Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria

- 635 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803

For decades, the name Mario’s has been synonymous with quality, authentic Italian-American dining and exceptional New York-style pizza across Long Island. Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria, centrally located in Plainview, NY, is a jewel in this culinary crown, serving as a pillar for both casual family dinners and more refined dining experiences. Classified as a classic Restaurant, Italian Restaurant, and Pizza Restaurant, Mario’s masterfully bridges the gap between a high-quality sit-down dining room (Ristorante) and a beloved local pizzeria, making it a highly versatile and essential fixture for local New York users.

The atmosphere inside is described as a blend of casual, cozy, and quiet, providing an ideal setting for a relaxed meal. It’s a place where families feel welcome, groups can gather, and solo diners can enjoy a quick bite. The extensive menu is a celebration of Italian favorites, ranging from robust, expertly prepared pasta dishes and hearty meat and seafood entrées to a spectacular array of specialty pizzas. Customer feedback consistently highlights the combination of consistently excellent food and personable service, often singling out staff members for their exceptional warmth and professionalism. This dedication to both cuisine and hospitality is what maintains Mario's status as a must-visit dining destination in Nassau County.

Whether you are seeking a comforting plate of Baked Ziti, an elegant Veal Sorrentino, or one of their inventive large specialty pizzas, Mario's provides a diverse, high-quality menu designed to satisfy the cravings of every generation of New York diners. It’s a true local spot where tradition meets modern convenience, offering everything from no-contact delivery to a full-service dining room that accepts reservations.

Location and Accessibility

Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria is ideally situated at 635 Old Country Rd, a highly trafficked and easily accessible corridor in Plainview, NY 11803. This central Long Island location makes it a convenient dining option for residents and commuters across the Nassau County area.

The facility is designed with comprehensive accessibility in mind, ensuring all patrons can enjoy the dining experience:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Ensures smooth entry and exit for all guests.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Dedicated parking spots for ease of access.
• Wheelchair Accessible Restroom: Provides comfort and convenience within the dining area.
• Wheelchair Accessible Seating: Offers accommodating seating arrangements in the dining room.

The amenities also include ample parking options, which is a significant convenience in the New York metropolitan area. Patrons can utilize the free parking lot and the availability of free street parking, eliminating the stress of finding a spot before a reservation. Furthermore, the restaurant offers multiple service methods, including dine-in, takeout, curbside pickup, and no-contact delivery, making its celebrated menu available wherever you are on Long Island.

Services Offered

Mario’s Ristorante & Pizzeria provides a holistic dining and food service experience, extending well beyond just serving food at a table. Key services include:

• Full-Service Dining: Offering brunch, lunch, and dinner with comfortable seating, table service, and the option to make reservations for a guaranteed spot.
• Comprehensive Takeout and Delivery: Facilitating convenient meal solutions through standard delivery, no-contact delivery, curbside pickup, and simple takeout options.
• Catering and Private Events: Providing full catering services with party packages and trays for off-site events, and offering a private dining room upstairs for on-site parties, making it a reliable host for large groups, reunions, and special occasions.
• Full Bar Service: A wide selection of Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Hard Liquor, and a Great Wine List, perfect for pairing with classic Italian fare or enjoying on its own.
• Specialty Menu Options: Features numerous small plates, quick bites, and dedicated Vegetarian Options, ensuring dietary needs are easily accommodated. A dedicated Kids' Menu and high chairs are available, making it highly Family-Friendly.
• Flexible Payment Methods: Accepts all major Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments for quick and easy transactions.

Features / Highlights

Mario’s has cultivated a reputation based on several defining features that resonate strongly with the local Long Island customer base:

• Dual Dining Experience: The ability to seamlessly transition from a casual pizzeria environment with grab-and-go slices (like the Regular Slice, Grandma Slice, or Drunken Sicilian Slice) to a sophisticated Ristorante setting for full-course Italian dining.
• Specialty Pizza Variety: An incredibly diverse and unique Large Pizza menu featuring inventive options like the 18" BBQ Chicken, 18" Chicken A La Vodka, 16" Square Drunken Pizza, and 18" Taco Pizza, alongside classics like the 18" Margherita Pizza.
• Signature Entrées and Comfort Food: A focus on classic Italian comfort food and high-end entrées, including customer favorites like Veal Parmigiana and Chicken Parmigiana, as well as specialty pasta dishes like Penne Bolognese, Whole Wheat Penne Pesto, and Frutti Di Mare.
• Exceptional Staff and Service: Noted for its "Fast service" and outstanding personnel. Server Nick M was specifically highlighted in a review for his "warm, thoughtful, and personable approach," underscoring the restaurant's commitment to memorable guest interactions.
• The Complimentary Bread Basket: A popular touch are the delicious garlic knots served in the bread basket at the start of the meal, demonstrating a welcoming attention to detail that enhances the dining experience.
• Impressive Beverage Program: Recognized for its "Great cocktails" and "Great wine list," providing the perfect liquid complement to any meal, from a casual pizza night to a celebration dinner.

Contact Information

For reservations, to inquire about catering, or to place an order for delivery or takeout, please use the contact information below. Reservations are accepted and highly recommended for large parties or weekend dining, especially when utilizing the private dining space.

• Address: 635 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803
• Phone: (516) 935-8800
• Mobile Phone: +1 516-935-8800

Guests looking to book the private party room should note the importance of clearly confirming all terms, including minimum guest counts and package inclusions, directly with the management to ensure a smooth planning process, as highlighted by a previous customer's experience. It is always best practice to get any party package details in writing beforehand.

What is Worth Choosing

Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria is an institution worth choosing for New York-area diners because it delivers on the promise of authentic, high-quality Italian food within a comfortable, community-focused environment. It’s a perfect option for nearly any occasion, offering the flexibility of a casual pizzeria for a quick slice or a full-scale restaurant for a significant celebration. The menu’s sheer depth, from satisfying heroes like the Veal Parm Hero and Grilled Chicken with Fresh Mozzarella, to sophisticated entrées like Salmon Semi Fredo and Chicken Marsala, guarantees a satisfying meal for every palate.

Choosing Mario’s means opting for a restaurant that is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining, indicating reliability and consistent appeal across all service types. The combination of excellent comfort food, highlighted by the consistently excellent BBQ Chicken Pizza and delicious Penne Bolognese, alongside their highly-rated cocktails and extensive wine list, makes for a truly complete dining experience. Furthermore, the commitment to accessibility, ample free parking, and accommodating service options like no-contact delivery underscores its dedication to the Long Island community. For an authentic taste of Italian-American tradition and hospitality in Plainview, Mario’s remains a premier and well-rounded choice.

Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria

635 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803, USA