Little Pie Company: A Taste of Classic Americana in Midtown NYC

Little Pie Company Introduce

For nearly four decades, the Little Pie Company has been a cherished institution in New York City, serving up a slice of Americana right in the heart of Midtown's Theater District. More than just a bakery, this is a place that evokes a sense of nostalgia and homemade comfort, where every pie is crafted with care and tradition. What began as a simple idea to create truly fresh, handmade pies has blossomed into a beloved local gem, attracting locals and tourists alike who are drawn in by the irresistible aroma of freshly baked goods.

The shop’s philosophy is built on quality and authenticity. With a commitment to using only the finest ingredients and avoiding preservatives, Little Pie Company ensures that every bite is as wholesome as it is delicious. The "theater of baking" is a key part of the experience, with large picture windows allowing customers to watch the skilled bakers at work, hand-pinching crusts and filling pies with seasonal ingredients. This dedication to craft has earned the bakery a stellar reputation and high praise from both customers and food critics.

While its name highlights the pies, the Little Pie Company is also a welcoming cafe and coffee shop, perfect for a quick stop and a satisfying treat. It is a certified Black-owned business and proudly LGBTQ+ friendly, creating an inclusive and welcoming environment for everyone who walks through its doors. Whether you're in the mood for a classic slice of pie, a slice of a homemade cake, or a simple cup of coffee to start your day, this spot offers a truly special and flavorful experience.

Location and Accessibility

Little Pie Company is located at 424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036. This prime address places it squarely in the vibrant Hell's Kitchen neighborhood, just a stone's throw from the world-renowned Broadway theaters. The location makes it a perfect stop for a pre-show treat or a post-show dessert.

The area is exceptionally well-connected by public transportation, making the bakery easily accessible from all parts of New York City. It is a short walk from major subway stations, including Times Square–42nd Street, which services a multitude of lines including the 1, 2, 3, 7, N, Q, R, W, and S trains, as well as the Port Authority Bus Terminal. The proximity to these hubs makes it a convenient stop for commuters, theatergoers, and tourists exploring the city's main attractions.

In addition to its central location, Little Pie Company is committed to accessibility for all customers. The business features a wheelchair-accessible entrance and wheelchair-accessible seating, ensuring that everyone can enjoy their delicious offerings. While street parking can be challenging in this busy part of Manhattan, the availability of free street parking is a notable feature, though it may require some searching.

Services Offered

The Little Pie Company offers a range of services designed for both convenience and a quality customer experience.

In-Store Shopping: Customers can come in and browse the fresh selection of pies, cakes, and other baked goods. The friendly staff are available to provide recommendations and help you choose the perfect treat.
Takeout: All pies and baked goods are perfectly packaged for takeout, making it easy to bring a delicious treat home or to a gathering. The secure boxes ensure the pies travel well.
In-Store Pickup: For customers who place their orders in advance, either by phone or online, the bakery offers convenient in-store pickup, saving time and ensuring your desired items are ready and waiting.
Delivery: The Little Pie Company provides local delivery services, bringing their classic pies and cakes right to your door. This is a great option for those who live or work nearby and want a fresh pie delivered.
Onsite Services: As a cafe, the shop provides a space to enjoy your food and drinks right on the premises. It's an ideal spot to sit down, relax, and savor a slice of pie with a cup of coffee.
Breakfast: The bakery is open early and offers breakfast items, including coffee and cakes, providing a sweet way to start your day.

Features and Highlights

What makes Little Pie Company a standout establishment in a city full of bakeries and cafes? It's the unique combination of its products and its community-focused ethos.

Handmade Pies and Cakes: The main highlight is the quality of the baked goods. All pies and cakes are made from scratch, with a focus on simple, high-quality ingredients like hand-sliced apples and rich, buttery crusts. This commitment to traditional methods is a major draw.
Variety of Sweet and Savory Pies: While renowned for its fruit and cream pies, the bakery also offers savory options like the famous chicken pot pie. The menu includes both classic and seasonal varieties, such as Sour Cream Apple Walnut, Mississippi Mud, and Southern Pecan, available in both 5-inch individual sizes and 10-inch family sizes.
Gluten-Free Options: Little Pie Company caters to various dietary needs with its gluten-free options, including the Gluten-Free Blueberry Apple Crumb and Gluten-Free Florida Key Lime pies. This ensures that more customers can enjoy their delicious products.
Black-Owned and LGBTQ+ Friendly: The business is a certified Black-owned establishment and a welcoming space for the LGBTQ+ community. This makes it a great choice for those who wish to support diverse and inclusive businesses in the city.
Quality Coffee: In addition to the baked goods, the shop offers freshly brewed coffee, providing the perfect pairing for a slice of pie or cake. The classic combination of coffee and pie is a signature experience here.

Contact Information

To place an order or learn more about the Little Pie Company, you can use the following contact information:

Address: 424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036
Phone: (212) 736-4780

What Is Worth Choosing

When you step into Little Pie Company, you are met with an array of tempting choices, but what truly makes this place a must-visit is its signature pie and the overall quality of its offerings. The undisputed star of the show is the Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie. As countless reviews and testimonials confirm, this pie is not just a dessert; it's a culinary masterpiece. It combines the familiar comfort of a classic apple pie with a rich, tangy sour cream filling and a delectable streusel topping of brown sugar, cinnamon, and walnuts. The result is a perfect balance of flavors and textures—the tender, hand-sliced Granny Smith apples are neither too sweet nor too tart, the crust is flaky and golden, and the topping provides a satisfying crunch. It's the kind of pie that people remember and seek out again and again.

Beyond the pies, Little Pie Company’s homemade cakes are also worth considering. The Creamy New York Cheesecake is praised for its rich, dense, and creamy texture, a testament to its fresh ingredients. The classic Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake is a decadent choice for chocolate lovers, and the Applesauce Carrot Cake is a moist and flavorful option. The availability of both 5-inch personal pies and 10-inch pies for a crowd, along with convenient sampler packs, makes it easy to choose the perfect size for any occasion. The experience is enhanced by the friendly staff who are quick with a smile and a recommendation. This combination of authentic, high-quality baking and a genuinely welcoming atmosphere is what makes Little Pie Company not just a coffee shop or a bakery, but a true New York City treasure that is well worth choosing.

Little Pie Company Menu

Samplers - Samplers
Dinner And Dessert (4pack) $46.00
Some like it sweet, some like it hot — and our brand-new Dinner and Dessert sampler pack was designed with even the pickiest of people in mind! It features four, five-inch fabulous pies. One Three-Berry: A delicious blend of fresh strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries simmered to perfection and topped with a superb lattice crust. Two Piping-Hot Chicken Pot Pies: Creamy, comforting Chicken Pot Pie made with our hand-rolled crust — plus tender white chicken chunks, fresh cream, and peas, carrots, and onions galore. One Sour Cream Apple Walnut: Our signature pie is baked with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream and topped with brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel.
Little Pie Company Sampler (4 Pack) $46.00
One Sour Cream Apple Walnut: Our signature pie is baked with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream and topped with brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel. One Florida Key Lime: made with fresh key lime from a 75-year-old recipe, unlocks a sunburst of flavors. It’s sweet and tart, smooth and creamy. One Old Fashioned Apple: is low in sugar and bursting with flavor. It’s made with fresh golden delicious apples, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and covered with a light flaky crust. One Mississippi Mud: made up of quality imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel and a chocolate glaze in a chocolate cookie crust.

Samplers
Dinner And Dessert (4pack) $46.00
Some like it sweet, some like it hot — and our brand-new Dinner and Dessert sampler pack was designed with even the pickiest of people in mind! It features four, five-inch fabulous pies. One Three-Berry: A delicious blend of fresh strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries simmered to perfection and topped with a superb lattice crust. Two Piping-Hot Chicken Pot Pies: Creamy, comforting Chicken Pot Pie made with our hand-rolled crust — plus tender white chicken chunks, fresh cream, and peas, carrots, and onions galore. One Sour Cream Apple Walnut: Our signature pie is baked with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream and topped with brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel.
Little Pie Company Sampler (4 Pack) $46.00
One Sour Cream Apple Walnut: Our signature pie is baked with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream and topped with brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel. One Florida Key Lime: made with fresh key lime from a 75-year-old recipe, unlocks a sunburst of flavors. It’s sweet and tart, smooth and creamy. One Old Fashioned Apple: is low in sugar and bursting with flavor. It’s made with fresh golden delicious apples, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and covered with a light flaky crust. One Mississippi Mud: made up of quality imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel and a chocolate glaze in a chocolate cookie crust.

Handmade Pies - 5 inch (serve 1-2)
Sour Cream Apple Walnut 5" $12.00
It’s not your ordinary pie. Our signature pie is baked with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream and topped with brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel.
Old Fashioned Apple 5" $12.00
Our old-fashioned apple pie is low in sugar and bursting with flavor. It’s made with fresh golden delicious apples, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and covered with a light flaky crust. Serve warm with a scoop of cold vanilla ice cream.
Florida Key Lime 5" $12.00
Our Key Lime Pie is made with fresh key lime juice from a 75-year-old recipe, unlocking a sunburst of flavors. It’s sweet tart, smooth and creamy. Serve chilled with fresh whipped cream.
Mississippi Mud 5" $12.00
Romance the chocolate lover in all of us. This sinful seducer is made up of quality imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel and a chocolate glaze in a chocolate cookie crust. Serve with freshly whipped cream or ice cream.
Southern Pecan 5" $12.00
A rich and tender crust is the perfect foil for this heavenly, not overly sweet, classic. The ratio of pecans to filling is generously balanced and a scoop of freshly whipped cream complements a warm slice.
Three Berry 5" $12.00
A taste revolution in and of itself, our blend of fresh strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries are simmered into a sweet confection and then topped with a superb lattice crust.
Sugarless Apple 5" $12.00
The right pie with the perfect sweetener. Nature’s own grade A golden delicious apples. We add a little nutmeg, cinnamon and unsalted butter to complete this great tasting pie.
Banana Coconut Cream 5" $12.00
This dessert is filled with fresh banana slices and banana custard. Topped off with freshly whipped cream and toasted coconut, make this pie supreme.
Chicken Pot Pie $12.00
This wholesome and hearty pie is filled with tender white chicken chunks and a mixture of fresh cream, peas, carrots and onions. Then baked just right.
GLUTEN-FREE Blueberry Apple Crumb 5" $14.00
Our Gluten Free Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie combines ripe blueberries with chunks of Golden Delicious Apples — making for the perfect not-too-sweet, not-to-tart filling. But, we didn’t stop there: Each Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie is topped with brown sugar-coated chopped walnuts for a crunchy, sweet finish that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
GLUTEN-FREE Florida Key Lime 5" $14.00
Our Gluten-Free Key Lime Pie is made with Florida Key lime juice and a homemade Gluten free graham cracker crust that's sweetened with a hint of honey. Each pie is sprinkled with fresh lime zest for a tropical burst of flavors you won’t be able to resist. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
Sweet Potato 5" (Seasonal) $12.00
With summer ending and fall beginning, we’re excited to offer Sweet Potato Pie as our Pie of the Month for September! This delicious pie is a tribute to the classic Southern dish, made with sweet potatoes and baked to perfection. It’s the perfect way to welcome the new season. Not only is our handmade pie a tasty dessert, but it’s also full of vitamins A, C, B6, and potassium.

Handmade Pies - 10 inch (serve 8-10)
Our seasonal specialty features a hand made-as-always sublime double crust. Delectable extra-sharp NY cheddar cheese envelopes our signature thinly sliced, honest to goodness Granny Smith Apple filling.
Sour Cream Apple Walnut 10" $45.00
It’s not your ordinary pie. Our signature pie is baked with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream and topped with brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel.
Old Fashioned Apple 10" $45.00
Our old-fashioned apple pie is low in sugar and bursting with flavor. It’s made with fresh golden delicious apples, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and covered with a light flaky crust. Serve warm with a scoop of cold vanilla ice cream.
Mississippi Mud 10" $45.00
Romance the chocolate lover in all of us. This sinful seducer is made up of quality imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel and a chocolate glaze in a chocolate cookie crust. Serve with freshly whipped cream or ice cream.
Florida Key Lime 10" $45.00
Our Key Lime Pie is made with fresh key lime juice from a 75-year-old recipe, unlocking a sunburst of flavors. It’s sweet tart, smooth and creamy. Serve chilled with fresh whipped cream.
Three Berry 10" $45.00
A taste revolution in and of itself, our blend of fresh strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries are simmered into a sweet confection and then topped with a superb lattice crust.
Southern Pecan 10" $45.00
A rich and tender crust is the perfect foil for this heavenly, not overly sweet, classic. The ratio of pecans to filling is generously balanced and a scoop of freshly whipped cream complements a warm slice.
Sugarless Apple 10" (24 HOURS IN ADVANCE) $45.00
The right pie with the perfect sweetener. Nature’s own grade A golden delicious apples. We add a little nutmeg, cinnamon and unsalted butter to complete this great tasting pie.
GLUTEN-FREE Blueberry Apple Crumb 10" $52.00
Our Gluten Free Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie combines ripe blueberries with chunks of Golden Delicious Apples — making for the perfect not-too-sweet, not-to-tart filling. But, we didn’t stop there: Each Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie is topped with brown sugar-coated chopped walnuts for a crunchy, sweet finish that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
GLUTEN-FREE Florida Key Lime 10" $52.00
Our Gluten-Free Key Lime Pie is made with Florida Key lime juice and a homemade Gluten free graham cracker crust that's sweetened with a hint of honey. Each pie is sprinkled with fresh lime zest for a tropical burst of flavors you won’t be able to resist. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
Sweet Potato Pie 10" (Seasonal) $45.00
With summer ending and fall beginning, we’re excited to offer Sweet Potato Pie as our Pie of the Month for September! This delicious pie is a tribute to the classic Southern dish, made with sweet potatoes and baked to perfection. It’s the perfect way to welcome the new season. Not only is our handmade pie a tasty dessert, but it’s also full of vitamins A, C, B6, and potassium. (Serves 8-10)

5 inch (serve 1-2)
Sour Cream Apple Walnut 5" $12.00
It’s not your ordinary pie. Our signature pie is baked with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream and topped with brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel.
Old Fashioned Apple 5" $12.00
Our old-fashioned apple pie is low in sugar and bursting with flavor. It’s made with fresh golden delicious apples, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and covered with a light flaky crust. Serve warm with a scoop of cold vanilla ice cream.
Florida Key Lime 5" $12.00
Our Key Lime Pie is made with fresh key lime juice from a 75-year-old recipe, unlocking a sunburst of flavors. It’s sweet tart, smooth and creamy. Serve chilled with fresh whipped cream.
Mississippi Mud 5" $12.00
Romance the chocolate lover in all of us. This sinful seducer is made up of quality imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel and a chocolate glaze in a chocolate cookie crust. Serve with freshly whipped cream or ice cream.
Southern Pecan 5" $12.00
A rich and tender crust is the perfect foil for this heavenly, not overly sweet, classic. The ratio of pecans to filling is generously balanced and a scoop of freshly whipped cream complements a warm slice.
Three Berry 5" $12.00
A taste revolution in and of itself, our blend of fresh strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries are simmered into a sweet confection and then topped with a superb lattice crust.
Sugarless Apple 5" $12.00
The right pie with the perfect sweetener. Nature’s own grade A golden delicious apples. We add a little nutmeg, cinnamon and unsalted butter to complete this great tasting pie.
Banana Coconut Cream 5" $12.00
This dessert is filled with fresh banana slices and banana custard. Topped off with freshly whipped cream and toasted coconut, make this pie supreme.
Chicken Pot Pie $12.00
This wholesome and hearty pie is filled with tender white chicken chunks and a mixture of fresh cream, peas, carrots and onions. Then baked just right.
GLUTEN-FREE Blueberry Apple Crumb 5" $14.00
Our Gluten Free Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie combines ripe blueberries with chunks of Golden Delicious Apples — making for the perfect not-too-sweet, not-to-tart filling. But, we didn’t stop there: Each Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie is topped with brown sugar-coated chopped walnuts for a crunchy, sweet finish that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
GLUTEN-FREE Florida Key Lime 5" $14.00
Our Gluten-Free Key Lime Pie is made with Florida Key lime juice and a homemade Gluten free graham cracker crust that's sweetened with a hint of honey. Each pie is sprinkled with fresh lime zest for a tropical burst of flavors you won’t be able to resist. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
Sweet Potato 5" (Seasonal) $12.00
With summer ending and fall beginning, we’re excited to offer Sweet Potato Pie as our Pie of the Month for September! This delicious pie is a tribute to the classic Southern dish, made with sweet potatoes and baked to perfection. It’s the perfect way to welcome the new season. Not only is our handmade pie a tasty dessert, but it’s also full of vitamins A, C, B6, and potassium.

10 inch (serve 8-10)
Our seasonal specialty features a hand made-as-always sublime double crust. Delectable extra-sharp NY cheddar cheese envelopes our signature thinly sliced, honest to goodness Granny Smith Apple filling.
Sour Cream Apple Walnut 10" $45.00
It’s not your ordinary pie. Our signature pie is baked with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream and topped with brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel.
Old Fashioned Apple 10" $45.00
Our old-fashioned apple pie is low in sugar and bursting with flavor. It’s made with fresh golden delicious apples, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and covered with a light flaky crust. Serve warm with a scoop of cold vanilla ice cream.
Mississippi Mud 10" $45.00
Romance the chocolate lover in all of us. This sinful seducer is made up of quality imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel and a chocolate glaze in a chocolate cookie crust. Serve with freshly whipped cream or ice cream.
Florida Key Lime 10" $45.00
Our Key Lime Pie is made with fresh key lime juice from a 75-year-old recipe, unlocking a sunburst of flavors. It’s sweet tart, smooth and creamy. Serve chilled with fresh whipped cream.
Three Berry 10" $45.00
A taste revolution in and of itself, our blend of fresh strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries are simmered into a sweet confection and then topped with a superb lattice crust.
Southern Pecan 10" $45.00
A rich and tender crust is the perfect foil for this heavenly, not overly sweet, classic. The ratio of pecans to filling is generously balanced and a scoop of freshly whipped cream complements a warm slice.
Sugarless Apple 10" (24 HOURS IN ADVANCE) $45.00
The right pie with the perfect sweetener. Nature’s own grade A golden delicious apples. We add a little nutmeg, cinnamon and unsalted butter to complete this great tasting pie.
GLUTEN-FREE Blueberry Apple Crumb 10" $52.00
Our Gluten Free Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie combines ripe blueberries with chunks of Golden Delicious Apples — making for the perfect not-too-sweet, not-to-tart filling. But, we didn’t stop there: Each Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie is topped with brown sugar-coated chopped walnuts for a crunchy, sweet finish that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
GLUTEN-FREE Florida Key Lime 10" $52.00
Our Gluten-Free Key Lime Pie is made with Florida Key lime juice and a homemade Gluten free graham cracker crust that's sweetened with a hint of honey. Each pie is sprinkled with fresh lime zest for a tropical burst of flavors you won’t be able to resist. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
Sweet Potato Pie 10" (Seasonal) $45.00
With summer ending and fall beginning, we’re excited to offer Sweet Potato Pie as our Pie of the Month for September! This delicious pie is a tribute to the classic Southern dish, made with sweet potatoes and baked to perfection. It’s the perfect way to welcome the new season. Not only is our handmade pie a tasty dessert, but it’s also full of vitamins A, C, B6, and potassium. (Serves 8-10)

Homemade Cakes - Small Cakes
SM Applesauce Carrot Cake $20.00
By making our own homemade apple sauce for the carrot cake, determined that we would not need to add a lot of additional sugar. The natural sweetness of the apples gave our cake a perfect balance of flavors. The addition of California walnuts, imported spices and cream cheese, added the right taste and texture to this delicious cake.
SM Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake $20.00
We wanted to meet three important goals with our chocolate cake: It should be very moist. It should have a rich chocolate taste and it should be luxurious. These are the qualities we trust you will find and enjoy in our Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake.
SM Creamy New York Cheese Cake $8.50
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.
SM Creamy NY Cheese Cake W/ Strawberry Topping(72 Hr. Pre-Order ONLY) $9.50
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.

Homemade Cakes - Medium Cakes
MD Applesauce Carrot Cake $40.00
By making our own homemade apple sauce for the carrot cake, determined that we would not need to add a lot of additional sugar. The natural sweetness of the apples gave our cake a perfect balance of flavors. The addition of California walnuts, imported spices and cream cheese, added the right taste and texture to this delicious cake.
MD Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake $40.00
We wanted to meet three important goals with our chocolate cake: It should be very moist. It should have a rich chocolate taste and it should be luxurious. These are the qualities we trust you will find and enjoy in our Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake.

Homemade Cakes - Large Cakes
LG Applesauce Carrot Cake $55.00
By making our own homemade apple sauce for the carrot cake, determined that we would not need to add a lot of additional sugar. The natural sweetness of the apples gave our cake a perfect balance of flavors. The addition of California walnuts, imported spices and cream cheese, added the right taste and texture to this delicious cake.
LG Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake $55.00
We wanted to meet three important goals with our chocolate cake: It should be very moist. It should have a rich chocolate taste and it should be luxurious. These are the qualities we trust you will find and enjoy in our Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake.
LG Creamy New York Cheese Cake $45.00
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.
Strawberry Cheesecake(72 Hr. Pre-Order ONLY) $53.00
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.

Small Cakes
SM Applesauce Carrot Cake $20.00
By making our own homemade apple sauce for the carrot cake, determined that we would not need to add a lot of additional sugar. The natural sweetness of the apples gave our cake a perfect balance of flavors. The addition of California walnuts, imported spices and cream cheese, added the right taste and texture to this delicious cake.
SM Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake $20.00
We wanted to meet three important goals with our chocolate cake: It should be very moist. It should have a rich chocolate taste and it should be luxurious. These are the qualities we trust you will find and enjoy in our Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake.
SM Creamy New York Cheese Cake $8.50
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.
SM Creamy NY Cheese Cake W/ Strawberry Topping(72 Hr. Pre-Order ONLY) $9.50
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.

Medium Cakes
MD Applesauce Carrot Cake $40.00
By making our own homemade apple sauce for the carrot cake, determined that we would not need to add a lot of additional sugar. The natural sweetness of the apples gave our cake a perfect balance of flavors. The addition of California walnuts, imported spices and cream cheese, added the right taste and texture to this delicious cake.
MD Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake $40.00
We wanted to meet three important goals with our chocolate cake: It should be very moist. It should have a rich chocolate taste and it should be luxurious. These are the qualities we trust you will find and enjoy in our Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake.

Large Cakes
LG Applesauce Carrot Cake $55.00
By making our own homemade apple sauce for the carrot cake, determined that we would not need to add a lot of additional sugar. The natural sweetness of the apples gave our cake a perfect balance of flavors. The addition of California walnuts, imported spices and cream cheese, added the right taste and texture to this delicious cake.
LG Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake $55.00
We wanted to meet three important goals with our chocolate cake: It should be very moist. It should have a rich chocolate taste and it should be luxurious. These are the qualities we trust you will find and enjoy in our Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake.
LG Creamy New York Cheese Cake $45.00
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.
Strawberry Cheesecake(72 Hr. Pre-Order ONLY) $53.00
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.

Dessert Loaves - By the Slice
Apple Cinnamon Slice $5.00
Sweet, chewy, moist, and oh-so-delicious: Our Apple Cinnamon Bread is a year-round favorite.
Banana Nut Slice $5.00
Very ripe bananas, give this bread its rich flavor. Walnuts and buttermilk bring out the moist and crunchy taste we enjoy, making it a treat we can enjoy anytime.
Lemon Pound Slice $5.00
Lemon bread is tart, tangy, moist and tender and a little like pound cake because it’s so buttery. The lemon glaze that’s brushed on top after it comes out of the oven, is to live for.

Dessert Loaves - Loaf (8 servings)
Apple Cinnamon Loaf $25.00
Sweet, chewy, moist, and oh-so-delicious: Our Apple Cinnamon Bread is a year-round favorite.
Banana Nut Loaf $25.00
Very ripe bananas, give this bread its rich flavor. Walnuts and buttermilk bring out the moist and crunchy taste we enjoy, making it a treat we can enjoy anytime.
Lemon Pound Loaf $25.00
Lemon bread is tart, tangy, moist and tender and a little like pound cake because it’s so buttery. The lemon glaze that’s brushed on top after it comes out of the oven, is to live for.

By the Slice
Apple Cinnamon Slice $5.00
Sweet, chewy, moist, and oh-so-delicious: Our Apple Cinnamon Bread is a year-round favorite.
Banana Nut Slice $5.00
Very ripe bananas, give this bread its rich flavor. Walnuts and buttermilk bring out the moist and crunchy taste we enjoy, making it a treat we can enjoy anytime.
Lemon Pound Slice $5.00
Lemon bread is tart, tangy, moist and tender and a little like pound cake because it’s so buttery. The lemon glaze that’s brushed on top after it comes out of the oven, is to live for.

Loaf (8 servings)
Apple Cinnamon Loaf $25.00
Sweet, chewy, moist, and oh-so-delicious: Our Apple Cinnamon Bread is a year-round favorite.
Banana Nut Loaf $25.00
Very ripe bananas, give this bread its rich flavor. Walnuts and buttermilk bring out the moist and crunchy taste we enjoy, making it a treat we can enjoy anytime.
Lemon Pound Loaf $25.00
Lemon bread is tart, tangy, moist and tender and a little like pound cake because it’s so buttery. The lemon glaze that’s brushed on top after it comes out of the oven, is to live for.

LPC Merch - Tshirt - LPC
Eat Fresh Pie T Shirt $28.00
LPC Pride T Shirt $28.00

LPC Merch - Tote Bag - LPC
This reusable tote bag is designed with durability in mind thanks to its sturdy canvas material, which will last for seasons to come! Plus, it features one zippered interior pocket and one outside pocket to keep your essentials safe, secure, and within arm’s reach.
Little Pie Company Printed Tote Bag $26.00

LPC Merch - LPC x Klean Kanteen
Featuring BPA-free stainless steel, this Klean Kanteen tumbler represents the same quality and standards we work to achieve in our business. Even better? It’ll keep your favorite beverages hot or cold for hours on end
LPC X Klean Kanteen $28.00

Tshirt - LPC
Eat Fresh Pie T Shirt $28.00
LPC Pride T Shirt $28.00

Tote Bag - LPC
This reusable tote bag is designed with durability in mind thanks to its sturdy canvas material, which will last for seasons to come! Plus, it features one zippered interior pocket and one outside pocket to keep your essentials safe, secure, and within arm’s reach.
Little Pie Company Printed Tote Bag $26.00

LPC x Klean Kanteen
Featuring BPA-free stainless steel, this Klean Kanteen tumbler represents the same quality and standards we work to achieve in our business. Even better? It’ll keep your favorite beverages hot or cold for hours on end
LPC X Klean Kanteen $28.00

Little Pie Company Details

From the business
Identifies as Black-owned

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Onsite services
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible seating
Assistive hearing loop
Wheelchair accessible restroom

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free street parking

Little Pie Company Photos

Little Pie Company Location

Little Pie Company

New York New York County New York West 43rd Street

424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036, USA

Little Pie Company Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 1313 user reviews.

apple piesour creamcheesecakekey lime piepecan piecarrot cakewalnut piechicken pot pieblueberry pieapplesauce

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

No wonder this place has such a high rating! My family was nearby and decided to grab some pies, and we’re so glad we did. We picked up a small sour cream apple walnut pie, a southern pecan pie, and a plain cheesecake. They pack your pies in secure boxes, making them easy to take to go!As soon as we got home, we warmed up the sour cream apple walnut pie—thanks to the instructions on the box, it was super easy. The pie wasn’t too sweet, and both the crust and the filling were amazing. Honestly, I think this is one of the best apple pies you can get in the city. The cheesecake was also delicious, and I can’t wait to try the pecan pie. Highly recommend getting pies here!
September 07 · B Heo
We stumbled upon this place before heading to see Six, and we’re so glad we did. The staff was friendly and welcoming as we walked in. We ordered the Georgia peach pie and the sour cream apple walnut pie, both recommendations from the staff. I was pleasantly surprised at how much we liked the apple pie, never hearing of a sour cream apple pit before. We were delighted to find this place because the pies were delicious and the staff was as sweet as the pies.
August 28 · Alesha Fields
We had the Sour Cream Apple Walnut pie and the Key Lime pie. Both were delicious. The staff was friendly and courteous. Worth a visit if you’re visiting New York.
July 12 · khanh phan
Seriously amazing pies in a pleasant, relaxed atmosphere. We had the peach pie with ice cream and the Mississippi mud pie. Loved them both.
August 24 · Andrew Reece
I always love the smell coming out of this place when I walk by! Their pies are a bit expensive, but that is because it's a gourmet bakery. The quality is definitely high.I also like their little display window that has different decorations depending on the seasons or holidays.
May 18 · Garrett Bremer