La Herradura

- 118 N Division St, Peekskill, NY 10566

La Herradura, situated in the vibrant community of Peekskill, NY, offers a unique and highly authentic culinary journey to the residents and visitors of Westchester County. While officially listed as a Spanish restaurant, the establishment’s true heart and specialty lie in its roots as a dedicated Guatemalan restaurant. This dual identity ensures a broad appeal, but customers should anticipate a deeply traditional experience focused on the rich, comforting flavors of Central America. This is an establishment where food, culture, and atmosphere merge to provide a slice of Guatemala right here in the New York region.

The menu is extensive, balancing familiar Latin favorites with unique national dishes. Appetizers include staples like Soft Tacos, Quesadillas, and Nachos With Guacamole, alongside the more authentic Pupusas, Tamales, and Garnachas. A specific highlight is the inclusion of unique dishes like Cassava With Chicharron, immediately signaling the restaurant's commitment to traditional fare.

The core of the menu showcases impressive protein offerings across the Seafood, Steak, and Combinations categories. Seafood lovers can choose from whole fish preparations such as Fried Mojarra ($18.00), Stewed Red Snapper ($20.00), or a variety of shrimp dishes like Breaded Shrimps ($19.00). The steak section is equally diverse, featuring traditional cuts and preparations like Churrasco Chapin (a Guatemalan grilled steak dish), Bistek With Sauteed Onions, and a premium Sirloin In Shrimp Sauce. For the ultimate feast, the combination plates, such as the hearty Bandeja Paisa ($20.00) and the generously portioned Mix Charbroiled ($20.00), are popular choices for a complete, traditional meal.

Customer feedback emphasizes that this is as traditional as traditional can get for Guatemalan food, and patrons should manage their expectations accordingly. One long-term patron noted, "Please do not come here expecting service or vibes like American restaurants. This is a homey authentic and relaxed environment." This means service may be more relaxed and less rushed than what New Yorkers typically expect from a fast-paced environment. The atmosphere is described as Casual, Cozy, and even Quiet, which makes it a good option for groups of Locals and Tourists seeking an intimate dining experience, particularly for Breakfast, Lunch, or Dinner.

A crucial cautionary note from customer reviews, however, relates to the parking situation. One user reported having their car vandalized with a sticker warning about booting, despite parking in what they believed to be the restaurant's lot while waiting to enter. The restaurant provides both a Free parking lot and Paid street parking. Potential patrons are strongly advised to confirm the correct and authorized parking zones before leaving their vehicle to avoid any potential hostility or parking-related issues, as this is a highly factual warning shared by a local user.

Location and Accessibility

La Herradura is conveniently located at 118 N Division St, Peekskill, NY 10566, placing it centrally for the Westchester community. Its proximity to local amenities makes it a practical choice for a quick meal or a relaxed dinner.

• Accessibility Features: The premises are inclusive, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a well-equipped Wheelchair accessible restroom, and comfortable Wheelchair accessible seating options for all diners.
• Parking Options: Parking is available via a Free parking lot, though caution is advised to confirm the proper zones as noted in customer feedback, along with available Paid street parking.
• Planning Ahead: The restaurant Accepts reservations, which is highly recommended for larger parties or peak dining times, ensuring a seamless experience.

Services Offered

The restaurant offers a wide variety of services designed to accommodate diverse schedules and dining preferences, from early morning meals to late-night cravings.

• Dining Options: Customers can enjoy a relaxed Dine-in experience with Table service or conveniently pick up their food via Takeout.
• Full Meal Service: La Herradura is one of the few places in the area offering service from morning to night, including Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert.
• Late-Night Availability: For those with later schedules, the availability of Late-night food is a significant advantage.
• Bar and Beverage Program: A full Bar onsite offers a rich selection of alcoholic beverages, including Alcohol, Beer (with a Great beer selection), Wine, and Hard liquor. They are especially known for their classic cocktails, such as the Lime Margarita, Strawberry Margarita, and popular mixes like Long Island Ice Tea.
• Family-Friendly: The restaurant is designated as Good for kids, offering a dedicated Kids' menu with familiar favorites like Chicken Nuggets and Morzarella Stick, and provides High chairs for the youngest guests.
• Payments: All major forms of payment are accepted, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and modern NFC mobile payments for added convenience.

Features / Highlights

Beyond the food, La Herradura stands out for its unique cultural ambiance and strong beverage program, making it a compelling cultural and dining destination in Peekskill.

• Authentic Central American Cuisine: The primary highlight is the deep authenticity of the Guatemalan menu, offering truly unique dishes like Pupusas, Rellenitos, and Sweet Corn Tamal With Cheese & Cream, which can be hard to find elsewhere in the region. The commitment to Serves local specialty means a true taste of Guatemala.
• Beverage Excellence: The bar is noted for both a Great beer selection and fantastic mixed drinks, making it an excellent stop for a casual night out. The cocktail list is robust, featuring tropical drinks like the Piña Colada and Mango Margarita.
• Diverse Offerings: The menu successfully balances hearty Comfort food with lighter, Healthy options and satisfying Small plates, catering to nearly any dietary mood or preference, including notable Vegetarian options.
• Entertainment and Atmosphere: The venue has a TV dedicated to watching Sports, contributing to the Casual and communal feel that attracts Locals. The environment is described as Trendy while maintaining its Cozy, homey feel.
• Efficient Service: Despite the focus on a relaxed, traditional atmosphere, the kitchen is capable of providing Fast service for those needing a Quick bite during their lunch break.

Contact Information

For general information, to inquire about a reservation, or to place a takeout order, please contact La Herradura directly:

Address: 118 N Division St, Peekskill, NY 10566Phone: (914) 737-2264Mobile Phone: +1 914-737-2264

What is Worth Choosing

La Herradura is an essential choice for the New York user in Westchester County seeking an authentic and cultural dining experience that specifically features high-quality Guatemalan cuisine. You should choose this restaurant if you prioritize unique, traditional flavors over a fast, standard American dining experience. The availability of difficult-to-find dishes like Pupusas and Churrasco Chapin, alongside a wide selection of fresh Seafood, makes it a destination for truly special flavors. It’s also an excellent choice if you're looking for a low-key, Quiet, and Cozy atmosphere where you can enjoy a Great cocktail or a beer while relaxing, as the venue excels in its beverage program and comfortable ambiance.

Furthermore, its all-day service, spanning from Breakfast to Late-night food, offers incredible flexibility for any schedule. The option to Accepts reservations makes planning easy for Groups. However, as noted in the customer feedback, prospective diners must be extremely diligent about confirming the authorized use of the Free parking lot to avoid potential issues before enjoying the authentic flavors inside. For a genuine taste of Central American culture and comfort food in a relaxed setting, La Herradura is a standout establishment in Peekskill.

La Herradura

118 N Division St, Peekskill, NY 10566, USA