which added a pleasant atmosphere.My fav spot 🤩Highly recommend!
July 20 · Аліна Кузневич
More restaurants near me
VEGAN 150.0 (0 reviews)4164 Victory Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10314, USA
Banhmis & Asian Cuisine4.0 (141 reviews)4018 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10308, USA
Pho Mac4.0 (754 reviews)1407 Richmond Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314, USA
Pho Rainbow4.0 (422 reviews)42 New Dorp Plaza, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA
The Alchemist Cocktail Lounge4.0 (53 reviews)1363 N Railroad Ave, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA
Pho 60 u5357u5317u8d8a Staten Island4.0 (186 reviews)2602c Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA
Taste of Vietnam3.0 (28 reviews)2602 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA
Home Frite4.0 (157 reviews)332 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA
PokeBowl Station -New Dorp Lane4.0 (125 reviews)331 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA
Pho Today Staten Island4.0 (80 reviews)2530 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices4.0 (344 reviews)2351 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA
Grant City Tavern4.0 (102 reviews)132 Fremont Ave, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Middle Village Bagels4.0 (366 reviews)
El Mil Sabores4.0 (166 reviews)
Anixi Mediterranean Vegan Restaurant4.0 (1207 reviews)
MochiiDo4.0 (89 reviews)
On the Way Cafe4.0 (231 reviews)
Los Tres Potrillos3.0 (860 reviews)Top restaurants Searches
Trending Dining Insights Posts
How Dessert Shops Are Reinventing Classic Treats With Modern Techniques
Exploring Barbecue Restaurants That Focus on Slow-Cooked Regional Specialties
Discovering the Best Buffet Restaurants for Family Dining
How Ramen Restaurants Are Becoming Cultural Hotspots
Exploring Indian Restaurants That Highlight Regional Specialties
The Art of Crafting the Perfect Burger at Hamburger Restaurants
