Lenny's Pizza

- 1046 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225

Lenny's Pizza on Nostrand Avenue stands as a neighborhood gem in Brooklyn, a true destination for locals seeking authentic New York-style pizza and a comprehensive menu of Italian comfort food classics. Unlike the famous but now-closed Lenny's Pizza featured in 'Saturday Night Fever' (which was in Bensonhurst), this Nostrand Avenue location is an active, bustling pizzeria serving the Flatbush community. It embodies the casual, familiar atmosphere that New Yorkers love in their local slice shops—a reliable, all-day spot that truly caters to the tastes and fast-paced life of the city. More than just a simple pizza joint, Lenny's Pizzeria offers everything from individual slices for a quick grab-and-go lunch to full, hearty Italian dinners, making it a staple for daily dining in the area.

When you're craving that perfect, foldable New York slice, or a full meal that feels like Sunday dinner, Lenny's Pizzeria is consistently recommended by those who live nearby. It’s the kind of establishment that builds a loyal local following by delivering quality, variety, and convenience. From the satisfying crunch of a Sicilian slice to the cheesy goodness of a calzone, the menu is built on time-honored recipes designed to satisfy even the biggest appetite. This pizzeria’s commitment to providing great value and an expansive selection ensures that every family member or solo diner can find exactly what they’re looking for, any time of day.

Lenny's Pizzeria expertly navigates the dynamic dining needs of Brooklynites. It functions perfectly as a quick-bite counter during a busy workday or a relaxed spot for a casual dinner. The kitchen’s focus on 'comfort food' is evident across its entire offering, ensuring every dish—whether it's a baked pasta specialty or a classic hero sandwich—is prepared to offer a warm, satisfying experience. As a cornerstone of the Nostrand Avenue culinary scene, this spot is essential for anyone living in or visiting the Flatbush area who wants to experience authentic, accessible Brooklyn Italian-American fare.

The wide variety of options available here is a testament to its dedication to being an all-purpose neighborhood eatery. The extensive menu goes well beyond the standard cheese and pepperoni, venturing into everything from vegetable-loaded pizzas to decadent Italian desserts. This diversity of offerings cements Lenny's as a reliable choice for any meal, proving that you don't have to sacrifice quality or variety for the convenience of a local pizzeria.

Location and Accessibility

Lenny's Pizza is conveniently situated at 1046 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, USA, placing it right in the heart of the Flatbush neighborhood. This strategic location on a major Brooklyn thoroughfare makes it highly accessible for both local residents and those commuting through the area. Being on Nostrand Avenue means it is well-served by public transportation, offering easy access via multiple bus routes. For New Yorkers relying on the subway, the location is a short distance from major transit hubs, ensuring a seamless trip whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch or picking up a full dinner for the family.

In line with prioritizing customer convenience, the establishment is set up for straightforward access. It features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, making it welcoming for all members of the community. Its positioning in a bustling, commercial section of Flatbush means it benefits from high visibility and an engaging neighborhood atmosphere. The local environment is casual and vibrant, reflecting the authentic energy of central Brooklyn dining. This ease of access, combined with its local vibe, solidifies Lenny's Pizzeria as a go-to spot for an effortless and satisfying dining experience.

The pizzeria is perfectly positioned to serve the daily ebb and flow of the neighborhood—ideal for students, workers, and families alike. For those utilizing personal vehicles, street parking is available in the surrounding area, though, as with any major Brooklyn street, it can vary. The focus, however, is clearly on serving the local crowd efficiently, especially with its extensive service options that cater to diners who need a quick and easy solution.

Services Offered

• Curbside Pickup: A convenient option for quick, zero-fuss meal collection.
• No-Contact Delivery: Prioritizing health and safety with seamless food drop-offs.
• Delivery: Fast and reliable service to bring Brooklyn's favorite pizza straight to your door.
• Takeout: The classic New York slice-shop experience for those on the move.
• Dine-in: A casual and comfortable atmosphere for enjoying a meal on-site.
• Catering to All Dayparts: Popular for lunch, dinner, and late-night food.
• Kids' Menu: Family-friendly options that are good for children.
• Flexible Payment Options: Accepts major credit cards and debit cards for easy transactions.

Features / Highlights

• Expansive Menu of Comfort Food: Beyond pizza, the menu includes hearty Baked Pasta Specialties (like Baked Ziti and Lasagna), Veal and Chicken Parmigiana dinners, and a variety of Hero Sandwiches.
• Authentic New York Pizza Slices: Offers both the classic Cheese Slice ($3.00) and the thicker Sicilian Slice ($3.50), perfect for a quick and satisfying bite.
• Specialty Pizza Options: A wide selection of whole pies including unique options like the 'Lenny's Special' (mixed meats and vegetables), White Pizza (sauceless, with ricotta), Margarita Pie, BBQ Pie, and Buffalo Pie.
• Dinner Specials and Full Meals: An excellent choice for a full, sit-down quality meal with options like Shrimp Parmigiana, Veal & Pepper Dinner, and the budget-friendly Gyro Dinner.
• Late-Night Food Availability: Recognizes the New York demand for food around the clock, offering quick bites and small plates late into the evening.
• Casual and Local Atmosphere: The vibe is purely 'Casual,' attracting a solid crowd of 'Locals,' cementing its status as a genuine neighborhood institution rather than a tourist destination.
• A Review Highlight: One local review specifically notes the 'Spanish seasoned Pizza with an okay flavor,' suggesting a unique, slightly seasoned tomato sauce—though this appears to be a point of debate among diners, with some noting only the oregano is prominent. It’s a definite talking point for pizza enthusiasts!

Contact Information

Address: 1046 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, USA

Phone: (718) 363-2323

Mobile Phone: +1 718-363-2323

What is Worth Choosing

Lenny's Pizza on Nostrand Avenue is a must-visit for New Yorkers who appreciate a vast selection of classic Italian-American comfort food, expertly prepared and served in a straightforward, local setting. While the quintessential New York Cheese Slice is a perfect, affordable introduction to their quality, the real value lies in their more substantial offerings.

For a deep dive into hearty Italian fare, the Baked Pasta Specialties are highly recommended. A generous portion of Baked Beef Lasagna or the classic Baked Ziti for under ten dollars offers unparalleled value for a satisfying meal in the city. These dishes are perfect for a cold evening or a truly filling lunch. The variety in their pasta dishes, with options for sauces ranging from classic Marinara to Meat Sauce, or additions like Meatballs and Sausage, ensures customization is simple.

If you're looking for a hero sandwich that hits the spot, the Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero or the Meatball Parmigiana Hero are top contenders, prepared with quality ingredients and melted cheese. For those seeking something beyond the norm, the full Dinner Specials provide a complete, plate-sized meal, with the Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Dinner being a great choice for just $13.00.

Finally, for a crowd-pleasing option, the Lenny's Special Pizza offers a mix of vegetables and meats that captures the spirit of a fully loaded Brooklyn pie. And don't forget the classic side of Garlic Knots—a New York pizzeria staple—which are offered affordably alongside other favorites like Mozzarella Sticks and Buffalo Wings. Lenny's provides the full spectrum of casual Italian dining, solidifying its place as an essential food spot in the Flatbush community. Whether you dine in for the casual local atmosphere or opt for their no-contact delivery, Lenny's Pizzeria is a reliable choice for authentic and satisfying meals.

Lenny's Pizza

1046 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225, USA