Dine Droop
Dine DroopDining Insightsrestaurants near me
ConnecticutNew JerseyNew York
Dine Drooprestaurants near meNew YorkOrange CountyNew Windsorrestaurants in Windsor HighwayMama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery
Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery ico

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery
- 374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553

Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant ★4.0 (62)·$10–20
restaurants near meNew YorkOrange CountyNew WindsorWindsor Highway

374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA

4.0
Just passing through the area I stopped in for a bite and to my delight... With a last name like mine I know an exceptional slice of pizza when I have one. The crust is flavorful and is the perfect balance of crispy yet soft. The sauce to cheese ratio is to a perfect balance. Truly a distinguished and exceptional slice of pizza. The service experience is flawless. A warm welcoming family & friendly environment that exuberates a passion and desire to ensure everyone they serve is satfied. This is, without a doubt a 5/5 pizzeria. The pizza King of New Windsor. - Anthony Romano
Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Overview Intro Food & drink Detail Photos Location Reviews
$10–20 per person Reported by 62 people$1–10$10–20$20–30

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Introduce

For those in the New York region seeking a truly authentic taste of Italy, look no further than **Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery**. This beloved local establishment, nestled in New Windsor, NY, isn't just a place to grab a slice—it's a full-service Italian restaurant and deli dedicated to serving up quality, homemade food with a passion that feels straight out of an Italian home kitchen. A true pillar of the local dining scene, Mama Theresa's has cultivated a reputation for excellence, from its signature Neopolitan Brick Oven Pizza to its extensive menu of classic Italian entrees, heroes, and specialty dishes.

The commitment to fresh, fine ingredients is evident throughout their expansive menu. Whether you're craving a simple, perfect slice of pizza, a hearty hero, or a full-course Italian dinner, Mama Theresa's provides a cozy, casual, and incredibly satisfying dining experience. They truly embody the spirit of feeding their customers like family, a promise that resonates in every dish they prepare daily. With offerings that appeal to every member of the family and cater to various dietary preferences, including excellent **vegetarian options**, this eatery is a mandatory stop for anyone craving exceptional Italian comfort food in the area.

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery is conveniently located at **374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553**. This address positions the restaurant as an easy-to-reach spot for locals and those traveling through the Hudson Valley area. Its location on Windsor Highway ensures straightforward navigation and access from surrounding communities within the New Windsor and greater Orange County region.

The eatery places a high value on ensuring a welcoming experience for all guests. The location offers excellent **accessibility** features, including a **wheelchair accessible entrance**, a **wheelchair accessible parking lot**, a **wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **wheelchair accessible seating**. Furthermore, customers can take advantage of ample **free parking**, with both a **free parking lot** and **on-site parking** available, often a significant convenience in the New York area. For those who prefer street parking, **free street parking** is also available, ensuring a hassle-free visit regardless of how busy the establishment might be.

The array of **Services Offered** by Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery caters to virtually every need, whether you are dining in, picking up, or having a meal brought to you:

  • **Dine-in:** Enjoy the full, cozy, and casual atmosphere with table service.
  • **Takeout:** Perfect for grabbing your favorites on the go for a meal at home or work.
  • **Delivery:** The convenience of having their exceptional food brought directly to your door.
  • **Table service:** Provided for a relaxing and attentive dining experience.
  • **Catering:** Available for events, gatherings, or business lunches, allowing you to share Mama Theresa's delicious Italian fare with a larger group.
  • **Kids' Menu and High Chairs:** Thoughtful accommodations ensuring a great experience for families dining with children.

The following **Features / Highlights** showcase what makes Mama Theresa's a standout choice in the New Windsor dining landscape, covering everything from the food quality to the overall dining environment and operational details:

  • **Authentic Italian and Pizzeria:** Specializing in both classic **Pizza restaurant** offerings and broader **Italian restaurant** fare.
  • **Signature Pizza Types:** Including **Neopolitan Brick Oven Pizza**, **Brooklyn Pizza**, and **Grandma's Pizza**, alongside a vast selection of Mama T's Specialty Pizzas like the **Eggplant Napoleon** and **Penne Vodka** pizza. Whole wheat crust is available upon request.
  • **Extensive Italian Menu:** Beyond pizza, they offer **Calzones & Stromboli**, **Antipasti & Appetizers** (like Baked Clams Oreganata and Fried Calamari), various **Insalate (Salad)** and **Zuppe (Soup)**, and a wide range of **Pasta! Pasta! Pasta!** dishes made with the finest Durham Wheat Semolina, including homemade ravioli and manicotti.
  • **Full Entree and Hero Selection:** The menu boasts generous **Entrees** (such as Chicken Parmigiana, Eggplant Rollatini, and Lemon Chicken), numerous **Mama Theresa's Heros** (both hot and cold, including the 'Da-Brooka-Leen' and 'New Windsor's Finest'), **Philly Cheese Steaks**, and **Paninis**.
  • **Italian Deli:** An additional feature offering favorites like **Pizza Rustica Balls**, **Rice Ball**, and a selection of oversized stuffed sandwiches and deli meats.
  • **Beverage Offerings:** Includes **Alcohol**, **Beer**, **Wine**, and **Coffee** to complement any meal.
  • **Service Excellence:** Praised for **Fast service** and a warm, attentive staff, as noted by customer reviews. The waiter service is known for being extremely attentive, ensuring a good dining experience.
  • **Atmosphere:** Described as **Casual, Cozy, and Quiet**, making it a perfect spot for solo dining, a family meal, or a relaxed gathering with **Groups** of **Locals**.
  • **Modern Payment Options:** Accepts all major forms of payment, including **Credit cards, Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments**.
  • **Popularity:** A highly popular choice for both **Lunch** and **Dinner**, known for serving a **local specialty** and being great for **Solo dining**.

To reach out to Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery for inquiries, takeout, or delivery, you can use the following information:

  • **Address:** 374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553
  • **Phone:** (845) 561-6262
  • **Mobile Phone:** +1 845-561-6262

**What is worth choosing** about Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery goes beyond just the quality of their food; it's the total experience. Customers consistently praise the perfect execution of their classic dishes. One customer, claiming to be a connoisseur of fine pizza, highlights the **distinguished and exceptional slice**, noting the crust is the "perfect balance of crispy yet soft" and the sauce-to-cheese ratio is "a perfect balance." This attention to detail in the staple dish speaks volumes about the care taken across the entire menu.

The menu provides a comprehensive selection, positioning the establishment as a reliable source of quality **comfort food** and a **quick bite** for all appetites. Whether you're in the mood for the depth of flavor in a **Lasagna** or the simplicity of a classic **Meatball Hero**, they have an option for you. The availability of **Small plates** and the option to add grilled chicken or shrimp to salads also allows for lighter fare or customizable meals.

What truly sets Mama Theresa's apart for New Yorkers and locals is the genuinely **warm, welcoming family & friendly environment**. The service experience is often described as flawless, reflecting a passion and desire from the staff to ensure every customer is satisfied. This is a place where the staff is attentive, and you're truly fed like family, making it an ideal choice for groups, families with kids, or anyone looking for a reliable, cozy, and high-quality Italian meal in the New Windsor area.

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Food & drink

  • Pizza

  • Neopolitan Brick Oven Pizza

    Mama Theresa's Neopolitan pizza is made with mama Theresa's own handmade fresh mozzarella, vine ripened tomatoes make our sauce the one you prefer, aged imported romano cheese brings a richness you have come to expect from everything you order from mama Theresa's and topped off with the finest of Italy's extra virgin olive oil, will make every bite you take of mama Theresa's Neopolitan

  • Brooklyn Pizza

    This is the pizza the whole country tries to imitate. Mama Theresa's roots are in brooklyn and no one knows brooklyn pizza better then mama Theresa's

  • Grandma's Pizza

  • Mama T's Specialty Pizza

    All specialty pizza's are available in medium, large, and sicilian. Whole wheat crust available upon request

  • Eggplant Napoleon

    Mama Theresa's fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, fire red roasted peppers and our own balsamic vinegar glaze

  • Pizza Margarita

    Mama Theresa's handmade fresh mozzarella, roma tomatoes, imported romano cheese, extra virgin olive oil and roasted garlic

  • Home on the Range

    Your choice of grilled or fried chicken breast with creamy ranch dressing, topped with crispy bacon

  • The Dominuche

    Mama Theresa's fresh mozzarella, ricotta, prosciutto, imported romano cheese, topped with our tomato sauce

  • Buffalo Chicken

    Fried slices of chicken breast tossed in mama Theresa's buffalo sauce and topped with bleu cheese dressing

  • Penne Vodka

    Penne pasta served with the infamous mama Theresa's vodka sauce

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    Golden fried chicken breasts, mama Theresa's fresh mozzarella and our homemade tomato sauce

  • White Pizza

    Ricotta, imported regiano parmigian, romano, mozzarella and fresh garlic

  • A Taste of Italy

    Artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, black olives and fontina cheese

  • Buffalo Shrimp

    Large breaded and fried shrimp tossed in mama Theresa's spicy buffalo sauce and topped with bleu cheese dressing

  • Greek Goddess

    Marinated grilled chicken, feta cheese, calamata olives, red onions, pepperoncini with extra virgin olive oil and roasted garlic

  • Pizza Insalate

    Romaine lettuce, black olives, fresh roma tomatoes, red onions, fire roasted red peppers with balsamic dressing

  • Grilled Chicken

    Sliced, plump chicken breasts marinated and served with mama Theresa's pesto sauce

  • Grilled Vegetable

    Peppers, onions, zucchini, portobello mushrooms marinated then grilled with olive oil, garlic and mama Theresa's pesto sauce

  • Shrimp

    Large tender shrimp on top of mama Theresa's marinara sauce with our homemade mozzarella and romano cheese

  • Mama Theresa's Giambotta

    Peppers, onions, meatballs, sausage and pepperoni

  • White Pizza Plus

    Choose one from the following: grilled chicken, broccoli, spinach or grilled vegetables

  • Calzones & Stromboli

    Mama Theresa's special dough, overstuffed with fresh ricotta, imported romano cheese, mozzarella and Italian spices then baked to a golden brown. Please place order for medium and large calzones one half hour before pick up. They are made to order and take time to bake

  • Stromboli

    Mama Theresa's overstuffed stromboli can be used as a meal in itself or sliced for all to share as an appetizer

  • Calzones

    Cheese, prosciutto or stuffed with any of the following: grilled vegetables, spinach broccoli, ham, meatball, sausage or pepperoni

  • Calzones & Stromboli

  • Pepperoni and Mozzarella
  • Mama T Stromboli

    Red roasted peppers, red onions, mozzarella and ham

  • Mixed Grilled Vegetables
  • Broccoli and Mozzarella
  • Broccoli Rabe and Provolone
  • Spinach, Ricotta and Mozzarella

  • Mama Therea's Heros

  • Lettuce and Tomato Included

    Available in Mini or Hero. Add cheese ($0.50)

  • Mama Therea's Heros: Cold Heros

  • Genoa Salami - Dillusso
  • Pepperoni
  • Roast Beef - Homemade
  • Turkey - Boar's Head
  • Ham - Boar's Head
  • Prosciutto
  • Sopressatta Sweet
  • Tuna Fish Salad

  • Mama Therea's Heros: Hot Heros

  • Chicken Parmigiana
  • Eggplant Parmigiana
  • Shrimp Parmigiana
  • Da-Brooka-Leen

    Fried chicken cutlets with mozzarella, roasted red peppers and pesto

  • Vails Gate's Bravest

    Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and Italian dressing

  • How You Doin?

    Genoa salami, prosciutto, cappicola, fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers

  • The Snitch

    Grilled chicken, provolone, roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato, parmigiana aioli dressing

  • American Combo

    Roast beef, turkey breast, ham, American cheese, swiss cheese with lettuce and tomato

  • Meatball Hero
  • Sausage and Peppers
  • Mama T's Italian Combo

    Ham, genoa salami, cappicola, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, provolone, roasted red peppers and Italian dressing

  • New Windsor's Finest

    Grilled chicken, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers with mama Theresa's homemade pesto

  • Sicilian Delight

    Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers and mama Theresa's homemade balsamic dressing

  • The Destefano

    Roasted red peppers, sopressatta and fresh mozzarella

  • The Don

    Fried shrimp, bacon, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing

  • Napolitano

    Prosciutto, sopressata, ham, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomato and Italian dressing

  • Philly Cheese Steaks

    Made from USDA choice sirloin. Add mushrooms or extra cheese sauce ($0.50). Add mozzarella ($1)

  • Mushroom Cheesesteak
  • Grilled Chicken Cheesesteak
  • Sicilian Cheesesteak

    With broccoli rabe, provolone and onions

  • Philly Cheesesteak
  • Pepper and Onion Cheesesteak
  • Italian Cheesesteak

    With mozzarella, peppers, onions and marinara sauce

  • Paninis

  • Fried Eggplant
  • Chicken Parmigiana
  • Baby Jimmy's Grilled Chicken

    Spinach, mozzarello and pesto

  • Mozzarella, Tomato and Basil
  • Shrimp

    Fried shrimp, roma tomatoes, mozzarella and basil

  • Antipasti & Appetizers

  • Hot Antipasti

    Baked clams, eggplant rollatini, stuffed mushrooms, pizza rustica balls and fried mozzarella

  • Baked Clams Oreganata

    Littleneck clams topped with mama Theresa's seasoned bread crumbs. extra virgin olive oil, white wine and garlic

  • Stuffed Mushrooms with Sauce

    Stuffed with mushrooms, peppers, bread crumbs and romano cheese

  • Pizza Rustica Balls (8) with Sauce

    Ricotta, mozzarella, roman cheese, salami, prosciutto, ham, cappicola covered with mama Theresa's bread crumbs. Fried golden brown

  • Fried Zucchini

    with Sauce

  • Garlic Bread
  • Potato Croquettes
  • Jumbo Wings

    Mama Theresa's uses jumbo wings so that your wings are always meaty and juicy. Choose from a variety of sauces to suite your taste. Mild, hot, firehouse hot, teriyaki, BBQ, honey glaze and oriental. 12 or 24 wings

  • Cold Antipasti

    Prosciutto, salami, cappicola, imported provolone, mozzarella, mixed olives, roasted peppers over a bed of mixed greens.

  • Steamed Mussels (12)

    Choose from spice marinara sauce or white wine and garlic with extra virgin olive oil

  • Rice Ball

    A mixture of rice, mozzarella, romano cheese, imported spices blended then shaped as a cone, stuffed with chopped meat, peas and mama theresa's seasoned bread crumbs. Fried golden brown. Served with mama theresa's tomato sauce

  • Fried Mozzarella (6)

    with Sauce

  • Fried Calamari

    with Sauce

  • Bruchetta
  • Fried Ravioli

  • Insalate (Salad)

    Add grilled chicken or grilled shrimp to any salad

  • Caesar Salad
  • Mama Theresa's Chef Salad
  • Pomodoro Salad

    Fresh plum tomatoes, red onions, mixed olives, romano cheese and choice of dressing

  • Mama Theresa's Garden Salad
  • Buffalo Chicken Salad
  • Greek Salad

  • Zuppe (Soup)

    Mama Theresa's soups are homemade everyday using the same fine ingredients you would use in your own kitchen. 12 oz

  • Cream of Broccoli
  • Soup of the Day
  • Pasta Fagioli
  • Chicken Soup

    W/ Rice Or Noodles

  • Pasta! Pasta! Pasta!

    When it comes to pasta, whether is it Mama Theresa's homemade ravioli, our handmade crepes for the Manicotti or the fettuccine all made fresh at Mama Theresa's Italian Specialty Shop or the imported pasta from Italy, only the finest Durham Wheat Semolina is used. Mama Theresa's sauces that you have come to enjoy over the years are made with loving care and the finest ingredients. As always, we pledge to feed you like family. Add meatballs or sausage, Add grilled chicken or shrimp

  • Pasta Your Way

    Choose your favorite pasta and sauce, then mangia! All pasta served with garden salad

  • Specialty Pasta Dishes

  • Lasagna

    Golden sheets of pasta layered with ricotta, romano cheese, mozzarella, sliced meatballs, tomato sauce and baked to a golden brown

  • Stuffed Shells

    Pasta shells gently baked with a blend of five cheeses

  • Manicotti

    Made from our own light and delicate handmade crepes, stuffed with our four cheese blend and topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce

  • Penne with Chicken

    Penne with chicken and broccoli in a white wine butter sauce

  • Rigatoni with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage

    Rigatoni pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage sauteed in a garlic and extra virgin olive oil topped with parmigian

  • Christine's Pasta

    Cappelini with broccoli, roasted red peppers, carrots and asparagus mixed with garlic and extra virgin olive oil, topped with romano cheese

  • Dominick's Penne with Chicken and Shrimp

    Tender pieces of chicken and shrimp in a cream sauce with Pancetta, cherry tomatoes with parmigian and regiano cheese over penne pasta

  • Baked Ziti

    Ziti mixed with homemade tomato sauce, regiano parmigian, ricotta, romano cheese, mozzarella and baked to perfection

  • Cheese Ravioli

    Made in mama Theresa's own specialty shop. topped with a bolognese sauce

  • Aglio e Olio

    Spaghetti served with browned garlic and extra virgin olive oil, topped with seasoned bread crumbs

  • Tortellini Neapolitan

    Cheese tortellini with sausage, peas and onion in an alfredo sauce

  • Fettuccine Asiago

    Fettuccine with prosciutto topped with an asiago cream sauce and asparagus

  • James' Choice

    Cheese ravioli with shrimp in a cream sauce topped with ricotta salata

  • Entrees

  • Mama Theresa's Chicken

    Fried chicken breasts topped with mozzarella, roasted peppers and pesto

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    Plump chicken breast breaded, then fried and topped with mama Theresa's tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella

  • Sausage and Peppers

    Mama Theresa's sweet Italian sausage sauteed with farm fresh sweet peppers and onions, herbs and spices

  • Eggplant Rollatini

    Golden fried fillets of eggplant rolled around three kinds of cheese, topped with fresh mozzarella and mama Theresa's tomato sauce

  • Shrimp Parmigiana

    Fried shrimp topped with fresh mozzarella and mama Theresa's marinara sauce

  • Calamari

    Sauteed in mama Theresa's marinara sauce

  • Mussels

    Steamed either red or white style. Served over linguini

  • Chicken Marsala

    Tender chicken breast sauteed in butter, infused with imported marsala wine, topped with mushrooms

  • Lemon Chicken

    Mama Theresa's seasoned breaded chicken cutlet sauteed in a lemon butter sauce and mushrooms

  • Eggplant Parmigiana

    Slices of garden fresh eggplant breaded, fried, then layered with fresh mozzarella, romano cheese and mama Theresa's tomato sauce

  • Shrimp Scampi

    Shrimp sauteed in garlic, white wine and butter

  • Shrimp Marinara

    Tender shrimp sauteed in mama Theresa's marinara sauce

  • Fried Shrimp

    Breaded with mama Theresa's bread crumbs, fried to a golden brown. served with choice of steak fries or pasta and our tarter sauce

  • Lemon Shrimp

    Mama Theresa's seasoned breaded shrimp sauteed in a lemon butter sauce

  • Side Orders

  • Sauteed Broccoli
  • Mama Theresa's String Beans
  • French Fries
  • Sauteed Mixed Vegetables
  • Potato Croquettes
  • Sauteed Spinach
  • Broccoli Rabe

    with Garlic and Oil

  • Meatballs or Sausage (2)
  • Onion Rings

  • Desserts

  • Cannoli

    Mama Theresa's crisp golden pastry tubes filled with our homemade rich creamy filling

  • Tartufo

    Rich dark chocolate topped over ice cream with a surprise inside

  • Tiramisu

    Made in our own kitchen, this blend of espresso, chocolate and brandy cream will delight your tastebuds

  • Italian Ices
  • Cheese Cake

  • Italian Deli

  • Pizza Rustica Balls (8)

    Ricotta, mozzarella, romano cheese, salami, prosciutto, ham and cappicola covered with mama Theresa's bread crumbs then fried to a golden brown with a side of sauce

  • Rice Ball

    A mixture of rice, mozzarella, romano cheese, imported spices blended then shaped as a cone and stuffed with chopped meat, peas and mama Theresa's tomato sauce then breaded with mama Theresa's seasoned bread crumbs then fried to a golden brown. served with mama Theresa's tomato sauce

  • Fried Zucchini

    With mama Theresa's tomato sauce

  • Hot Antipasto

    Baked clams, eggplant rollatini, fried mozzarella, stuffed mushrooms, pizza rustica balls served with mama Theresa's marinara sauce

  • Baked Clams Oreganata (6)

    Clams topped with mama Theresa's seasoned bread crumbs, olive oil, white wine sauce then baked to perfection

  • Potato Croquettes (6)

    Potato, mozzarella, romano cheese coated with mama Theresa's seasoned bread crumbs and fried to a golden brown

  • Fried Mozzarella (6)

    Served with mama Theresa's marinara sauce

  • Stuffed Mushrooms (6)

    Stuffed with mushrooms, peppers, bread crumbs and romano cheese available with sausage stuffing

  • Cold Antipasto

    Prosciutto, salami, cappicola, imported provolone, marinated mozzarella, mixed olives, giardiniera over a bed of mixed greens

  • Mussels Steamed

    Choose from spicy marinara or white wine sauce

  • Wings (12)

    Everybody loves wings: BBQ, teriyaki, mild or hot buffalo, served with celery and bleu cheese dressing

  • Oversized Stuffed Sandwiches

    Available on hard roll, mini hero, hero, white, wheat, or rye bread. Lettuce and tomate included

  • Bologna or Liverwurst
  • Genoa Salami Dilusso
  • Ham Cappi Boar's Head
  • BLT
  • Pepperoni
  • Roast Beef

    Homemade in mama Theresa's kitchen

  • Turkey Boar's Head

    Oven golden, smoked, cracked pepper or honey maple

  • Chicken Salad
  • Buffalo Chicken Breast Boar's Head
  • Cappicola Imported
  • Ham Boar's Head
  • Corned Beef or Pastrami

    Boar's head extra lean

  • Shrimp Salad
  • Prosciutto
  • Sopressata Hot or Sweet
  • Tuna Fish Salad

  • Mama Theresa's Heros

    Available on hard roll, mini hero, or hero

  • One Hot Italian

    You will be one hot Italian after a bite of this spicy hero. hot cappicola, spicy sopressata, prosciutto, genoa salami, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, onions and Italian dressing

  • Italian Princess

    Marinated eggplant, roasted red peppers, provolone, sun dried tomatoes, lettuce and tomato

  • Guido's Garden

    Sauteed vegetables, including zucchini, eggplant, red and green peppers and onion sauteed in extra virgin olive oil and mama Theresa's Italian herbs and spices

  • Sicilian Delight

    Fried eggplant with fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers and mama Theresa's homemade balsamic dressing

  • American Combo

    Roast beef, turkey breast, ham, American cheese and swiss cheese with lettuce and tomato

  • The Don

    Fried shrimp, bacon, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing

  • Vails Gate Bravest

    Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and Italian dressing

  • Mama T's Italian Combo

    The classic Italian hero. ham, genoa salami, cappicola, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, provolone, roasted red peppers and Italian dressing

  • How You Doin'?

    Genoa salami, prosciutto and cappicola with fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers. Guaranteed you'll be doin' just fine!

  • The Destefano

    Mama Theresa's family favorite. fresh roasted red peppers, sliced sopressata and mama Theresa's fresh mozzarella. simple and scrumptious

  • The Napoletano

    Prosciutto, sopressata, ham, fresh mozzarella, fresh roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato and Italian dressing. Sure to put a smile on your face

  • Kosher Nostra

    Corned beef, pastrami, swiss cheese and spicy brown mustard

  • Snitch

    Grilled chicken, provolone, roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato and parmigiana aioli dressing

  • New Windsor's Finest

    Grilled chicken, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers with mama Theresa's homemade pesto

  • Paninis

    These Italian grilled sandwiches are made on huge slices of arthur avenue pannella bread, spread with either mama Theresa's garlic butter or for a milder taste, farm fresh creamery butter, then loaded with our delicious fillings and pressed between two hot grills to produce the most outrageous delights

  • Cuban

    Roast pork, ham, swiss, pickle and mustard

  • Pastrami

    Pastrami, swiss, butter, russian dressing on the side

  • Fresh Eggplant

    Golden fried slices of eggplant, fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers fresh mozzarella, tomato and basil

  • Shrimp

    Fried shrimp, roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    Fried chicken breast topped with fresh mozzarella and mama Theresa's tomato sauce

  • Wraps

    Served with a pickle and cole slaw. Ask about our wrap of the day!

  • Wrap Italiano

    Fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato and mama Theresa's balsamic dressing

  • Surf's Up

    Mama Theresa's all white meat tuna salad with lettuce and roma tomatoes

  • Grilled Chicken Caesar

    Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, sun dried tomatoes, provolone, artichoke hearts, roma tomatoes and caesar dressing

  • All American

    Turkey breast, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomatoes and ranch dressing

  • Buffalo Chicken

    Fried chicken tenders, lettuce, tomato, blue cheese dressing

  • Philly Steaks

    Made from USDA choice sirloin. Add mushrooms ($0.50) extra cheese sauce ($0.50) add fresh mozzarella ($1). Available on hard roll, mini hero, or hero

  • Mushroom Cheesesteak
  • Italian Cheesesteak

    With mozzarella, peppers, onions and mama Theresa's marinara sauce

  • Sicilian Cheesesteak

    With broccoli rabe, provolone and onions

  • Philly Cheesesteak

    With sauteed onions and cheese sauce

  • Pepper and Onion Cheesesteak

    Slices of grilled chicken breast sauteed with onions and cheese sauce

  • Hamburgers

    At mama Theresa's we use only fresh 100% us beef to make our jumbo 8 oz. hamburgers, grilled the way you like them. all burgers served on a kaiser roll with 1/2 pickle and cole slaw. deluxe comes with lettuce, tomato and steak fries

  • Cheeseburger
  • Pizza Burger
  • Veggie Burger
  • Hamburger
  • Bacon Cheeseburger
  • Mushroom and Swiss Burger

  • Insalata (Salads)

    Add to any salad: fresh mozzarella or roasted red peppers. Add grilled chicken, add grilled shrimp. Available in small or large sizes

  • Garden Salad

    Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, mixed olives, romano cheese and choice of dressing

  • Frutti Dimare Italian (Seafood) Salad

    Shrimp, calamari, octopus, mussels, celery and red peppers

  • Ravioli Salad

    Cheese ravioli, baby spinach, red onion, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella and romano cheese

  • American Chef Salad

    Mixed greens, roast beef, ham, roast turkey breast, swiss cheese and choice of dressing

  • Buffalo Chicken Salad

    Boneless chicken tenders batted then fried to a golden brown, tossed in mama Theresa's spicy buffalo sauce then sliced and mixed with romaine lettuce, roma tomatoes, celery and bleu cheese dressing

  • Caesar Salad

    Crisp romaine tossed with our creamy caesar dressing, seasoned croutons and parmesan cheese

  • Pomodoro (Tomato) Salad

    Fresh plum tomatoes, red onions, basil, imported spices, red wine vinaigrette

  • Greek Salad

    Crisp romaine, greek olives, feta cheese, red onions, pepperonchini, red wine vinaigrette

  • Mama Theresa's Chef Salad

    Mixed greens, genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone cheese and choice of dressing

  • Fried Chicken Salad

    Mama Theresa's breaded and fried chicken cutlet over a bed of mixed greens, olives, tomatoes, red onions with your choice of dressing

  • Mama Theresa's Favorites

    Available on hard roll, mini hero, or hero

  • Meatball Hero

    Mama Theresa's meatballs are made from the finest grain fed beef, imported romano cheese, Italian bread, farm fresh eggs, herbs and spices. Cooked until golden brown, then simmered in mama Theresa's rich tomato sauce.

  • Sausage and Peppers

    Mama Theresa's Italian sausage, sauteed with farm fresh peppers, onions, herbs and spices

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    Plump chicken breasts breaded, fried and topped with mama Theresa's tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella, then baked to the peak of perfection

  • Eggplant Parmigiana

    Slices of garden eggplant breaded, fried then layered with fresh mozzarella, romano cheeses and mama Theresa's tomato sauce and baked to perfection

  • Shrimp Parmigiana

    Plump shrimp breaded, fried then topped with mama Theresa's marinara sauce and fresh mozzarella

  • Zuppe (Soups)

    Mama Theresa's serves only homemade soups prepared fresh daily in our own kitchen with the finest ingredients. Available in 12 oz., 16 oz., or quarts

  • Chicken Soup

    Made with all white meat chicken breast, fresh onions, carrots and celery with your choice of rice or egg noodles

  • Cream Soups

    Made with butter cream and milk

  • Entrees

    All entrees served with pasta and garlic bread. Dinner portions include garden salad. Available for lunch of dinner

  • Chicken Parmigiana

    Plump chicken breast breaded then fried and topped with mama Theresa's tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella

  • Fried Chicken

    Four pieces of grade a chicken, batter dipped with a touch of honey then fried the way you like it. Served with steak fries or pasta

  • Pork Pizzaiola

    Tender slices of pork loin sauteed with fresh mushrooms, plum tomatoes, herbs and spices

  • Italian Pepper Steak

    Slices of choice sirloin steak sauteed with peppers, onions, plum tomatoes, romano cheese, herbs and spices

  • Eggplant Rollatini

    Golden fried filets of eggplant rolled around three kinds of cheese, topped with fresh mozzarella and mama Theresa's tomato sauce

  • Chicken Marsala

    Tender chicken breast sauteed in butter, infused with imported marsala wine and topped with mushrooms

  • Lemon Chicken

    Mama Theresa's seasoned breaded chicken cutlet sauteed in a lemon butter sauce with mushrooms

  • Sausage and Peppers

    Mama Theresa's sweet Italian sausage made right here. sauteed with farm fresh sweet peppers and onions, herbs and spices

  • Steak ala Pizzaiola

    Choice sirloin steak sauteed in mama Theresa's special mushrooms and tomato sauce

  • Eggplant Parmigiana

    Slices of garden fresh eggplant breaded, fried then layered with fresh mozzarella and mama Theresa's tomato sauce

  • Mama Theresa's Specialty Pastas

    All pasta served with mama Theresa's tomato sauce unless noted. Dinner size includes garden salad. add meat sauce or vodka sauce. Add grilled chicken, meatballs or sausage. Add grilled shrimp. Available in lunch of dinner size

  • Stuffed Shells
  • Cheese Ravioli
  • Manicotti
  • Baked Ziti
  • Spaghetti, Ziti or Penne
  • Lasagna
  • Penne ala Vodka

  • Seafood

  • Shrimp Scampi

    Shrimp sauteed in garlic, white wine and butter

  • Shrimp Marinara

    Tender shrimp sauteed in mama Theresa's marinara sauce

  • Mussels

    Steamed either red or white style served over linguini

  • Shrimp Parmigiana

    Fried shrimp topped with fresh mozzarella and mama Theresa's marinara sauce

  • Fried Shrimp

    Breaded with mama Theresa's bread crumbs, fried to a golden brown. Served with a choice of steak fries or pasta and our own tarter sauce

  • Lemon Shrimp

    Fried shrimp sauteed in a lemon butter sauce with mushrooms and a kiss of white wine

  • Sides

  • Steak Fries
  • Onions Rings
  • Mama Theresa's String Beans
  • Cheese Fries
  • Chicken Fingers (4)

    With fries

  • Sauteed Broccoli Rabe

  • Beverages

  • Bottled Water–Poland Springs
  • Coffee or Tea
  • Bottled Water–Desani
  • Coke Products

  • Desserts

  • Cannoli (Large)
  • Tiramisu
  • Chocolate Cannoli (Large)

  • Daily Special

  • Monday - Mushroom
  • Monday: Tuesday - Spinach
  • Monday: Wednesday - Broccoli
  • Monday: Thursday - Potato and Bacon
  • Monday: Friday - Ask for the Soup of the Day
  • Monday: Friday - Chicken Corn Chowder
  • Monday: Monday - Pasta Fagioli
  • Monday: Tuesday - Escarole and Bean
  • Monday: Wednesday - New England Clam Chowder
  • Monday: Thursday - Lentil
  • Monday: Friday - Lobster Bisque

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Details

  • Service options

  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

  • Highlights

  • Fast service
  • Serves local specialty

  • Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining

  • Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating

  • Offerings

  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Coffee
  • Comfort food
  • Quick bite
  • Small plates
  • Vegetarian options
  • Wine

  • Dining options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Catering
  • Dessert
  • Seating
  • Table service

  • Amenities

  • Restroom

  • Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Cozy
  • Quiet

  • Crowd

  • Groups
  • Locals

  • Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards

  • Children

  • Good for kids
  • High chairs
  • Kids' menu

  • Parking

  • Free parking lot
  • Free street parking
  • On-site parking
  • Parking

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Photos

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Picture 1Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Picture 2Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Picture 3Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Picture 4Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Picture 5Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Picture 6Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Picture 7Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Picture 8Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Picture 9Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Picture 10

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Location

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery

New YorkOrange CountyNew WindsorWindsor Highway

374 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY 12553, USA

Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 325 user reviews.

priceeggplantareagarlic knotscateringpiecheese steakchicken parmdining roompenne vodka

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More restaurants near me

  • Chai HingChai Hing4.0 (76 reviews)

    5B New Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA

  • Flours Pasta & BakeshopFlours Pasta & Bakeshop4.0 (49 reviews)

    11 New Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA

  • LC Craft Beer BrittleLC Craft Beer Brittle5.0 (1 reviews)

    8 Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA

  • Lucas CandiesLucas Candies4.0 (72 reviews)

    6 Main St, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA

  • Mari's CafeMari's Cafe3.0 (3 reviews)

    75 Maple Ave, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA

  • Asi y AsadoAsi y Asado4.0 (79 reviews)

    75 Maple Ave, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA

  • Treats by EstherTreats by Esther0.0 (0 reviews)

    4402 Admirals Cove Blvd, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA

  • Riverside ScoopsRiverside Scoops5.0 (37 reviews)

    1000 Round Pointe Dr, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA

  • Harbors CafeHarbors Cafe4.0 (85 reviews)

    1000 Round Pointe Dr, Haverstraw, NY 10927, USA

  • Winfield Street Coffee - CrotonWinfield Street Coffee - Croton4.0 (10 reviews)

    4 Veterans Plaza, Croton-On-Hudson, NY 10520, USA

  • Frost Boss Ice Cream TruckFrost Boss Ice Cream Truck0.0 (0 reviews)

    245 N Main St, New City, NY 10956, USA

  • Hong Kong KitchenHong Kong Kitchen4.0 (120 reviews)

    285 NY-303 Unit 3, Congers, NY 10920, USA

    • Categories

    Dining Insightsrestaurants near me

    Top Visited Sites

    Halal Top GrillHalal Top Grill4.0 (28 reviews)Geo KhinkaliGeo Khinkali4.0 (130 reviews)Akwaaba Meat & Fish Market, West Indian StoreAkwaaba Meat & Fish Market, West Indian Store4.0 (105 reviews)Jerk Shack GrillJerk Shack Grill3.0 (110 reviews)Grand Army SouthGrand Army South5.0 (2 reviews)Ciara's Deli GroceryCiara's Deli Grocery0.0 (0 reviews)

    Top restaurants Searches

    sugar hill restaurant & supper clubcambodian restaurant nycantica pesa brooklyn nygood thanks cafethe smith 3rd averestaurant bond 45brooklyn diner laguardiacafe eighty twochocolate house astoriatacos el brother truckbootleg barlagos tsqanasa tavernanoche de margaritas menukeg and lantern brooklynroxy delicatessenlaissez faire new yorkmr moto nyckings of kobe wagyu kitchen & barxing chef

    Trending Dining Insights Posts

    The Secrets Behind Successful Bakery Shops and Their Recipes: Tips for Thriving in the Bakery BusinessThe Secrets Behind Successful Bakery Shops and Their Recipes: Tips for Thriving in the Bakery BusinessHow Vegan Restaurants Are Creating Plant-Based Comfort Foods With Gourmet FlavorsHow Vegan Restaurants Are Creating Plant-Based Comfort Foods With Gourmet FlavorsThe Appeal of French Restaurants for Special OccasionsThe Appeal of French Restaurants for Special OccasionsTop Dessert Shops Worth Traveling For: Sweet Spots Around the WorldTop Dessert Shops Worth Traveling For: Sweet Spots Around the WorldDiscovering Middle Eastern Restaurants with Creative Menus for Modern DinersDiscovering Middle Eastern Restaurants with Creative Menus for Modern DinersExploring American Restaurants That Combine Traditional and Modern Culinary TechniquesExploring American Restaurants That Combine Traditional and Modern Culinary Techniques