Mateo’s Cantina

- 1929 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793

As New Yorkers and Long Islanders, we are always on the lookout for authentic, high-quality local dining spots that offer both great food and a welcoming atmosphere. Mateo’s Cantina, located right in the heart of Wantagh, NY, is quickly becoming a standout destination for those craving genuine Mexican cuisine. Far beyond the standard fare, this establishment offers a culinary journey through the vibrant flavors of Mexico, right here in Nassau County. It’s a perfect spot whether you are looking for a quick bite, a casual family dinner, or a cozy place to enjoy drinks with friends. The commitment to fresh ingredients and traditional recipes is evident in every dish, from the tantalizing tacos to the robust main courses and inventive cocktails.

Mateo's Cantina has established itself as more than just a place to eat; it is a community hub where excellent service meets a relaxed, trendy, and cozy atmosphere. The restaurant prides itself on being a destination that appeals to everyone, whether you are dining solo for lunch, planning a large group dinner, or seeking a comfortable spot for a date night. With a menu that is both extensive and carefully curated, it caters to all tastes, offering everything from classic comfort food to sophisticated regional specialties. Their focus on providing a consistently positive experience has earned them high praise from local patrons, who frequently highlight the friendly staff and the overall deliciousness of the food and drinks. When the craving for truly authentic Mexican food strikes on Long Island, Mateo’s Cantina is the name that should come to mind first.

Mateo’s Cantina is conveniently situated at 1929 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793, making it easily accessible for residents across Long Island and visitors to the area. Wantagh is a prime location in Nassau County, allowing for a comfortable drive and convenient access from various surrounding towns. For those arriving by car, the restaurant is well-prepared with multiple parking options. Patrons can utilize the Free parking lot available on-site, as well as Free street parking in the vicinity. This blend of on-site and street parking removes one of the common frustrations of dining out in the greater New York area.

Furthermore, accessibility is a priority at Mateo’s Cantina, ensuring that all members of the community can enjoy their dining experience comfortably. The location features comprehensive accommodations, including a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a designated Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating. This attention to detail highlights their commitment to serving the diverse needs of the New York community, providing a welcoming environment for everyone looking to enjoy authentic Mexican flavors. The combination of its central address and its dedication to accessibility makes it a practical and appealing choice for any meal out in the area.

Mateo’s Cantina provides a comprehensive suite of service options designed to fit the busy lifestyles of New Yorkers and Long Islanders, offering flexibility whether you prefer to dine in or enjoy their food at home.

• Dine-in: Enjoy the full, vibrant atmosphere with comfortable seating, a Bar onsite, and excellent table service for lunch, dinner, or dessert. Reservations are accepted, making it easy to plan your visit, especially for groups.
• Delivery: Have your favorite Mexican dishes brought directly to your home or office.
• No-contact delivery: A convenient and safe option for receiving your order with minimal interaction.
• Takeout: Place your order and pick it up to enjoy high-quality Mexican food on the go.
• Curbside pickup: A highly convenient option, allowing you to quickly grab your order without needing to leave your vehicle.
• Table service: Full-service dining is offered for both lunch and dinner, ensuring a relaxed and attentive experience.
• Reservations: The restaurant Accepts reservations, making it simple to secure a table, particularly for larger parties or during peak dining hours.
• Payments: For ease of transaction, the restaurant accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

The unique attributes of Mateo’s Cantina set it apart as a premier Mexican dining destination in the Wantagh area. They focus on delivering a memorable experience through exceptional food, efficient service, and a great beverage selection.

• Fast service: Patrons frequently praise the quick and efficient service, making it an excellent choice for a lunch break or a time-conscious dinner.
• Great cocktails: The cocktail menu is a significant highlight, featuring unique and popular drinks like the potent Pica De A Madres (Spicy Margarita) ($16.00), the classic Mexico Lindo & Querido Margarita ($15.00), and the premium El Jefe Margarita ($19.00). They also offer the smoky Ay Mi MEZCALITA!!! ($16.00), along with Sangria ($17.00) and a Michelada ($15.00).
• Great beer selection: Complementing the food is a diverse and well-chosen selection of beers.
• Offerings: A full range of beverages is available, including Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and Wine.
• Authentic Menu Variety: The menu includes staples like Guacamole & Chips ($17.00) and Queso Fundido ($18.00), a diverse La Taqueria section with specialty tacos such as Taco De Birria ($8.00) and Baja Fish Taco ($7.00), and extensive main courses (Pa' Rematar) like the popular Fajitas ($0.00), Grilled Arrachera Steak ($50.00), and Camarones En Crema De Chipotle ($30.00).
• Dessert Options: Don't miss the traditional Mexican desserts, including Coconut Flan ($12.00), fresh Churros ($15.00), and Tres Leches ($12.00).
• Atmosphere: The ambiance is described as Casual, Cozy, and Trendy, creating an inviting and enjoyable setting.
• Kid-Friendly: The restaurant is Good for kids and provides High chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu, making it a great spot for family dining.
• Popularity: It’s a popular choice for Lunch, Dinner, and for those who prefer Solo dining, and is an ideal spot for Groups.

For directions, reservations, or to place an order for takeout or delivery, please use the following contact details:

• Address: 1929 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793
• Phone: (516) 214-0958
• Mobile Phone: +1 516-214-0958

For those in the New York area seeking a truly authentic and high-quality Mexican dining experience, Mateo’s Cantina offers a combination of factors that make it a uniquely compelling choice. Firstly, the menu is a celebration of Mexican culinary depth. While many places offer tacos and burritos, Mateo’s Cantina elevates the offering with specialty items like the rich Beef Birria Ramen Consommé ($14.00), the savory Chile Relleno ($29.00), and the exceptional Chuleta De Cerdo Al Tamarindo ($30.00), showcasing a commitment to regional and intricate flavors. The use of traditional preparation methods and fresh ingredients is evident, moving the dining experience beyond mere "comfort food" and into a category of refined, yet approachable, Mexican dining.

Secondly, the dedication to a superior customer experience is a constant highlight. With the Fast service and a staff known for being friendly and providing great suggestions, as noted by local diners, the Cantina ensures a positive visit every time. The emphasis on great service extends to their beverage program. The bar offers a wide range of top-shelf selections, including a Great cocktails and Great beer selection, making it a perfect spot for unwinding. The specialty margaritas, such as the spicy Pica De A Madres, are often cited as a must-try, distinguishing them from generic bar offerings.

Finally, the sheer convenience and flexibility of the service options cater perfectly to the Long Island lifestyle. Whether you need the speed of Curbside pickup, the safety of No-contact delivery, or the comfort of a Cozy and Trendy dine-in atmosphere with Table service, Mateo’s Cantina accommodates. The added benefit of being fully Wheelchair accessible and having abundant Free parking lot and Free street parking removes common dining hassles, positioning it as a top local choice for both spontaneous meals and planned celebrations. For New Yorkers seeking authentic flavor, reliable service, and a welcoming environment, Mateo’s Cantina in Wantagh is the undisputed local destination.

Mateo’s Cantina

1929 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA